Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. "Colonialism is the establishment, maintenance, acquisition and expansion of colonies in one territory by people from another territory."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonialism

2. Nowhere in the above are two territories discussed.
==========================================================
Conclusion: Therefore colonialism can't be what above is about.


Sometimes logic can be fun for it's own sake and an entertaining brain exercise. But it takes a high IQ to use it consistently. And Practice. Practice. Practice.

That would be point 20 on the link you published.
 
Replace "they" with "Jew" and it might illuminate the type of thought process at work.
 
It's really surprising that such a fuss was made about the UC Davis pepper spray incident but not much mention about the man beaten to within an inch of his life, beaten by Occupiers and without a pulse or breath, police gave him CPR and now he is in intensive care:
http://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-n...sf/2011/12/occupy_eugene_faces_early_end.html
Thanks to the police for saving this mans life from the Occupy movement violence and preventing another death. The pathetic perpetrators of this attempted homicide likely still see themselves as victims nevertheless, stomping on other peoples rights and imagining that their rights are taken away which is the irony here.
 
Dick Gregory, who is apparently 14 months into his "liquids only" strike.

The fact that this guy can carry out a hunger strike for 14 months seems to sabotage the point of his effort. If he can subsist on his liquid diet for over a year without suffering any ill effects then why should anyone care whether he does it or for how long?
 
Recent events at Occupy Berkely:

A stabbing.

An attempted rape.

A man on probation for battery nabbed with stolen alcohol, a machete and gas mask.

A brawl involving 30 people broke out after a man dragged a naked woman from a tent and slammed her to the ground. Crowd abused police when they arrived.
 
The fact that this guy can carry out a hunger strike for 14 months seems to sabotage the point of his effort. If he can subsist on his liquid diet for over a year without suffering any ill effects then why should anyone care whether he does it or for how long?

You're not being skeptical (or should I say, cynical) enough. If you look at his hunger strike as an "or else I die" directed towards "the man" then your comment is valid. If you look at it as a "look at how radical I am" directed towards his fellow protestors, it makes perfect sense.
 
That would be point 20 on the link you published.

That wasn't in my post that he quoted and referred to. He quoted my post and then said "Gotta fight all that colonialism." This makes it sound like he was critiquing the posted words he quoted. But like i said nothing like that was in my post. If that is his point then he should have referenced that statement directly as his reason for saying so and left my post out. Then people who never read/memorized Doc will know what he is talking about.
 
That wasn't in my post that he quoted and referred to. He quoted my post and then said "Gotta fight all that colonialism." This makes it sound like he was critiquing the posted words he quoted. But like i said nothing like that was in my post. If that is his point then he should have referenced that statement directly as his reason for saying so and left my post out. Then people who never read/memorized Doc will know what he is talking about.

It was in your link though, let's assume he actually read it.

So then, what does occupy actually mean by colonialism ? If we take an example like, say Levi Strauss operating in Haiti Is this a veiled call for a boycott of Levi Strauss products because the garment workers aren't paid a living wage ?

Maybe they mean some form of cultural colonialism, like 7-11 taking over Thailand with the implication that Thai people should only shop in traditional Thai markets ?

Dunno

Or maybe occupy is so caught up in their own movement and just tossing the word out as a soundbite designed to appeal to those who share their politics, sort of upping the activist cred, if you will.

If occupy want's to communicate with "the masses" they need to clarify their position ie. defend their identity because right now, they seem to be against everything that both the occupiers and "the masses" benefit from.

Corporations are bad...mmmmmkay.
 
It was in your link though, let's assume he actually read it.

So then, what does occupy actually mean by colonialism ? If we take an example like, say Levi Strauss operating in Haiti Is this a veiled call for a boycott of Levi Strauss products because the garment workers aren't paid a living wage ?

Maybe they mean some form of cultural colonialism, like 7-11 taking over Thailand with the implication that Thai people should only shop in traditional Thai markets ?

Dunno

Or maybe occupy is so caught up in their own movement and just tossing the word out as a soundbite designed to appeal to those who share their politics, sort of upping the activist cred, if you will.

If occupy want's to communicate with "the masses" they need to clarify their position ie. defend their identity because right now, they seem to be against everything that both the occupiers and "the masses" benefit from.

Corporations are bad...mmmmmkay.

Yeah I see what you mean. But I don't think they are referring to a corp., Levi Straus operating in a territory like Haiti as 'colonialism' because two territories are not involved. (Levi Straus is not a territory.)

So what can we infer? This part is telling: "We come to you at a time when corporations ... run our governments. We have peaceably assembled here, as is our right, to let these facts be known."

So this appears to label their Prime General Concern as "Corporations ... run our governments."

So still no colonialism per se because they do not mention two territories; their assertion is that "Corporations are running our Governments." This seems to be their Prime General Concern, and then they list specific negative facts about this situation, by bullet points.

One of their negative facts about the "Corporations running our Governments," their Prime General Concern, does in fact refer to "colonialism":

* "They [Corporations] have perpetuated colonialism at home and abroad. They have participated in the torture and murder of innocent civilians overseas."

This seems to refer to Corporations helping the USA in fight in Afghanistan and Iraq. This has the two territories needed for colonialism to possibly apply.

So I guess they are saying that Corporations are participating in and profiting from Countries Colonial conflicts. An example I guess would be the private contractors like Cheney's Corporation.

So I don't think their Prime General Concern can be stated as "Corporations are bad." It's "Corporations are running our Governments." This seems to be the gist of the matter in this new social movement.
 
Last edited:
Meaning then that the government ( as run by corporations ) is guilty of colonialism ? I suppose we could offer up Hawaii as an example of this. Imperialism would be a better description of the supposed motivation of the government in places like Iraq Afghanistan and Libya.

Colonialism usually refers to the situation at home here, the one where "we're" occupying the territory of the ingenious population a very sticky point for occupy Vancouver in their first general assembly.
 
Well more specifically, "perpetuating" colonialism solely for profits. Corporations have a bottom line of profits, not say peace on earth or justice. That they have no corporate concern for. Thus for example they could get into the government business of building prisons and their motive would not be to find ways to keep people from becoming prisoners, or to analyze the justice of jailing people for non-violent behaviors, and finding novel solutions like government experts are supposed to do, and be petitioned to do. They are interested only in getting as many prisoners as possible, no matter what for, in order to profit. So here we can see a glimpse of how things get screwed up and twisted when corporations run governments. Their sole motive and interest is getting profits any way they can. And this makes for a broken government not doing government functions. But I think colonialism is only a small angle on the effect of this, not a main point.

I think their main concern is today corporations are running government by buying elections and lobbying for their product. Thus the people, "the 99%" are cut out of the loop and have no more input or impact. And the corporate government isn't working for them but for the profits of the corporations. The people's concerns are no longer in the loop.

I think most people would agree this is not a healthy situation in a democracy. The other negative outcomes of corporations running government are listed in their bullet points. I think that's what we are witnessing here. The auto industry get bailed out and saved. The bank industry get bailed out and no one arrested for their devious schemes. For them life goes on without any loss and even increases in their lifestyle thanks to the corporation controlled government. But the people who lost their house; the people who lost their jobs, the people who are saddled with huge student debt in this rubble of an economy after the 2008 collapse are forgotten by the government, hung out to dry, by a government in the pocket of corporations, a corporation government who's no longer interested in their concerns, but only concerned about the profits of their puppet master corporations.

Thus there is no more government "of the people, by the people, and for the people" whose jobs are to revolve around the people's concerns and helping them (which is why we pay taxes to them). It has become a government "of the corporations, by the corporations, and for the corporations." Which is no government at all.
 
Last edited:
Yes I agree, corporations have a bottom line of profits, that's what they're for all the peace on earth or justice. is the role of government.

The prison example is an interesting one. Public private partnerships, so called P3s have been shown to have an economic benefit to the taxpayer the problem, however comes if/when there's corruption in the justice system ( government ) causing "innicent" people to be imprisoned. This has already happened IIRC in Pa. with a youth detention center.

None of this, of course, has anything to do with "colonialism"

I'll cite the shutdown of Keystone XL as an example of government listening to the people and putting their interests ahead of corporate profits.

Um yea, the auto industry bailout, for a while there the consumer was demanding those monster SUVs, the ones that plummet in value after only a few short years off the lot. Up went the price of fuel and, suddenly, these things went out of vogue ( remember Hummers ? ) I don't know how many jobs would have been lost had the industry been allowed to fail, millions.

Occupy would get a lot of mileage out of focusing their demands on infrastructure spending rather than complaining.
 
http://townhall.com/columnists/larryelder/2011/12/22/creators_oped

The real reason for the lack of black participation, or lack of participation by anyone else in the Occupy movement, should be simple: a complete rejection of its sole unifying theme, which seems to be "give me some of what 'they' have."

The real reason to reject the Occupy movement is that complaining about "inequality" without regard to how the haves became the haves is a time-waster. Those in the top earning demographic have some things in common: They are more likely than the non-top-20-percenters to have at least a college degree; are married; work long hours; and did not inherit, marry, steal or win their wealth.

The problem is blacks reject the Occupy movement, but not the party whose values reflect its unifying "victicrat" theme. Yet Democrats and the Occupy movement share a common philosophy. Obama said to the Occupiers, "You're the reason I ran for office."

Both believe in empowering government to address "inequality" by redistributing wealth. Both believe that those who achieve great wealth do so through exploitation, which justifies the claim others make on the money.

The economy of the early '80s saw higher inflation, interest rates and unemployment than during the so-called Great Recession. But unlike Obama, President Ronald Reagan deeply and broadly cut taxes, continued deregulation and slowed down the rate of domestic spending. The result? Black adult and teen unemployment fell dramatically, much faster than it did for white adults and teens.

The real question is not why so few blacks belong to the Occupy movement. The real question is why so many blacks still belong to the Democratic Party.
 
http://townhall.com/columnists/larryelder/2011/12/22/creators_oped
The real question is not why so few blacks belong to the Occupy movement. The real question is why so many blacks still belong to the Democratic Party.

Quite simply, the reason that so many African Americans support the Democratic party is that it is in their self interests to do so.

For one, there are major economic advantages from the Democratic party due to its much better support for the middle class, education, and other engines of growth.

Another advantage is that the Democratic party is incredibly more capable in dealing with our foreign policy issues. Since the armed forces include such a high percentage of African Americans, it is much better to have more rational and cooler heads in charge who won't start wars for willy nilly reasons based on faked intelligence.

If the Republican party wanted more support, they should address the major problems in their own positions.

How's that hopey changey thing workin out for ya?
Very well thanks.

We finally have someone in charge who is serious about getting our economy back on track, and he has already made some major improvements and really turned things around after the mess the last guy left. He also was successful in finally dealing with the problems in our health industry, got our troops out of Iraq, created a new GI bill, and vastly improved our image worldwide.

The hopey changey thing is working out quite well indeed. Especially compared to the mentally unbalanced thing going on over on the other side.
 
"Infantile" is a descriptor of a person not a point or position.
False. Very false.

Therefore you are attacking the person and not the point through counter-evidence.
That almost looks like a reasonable sentence. What Virus is saying is that much or most of the "nonsense" OWS comes up with is comparable, in some fashion, to an infant's mewlings.

Not only is this empty of any content, but it is an ad hominen, which is bad form in debate.
No, it's not. Your argument is based on a false premise; your incorrect definition of "infantile". Virus is offering his opinion on the "manifesto", and only by extension the people making it.

Okay, now you're into just full-on irrelevant nonsense and condescension.
 
It's really surprising that such a fuss was made about the UC Davis pepper spray incident but not much mention about the man beaten to within an inch of his life, beaten by Occupiers and without a pulse or breath, police gave him CPR and now he is in intensive care:
http://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-n...sf/2011/12/occupy_eugene_faces_early_end.html
Thanks to the police for saving this mans life from the Occupy movement violence and preventing another death. The pathetic perpetrators of this attempted homicide likely still see themselves as victims nevertheless, stomping on other peoples rights and imagining that their rights are taken away which is the irony here.

Less surprising, for me, than you might think.

#000063bookmark
 
Recent events at Occupy Berkely:

A stabbing.

An attempted rape.

A man on probation for battery nabbed with stolen alcohol, a machete and gas mask.

A brawl involving 30 people broke out after a man dragged a naked woman from a tent and slammed her to the ground. Crowd abused police when they arrived.
I think I've run out of witty ways to say that OWS supporters will say those people aren't True Occupiers, and/or aren't representative.

Maxina Ventura, who helped establish the Occupy Berkeley camp, blamed the deterioration on a small group she said seems bent on violence.
"Most who have been most actively
involved have come to the conclusion that we cannot in good conscience try to defend the camp when people who have created violence, have nothing whatsoever to do with Occupy Berkeley, and who have for weeks said they want a raid, continue to be there, refusing to leave, threatening people in various ways, and stealing from others and the kitchen," Ventura said in a letter she distributed Wednesday. " This does not represent anything which ever has been part of Occupy Berkeley."

Make that past tense.
 
I think I've run out of witty ways to say that OWS supporters will say those people aren't True Occupiers, and/or aren't representative.

I won't buy that dodge from occupy.

If they want to call themselves the 99% they can damn well take all the responsibilities that come along with claiming to speak for everybody and wanting to rebuild society from the ground up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom