Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nope. Yours is off-topic crap, mine is a collection of stupid on-topic "arguments", most if not all of which are found already in this thread. HoverBoarder repeated at least two of them to prove the point. Thanks for that.

Well that's a great way to put your head in the sand.

Which criticisms are you referring to:

- The one about how OWS has no primary coherent point or solutions to actually make any concrete change?

- The one about how OWS refuses to take responsibility for their own actions which allows members to break laws, attack and assault people, rape/sexually assault people, destroy people's property (including people who would support them if they were more in control), and put children on train tracks?

- The one about how OWS has been unable to stay nonviolent?

- The one about the lack of condemnation of radical counterproductive anarchist ideas in OWS like getting rid of corporations, the police, and all money in general?

All of those are very valid criticisms, and OWS will just continue to lose more support and become more ostracized if they do not get serious about addressing their problems instead of just brushing them off.

OWS will have to start acting seriously and responsibly if they want to actually make a real change.

Otherwise, those who may agree with the issue of wealth inequality but not with their radical counterproductive ideas and violent tactics will have to find a responsible and capable group or party that will be able effectively tackle the issues that OWS has rightly brought up, but has been unable or unwilling to effectively, responsibly, and peacefully address themselves.
 
Last edited:
Financial System parasitism??!?



It is that exact kind of lack of focus on realistic ideas and problems that would actually solve the problem of wealth inequality and massive unemployment that is preventing OWS from getting a coherent message out.

Why do you regard acknowledging the parasitic nature of the financial "services" industry as evidence of lack of focus?

IF OWS want to make any kind of real change, they need to get serious and organized with a core message that actually makes sense, and the ability to affect public policy.

in the article that Stout linked to on the OWS news site, the message was that what OWS needed to do was to walk around neighborhoods and help to "remove snow, find used clothes, and clean their yard," and that "With mass media, and especially the new democratized media of social networks, the Internet, anonymous leaks and independent media, it is very likely the end of the rule of money will come more quickly." :covereyes

In the comments section, there were excited comments about how all that needed to be done was just switch to silver as money and "forget big brother." Than all our problems would be solved.

Seriously. It is that kind of disconect from reality and lack of coherent thought that is preventing OWS from being accepted by the public at large.

Whatever, we can get to this when you've answered my fundamental question, above, about the financial sector's economic parasitism.


On the other hand, in the same site, they had an article about The Way to Occupy a Bank is to Own One

A novel idea about setting up city banks that would invest city funds in projects and loans in the city.

It is not a terrible idea and at least it is something that would actually make a difference, but it is also just one idea in a sea of ideas (both bad and good) form OWS that the public cannot wade through.

What OWS should do is to have a site that is dedicated towards voting on what they think should be the main ideas and goals of OWS, and use those ideas to influence policy.

See above. If you are unable to recognize the intrinsically destructive nature of the financial sector then your armchair advice to OWS is worthless.


Yes, it is poor police. Many succesful movements have done so by staying non-violent.

OWS likes to claims that it is most of the time, but do to their chosen lack of leadership and inability to control their members, they have not been able to do so.

Occupy Port protesters violent, officers say

OWS has been an overwhelmingly non-violent movement so far.

Unlike the police:

'Seattle Police Use Excessive Force 20 Percent of Time, Report Says‎'


Which ones, the ones that supported them, or the ones that did not? I have seen plenty of both.

If they didn't support them they would not have respected their community picket.





The poll doesn't ask about whether people support OWS tactics.


It is to the OWS detriment to be leaderless. They cannot control themselves as evidence by their actions.

If they want to make a difference, they have to get serious, stop allowing the anarchists in, stop putting kids on train tracks, stop attacking the police, and start to make a real difference.

They have already made a real difference. They are serious.

It is the police who violently attack people.
 
Last edited:
Oh for crying in the dark... what maudlin BS.
You are not actually saying it is incorrect, I note.

This is not maudlin. There are videos and reports of people being told precisely that.

http://www.redstate.com/snarkandboo...-benefit-of-eviction-is-helping-the-movement/
http://www.dominionpaper.ca/articles/4268
http://www.verumserum.com/?p=32070
http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=47257
http://thefeministwire.com/2011/11/occupy-rape-culture/
FWIW, I resent the implication that the onus is solely on men to stop the rapes. If women are helping to create an atmosphere which encourages it, stop them too. Like this lady;



The reason these are mostly conservative sources is that left-leaning sources, for some reason, don't like to talk about these alleged rapes. And when they do, they are blamed on "outsiders" by commenters. I've stressed before that I think dealing with threats to Occupiers should be a humanitarian concern, not a political one. The people getting hurt come before anything else. I cannot imagine why Occupy is, largely, loathe to do it themselves.
 
They are common. No strawman anywhere. Read this thread. That you can't see the stupidity of them is your problem.

It's not a straw man if the objections presented were, as the cartoonist says, actual objections. It's not a comprehensive list, it is an attempt at showing how stupid the opposition is. Trouble is that the cartoonist should have come here first, because some of what people have posted here is even stupider.
 
Is it stupid to point out all the rapes, violence, fights and how the movement is made up of political extremists who advocate revolution? I'm just wondering why the cartoonist didn't include those criticisms.
 
Last edited:

The funny thing about the cartoon, is that there are a lot of criticisms that I have heard of OWS, but I have never heard anyone make any of the arguments in the cartoon.

That shows just how out of touch with reality some of the people in OWS are when they can't include even one of the many valid criticisms in the comic.

Not having a major coherent point or solution is not the same as not being able to put something in a soundbite. Not being able to stay in control of their radical violent and destructive members is not the same as not wearing neckties.

The writer may have thought that they were funny in writing the cartoon, but it might not have been for the reasons that they wanted. It's the difference of people laughing with them rather than laughing at them. It just shows how far the movement needs to go in growing up and getting serious.

OWS has brought up some valid points about wealth inequality, and I have seen some signs about taxing the rich and focusing on jobs which is all fine and good, but they need to transform themselves into a responsible and realistic political force if they want to make any kind of difference. As it is, political leaders are timid at best in courting a movement, that leaves such high levels of destruction and violence in its wake.
 
... it is an attempt at showing how stupid the opposition is.
It's not even that. Read the first panel carefully: It's actually just the cartoonist claiming (without evidence) that up to ten people in the world are that stupid.

Trouble is that the cartoonist should have come here first, because some of what people have posted here is even stupider.

Trouble is that anybody would take it seriously or try to present it as making a valid point.

Also, if you happen to know of any stupider arguments here in this thread, feel free to cite them so we can all point and laugh.
 
6. Idiot.

I think this one is my favorite. The actual panel reads "[w]hy aren't they wearing neckties, like the civil rights marchers 50 years ago?"

Obviously neckties are largely irrelevant to considerations of the value or competence of a protest movement. What is actually notable about the Freedom Riders, for example, is that they displayed such qualities as leadership, professionalism, careful planning, strategic vision, tactical prudence, and clarity of communication. Most notably, perhaps is the discrimination they applied to staffing their protest actions.

This could be discussed at length and in detail. But for someone who is perhaps not very articulate, who can't quite find the words to describe how they feel that the OWS movement is different from the Civil Rights movment, but who belongs to a generation that places a high premium on "professional" attire, neckties (and the lack thereof) can carry very real and important connotations about the value and competence of a movement.

But of course this cartoonist cares nothing about that. He's not interested in discussing, even in cartoon form, all the rich material for consideration here. How the real Civil Rights movement differs from OWS? Not important. What's important is that the cartoonist makes sure to include in his straw-man variety pack at least one glib dismissal of that entire line of discussion.

You think OWS could learn a thing or two from Martin Luther King? You're just a necktie-fetishizing hater.
 
In like manner, the entire course of discussion regarding consensus and consistency of message is dismissed with a glib strawman about not having an "official media spokesman".
 
What ever happened to that half million OWS was supposed to have in the bank credit union ?
 
What ever happened to that half million OWS was supposed to have in the bank credit union ?

What OWS? How do we even know that those people with that money are even a part of the true OWS? Speaking of which, do we even know what that money is supposed to be buying? Do the people spending it, at least, have a specific, concrete message?
 
What OWS? How do we even know that those people with that money are even a part of the true OWS? Speaking of which, do we even know what that money is supposed to be buying? Do the people spending it, at least, have a specific, concrete message?

THE OWS, not these reasonable facsimiles but the REAL one in the REAL NYC.

I just hope it's not earning any of that evil interest, money created out of thin air ya' know and if they're seeking to redistribute the wealth as per one of their original mandates, I just thought I might toss my name in the had as someone who really needs some of that redistributable, idle wealth.
 
Why do you regard acknowledging the parasitic nature of the financial "services" industry as evidence of lack of focus?

Let's just start with the fact that the financial industry is required for the function of economics.

It is one thing to protest against robo-signing, foreclosure abuses, refusal to lend to new businesses, and large fees, but it is quite another to just blanket blame the banks and "financial industry" without any serious ideas for reform or regulation.

This is not about getting rid of the banks, it is about reforming and regulating the banks.

without more vocal support for realistic ideas, any meaningful ideas for change to improve the problems of wealth inequality and unemployment gets drowned out by the plethora of radical communist and anarchist ideas that would only make our problems worse off.

It is the police who violently attack people.
When they make it a battle against the police and provoke clashes, they lose not only the focus of the movement, but the support of the people.
 
THE OWS, not these reasonable facsimiles but the REAL one in the REAL NYC.

I just hope it's not earning any of that evil interest, money created out of thin air ya' know and if they're seeking to redistribute the wealth as per one of their original mandates, I just thought I might toss my name in the had as someone who really needs some of that redistributable, idle wealth.

Actually, it is gaining interest in a credit union, in part by being lent out to small businesses that "real" banks won't bother with and non-predatory home loans. In this way those donations are helping the people of the local community while supporting the OWS office space.

It's pretty cool what you can do with money besides stick it in an overseas account. ;)

OWS as a nationwide movement is in flux right now. The physical action worked for the first goal - to bring attention to economic injustice and the undue effect of corporate sponsorship on our elected officials. The problems are still there, of course. These issues are too large to be solved in a few months.

The next step is undecided, it will be chaotic for a while. Many supporters of OWS will focus on smaller or local issues. There will be other types of activism inspired by OWS but unrelated that will pull occupiers.

This thread has over 100 pages and this is one teeny, tiny corner of the internet. People are talking, even if they don't agree with the tactics of OWS. The original OWS achieved that much. The final occupiers will entertain the detractors for a while. The supporters will be in a better position to recognize the next step. Although my involvement with OWS has ended, I am satisfied with the outcome.
 
This thread has over 100 pages and this is one teeny, tiny corner of the internet. People are talking, even if they don't agree with the tactics of OWS. The original OWS achieved that much. The final occupiers will entertain the detractors for a while. The supporters will be in a better position to recognize the next step. Although my involvement with OWS has ended, I am satisfied with the outcome.

Being famous for being famous only counts as a success if that was your goal all along. Not that it's not a viable business model, but in a world that already has Paris Hilton, Kim Kardashian, and Lady GaGa, do we really need an OWS that prides itself on the same accomplishment?
 
Being famous for being famous only counts as a success if that was your goal all along. Not that it's not a viable business model, but in a world that already has Paris Hilton, Kim Kardashian, and Lady GaGa, do we really need an OWS that prides itself on the same accomplishment?

That is (obviously) not how I see it. There have been changes in tone unrelated to OWS - Ivy League students looking down on recruiters for the finance industry, polls that show more Americans are frustrated with corporate influence, my ridiculously Republican sister getting miffed at Walmart, people quoting Elizabeth Warren, the huge amount of people who switched to credit unions from banks, and a bunch of other little issues that were not even in our collective consciousness prior to OWS.

Social issues take time, often years. I never expected OWS to fix things.
 
Actually, it is gaining interest in a credit union, in part by being lent out to small businesses that "real" banks won't bother with and non-predatory home loans. In this way those donations are helping the people of the local community while supporting the OWS office space.

It's pretty cool what you can do with money besides stick it in an overseas account. ;)

OWS as a nationwide movement is in flux right now. The physical action worked for the first goal - to bring attention to economic injustice and the undue effect of corporate sponsorship on our elected officials. The problems are still there, of course. These issues are too large to be solved in a few months.

The next step is undecided, it will be chaotic for a while. Many supporters of OWS will focus on smaller or local issues. There will be other types of activism inspired by OWS but unrelated that will pull occupiers.

This thread has over 100 pages and this is one teeny, tiny corner of the internet. People are talking, even if they don't agree with the tactics of OWS. The original OWS achieved that much. The final occupiers will entertain the detractors for a while. The supporters will be in a better position to recognize the next step. Although my involvement with OWS has ended, I am satisfied with the outcome.

Fair enough, I will definitely agree that OWS succeeded in getting people to talk about very real problems that affect everyone in the Country.

Even if OWS did not present that many solutions themselves, getting people talking about it is a great way to find solutions to the problems.

In that sense, OWS has been a great success. The Tea Party was much better organized, but they only did so by selling their soul and movement to corrupt immoral corporations like the Koch Bros who helped to guide the Tea Party in advocating for higher taxes for the majority of Americans, attacking worker rights, and trying to get rid of programs that have some of the biggest advantages for our economy (education, health care reform, unemployment benefits, etc.).

The Tea Party may have been an organizational success, but they were the biggest policy disaster group since communism. Despite OWS's problems with violence, extremist radicals, and a lack of a coherent message, they have succeeded in bringing up very valid problems that this Country, and one party in particular have been ignoring.

IF OWS can learn from their mistakes, and their successes, and honestly address them, than they could be a major success. If they cannot do that, at least they will have raised very valid issues that other groups will take over in solving.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom