Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Threatening the cops is, by definition, an indication of violence. They were not merely disobeying police orders, they were issuing demands to the cops, with threat of not letting the cops leave and not "[protesting] peacefully".

The students didn't threaten the police with violence.


Jane, they were an angry crowd, and an angry mob. The subset of Mobs is contained within the set Crowds. I used the more neutral term to be accommodating to you.
Why are you calling me Jane, 63?

A "crowd" is usually called a "mob" as a way of dehumanizing them and facilitating acts of violence against them, treating them like bugs etc. Politically, it is propagandistic term., e.g "A mob of riot police".
 
Last edited:
The students didn't threaten the police with violence.

Are you of the mind the police were not threatened, either verbally or physically, at all?

A "crowd" is usually called a "mob" as a way of dehumanizing them and facilitating acts of violence against them, treating them like bugs etc. Politically, it is propagandistic term., e.g "A mob of riot police".

I think a more politically-correct definition for OWS is Ochlocracy.

Learn something new every day.
 
their actions should be dictated by pre-ordained operating procedures rather than by their feelings.

You should contribute to these threads a little more. You've apparently missed the dozen or so pages where police escalation procedure was the topic, and even your own side provided evidence that:

A) Proper police escalation was used at U.C. Davis
B) Pepper spray may lead to fewer injuries among protesters and police units
 
Why? Sadists frequently enter professions that involve inflicting pain on others just as pedophiles seek employment that gives them access to children.

Police behave like "mobs" too. Sadists often act within the law. The Nazi regime issued about 429 separate laws and decrees against the Jews in Germany.
1. "Could be". "Might have".
2. Godwin's.
3. Nazi =/= Sadist.

The students didn't threaten the police with violence.
They said that if the prisoners were released, they'd 'continue to protest peacefully'. It's like saying 'If you'll give me a down payment on what you owe, I'll continue to ask nicely.' The clear indication is that if the demands are not met, they will stop protesting peacefully or asking nicely. That's a threat.

Why are you calling me Jane, 63?
I'm lazy.

A "crowd" is usually called a "mob" as a way of dehumanizing them and facilitating acts of violence against them, treating them like bugs etc. Politically, it is propagandistic term., e.g "A mob of riot police".
It is I notice you don't include the actual standard definition. That is, a group of people acting in an unruly and often unlawful manner.

I'm not sure if you noticed, but I'm very good with words. I notice little tricks like that, and others, such as not actually asking me in what sense I used the term 'mob'. You merely described what sense you believe it is 'usually' used in. It's kind of like the way GeekFeminism's definition of "The Tone Argument" starts not by defining it, but by saying who it is used by, then defining it. But further on that is for another forum.
 
Last edited:
Wow, way to miss the obvious point. Nobody is claiming that the OWS movement is actually like Charles Manson, but that's the point! They AREN'T like Charles Manson, even though there's this superficial similarity (people paid attention to both). Which means that this superficial similarity, which YOU used to compare the OWS movement with Gandhi, is similarly meaningless. It's precisely because the OWS movement is not like Charles Manson that your own argument is worthless. The OWS movement isn't really very similar to either one.

So, in your conservatively-euphoric mind, what is the OWS similar to?
 
So, in your conservatively-euphoric mind, what is the OWS similar to?

I see no need to find something for it to be similar to. I'm fully capable of evaluating the movement on its own. Are you not able to do so? And are you only able to make comparisons based on the most superficial of similarities?

If you feel the need to find something for OWS to be similar to, be my guest. But you didn't like how it turned out last time you tried that, so you might want to find a more significant basis for comparison next time.
 
Those protests have no resemblance to the Occupy Wall Street crowd, and they aren't acting on inspiration from OWS either. Which you'd know if you had read the article. But maybe you do know, and just aren't being honest. I'll let you tell us which one.
JihadJane's curtain twitching habits are hard to break.
 
Occupy Mother of the Year...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ztak_wBwGc&feature=player_embedded

places 4yr old on tracks to halt trains.

The closing caption on that clip is indicative of the OWS movement's lack of understanding of reality. She claims that her "faith in humanity" gives her confidence that her child won't be harmed by any train-driving engineer. Hey lady - "Faith in humanity has little bearing on the ability of an engineer to stop a loaded train."
 
The closing caption on that clip is indicative of the OWS movement's lack of understanding of reality. She claims that her "faith in humanity" gives her confidence that her child won't be harmed by any train-driving engineer. Hey lady - "Faith in humanity has little bearing on the ability of an engineer to stop a loaded train."

So, OWS is a faith based organization now?:boggled:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom