Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Zombie. Pics of Occutard hangers-on and leftists doing dumb stuff.

Welcome to San Francisco. :)

Wonderful article, it highlights why Occupy SF is a failure. Marching through the Financial District on a Saturday? There's nothing there except for a handful of office workers, security guards and surely a few bewildered tourists who'll have a story to tell when the go home. Most of the bank branches they're seen in front of are closed.


Unreal.

Why are they protesting circumcision? How does that fit in?

First, you get some lube... :duck:

That's another reason why it failed. So many folks here with their pet causes and agendas and they all were drawn to Occupy because they had the spotlight. What followed was the camp split up into factions who could never come to a decision, so the whole thing devolved into a two month long block party.

Sad really.
 
I've watched the videos. Where's the "mob"?

Did you watch it with your eyes open? Actually, nevermind. It was probably what - 3 people short of what you'd refer to as a "mob"?

If police actions are dictated by their feelings the police should be disbanded.
Then we should do away with detectives who have a "hunch"? Those feelings are built based on past experiences.
 
That would be the large group of upset people trying to threaten the police.

In your increasingly fantastical bubble.

What has made you change your position from "threatening the police" to "trying to threaten the police"

Not my argument. I was pointing out that trying to extrapolate what the police were "feeling" is a straw man, and logically inconsistent. One cannot argue that the police did not act threatened, therefore they weren't threatened, while ignoring that they felt they needed to use pepper spray, as indicated by their use of pepper spray.

What evidence do you have that they "felt they needed to use pepper spray"? What have feelings got to do with it?

If you have nothing to say, say nothing.

I did have something to say and I said it. Don't clutter up the thread with irrelevant gossip.

Such as, say, a crowd demanding police release prisoners. In that situation, they are the "authoritarians", only their tenuous authority derives from threat of force, not rule of law.

No they aren't.

I wasn't talking about the police or the protestors. I was talking about a mindset.

Why have you now reverted to calling the crowd a crowd? What happened to the "mob"?

What threat of force? Were the crowd showing signs of becoming violent? No. Refusing to obey police orders doesn't make one an authoritarian. It makes one a refusenik or a rebel.
 
Occutard Seattle block port, make barricade and throw flares and paint at police. 11 arrests. Pepper spray and flashbangs used. Better have a big cry about it.

In a statement, port officials said nearly 22,000 people work in jobs created by the cargo that comes through the port.
"Just one day's wages for those jobs total $1.9 million – dollars that can't be earned if they can't go to work," the statement said. "Money is tight for many of us, particularly at this time of year, and those who work the port's docks must be able to do their jobs."

Read more: http://www.seattlepi.com/local/tran...ice-disperse-Occupy-2398699.php#ixzz1gRczvRBY

 
Last edited:
Occutard Seattle block port, make barricade and throw flares and paint at police. 11 arrests. Pepper spray and flashbangs used. Better have a big cry about it.
It's not too big of a leap to note that that blockading a port can be seen as an act of war.

It's also worth noting that this discussion would progress on a higher level without calling people "Occutards."
 
What does it matter to you, other than arguing in circles?
I don't think she does. Note that she makes not a single factual assertion in her post. Just denials and "I think"/"you think".

Do you have a problem with pejoratives?
Apparently not, since she's used them before. She also seems to be implying I'm specifically using certain types of emotive language.

Jane, they were an angry crowd, and an angry mob. The subset of Mobs is contained within the set Crowds. I used the more neutral term to be accommodating to you.

They were trying to threaten the police. They were succeeding in threatening the police. They issued threats to police. I didn't mean anything by "trying", but I'm not backing off from my position; they threatened police.

I didn't bring in feelings. I referred to a straw man, used by several of those who would condemn the police, where "they were threatened" is turned into "they felt threatened", using the rationale that the way the police acted was not that of threatened people. The problem with that logic is that by the same reasoning, the police "felt" they needed to pepper spray the protestors, as evidenced by them pepper spraying the protestors.

Threatening the cops is, by definition, an indication of violence. They were not merely disobeying police orders, they were issuing demands to the cops, with threat of not letting the cops leave and not "[protesting] peacefully".
 
Doesn't prove they felt it needed. They could've just wanted to do it for entertainment, or other alternate purposes. Some people are just sadistic.
Yet I and several others have provided evidence that it was justified and proper police procedure. Unless there's evidence to the contrary, sadism should be set aside.

In fact, a policeman who is sadistic would most likely rationalize it as something the protestors "deserve" or were "asking for". As far as he's concerned, they need to be pepper sprayed. This was not the action of Pike alone, mind you. He discussed it with the other officers, and they were ready to back him up.
 
Doesn't prove they felt it needed. They could've just wanted to do it for entertainment, or other alternate purposes. Some people are just sadistic.

Indeed. While police around the world do often appear to get violent simply because they feel like it and because it gives them a kick to bully people, their actions should be dictated by pre-ordained operating procedures rather than by their feelings. Did President Harry S. Truman drop nuclear bombs on Japan because he felt like it?

It's easy to tell when police are physically under threat from a crowd because the crowd will start throwing things at them. Even then, police sometimes decide that dodging a few sticks is better than escalating the violence and provoking a full-scale riot.


Yet I and several others have provided evidence that it was justified and proper police procedure. Unless there's evidence to the contrary, sadism should be set aside.

Why? Sadists frequently enter professions that involve inflicting pain on others just as pedophiles seek employment that gives them access to children.


In fact, a policeman who is sadistic would most likely rationalize it as something the protestors "deserve" or were "asking for". As far as he's concerned, they need to be pepper sprayed. This was not the action of Pike alone, mind you. He discussed it with the other officers, and they were ready to back him up.

Police behave like "mobs" too. Sadists often act within the law. The Nazi regime issued about 429 separate laws and decrees against the Jews in Germany.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom