Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Interest from money in banks comes from more than just what is paid to the depositor. Banks use money to make money. For example, loaning it out at higher rate than the interest they pay the original depositor. Better that those funds should benefit CA than the banks.
I would trust Ken Lay to run a bank more than I would Illinois politicians. You must hold CA politicians in very high regard!
 
As I said, I'm still looking into. Right now the only working model is in North Dakota (Which is, incidentally, not experience the same sort of budget deficit as its neighbors.)
North Dakota is known for having among the lowest corruption of any state, and is the beneficiary of an oil boom responsible for the lowest unemployment rate of any state.

I don't think California is in such a circumstance.
 
Although it is pretty easy to see some of the benefits. For example, if a guy gets a $100,000 loan from the state bank of CA, all of those funds benefit the state. He pays a contractor to gut and rebuild a space, buys equipment, hires employees, buys some products and ingredients locally and so forth. All of this stimulates the economy. Even if the business goes under in a year and the loan is not paid back, a large percentage of it has already returned to the state coffers through taxes along the supply line, less unemployment payments, and so forth.

If the same guy borrows from BofA, that loan gets written off and the loss is distributed to the customers of the bank.

A state bank can afford to stimulate the economy because the risk is lower, a private bank can't.
:eye-poppi

So the plan is to make risky loans?
 
263894ef0941f8630b.jpg
 
Actually, it is gaining interest in a credit union, in part by being lent out to small businesses that "real" banks won't bother with and non-predatory home loans. In this way those donations are helping the people of the local community while supporting the OWS office space.

It's pretty cool what you can do with money besides stick it in an overseas account. ;)

OWS as a nationwide movement is in flux right now. The physical action worked for the first goal - to bring attention to economic injustice and the undue effect of corporate sponsorship on our elected officials. The problems are still there, of course. These issues are too large to be solved in a few months.

The next step is undecided, it will be chaotic for a while. Many supporters of OWS will focus on smaller or local issues. There will be other types of activism inspired by OWS but unrelated that will pull occupiers.

This thread has over 100 pages and this is one teeny, tiny corner of the internet. People are talking, even if they don't agree with the tactics of OWS. The original OWS achieved that much. The final occupiers will entertain the detractors for a while. The supporters will be in a better position to recognize the next step. Although my involvement with OWS has ended, I am satisfied with the outcome.

IOW occupy is using the same fractional reserve system that they're opposed to. This money would be much better off as a donation to a homeless shelter as people are freezing on the streets right now rather than sitting in some vault waiting for occupy #2, or whatever.

Whatever, of course being whoever has signing authority on that account quietly withdrawing the money a year from now, when occupy is but a distant memory and having a nice holiday in Jamaica.

Yes, people are talking, people have always been talking. We know about corruption and how it's existed since the dawn of time, we know about corporate influence on government, we know about predatory lending practices, we know about Walmart, we know about global warming, we know about pretty much everything occupy is on about.

Occupy has given us nothing new, they've just given us the same old complaints with the added embellishment of tents.
 
Well, then, there's your OWS difference:
There's always been a low level of dissatisfaction, but this was in tents!
 
Occupy has given us nothing new, they've just given us the same old complaints with the added embellishment of tents.

That's a completely unfair characterization. They also had drum circles!
 
You did. You explicitly want these banks to operate in a manner other than how private banks operate. Private banks operate to maximize profits. Therefore, you're asking these banks to do something other than maximize profits.

Furthermore, since these local loans that you are demanding are NOT being met by banks currently (otherwise, why would you need to get a state-run bank to make them?), that means that they are worse bets than other available loans (locally or not). You are explicitly calling for banks to make loans which they are currently unwilling to make because they're too risky.

You don't think that Banks are not making any local loans at all? There are still a lot of valid loans that could be made, and these new banks would not be asked to make bad loans. Focusing locally does not mean making bad loans.

You are just assuming that they would make bad loans.


Short selling is to blame? Hardly. You're deeply ignorant of economics if you think that. And as for negligent housing loan practices, well, that's exactly what you're calling for! You're demanding a state-run bank make loans which private banks think are too risky! You're demanding a repeat of exactly the problem you're mad about. Where the hell is the sense in that?

This is about focusing locally, not giving out risky home loans. There is no reason why that would happen except for your assumption that it would. There are plenty of good local loans that could be made which would be profitable for both the bank and the State in the form of a higher tax base.

As for short selling, that was absolutely a factor in the collapse of the economy. It's pretty ironic to say it is ignorant of economics to include one of the major factors that caused a bad recession to get much worse...



Oh, but that's not what we're talking about. We aren't talking about better regulation, more transparency, tighter accounting standards. We're talking about the state taking on the role of banks, in order to accomplish political goals that the private sector is unwilling to perform BECAUSE it's too risky. And you're putting taxpayers on the hook for those loans, and in the process creating a monstrosity of an agency problem.
Again, your assumptions do not equal facts.
 
You don't think that Banks are not making any local loans at all? There are still a lot of valid loans that could be made, and these new banks would not be asked to make bad loans. Focusing locally does not mean making bad loans.

You are just assuming that they would make bad loans.
Why haven't all the existing local banks discovered this untapped bonanza?
 
Although it is pretty easy to see some of the benefits. For example, if a guy gets a $100,000 loan from the state bank of CA, all of those funds benefit the state. He pays a contractor to gut and rebuild a space, buys equipment, hires employees, buys some products and ingredients locally and so forth. All of this stimulates the economy. Even if the business goes under in a year and the loan is not paid back, a large percentage of it has already returned to the state coffers through taxes along the supply line, less unemployment payments, and so forth.

That's not how it works. In reality, your scenario has the state loan money to someone. They spend it all unprofitably, and so they can't pay it back. Now the state is short that money. It must go to the taxpayers to get that money back. Luckily, the taxpayers have that money: it's the money the debtor spent, in your scenario. So instead of stimulating the economy, all that money has to go from the state, to the debtor, to the taxpayers, and back to the state, just for the state to break even.

Of all the debt-based methods of allegedly stimulating the economy, making bad loans is probably the worst. It would, in fact, be more cost-effective for the state to simply select a boondoggle at random, and hire contractors directly to work on it. High speed rail, for example.
 
It's not a straw man if the objections presented were, as the cartoonist says, actual objections.

I love it.

A statement from someone at a protest is out of bounds because it isn't from a true protestor or hasn't been shown as a majority opinion, but someone in an internet comment makes a statement somewhere and it is now the *perfect* way to show how dumb every single opponent or critic is.


And best part is, you don't even see it when you do it.
 
I love it.

A statement from someone at a protest is out of bounds because it isn't from a true protestor or hasn't been shown as a majority opinion, but someone in an internet comment makes a statement somewhere and it is now the *perfect* way to show how dumb every single opponent or critic is.


And best part is, you don't even see it when you do it.

Interesting isn't it, occupy with it's far left politics and disconnect from reality.

Did you read that article JihadJane posted, How the Occupy Movement Has Embraced Liberation Psychology ?

I couldn't help but laugh at the necktie panel in the cartoon and figured the cartoonist just tossed it in there to make it up to 10.
 
I never have understood how a Party could be blatantly purchased by corrupt corporations and still be blindly followed without question. When people like the Koch Bros pay to convince people that they should pay more taxes and hurt the economy, it would seem like no one would be crazy or masochistic enough to follow it, but there are people who don't even take the time to consider the rationality of it, because they are told that it is somehow a good idea to do so.

I don't understand how anyone could be that easily duped. Raising taxes on groups that spend the largest percentage and collective quantitative amount of their income on economic spending is a terrible economic idea. Getting rid of programs that have some of the biggest advantages for our economy (education, health care reform, unemployment benefits, etc.) does nothing to help anyone, rich or poor.

That kind of conservative and Republican propaganda that advocates for people to make their lives worse off seems so ridiculous to me, I just don't understand how anyone would ever support it.
Some of us didn't get the koolaid laced education most posters here seem to be under the spell of; too bad for you we vote too, most usually republican.

I don't agree with the analysis above, and we both know Dem funding is from their union buddies -- and other idiots too (many limousine libs for example; corporations too).

Whatever floats your boat.
 
That's not how it works. In reality, your scenario has the state loan money to someone. They spend it all unprofitably, and so they can't pay it back. Now the state is short that money. It must go to the taxpayers to get that money back. Luckily, the taxpayers have that money: it's the money the debtor spent, in your scenario. So instead of stimulating the economy, all that money has to go from the state, to the debtor, to the taxpayers, and back to the state, just for the state to break even.

Of all the debt-based methods of allegedly stimulating the economy, making bad loans is probably the worst. It would, in fact, be more cost-effective for the state to simply select a boondoggle at random, and hire contractors directly to work on it. High speed rail, for example.

That would be the case if the money spent created the same amount of money that was loaned. Even in a failed business (Worst case scenario) the money generated for a short time could exceed the original loan, even if the original loan wasn't paid off.

The goal, of course, is to have a state bank that primarily makes good loans but there is always some risk. A state bank would be able to mitigate that risk in part because the state would benefit directly from the loan.

Part of the TARP deal was that the rescued banks would use some of that money (and the $7 Billion at ridiculously low interest) to stimulate the economy by investing in small business. They haven't. Small business loans decreased. Some of the slack has been picked up by credit unions but it is not enough.

Interest rates on credit cards have also sky-rocketed. If people could transfer their credit card balances to a state run bank at a much lower rate, the bank would have another source of revenue. One that has less risk than home or business loans thanks to the new bankruptcy laws. This would also stimulate the economy.

As I said, I'm looking into this. I appreciate the chance to discuss it. If I decide to work towards this goal, it'll take a lot of time. I'd rather go into that knowing all the pros and cons.
 
You did. You explicitly want these banks to operate in a manner other than how private banks operate. Private banks operate to maximize profits. Therefore, you're asking these banks to do something other than maximize profits.

Yes, I suppose I am. I would be asking this bank to balance profits with good governance because it was run by the state. Maximizing profits has lead to predatory practices, it would be nice if CA's millions of dollars in revenue were used to create wealth for CA instead of private industry. If the bank of CA made less profit than BofA but was still in the black, it would be a success. If it could do that by reducing credit card interest rates, refinancing mortgages, making small business loans, it would stimulate the economy.

Furthermore, since these local loans that you are demanding are NOT being met by banks currently (otherwise, why would you need to get a state-run bank to make them?), that means that they are worse bets than other available loans (locally or not). You are explicitly calling for banks to make loans which they are currently unwilling to make because they're too risky.

The economy has tanked, partially because of the actions of the banks. The banks were given insane amounts of money at ridiculously low interest rates with the agreement that part of it would refinance home loans and offer small business loans. They have done neither, even though it would have been nearly painless to do so. It is hard to say that those loans would be too risky.

Short selling is to blame? Hardly. You're deeply ignorant of economics if you think that. And as for negligent housing loan practices, well, that's exactly what you're calling for! You're demanding a state-run bank make loans which private banks think are too risky! You're demanding a repeat of exactly the problem you're mad about. Where the hell is the sense in that?

Oh, but that's not what we're talking about. We aren't talking about better regulation, more transparency, tighter accounting standards. We're talking about the state taking on the role of banks, in order to accomplish political goals that the private sector is unwilling to perform BECAUSE it's too risky. And you're putting taxpayers on the hook for those loans, and in the process creating a monstrosity of an agency problem.
[/QUOTE]

You can't have both? Just because the state has a bank doesn't mean that there should not be better regulation for private banks. That regulation wont happen overnight. The financial industry spends millions on lobbies and political campaigns. Instead of trying to fight a deeply entrenched system, it's better to create an alternative. CA has enough revenue to start a strong bank, our real estate market is huge, we have 36 million people many of whom are paying off credit card debt with high interest. Those aspects alone could make the bank profitable.

If the major banks had competition in this area, perhaps some of that regulation wouldn't be needed as immediately.
 
The goal, of course, is to have a state bank that primarily makes good loans but there is always some risk. A state bank would be able to mitigate that risk in part because the state would benefit directly from the loan.

That doesn't mitigate the risk, though. As I pointed out, if the loan is not repayed, the State has to recover the lost funds by taxing the people that received money from the debtor. This recovery can't be counted as a benefit to the state, unless and until the tax revenues make up the funding shortfall caused by the bad loan. The state can't create wealth out of bad loans any more than banks can.

If the state is going to embark on a program of government debt-funded stimulus, it should do what banks can't do, not what banks shouldn't do. Infrastructure spending, for example, or welfare spending.
 
Yes, I suppose I am. I would be asking this bank to balance profits with good governance because it was run by the state.

And if there's one thing California is known for, it's good governance.

The economy has tanked, partially because of the actions of the banks.

Yes: banks making loans which were politically desirable but economically nonsensical, and bought up by... (wait for it)... government-established enterprises in the form of Freddie and Fannie.

It still looks a hell of a lot like you're trying to recreate what caused this mess in the first place.

You can't have both? Just because the state has a bank doesn't mean that there should not be better regulation for private banks.

Whether or not you can have both, you can't substitute the justification of one for the justification of the other, which was what I was pointing out.

The financial industry spends millions on lobbies and political campaigns. Instead of trying to fight a deeply entrenched system, it's better to create an alternative.

Yeah, sorry, not buying it. If this alternative is really as great as you claim, then isn't it just as much of a threat, if not even more, to the existing financial industry than more regulations? If you think you can't make headway on regulations because they'll lobby against it, why would you think you could make headway against lobbying for this alternative? Wouldn't they spend just as much to kill or corrupt it?

And that's really the bigger danger: that they won't kill it, but merely perform regulatory capture.

CA has enough revenue to start a strong bank

California has massive deficits AND debts. It doesn't have the money to start a strong bank.

our real estate market is huge

Your real estate market is also a complete mess. Prices are still incredibly volatile, the California job market is in shambles... your default risks are terrible.

If the major banks had competition in this area, perhaps some of that regulation wouldn't be needed as immediately.

If you think the banks don't have competition, why bother turning to California government? Start your own bank and make a fortune. After all, if the market is really under-competitive, then you should be able to beat all the existing players. The greatest fortunes are always made by lowering costs to consumers. You've spotted a major opportunity that nobody is exploiting, go out there and become a billionaire!

Or maybe it's not that simple. Maybe the market really is competitive. Maybe interest rates are high because credit risks and default rates are high.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom