Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Video of the December 7th raid on Occupy SF. It's 21 minutes long and if you don't want to watch it all, forward to the echo speech at the 11:30 mark. Pure gold. There aren't enough laughing dogs.



I guess the video is supposed to show our brutal SFPD in action, but I don't see any misconduct. I also don't see the assault on a police officer that resulted in two occutards up on felony charges. Funny that.

Two protesters were arrested on suspicion of felony assault on a police officer. The suspects hurled a metal chair at a cop wearing a helmet, breaking the shield protecting his face, Esparza said. The cop was not injured.
http://www.sfexaminer.com/local/cri...an-francisco-police-70-arrested#ixzz1gc7c7msG
 
When did this happen?
Someone on the LA Times said that the Unions are not allowed to officially endorse protests, for fear of breach of contract. So they have to officially decry it while giving their approval under the table.

I asked the guy how he would know the difference between the union calling them out as a pretense and calling OWS out for real.

He never responded.
 
New Zealand police abide by the law:

"I am the Area Commander for Auckland City Central Police and the officer in charge of the Police response to the current occupation of Aotea Square.
...

Police is aware that Council has issued trespass notices to the occupiers of Aotea Square. Having considered all the circumstances, including that the occupiers are protestors exercising rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of expression, Police has formed the view that there is not currently legal justification for Police to forcibly remove those in the square pursuant to criminal trespass.
...

Andrew D Coster
Inspector
"



http://hphotos-sea1.fbcdn.net/hphot...46145_294717643871646_1452545_547271594_o.jpg
 
BTW, it is possible stop a train safely, get a 6' wire with clip leads on the ends, and clip one end to each rail. In many places (not in "dark territory" and not in PTC blocks) this will cause the signals at either side of the signal block to go to red.

Then, even if trains get approval from dispatch they can traverse the block only at restricted speed.

And instead of getting killed you will only have committed a crime under 18 U.S.C. 1992.a.5 - "Terrorist attacks and other violence against railroad carriers and against mass transportation systems on land, on water, or through the air" - up to 20 years in the slammer.
 
Someone on the LA Times said that the Unions are not allowed to officially endorse protests, for fear of breach of contract. So they have to officially decry it while giving their approval under the table.

I asked the guy how he would know the difference between the union calling them out as a pretense and calling OWS out for real.

He never responded.

Are you taking about the comments section?
 
Video of the December 7th raid on Occupy SF. It's 21 minutes long and if you don't want to watch it all, forward to the echo speech at the 11:30 mark.

Heh, love the vagina monologue; even her fellow protestors balk a bit at that part.
 
New Zealand police abide by the law:

"...there is not currently legal justification for Police to forcibly remove those in the square pursuant to criminal trespass.
...

Andrew D Coster
Inspector[/I]"

If they proceed to turn the park into an odiferous biohazard, I'm sure things will change as they did in NYC.
 
...

I consider that part of your username the equivalent of a nickname, such as "Calamity" Jane, "Wild" Bill Hickok, or beloved Sesame Street character "Forgetful" Jones. I also call Leftysergeant "Lefty, BenBurch "Ben", NoahFence "Noah", and so on. I will call you "Jihad" in the future.

...
IIRC, Jane doesn't like that, and there's an older thread in Forum Management Feedback to that effect. I vaguely recall the mods agreeing with her on that point.

ps. You can call me Al, or Bell, or AlBell. :D
 
Occupy goes into damage control mode.

http://owsnews.org/occupy-is-not-ju...is-not-to-occupy-it-is-to-end-corporate-rule/

What to do next? The Occupy Movement needs to bring participatory democracy to communities. Occupiers should develop an aggressive organizing plan for their city. Divide the city and appoint people to be responsible for different areas of the city. Depending on how many people you have make these areas as small as possible. Develop plans for house-to-house campaigns where you knock on doors, provide literature, ask what you can do to make their lives better. Do they need snow removed? Clothes? If so, get the occupy team to fulfill their needs, find used clothes, clean their yard – whatever you can do to help. This shows community and builds relationships.

Excellent, they're finally doing something other than complaining. What are the chances I could get them to wax the Ferraris ?
 
Update on the Washington hunger strikers:
One week into their hunger strike for District of Columbia voting rights in Congress, Joe Gray and Kelly Mears have lost 20 pounds each. Fellow strikers Adrian Parsons and Sam Jewler, who had wiry frames to begin with, have dropped 10 and 8 pounds, respectively.

Congress is consumed with last-minute budget negotiations ahead of its winter recess, meaning the hunger strikers likely would have to wait until January to see even incremental progress.

“We want them to leave with that looming over their heads,” said Parsons, a 29-year-old artist. “Go back to your families, go back to your states, where there are representatives, and understand that you’re leaving 600,000 citizens disenfranchised.”
I doubt the congressional representatives will feel anything looming over their heads.

The New York hunger strikers aren't getting much press compared to their DC brethren, but they claim to be on day 14 of their strike.
They say their hunger strike is for “space” which according to Diego Ibanez, one of the hunger strikers is not a “mere necessity- a place to lay our head, to eat our meals, to congregate and assemble” but is also “a symbol and a direct action.”

The strikers encouraged participants to use the national strike to “remember” all those occupation activists that have been evicted, and those who are currently on hunger strikes around the world.

Congressman Keith Ellison beclowns himself by taking the day off from the buffet table:

Rep. Keith Ellison, D-Minn., embarked on a 24-hour hunger strike in solidarity with four Occupy DC protesters who have gone without food since Dec. 8 to advocate for D.C. voting rights.
 
Wouldn't giving DC a Congressional vote require a constitutional amendment? I'm fairly certain the Constitution specifies that voting in Congess is for states.
 
Starving yourself until 3/4 of states ratify an Amendment is a pretty stupid thing to do. Even the repeal of Prohibition took the better part of a year. These kids are living in a dream world.
 
Starving yourself until 3/4 of states ratify an Amendment is a pretty stupid thing to do. Even the repeal of Prohibition took the better part of a year. These kids are living in a dream world.

They'd have better luck trying to get the Child Labor Amendment (Wikipedia) passed as there is no 'clock' on the ratification process, unlike the last attempt at giving DC Voting Rights (Wikipedia), which did have such a 'clock'.

It makes me wonder just what Americans are learning about their constitutional history...
 
Yes, I do. I also do not think that John Pike, on the morning of November 18th, 2011, when pepper spraying obstructive students after several warnings and attempts to use lesser force by himself and other officers, was acting in a sadistic manner, nor can it be positively determined or indicated he had sadistic motivations.

I agree. The converse is also true, which was why the poster brought up the possibility of sadism in the first place in response to your non-sequitur.

Not necessary for the police to use force, much less pepper spray. It is interesting how you keep reading "threatened police" as "were violent toward police".

What harm was likely to befall the the police from these dangerous seated students had the police not resorted to their traditional brutality and handed the Occupy movement another PR gift?

By "actions were dictated by a few chants", you mean "response was to an angry crowd surrounding, obstructing, and threatening police", I assume. Because that is what I'm arguing, not that they were responding to "a few chants".

Where did your information that they weren't going to remain peaceful if the police didn't let their friends go, if not from a few chants?

Again, good with words. Fair lady, I did seek to contrast mine brevity with needless loquacity, for purposes of jest. Methinks thou protest too much about th'omission of five letters.

I haven't protested at all. I simply asked you why, because I am curious to know.

When I wrote it, it was because I didn't feel like writing "Jihad".

Why not?

I consider that part of your username the equivalent of a nickname, such as "Calamity" Jane, "Wild" Bill Hickok, or beloved Sesame Street character "Forgetful" Jones. I also call Leftysergeant "Lefty, BenBurch "Ben", NoahFence "Noah", and so on. I will call you "Jihad" in the future.

How is does this support your claim that the reason you needed to alter my screenname was because you are lazy?

Yep. I indicated. I did not state. I said 'crowd' was "more neutral" than 'mob'. Sitting in one's living room is safer than making dinner in the kitchen, but both are considered "safe". This does not entirely remove the possibility that I was saying mob was not neutral, but it also does not mean that I was saying it was neutral.

Since you still haven't asked me whether I was using it in a neutral manner; I wasn't. I used "mob" in the sense which indicates unruliness and disorder, along with the connotations of "mob mentality", wherein people act in unison with the group in which they are a part. Often times, this is in a fashion they would not behave alone. I used it to indicate the crowd/mob was acting in an irrational manner which they nonetheless bear responsibility for.

I.e spin, i.e propagandistic.

In what way was using the word "crowd" rather than "mob" to my benefit?


I don't watch videos where there no indiction of their content.

So! Would you care to prove, with affirmative evidence, that John Pike was acting out of sadism? Nothing about what you or anyone else "think" the look on his face was.

No, because proving it is irrelevant to why the poster brought up the possibility of sadism in the first place. It was offered only as a possibility in response to your dogmatic non-sequitur.


Originally Posted by AlBell:

IIRC, Jane doesn't like that, and there's an older thread in Forum Management Feedback to that effect. I vaguely recall the mods agreeing with her on that point.


"JJ", then.

AlBell remembers incorrectly. I didn't say I didn't like it and the moderators were not, in the end, supportive of my position. I said I liked it because it gave me license to play around with other people's screenames in an amusing manner. Unfortunately Darat then invented a new rule saying that I'm not allowed to do it but everyone else is, without fear of sanction, 063.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Originally Posted by carlitos

Starving yourself until 3/4 of states ratify an Amendment is a pretty stupid thing to do. Even the repeal of Prohibition took the better part of a year. These kids are living in a dream world.

There were objections when people referred to Pepperspray Pike's victims as "kids"...
 
Last edited:
J.Jane, I'm not responding to your nitpicking strawmanning nonsense any more.

Using a word with a particular implication is not necessarily "spin", it is called "using language". I sincerely believe that the crowd was also a mob, a claim which you have not actually contested, only decried.

If there is no evidence for or against sadism, and evidence for the police acting in a professional and standards appropriate manner, the question of sadism as a motivator should be tabled, barring the introduction of new evidence. You are attempting to conflate the possible with the probable, a favored tool of the sophist. In fact, you used this "the cops could've..." canard earlier, to which I responded that they "could've" done handstands in red noses.

It doesn't matter what it was "in response" to if there's stronger (in this case, any) evidence for something else. My point from the start has been there's no evidence of sadism, just a possibility, so the question should be set aside.

The seated students may or may not have been a threat. What is clear, however, is that they were deliberately obstructing the transport of prisoners, and were hostile to police. The police could either leave the prisoners behind, use force to remove the obstructors, or just hang about in the middle of a hostile crowd and hope they don't attack. The second option carries the least risk of harm to the cops, the crowd, and the prisoners. The officers attempted to use force lesser than pepper spray, and it was ineffective. Anything else was unavailable due to the linked-arm configuration, or would require stronger force than pepper spray.

You ignore video evidence unless someone tells you what it is ahead of time. That does not speak well for your ability to seek out information on your own, or your assessment of such information.

I note how you selectively quoted my post, and say that the students actively saying they might harm the police if their demands weren't met is just "a few chants". The content of those few chants is consistently glossed over in your posts.

Basically, you're not willing to have your mind changed, and will argue up and down and left and right to ignore facts you don't like. There is plenty of evidence in this thread if anyone needs to make an informed decision.
 
I've already run into Occupy-sympathizers claiming that the Egyptian revolution was part of the "occupy" movement. A little historical revision for you.

Indeed. About 1,000 people died in the Egyptian revolution, about 35,000 in the ongoing "Arab Spring". Is this what the Occupy movement wants for the rest of the world?
 
Starving yourself until 3/4 of states ratify an Amendment is a pretty stupid thing to do. Even the repeal of Prohibition took the better part of a year. These kids are living in a dream world.

You're right. The 21st Amendment was ratified very fast, in only 10 months. Bobby Sands, the IRA hunger striker, died after just 66 days on a huger strike.

In addition, Congress will go on holiday recess in a few days and won't be back in session again until at least January 3. This is nothing but a pathetic PR stunt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom