Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
The word "occupy" does not appear in that article, and that protest isn't even tangentially related to the "Occupy" movement. Thanks for noting how this brave village's efforts to throw off the yoke of their communist oppressors, though. :)

I've already run into Occupy-sympathizers claiming that the Egyptian revolution was part of the "occupy" movement. A little historical revision for you.
 
Those protests have no resemblance to the Occupy Wall Street crowd, and they aren't acting on inspiration from OWS either. Which you'd know if you had read the article. But maybe you do know, and just aren't being honest. I'll let you tell us which one.

But... but.. they're protesting! ;)
 
Occupiers' planned meeting with progressive Democrats called off when the media learns of the powwow:

“Due to a leak from within the caucus, press were alerted to our Occupy guests this week,” he wrote in an email obtained by Roll Call. “Our guests will now not be participating in the Member meeting. ... All internal communications are OFF THE RECORD.”

The progs wanted to embrace the message, not the messengers:
“I think that there is a distinction that needs to be made between embracing Occupiers and embracing the issues and the struggle that they have brought to the forefront of the national agenda,” said Rep. Raúl Grijalva (Ariz.), co-chairman of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, in a statement to Roll Call.
Can't blame him, given that the distinction is that the Occupiers smell like rotting fish.

We do get an update on one of the hunger strikers in DC:
Sam Jewler, a member of the Occupy DC group based in McPherson Square, seemed skeptical when he heard about the meeting with the Progressive Caucus. “No idea who they are, but very intrigued,” he said in an email sent from a sit-in at Speaker John Boehner’s (R-Ohio) office six days into a hunger strike aimed at winning the District full Congressional voting rights. “This is a serious new step in the Occupy movement, bound to be controversial within it.”
 
Please folks, never never never, no matter the strength of your convictions, put a child into some kind of situation like this. It's only going to make you look bad. Don't take the kiddies to Folsom Street Fair, don't put'em in the path of oncoming trains, don't hold them in front of you as you sass the police.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZKa4ibE9SAg&feature=player_embedded

I think if you look up the word "wuss" in the dictionary, you'll find his picture.
 
The progs wanted to embrace the message, not the messengers:

That's how I feel.

The desire to create a more balanced economic state with a more capable, competitive, and strong middle class is something that would help everyone in the Country, including the 1%, but it is the way that the OWS protesters are delivering that message (if that is their message), that is counterproductive.

Provoking clashes with the police, preventing people from being able to work, failing to control the extremist and law breaking members does nothing to help their message.

OWS went in one month from a movement that had broad National support, to one that lost that majority of support in a mere month. It was not the message that made them lose that support, but their tactics.

OWS brings up some valid points, but if they want to make something out of it, they need to get organized and start electing leaders with clear goals and mandates to make a real difference.
 
That's how I feel.

The desire to create a more balanced economic state with a more capable, competitive, and strong middle class is something that would help everyone in the Country, including the 1%, but it is the way that the OWS protesters are delivering that message (if that is their message), that is counterproductive.

It's strange that there is no mention of financial industry parasitism and criminality in your rosy review of the state of the "Country"!

Provoking clashes with the police, preventing people from being able to work, failing to control the extremist and law breaking members does nothing to help their message.

Aw, poor police! They just can't control themselves!

The dock workers supported OWS action in closing down ports and respected their community picket line.

How do you think workers have any rights at all the the West?

OWS went in one month from a movement that had broad National support, to one that lost that majority of support in a mere month. It was not the message that made them lose that support, but their tactics.

Evidence?

OWS brings up some valid points, but if they want to make something out of it, they need to get organized and start electing leaders with clear goals and mandates to make a real difference.

The electoral process has been hijacked and corrupted by big money. That's how a fake like Obama can get elected and get away with it.

The movement is having strong political impact (see posts above).

It is deliberately leaderless. Understand this.
 
Last edited:
1. "Could be". "Might have".
2. Godwin's.
3. Nazi =/= Sadist.

So you don't think the police can be institutionally sadistic within the law?

They said that if the prisoners were released, they'd 'continue to protest peacefully'. It's like saying 'If you'll give me a down payment on what you owe, I'll continue to ask nicely.' The clear indication is that if the demands are not met, they will stop protesting peacefully or asking nicely. That's a threat.

Where's the violence? Where is your evidence that the police actions were dictated by a few chants?

I'm lazy.

No, you're not:

It is I notice you don't include the actual standard definition. That is, a group of people acting in an unruly and often unlawful manner.

I'm not sure if you noticed, but I'm very good with words. I notice little tricks like that, and others, such as not actually asking me in what sense I used the term 'mob'. You merely described what sense you believe it is 'usually' used in. It's kind of like the way GeekFeminism's definition of "The Tone Argument" starts not by defining it, but by saying who it is used by, then defining it. But further on that is for another forum.

Don't lie. You yourself indicated that you were aware that "mob" isn't a neutral term:

Jane, they were an angry crowd, and an angry mob. The subset of Mobs is contained within the set Crowds. I used the more neutral term to be accommodating to you.
 
Last edited:
Jane, what's your opinion of lying down on train tracks and putting four-year old kids on train tracks?

Would you describe that as retarded activity?
 
So you don't think the police can be institutionally sadistic within the law?
Yes, I do. I also do not think that John Pike, on the morning of November 18th, 2011, when pepper spraying obstructive students after several warnings and attempts to use lesser force by himself and other officers, was acting in a sadistic manner, nor can it be positively determined or indicated he had sadistic motivations.

Where's the violence?
Not necessary for the police to use force, much less pepper spray. It is interesting how you keep reading "threatened police" as "were violent toward police".

Where is your evidence that the police actions were dictated by a few chants?
By "actions were dictated by a few chants", you mean "response was to an angry crowd surrounding, obstructing, and threatening police", I assume. Because that is what I'm arguing, not that they were responding to "a few chants".

No, you're not:
Again, good with words. Fair lady, I did seek to contrast mine brevity with needless loquacity, for purposes of jest. Methinks thou protest too much about th'omission of five letters.

When I wrote it, it was because I didn't feel like writing "Jihad". I consider that part of your username the equivalent of a nickname, such as "Calamity" Jane, "Wild" Bill Hickok, or beloved Sesame Street character "Forgetful" Jones. I also call Leftysergeant "Lefty, BenBurch "Ben", NoahFence "Noah", and so on. I will call you "Jihad" in the future.

Don't lie. You yourself indicated that you were aware that "mob" isn't a neutral term:
Yep. I indicated. I did not state. I said 'crowd' was "more neutral" than 'mob'. Sitting in one's living room is safer than making dinner in the kitchen, but both are considered "safe". This does not entirely remove the possibility that I was saying mob was not neutral, but it also does not mean that I was saying it was neutral.

Since you still haven't asked me whether I was using it in a neutral manner; I wasn't. I used "mob" in the sense which indicates unruliness and disorder, along with the connotations of "mob mentality", wherein people act in unison with the group in which they are a part. Often times, this is in a fashion they would not behave alone. I used it to indicate the crowd/mob was acting in an irrational manner which they nonetheless bear responsibility for.



Agent Kay said:
A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it.

So! Would you care to prove, with affirmative evidence, that John Pike was acting out of sadism? Nothing about what you or anyone else "think" the look on his face was.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom