Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Three of the DC hunger strikers bail out; one remains:

Sam Jewler said he broke his fast with a glass of coconut juice and a bowl of miso broth around noon Monday. In an interview, Jewler said his family was pressuring him to give up the protest, at least for now.

This comes only a day or two after they met with 9-11 Truth hunger striker Dick Gregory, who is apparently 14 months into his "liquids only" strike.

The New York hunger strikers have given up as well.
 
And if there's one thing California is known for, it's good governance.



Yes: banks making loans which were politically desirable but economically nonsensical, and bought up by... (wait for it)... government-established enterprises in the form of Freddie and Fannie.

It still looks a hell of a lot like you're trying to recreate what caused this mess in the first place.



Whether or not you can have both, you can't substitute the justification of one for the justification of the other, which was what I was pointing out.



Yeah, sorry, not buying it. If this alternative is really as great as you claim, then isn't it just as much of a threat, if not even more, to the existing financial industry than more regulations? If you think you can't make headway on regulations because they'll lobby against it, why would you think you could make headway against lobbying for this alternative? Wouldn't they spend just as much to kill or corrupt it?

And that's really the bigger danger: that they won't kill it, but merely perform regulatory capture.



California has massive deficits AND debts. It doesn't have the money to start a strong bank.



Your real estate market is also a complete mess. Prices are still incredibly volatile, the California job market is in shambles... your default risks are terrible.



If you think the banks don't have competition, why bother turning to California government? Start your own bank and make a fortune. After all, if the market is really under-competitive, then you should be able to beat all the existing players. The greatest fortunes are always made by lowering costs to consumers. You've spotted a major opportunity that nobody is exploiting, go out there and become a billionaire!

Or maybe it's not that simple. Maybe the market really is competitive. Maybe interest rates are high because credit risks and default rates are high.

California's deficits and debts would not affect the bank. The state of California would be run the same way. The bank would not be in charge of the budget. It would only hold the revenue which came in. Any gain from holding that revenue would go to the state bank, instead of private banks. If the state bank turned a profit from this revenue, it would only need to be more than any interest gained from putting the money into a private bank. It does not need to be equal to CA's deficits.

I am not expecting a state bank to fix all of CA's budget woes, that would be ridiculous. I would only like the millions of dollars currently profiting private banks to work for the citizens of CA instead.

CA was hit hard by predatory loans. Countrywide in particular. (Remember those "it's just that easy!" ads?) There was no political motivation behind this. If there were these loans would have been made grudgingly. There would have been no need to encourage people to lie about their income, to sell the most confusing mortgages to the most naive consumers, or to target low-income areas. The only reason to make those loans was to repackage them and sell them as good investments. There is no reason to believe that a state bank would have made those loans in the first place.
 
California's deficits and debts would not affect the bank.

Yes they would. It takes a lot of capital to set up a bank. Where's that capital going to come from? If it comes from investors, well, the bank won't be owned by California and it won't be run for the benefit of California. To accomplish what you want to accomplish, they have to come from the state's budget. Which is already a disaster, and doesn't have much to spare.

The bank would not be in charge of the budget.

I never said they would. But the money to start the bank would need to come from the the state budget. And the state would hold any liabilities from the bank. Which means that when the bank implodes (as it almost certainly would), taxpayers are on the hook.

If the state bank turned a profit from this revenue, it would only need to be more than any interest gained from putting the money into a private bank.

No, it would need to be more than interest that California currently has to pay on its bonds.

And they're not likely to be able to do that pursuing your agenda.

I am not expecting a state bank to fix all of CA's budget woes, that would be ridiculous. I would only like the millions of dollars currently profiting private banks to work for the citizens of CA instead.

I asked this question before, and got no answer: under this logic, why banks? Why not grocery stores, or gas stations? Why not have California run any profitable business?

CA was hit hard by predatory loans. Countrywide in particular.(Remember those "it's just that easy!" ads?) There was no political motivation behind this. If there were these loans would have been made grudgingly. There would have been no need to encourage people to lie about their income, to sell the most confusing mortgages to the most naive consumers, or to target low-income areas. The only reason to make those loans was to repackage them and sell them as good investments.

And who was buying?

Oh, that's right: Fannie and Freddie.

There most definitely was a political motivation. There was a deliberate effort across many administrations to artificially increase home ownership. This was an explicitly stated goal. And it worked, in a fashion. Yet it had side effects.

But for some reason, you think you can engage in social engineering through state manipulation of the market, and NOT get any side effects. Because this time, this time, it will be different.

There is no reason to believe that a state bank would have made those loans in the first place.

Yet you still want this state bank to make loans which private banks are unwilling to make. And these loans are clearly going to underperform, because if they didn't, well, either banks would be making them already, or they're missing out on a golden opportunity and you should start up your own bank and make those loans yourself.
 
I foresee a lot of political pressure to have the state bank give our loans to low-income families who "can't get a loan otherwise" and who "can't get a fair shake form the regular banks." How long before that desire to put people into homes translates into bad decisions. Or how about the combination of a demand for loans to garner votes along with the linked threat to hold people accountable for NOT giving out loans to low-income people (there were a lot of claims of racism from banks not giving out loans to low income families, why not again?).

Maybe the idea has some merit, but it looks like a possible quagmire, and I don't really see much return for the investment(s).
 
California's deficits and debts would not affect the bank.
It affects how much funding the state has available to set up this bank. The state will either have to increase its deficits, or increase its debts.

[The state bank] would only hold the revenue which came in.
If the bank holds the revenue, what will the state use to reduce its budget deficits and pay down its existing debt?

Any gain from holding that revenue would go to the state bank, instead of private banks.
Gain from holding the revenue, or from investing the revenue?

If the state bank turned a profit from this revenue, it would only need to be more than any interest gained from putting the money into a private bank.
The interest earned by money in private banks is the result of private banks investing wisely, and avoiding unprofitably risky investments.

I think we are all curious to see how you propose that the state bank pay higher interest on its deposits by adopting a risky investment strategy that private banks consider unprofitable.

It does not need to be equal to CA's deficits.

Need doesn't even enter into it; it's a question of possible. There is not an investment strategy in the world that could equal California's deficits. What I'm looking for here is some explanation of how your state banking proposal won't actually make those deficits worse.

Your proposal makes no sense at all. Do you know what budget deficits actually are? California has a budget deficit because its revenues are less than its expenditures. It's already not bringing in enough money to pay for all the things it buys.

Your suggestion is that instead of using its revenues to pay off (some of) its expenses, the state should use those revenues to make risky loans--loans that for-profit banks, and profitable banks, should not make.

And then, piling senselessness upon senselessness, you further suggest that by adopting a riskier, less-profitable loan strategy, the state bank should hope to somehow achieve better returns on its investment (your "interest gained") than do banks that turn a profit by avoiding unprofitably risky loan strategies.

I am not expecting a state bank to fix all of CA's budget woes, that would be ridiculous. I would only like the millions of dollars currently profiting private banks to work for the citizens of CA instead.
Why banking, exactly? If the goal is for the state to enter some profitable market sector, why banking? Why not software development, or aerospace, or oil exploration, or retail?

Come to think of it, why aren't governments just big, profitable corporations already?

There is no reason to believe that a state bank would have made those loans in the first place.

No, the state is provably more likely to make gifts instead. Where do you think those budget deficits come from?
 
It affects how much funding the state has available to set up this bank. The state will either have to increase its deficits, or increase its debts.


If the bank holds the revenue, what will the state use to reduce its budget deficits and pay down its existing debt?


Gain from holding the revenue, or from investing the revenue?


The interest earned by money in private banks is the result of private banks investing wisely, and avoiding unprofitably risky investments.

I think we are all curious to see how you propose that the state bank pay higher interest on its deposits by adopting a risky investment strategy that private banks consider unprofitable.



Need doesn't even enter into it; it's a question of possible. There is not an investment strategy in the world that could equal California's deficits. What I'm looking for here is some explanation of how your state banking proposal won't actually make those deficits worse.

Your proposal makes no sense at all. Do you know what budget deficits actually are? California has a budget deficit because its revenues are less than its expenditures. It's already not bringing in enough money to pay for all the things it buys.

Your suggestion is that instead of using its revenues to pay off (some of) its expenses, the state should use those revenues to make risky loans--loans that for-profit banks, and profitable banks, should not make.

And then, piling senselessness upon senselessness, you further suggest that by adopting a riskier, less-profitable loan strategy, the state bank should hope to somehow achieve better returns on its investment (your "interest gained") than do banks that turn a profit by avoiding unprofitably risky loan strategies.


Why banking, exactly? If the goal is for the state to enter some profitable market sector, why banking? Why not software development, or aerospace, or oil exploration, or retail?

Come to think of it, why aren't governments just big, profitable corporations already?



No, the state is provably more likely to make gifts instead. Where do you think those budget deficits come from?


You are assuming that this is a new idea, one that has no model to follow. That is not the case.

Here is the Bank of North Dakota
As the only state-owned bank in the nation we act as a funding resource in partnership with other financial institutions, economic development groups and guaranty agencies. We have four established business areas: Student Loans, Lending Services, Treasury Services and Banking Services. BND’s support services and dedicated employees provide you with the best customer service.

From a report titled The Public Option: The Case for Parallel Public Banking Institutions

At the state level, North Dakota has enjoyed the benefits of a public bank since 1919.11 The Bank of North Dakota, the model of a state-owned bank, has operated continuously at a profit and according to conservative banking practices (including relatively modest compensation for the bank’s management). The state deposits its tax revenues in the Bank which in turn ensures that a high portion of state funds are invested in the state economy. In addition, the Bank is able to remit a portion of its earnings back to the state treasury – more than $300 million in the past decade.12 Thanks in part to these institutional arrangements, North Dakota is the only state that has been in continuous budget surplus since before the financial crisis and it has the lowest unemployment rate in the country.
 
You are assuming that this is a new idea, one that has no model to follow. That is not the case.

Here is the Bank of North Dakota

That's everything that a California state bank would NOT be. It's been around for a long time, so the capital costs have already been spent. That wouldn't be the case with California. Furthermore, you have the causality backwards: the state budget isn't in good shape because the bank is well managed, the bank is well managed because it's overseen by a state which can also manage its own budget. But California can't manage its own budget. It would, with virtual certainty, royally screw up an attempt to create a state bank. Especially in the current environment.
 
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/dec/20/hackers-post-cops-personal-data-online/





"Computer hackers are avenging the Occupy movement by exposing the personal information of police officers who evicted protesters and threatening family-values advocates who led a boycott of an American Muslim television show.
In three Internet postings last week, hackers from the loose online coalition called Anonymous published the email and physical addresses, phone numbers and, in some cases, salary details of thousands of law enforcement officers all over the country.
The hackers said they were retaliating for police violence during evictions of Occupy protest camps in cities around the country, but law enforcement advocates slammed the disclosures as dangerous."






Whoa boy, that'll sure make more people want to support OWS!
 
You are assuming that this is a new idea, one that has no model to follow. That is not the case.

Here is the Bank of North Dakota


From a report titled The Public Option: The Case for Parallel Public Banking Institutions

Would you care to answer any of the questions posed by theprestige? I'm genuinely finding this discussion interesting. Incidentally, several critical differences between CA and SD were pointed out earlier.


Sorry, that's from Fox News, so it's automatically biased. Clearly there was some sort of context we're missing, or the people making a fuss don't really represent OWS, or swamp gas reflecting off Venus. Insert subject change here.
 
It affects how much funding the state has available to set up this bank. The state will either have to increase its deficits, or increase its debts.


If the bank holds the revenue, what will the state use to reduce its budget deficits and pay down its existing debt?


Gain from holding the revenue, or from investing the revenue?


The interest earned by money in private banks is the result of private banks investing wisely, and avoiding unprofitably risky investments.

I think we are all curious to see how you propose that the state bank pay higher interest on its deposits by adopting a risky investment strategy that private banks consider unprofitable.



Need doesn't even enter into it; it's a question of possible. There is not an investment strategy in the world that could equal California's deficits. What I'm looking for here is some explanation of how your state banking proposal won't actually make those deficits worse.

Your proposal makes no sense at all. Do you know what budget deficits actually are? California has a budget deficit because its revenues are less than its expenditures. It's already not bringing in enough money to pay for all the things it buys.

Your suggestion is that instead of using its revenues to pay off (some of) its expenses, the state should use those revenues to make risky loans--loans that for-profit banks, and profitable banks, should not make.

And then, piling senselessness upon senselessness, you further suggest that by adopting a riskier, less-profitable loan strategy, the state bank should hope to somehow achieve better returns on its investment (your "interest gained") than do banks that turn a profit by avoiding unprofitably risky loan strategies.


Why banking, exactly? If the goal is for the state to enter some profitable market sector, why banking? Why not software development, or aerospace, or oil exploration, or retail?

Come to think of it, why aren't governments just big, profitable corporations already?



No, the state is provably more likely to make gifts instead. Where do you think those budget deficits come from?

Many of these questions (which are excellent, btw. The reason I brought this idea here) are based on the premise that private banks are not making small business loans only because they are too risky. These same banks have had access to nearly unlimited funds with insanely low interest. For the last three years, their risk has decreased.

During the same period, small business lending by credit unions has increased. So much so that a bill was introduced to raise the cap on lending (by non-profit financial institutions) from 12% to 27% of assets. Small business lending does not necessarily equal dangerous risk.

Although this does raise the question of the tax-status of a state bank.
 
Last edited:
Many of these questions (which are excellent, btw. The reason I brought this idea here) are based on the premise that private banks are not making small business loans only because they are too risky. These same banks have had access to nearly unlimited funds with insanely low interest. For the last three years, their risk has decreased.

During the same period, small business lending by credit unions has increased. So much so that a bill was introduced to raise the cap on lending (by non-profit financial institutions) from 12% to 27% of assets. Small business lending does not necessarily equal dangerous risk.

Although this does raise the question of the tax-status of a state bank.

And it leaves a lot of other questions raised by me and Zig unanswered. For example, several questions under the general heading: What is the point, exactly?

If the point is for the state to increase revenues by investing capital in profitable enterprises, why a bank? Why not a software development firm, or an oil exploration outfit, or a chain of big-box retail stores?

If the point is for the state to stimulate the economy through deficit spending, why a business at all? Why not invest in infrastructure, which is something the citizens need that the private sector can't provide?

And then there's all of Zig's concerns under the general heading: You have a disturbing amount of faith in the people and government of California to get this right. Maybe you don't live here? I do.

And of course there's all the questions under the general heading: Where is the initial capital investment coming from, for this bank?

California is deeply in debt, and it has a chronic budget shortfall.
 
Mission Accomplished!

http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2011/12/21/mayor-calls-for-budget-cuts-to-offset-millions-in-occupy-la-costs/

Repairs to City Hall’s lawn where the Occupy group set up camp on Oct. 1 will require an estimated $400,000. The police action to clear out the encampment on Nov. 30 cost more than $700,000.

Additional expenses are attributed to hauling away debris from the camp, and cleaning up graffiti that defaced City Hall marble walls and trees.

Mayor Villaraigosa says more budget cuts will be necessary to offset the costs.

oh...that...that wasn't the plan was it?
 
I don't know if this has been reported here yet, but they have defined their identity and issues very clearly in their Declaration and Manifesto of the Occupy Wall Street Movement.

A part of the Declaration and Manifesto of the Occupy Wall Street Movement

"We come to you at a time when corporations, which place profit over people, self-interest over justice, and oppression over equality, run our governments. We have peaceably assembled here, as is our right, to let these facts be known.

They have taken our houses through an illegal foreclosure process, despite not having the original mortgage.
They have taken bailouts from taxpayers with impunity, and continue to give Executives exorbitant bonuses.
They have perpetuated inequality and discrimination in the workplace based on age, the color of one’s skin, sex, gender identity and sexual orientation.
They have poisoned the food supply through negligence, and undermined the farming system through monopolization.
They have profited off of the torture, confinement, and cruel treatment of countless animals, and actively hide these practices.
They have continuously sought to strip employees of the right to negotiate for better pay and safer working conditions.
They have held students hostage with tens of thousands of dollars of debt on education, which is itself a human right.
They have consistently outsourced labor and used that outsourcing as leverage to cut workers’ healthcare and pay."

And the list goes on. Read the full document at http://usliberals.about.com/od/soci...-Manifesto-Of-Occupy-Wall-Street-Movement.htm
 
I don't know if this has been reported here yet, but they have defined their identity and issues very clearly in their Declaration and Manifesto of the Occupy Wall Street Movement.... http://usliberals.about.com/od/soci...-Manifesto-Of-Occupy-Wall-Street-Movement.htm

Interesting. I think a lot of the points are certainly debatable, but none of them struck me as being outright laughable.

And a "general assembly" of people actually occupying a public space at or near Wall Street is probably the closest you're going to get to an "official" OWS. I'm willing to stipulate that this is the real OWS, but I wonder how many other current or past participants in this thread will agree with me.

Anyway, if this is the real OWS, then my main concerns are that their idea of "occpuy public spaces" is demonstrably uncivil and undemocratic (something they still haven't realized), and their proposal of government-through-consensus-making is clearly unscalable and also looks like absurdist street theater.
 
I don't know if this has been reported here yet, but they have defined their identity and issues very clearly in their Declaration and Manifesto of the Occupy Wall Street Movement.

A part of the Declaration and Manifesto of the Occupy Wall Street Movement

"We come to you at a time when corporations, which place profit over people, self-interest over justice, and oppression over equality, run our governments. We have peaceably assembled here, as is our right, to let these facts be known.

They have taken our houses through an illegal foreclosure process, despite not having the original mortgage.
They have taken bailouts from taxpayers with impunity, and continue to give Executives exorbitant bonuses.
They have perpetuated inequality and discrimination in the workplace based on age, the color of one’s skin, sex, gender identity and sexual orientation.
They have poisoned the food supply through negligence, and undermined the farming system through monopolization.
They have profited off of the torture, confinement, and cruel treatment of countless animals, and actively hide these practices.
They have continuously sought to strip employees of the right to negotiate for better pay and safer working conditions.
They have held students hostage with tens of thousands of dollars of debt on education, which is itself a human right.
They have consistently outsourced labor and used that outsourcing as leverage to cut workers’ healthcare and pay."

And the list goes on. Read the full document at http://usliberals.about.com/od/soci...-Manifesto-Of-Occupy-Wall-Street-Movement.htm

Wow. That's just so different to all the other infantile nonsense they come out with.

Gotta fight all that colonialism.
 
Last edited:
Wow. That's just so different to all the other infantile nonsense they come out with.

Gotta fight all that colonialism.

"Infantile" is a descriptor of a person not a point or position. Therefore you are attacking the person and not the point through counter-evidence. Not only is this empty of any content, but it is an ad hominen, which is bad form in debate. Ad homs can never win an argument because they don't attack the argument, just the person. Critical Thinking 101 says giving a conclusion AND a reason is the only way to win an argument. For example:

1. "Colonialism is the establishment, maintenance, acquisition and expansion of colonies in one territory by people from another territory."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonialism

2. Nowhere in the above are two territories discussed.
==========================================================
Conclusion: Therefore colonialism can't be what above is about.


Sometimes logic can be fun for it's own sake and an entertaining brain exercise. But it takes a high IQ to use it consistently. And Practice. Practice. Practice.
 
Interesting. I think a lot of the points are certainly debatable, but none of them struck me as being outright laughable.

I sure wish they'd back up their allegations with some examples. I'm wreading that list and asking myself what ? how ?

For instance, point #1 about the foreclosures being illegal. Just how were these forclosures "illegal" ? Does OWS have any proof that illegal acts were committed ? If they do have a case then are they seeking to have it prosecuted ? We are after all, discussing the USA a country that is not shy about putting people in jail.

How, have the corporations sold out privacy as a commodity ? That wouldn't be through someone using a free service like facebook and not doing any research on why facebook is free, would it ?

How, specifically, is alternate energy being blocked to keep us dependent on oil ? Nobody is forcing anyone to use oil, it's just that it's such a convenient form of energy that alternative sources can't come close to equaling. Are occupiers going to stand up for their principals and declare their refusal to fly or ride in a car again, or are they just going to continue to use up the same amount of oil as the rest of us and complain that the corporations are making them do it ?

The corporate media keep us misinformed and fearful ? Hello...occupiers,,,we have access to all the media we want we can make our own decisions thank you. Yes we know about Truthout, Counterpunch, et al. Sometimes we find them to be as questionable as Fox news.

This is typical for occupy and their radical left politics. Wallowing in victimhood, pretending we're all subjugated, enslaved, and miserable because the world doesn't fit their unrealistic childish vision of how things "should" be and how human nature works.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom