Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
IF OWS can learn from their mistakes, and their successes, and honestly address them, than they could be a major success. If they cannot do that, at least they will have raised very valid issues that other groups will take over in solving.

I'm looking foward to what these other groups will do/be. (doobie do be do be do ;))

For myself, I'm currently looking into the viability of a state-owned bank for California. North Dakota has had some success with their state bank. The very basic principal is that CA takes in millions in revenue in taxes, fines and so forth. Right now that money is split up between several major banks. All interest from the money goes to these private banks. It would be better if the interest from that money went to the state of California.

So far, there is only small grassroots support for this idea. I'm hoping to see that expand.
 
For myself, I'm currently looking into the viability of a state-owned bank for California. North Dakota has had some success with their state bank. The very basic principal is that CA takes in millions in revenue in taxes, fines and so forth. Right now that money is split up between several major banks. All interest from the money goes to these private banks. It would be better if the interest from that money went to the state of California.

If it's the State of California that is depositing taxes, fines, etc. into private banks than it's the State of California that's collecting the interest, not the banks.
 
I'm looking foward to what these other groups will do/be. (doobie do be do be do ;))

For myself, I'm currently looking into the viability of a state-owned bank for California. North Dakota has had some success with their state bank. The very basic principal is that CA takes in millions in revenue in taxes, fines and so forth. Right now that money is split up between several major banks. All interest from the money goes to these private banks. It would be better if the interest from that money went to the state of California.

So far, there is only small grassroots support for this idea. I'm hoping to see that expand.

Not a bad idea at all...
 
If it's the State of California that is depositing taxes, fines, etc. into private banks than it's the State of California that's collecting the interest, not the banks.

Interest from money in banks comes from more than just what is paid to the depositor. Banks use money to make money. For example, loaning it out at higher rate than the interest they pay the original depositor. Better that those funds should benefit CA than the banks.
 
Not a bad idea at all...

I do like it. It gives CA desperately needed revenue without raising taxes or cutting spending and it reduces the influence that banks have on the system. A state bank has all citizens as shareholders. Income would not need to be the only concern. A state bank could offer small business loans at a better rate because the gain from a small business would include both the interest on the loan, higher tax income from the business and its employees, as well as secondary financial gain from community redevelopment.
 
Interest from money in banks comes from more than just what is paid to the depositor. Banks use money to make money. For example, loaning it out at higher rate than the interest they pay the original depositor. Better that those funds should benefit CA than the banks.

And what happens when California starts making bad loans, and its debtors start defaulting? What then?

You don't think it's possible that once politicians are in charge of banks, the banks might start making politically-motivated loans? You don't think that politically motivated loans might possibly have higher risks? You can't imagine any way this might possibly backfire in California's face?

Look, EVERY business tries to operate at a profit. What you're basically saying is that California, as a state, should go into business and earn a profit. But why banking? Why not grocery stores? Why not laundromats? Why not auto repair shops? Or does that actually sound like a good idea to you?
 
And what happens when California starts making bad loans, and its debtors start defaulting? What then?

You don't think it's possible that once politicians are in charge of banks, the banks might start making politically-motivated loans? You don't think that politically motivated loans might possibly have higher risks? You can't imagine any way this might possibly backfire in California's face?

Look, EVERY business tries to operate at a profit. What you're basically saying is that California, as a state, should go into business and earn a profit. But why banking? Why not grocery stores? Why not laundromats? Why not auto repair shops? Or does that actually sound like a good idea to you?

As I said, I'm still looking into. Right now the only working model is in North Dakota (Which is, incidentally, not experience the same sort of budget deficit as its neighbors.) There are issues, you've brought up some of them. However, the state already has a budget and it already has systems in place to provide checks and balances with the money that is brought in. A bank regulated by the state to meet the state's needs, instead of those of private shareholders might be beneficial. The bank would have different goals.

Worst case scenario wouldn't be any worse than what the banks have already done to CA.
 
Creating a state bank would be creating a new state department/bureaucracy that would have to be financed by the state. What's the cost-benefit analysis?
 
Last edited:
....

The Tea Party was much better organized, but they only did so by selling their soul and movement to corrupt immoral corporations like the Koch Bros who helped to guide the Tea Party in advocating for higher taxes for the majority of Americans, attacking worker rights, and trying to get rid of programs that have some of the biggest advantages for our economy (education, health care reform, unemployment benefits, etc.).
Sounds ok to many of us non-progressives. Sorry.

The Tea Party may have been an organizational success, but they were the biggest policy disaster group since communism. Despite OWS's problems with violence, extremist radicals, and a lack of a coherent message, they have succeeded in bringing up very valid problems that this Country, and one party in particular have been ignoring.
I'd say a House majority isn't too bad an outcome, but they did help a few Senate Dems win.... dammit.

IF OWS can learn from their mistakes, and their successes, and honestly address them, than they could be a major success. If they cannot do that, at least they will have raised very valid issues that other groups will take over in solving.
I don't see them adding senators or representatives under their banner(s).
 
Creating a state bank would be creating a new state department/bureaucracy that would have to be financed by the state. What's the cost-benefit analysis?

I've been trying to find all of the studies and reports from before ND instituted their bank. Those would probably give the clearest answer to this question.

Although it is pretty easy to see some of the benefits. For example, if a guy gets a $100,000 loan from the state bank of CA, all of those funds benefit the state. He pays a contractor to gut and rebuild a space, buys equipment, hires employees, buys some products and ingredients locally and so forth. All of this stimulates the economy. Even if the business goes under in a year and the loan is not paid back, a large percentage of it has already returned to the state coffers through taxes along the supply line, less unemployment payments, and so forth.

If the same guy borrows from BofA, that loan gets written off and the loss is distributed to the customers of the bank.

A state bank can afford to stimulate the economy because the risk is lower, a private bank can't.
 
As I said, I'm still looking into. Right now the only working model is in North Dakota (Which is, incidentally, not experience the same sort of budget deficit as its neighbors.)

I doubt that their relatively healthy budget has much to do with running a bank, though the reverse might be true. Given California's disatrous budget management, it seems more likely that trying to run a bank would just result in a bank that gets run into the ground, rather than a state enterprise which rescues California.

Worst case scenario wouldn't be any worse than what the banks have already done to CA.

Oh yes it would be. Far worse. Tax payers would be on the hook for vastly larger debts than California already has if bank loans went bad, and unlike the feds, California can't print money.
 
And what happens when California starts making bad loans, and its debtors start defaulting? What then?

You don't think it's possible that once politicians are in charge of banks, the banks might start making politically-motivated loans? You don't think that politically motivated loans might possibly have higher risks? You can't imagine any way this might possibly backfire in California's face?

Look, EVERY business tries to operate at a profit. What you're basically saying is that California, as a state, should go into business and earn a profit. But why banking? Why not grocery stores? Why not laundromats? Why not auto repair shops? Or does that actually sound like a good idea to you?

Well obviously, you would not set up a bank that would callously give out loans without scrutiny, and defaulted lenders would be treated the same way they would under any other bank.

In fact, I don't think a State Bank would have public employees, it would just be a normal bank that would be regulated to benefit the State instead of far off CEOs.

It is also very unlikely that politically motivated loans, or any other conservative created socialism boogymen would be a real risk.


All in all, it is a pretty good idea. Similar to regulated but privatized State energy companies.
 
Well obviously, you would not set up a bank that would callously give out loans without scrutiny

Well obviously the Department of Energy would not loan money to a solar power company without scrutiny.

And yet...

and defaulted lenders would be treated the same way they would under any other bank.

Treating them the same way is rather irrelevant if it's not possible to get the money back.

In fact, I don't think a State Bank would have public employees, it would just be a normal bank that would be regulated to benefit the State instead of far off CEOs.

Like Fannie and Freddie?

How's that working out?

It is also very unlikely that politically motivated loans, or any other conservative created socialism boogymen would be a real risk.

Why not? The incentive would certainly be there.

All in all, it is a pretty good idea. Similar to regulated but privatized State energy companies.

But the profits from those companies don't go to the state. So what's the point? And unlike utilities, banks aren't natural monopolies.
 
Even if OWS did not present that many solutions themselves, getting people talking about it is a great way to find solutions to the problems.

In that sense, OWS has been a great success. The Tea Party was much better organized, but they only did so by selling their soul and movement to corrupt immoral corporations like the Koch Bros who helped to guide the Tea Party in advocating for higher taxes for the majority of Americans, attacking worker rights, and trying to get rid of programs that have some of the biggest advantages for our economy (education, health care reform, unemployment benefits, etc.).

The Tea Party may have been an organizational success, but they were the biggest policy disaster group since communism.

Sounds ok to many of us non-progressives. Sorry.
I never have understood how a Party could be blatantly purchased by corrupt corporations and still be blindly followed without question. When people like the Koch Bros pay to convince people that they should pay more taxes and hurt the economy, it would seem like no one would be crazy or masochistic enough to follow it, but there are people who don't even take the time to consider the rationality of it, because they are told that it is somehow a good idea to do so.

I don't understand how anyone could be that easily duped. Raising taxes on groups that spend the largest percentage and collective quantitative amount of their income on economic spending is a terrible economic idea. Getting rid of programs that have some of the biggest advantages for our economy (education, health care reform, unemployment benefits, etc.) does nothing to help anyone, rich or poor.

That kind of conservative and Republican propaganda that advocates for people to make their lives worse off seems so ridiculous to me, I just don't understand how anyone would ever support it.
 
Well obviously the Department of Energy would not loan money to a solar power company without scrutiny.

And yet...
Or give millions in tax breaks to nuclear and oil, but that is a whole nother matter altogether

Treating them the same way is rather irrelevant if it's not possible to get the money back.
Umm... how is that any different than any other bank?

The only difference is that the bank benefits the State through local development and community investment instead of some far off CEO


Like Fannie and Freddie?

No

Why not? The incentive would certainly be there.
It's an irrelevant boogeyman. There are real risks, that is just not one of them.


But the profits from those companies don't go to the state. So what's the point? And unlike utilities, banks aren't natural monopolies.
There would still be a ton of other banks, so there would be no monopoly, the only difference is that the bank benefits the State through local development and community investment instead of some far off CEO
 
Or give millions in tax breaks to nuclear and oil, but that is a whole nother matter altogether

Actually, it's not. If you think that's an example of government corruption, then it's precisely the sort of thing you should worry about happening when government gets even more involved with the market. Regulatory capture.

Umm... how is that any different than any other bank?

When a bank has loans which default, it's the shareholders who get hurt. You're putting the risk on taxpayers. That's the difference. Well, that's one difference, the other being that the people making the decisions have little incentive to minimize risks. Hell, you're explicitly stating that you want them to run HIGHER risks than private banks (see below).

The only difference is that the bank benefits the State through local development and community investment instead of some far off CEO

So instead of trying to maximize the profits from loans, you want the state-run bank to give out loans which are riskier than private banks would accept, in order to achieve political objectives.

And you really don't see how that could possibly backfire?

It's an irrelevant boogeyman. There are real risks, that is just not one of them.

Go on, pull the other one.

There would still be a ton of other banks, so there would be no monopoly, the only difference is that the bank benefits the State through local development and community investment instead of some far off CEO

Thus taking on risks that private banks decide are too high. Because if the private banks didn't think the risks were too high, they would be making the loans themselves.

Again, you really can't figure out how this could lead to trouble? You can't figure out how this has already cratered our economy?
 
Actually, it's not. If you think that's an example of government corruption, then it's precisely the sort of thing you should worry about happening when government gets even more involved with the market. Regulatory capture.

I would much rather that the government loan oil and nuclear companies money rather than just give it to them.


When a bank has loans which default, it's the shareholders who get hurt. You're putting the risk on taxpayers. That's the difference. Well, that's one difference, the other being that the people making the decisions have little incentive to minimize risks. Hell, you're explicitly stating that you want them to run HIGHER risks than private banks (see below).
Any bank that a State puts its money in is a risk. You are just assuming, that loaning locally is more risky than international loaning (like foreign bonds in say... Greece), or lining the pocket margins of far off CEOs.


So instead of trying to maximize the profits from loans, you want the state-run bank to give out loans which are riskier than private banks would accept, in order to achieve political objectives.

And you really don't see how that could possibly backfire?
Who says that they would not be maximizing profits?

Thus taking on risks that private banks decide are too high. Because if the private banks didn't think the risks were too high, they would be making the loans themselves.

Again, you really can't figure out how this could lead to trouble? You can't figure out how this has already cratered our economy?

Short selling and negligent housing loan practices are why we are in the mess that we are in.

Among other things, these were practices that were supposed to be protected against with regulation that was enacted after the last great depression, but was repealed after a certain Republican party got rid of after it was bought off with campaign donations and dirty lobbyists...

Regulating banks to be more responsible is not more risky, it is what we should have been doing all along.
 
Any bank that a State puts its money in is a risk. You are just assuming, that loaning locally is more risky than international loaning (like foreign bonds in say... Greece), or lining the pocket margins of far off CEOs.

Who says that they would not be maximizing profits?

You did. You explicitly want these banks to operate in a manner other than how private banks operate. Private banks operate to maximize profits. Therefore, you're asking these banks to do something other than maximize profits.

Furthermore, since these local loans that you are demanding are NOT being met by banks currently (otherwise, why would you need to get a state-run bank to make them?), that means that they are worse bets than other available loans (locally or not). You are explicitly calling for banks to make loans which they are currently unwilling to make because they're too risky.

Short selling and negligent housing loan practices are why we are in the mess that we are in.

Short selling is to blame? Hardly. You're deeply ignorant of economics if you think that. And as for negligent housing loan practices, well, that's exactly what you're calling for! You're demanding a state-run bank make loans which private banks think are too risky! You're demanding a repeat of exactly the problem you're mad about. Where the hell is the sense in that?

Regulating banks to be more responsible is not more risky, it is what we should have been doing all along.

Oh, but that's not what we're talking about. We aren't talking about better regulation, more transparency, tighter accounting standards. We're talking about the state taking on the role of banks, in order to accomplish political goals that the private sector is unwilling to perform BECAUSE it's too risky. And you're putting taxpayers on the hook for those loans, and in the process creating a monstrosity of an agency problem.
 
Let's just start with the fact that the financial industry is required for the function of economics.

It is one thing to protest against robo-signing, foreclosure abuses, refusal to lend to new businesses, and large fees, but it is quite another to just blanket blame the banks and "financial industry" without any serious ideas for reform or regulation.

I am against the instituionalized criminal activity of the finance industry and its corrupting influence on governments.

The financial sector has expanded massively over the last three decades and takes far more out of the economy than it puts in.

This is not about getting rid of the banks, it is about reforming and regulating the banks.

I said financial "services" industry, not banks.

without more vocal support for realistic ideas, any meaningful ideas for change to improve the problems of wealth inequality and unemployment gets drowned out by the plethora of radical communist and anarchist ideas that would only make our problems worse off.

Which ideas, specifically, are getting drowned out and how and where?

US casino capitalism is one of the most radical, destructive ideologies the word has ever seen.

The problems are going to get much worse whatever solutions are offered, whether by your personal political bug-bears or by others. The whole system is collapsing like a pack of cards. Capitalism, with its insane and suicidal dependence on ever-increasing debt and perpetual growth has failed.



When they make it a battle against the police and provoke clashes, they lose not only the focus of the movement, but the support of the people.

In what way is assembling peaceably to petition the Government for a redress of grievances in a park and then getting attacked by the police, making it "a battle against the police"?

Short selling and negligent fraudulent housing loan practices are why we are in the mess that we are in.

ftfy.

What about all the other exotic practices of the finance industry and it supposed regulators? Short selling and fraudulent home loans practices represent only only a fraction of their funny money production conveyor belt.

Among other things, these were practices that were supposed to be protected against with regulation that was enacted after the last great depression, but was repealed after a certain Republican party got rid of after it was bought off with campaign donations and dirty lobbyists...


Wikipedia:

"""The bill that ultimately 'repealed' the [Glass-Steagall] Act was brought up in the Senate by Phil Gramm (R-Texas) and in the House of Representatives by Jim Leach (R-Iowa) in 1999. The bills were passed by a Republican majority, basically following party lines by a 54–44 vote in the Senate and by a bi-partisan 343–86 vote in the House of Representatives. After passing both the Senate and House the bill was moved to a conference committee to work out the differences between the Senate and House versions. The final bill resolving the differences was passed in the Senate 90–8 (one not voting) and in the House: 362–57 (15 not voting). The legislation was signed into law by President Bill Clinton on November 12, 1999."""

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

'How the Occupy Movement Has Embraced Liberation Psychology'

"While the term liberation psychology is less commonly known in the United States than in Latin America, the spirit of liberation psychology has been embraced by U.S. Occupy participants.

Liberation psychology, unlike mainstream psychology, questions adjustment to the societal status quo, and it energizes oppressed people to resist all injustices. Liberation psychology attempts to discover how demoralized people can regain the energy necessary to take back the power that they had handed over to illegitimate authorities.
"
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom