Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're right. The 21st Amendment was ratified very fast, in only 10 months. Bobby Sands, the IRA hunger striker, died after just 66 days on a huger strike.

In addition, Congress will go on holiday recess in a few days and won't be back in session again until at least January 3. This is nothing but a pathetic PR stunt.

Let me be the first to predict that come January, inquiries into the status of the hunger strike will be met with some variation on "we put the strike on hold during the winter break, but it's back in effect now and/or the strike was always in effect in spirit and/or it's not the strike itself but the thought that counts and/or we made our point and sent our message and now it's up to the legislature to respond in the same spirit".
 
Let me be the first to predict that come January, inquiries into the status of the hunger strike will be met with some variation on "we put the strike on hold during the winter break, but it's back in effect now and/or the strike was always in effect in spirit and/or it's not the strike itself but the thought that counts and/or we made our point and sent our message and now it's up to the legislature to respond in the same spirit".

In essence, a 'lunch break' for the hunger strike. :D
 
Local church sympathizes with Occutards. Occutards demand to use church's land. Church says no. Occutards try and break in and take it anyway.

Of course, if they don't get what they demand, they just try to steal it. Last week they stole a house in Brooklyn. A house that wasn't in foreclosure, a house that wasn't owned by a bank. It was just vacant so they stole it.
 
20sfuyb.png
 
Let me be the first to predict that come January, inquiries into the status of the hunger strike will be met with some variation on "we put the strike on hold during the winter break, but it's back in effect now and/or the strike was always in effect in spirit and/or it's not the strike itself but the thought that counts and/or we made our point and sent our message and now it's up to the legislature to respond in the same spirit".

That's too coherent for this bunch of drama queens. It seems that a few years ago of the hunger strikers circumcised himself with a dull knife during a performance piece. He had better hope the Occupy Foreskin folks don't hear about this!

And Congress doesn't reconvene on January 3, it's January 17.

Article is ok but video is NSFW:
http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/blogs/citydesk/2007/04/30/the-dismemberment-plan/
 
Last edited:
That's how I feel.

The desire to create a more balanced economic state with a more capable, competitive, and strong middle class is something that would help everyone in the Country, including the 1%, but it is the way that the OWS protesters are delivering that message (if that is their message), that is counterproductive.

It's strange that there is no mention of financial industry parasitism and criminality in your rosy review of the state of the "Country"!

Financial System parasitism??!?

It is that exact kind of lack of focus on realistic ideas and problems that would actually solve the problem of wealth inequality and massive unemployment that is preventing OWS from getting a coherent message out.

IF OWS want to make any kind of real change, they need to get serious and organized with a core message that actually makes sense, and the ability to affect public policy.

in the article that Stout linked to on the OWS news site, the message was that what OWS needed to do was to walk around neighborhoods and help to "remove snow, find used clothes, and clean their yard," and that "With mass media, and especially the new democratized media of social networks, the Internet, anonymous leaks and independent media, it is very likely the end of the rule of money will come more quickly." :covereyes

In the comments section, there were excited comments about how all that needed to be done was just switch to silver as money and "forget big brother." Than all our problems would be solved.

Seriously. It is that kind of disconect from reality and lack of coherent thought that is preventing OWS from being accepted by the public at large.


On the other hand, in the same site, they had an article about The Way to Occupy a Bank is to Own One

A novel idea about setting up city banks that would invest city funds in projects and loans in the city.

It is not a terrible idea and at least it is something that would actually make a difference, but it is also just one idea in a sea of ideas (both bad and good) form OWS that the public cannot wade through.

What OWS should do is to have a site that is dedicated towards voting on what they think should be the main ideas and goals of OWS, and use those ideas to influence policy.

Provoking clashes with the police, preventing people from being able to work, failing to control the extremist and law breaking members does nothing to help their message.
Aw, poor police! They just can't control themselves!
Yes, it is poor police. Many succesful movements have done so by staying non-violent.

OWS likes to claims that it is most of the time, but do to their chosen lack of leadership and inability to control their members, they have not been able to do so.

Occupy Port protesters violent, officers say

Seattle police say the level of open violence toward officers at Monday's Occupy the Port protest hasn't been seen since the World Trade Organization was here in 1999.

"It's been a long time since we've seen people throwing things that could kill people, not since WTO," said Asst. Chief Mike Sanford at a news conference Thursday. "We've seen debris thrown, but ... not bricks, not sharpened rebar, not things that would kill somebody."

Sanford spoke while airing a five-minute video shot by civilian employees of the Police Department during Monday's protest, which was part of an effort to shut down ports along the West Coast.


The 5 p.m. melee in which Helmiere claimed to be assaulted happened near the Terminal 18 entrances where Sanford said a group of people who were "bent on being violent" had cut through a fence and built a barricade in the road of wood, metal and debris.

When police moved to clear the street, someone in the crowd of demonstrators tossed a lit flare at them, and police then rushed to seize people. The police video shows items identified by Sanford as bricks flying through the air and paper bags filled with paint littering the ground.

Sanford said flares, smoke grenades and sticks also were thrown at police.

He said police released "blast balls," concussive devises, into the crowd.

In all, 11 people were arrested on investigation of failure to disperse, assaulting an officer and obstruction, police said. Helmiere was among them.



Sanford, who said he watched the melee unfold in front of him, said he was "surprised at the level of violence." He said there's a "difference between peaceful picketing ... and violent, illegal picketing."

For officers standing the line, "it's scary and it's dangerous" to see objects thrown at you from the crowd, he said.

He said that the Occupy movement, which began in New York as a protest against what was seen as immoral tactics used by Wall Street to gain wealth, have been primarily peaceful.

Sanford suggested that demonstrators who want to protect the purity of the movement's message may want to help police identify those who threw objects at officers.

"Help us identify those people," he said. "That is not the message that Occupy Seattle wants to get out."



The dock workers supported OWS action in closing down ports and respected their community picket line.

How do you think workers have any rights at all the the West?!

Which ones, the ones that supported them, or the ones that did not? I have seen plenty of both.

OWS went in one month from a movement that had broad National support, to one that lost that majority of support in a mere month. It was not the message that made them lose that support, but their tactics.
Evidence?!

http://blog.seattlepi.com/seattlepolitics/2011/11/16/support-for-occupy-wall-street-drops-in-poll/

Public support for the Occupy Wall Street movement is down and opposition up sharply in a new national survey taken by the Democratic-leaning firm of Public Policy Polling.

“What the downturn in Occupy Wall Street’s image suggest is that voters are seeing the movement as more about ‘Occupy’ than ‘Wall Street.’ The controversy over the protests is starting to drown out the actual message,” wrote Tom Jensen of Public Policy Polling.

Jensen reported, however, that public support remains high for raising taxes on the wealthy and taking away their multiple tax breaks.

Tactics not the core message of wealth inequality.


OWS brings up some valid points, but if they want to make something out of it, they need to get organized and start electing leaders with clear goals and mandates to make a real difference.
The electoral process has been hijacked and corrupted by big money. That's how a fake like Obama can get elected and get away with it.

The movement is having strong political impact (see posts above).

It is deliberately leaderless. Understand this.

It is to the OWS detriment to be leaderless. They cannot control themselves as evidence by their actions.

If they want to make a difference, they have to get serious, stop allowing the anarchists in, stop putting kids on train tracks, stop attacking the police, and start to make a real difference.
 
I was saying "your" comic is full of straw men. Occupy oft complains about how they're being judged by the outliers, but the comic implies the opinions depicted are common, including denigrating the people who made them by caricature. Also, just because an argument is common doesn't mean it is wrong. Why "stupidest objections"? Why not "stupidest criticisms"?

In fact, let me see if I can turn all of these into better arguments.

1. Actual common complaint: Pointing out that America is the 1% on a global scale, yet there seems to be little concern about that within the movement.
2. Actual common complaint: lack of leadership within the movement.
3. Except for the "clothes" bit, that's pretty accurate. Protestors say they want corporations to have less power, yet they're still purchasing stuff from them.
4. Valid question.
5. Far-right stereotype, though one that is actually encountered.
6. Idiot.
7. Difference between "poorly researched" and "liar", I admit.
8. Good question. Maybe they feel protesting is more important. Maybe they don't have jobs.
9. Funny thing; I've heard OWS bleat about "agent provocateurs". Same basic argument, different direction.
10. Actual common complaint: Why can't OWS summarize its intent and message in more than the vaguest of terms?

Now if you'll excuse me, I have to draw a comic about all the OWS supporters who think Megyn Kelly should be hit with pepper spray.
 
The comic makes no mention of the rapes, the violence, the riots, the vandalism or the political extremists associated with the movement.

I guess they just picked the easy stuff.
 
It's obvious they cared less about the rapes than about how it would affect their image.
 
The awards just keep on coming:

The growing scrutiny of the rich dominated this year’s best quotes, according to a Yale University librarian who anointed the Occupy Wall Street protesters’ slogan — “We are the 99 percent” — as the year’s best.

Fred Shapiro, associate librarian at Yale Law School, has released his sixth annual list of the most notable quotations of the year.

It's not always a compliment to be chosen; remember a couple years back, "Don't tase me, bro!" won the prize.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom