Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
...

The officers on the scene would've been sufficient, had not a mob of dozens surrounded them and prevented them from getting out. At that point, it was, as always, the duty of the officers to resolve the situation in the most expedient and minimum force manner possible, which, as I have already argued, was pepper spray. You don't stick around in front of the people who threatened you seconds ago. All they have to do is let the new officers in, then surround them too, and you have the exact same situation.

...

Out numbered and felt threatened? Poor babies. Elementary tactics would be close ranks and withdraw, call for re-enforcement and police wagons and then re-engage in sufficient numbers to end the situation without resort to a police weapon.
 
Out numbered and felt threatened? Poor babies.

What's your job again?

Elementary tactics would be close ranks and withdraw

Which is what happened, at which point they were surrounded.

call for re-enforcement and police wagons

This was done, unless a cruiser is not up to your "wagon" standards.

and then re-engage in sufficient numbers to end the situation without resort to a police weapon.

I'm not sure how you think a crowd can be dispersed without a "weapon". Perhaps you could explain what you mean?

Also, please define 'weapon'.
 
Last edited:
Cite? I see video of people making no attempt at defensive coverage spraying sitting persons. Not video of a platoon covering fore and aft and trying to make way.
What were those persons sitting on again? Could it be the road out?

The police were there to remove the tents, which they did. This incident happened when they were on their way out with several people they arrested.
 
BenBurch, the only way they could have left without using force is if they had left the people they had arrested behind. In what sane, law-abiding world would that be an acceptable outcome.

Indeed, I would say that any time a police officer is confronted by a crowd of people who won't let him leave unless he releases his prisoner, that's automatically and necessarily a call to use any and all disabling force necessary to complete the arrest.
 
"Militarized" here meaning "wearing black military-like clothing on a few special occasions".
I once defined the Occupy usage of it as "wearing uniforms, boots and helmets", when you stripped away all the ways the cops are not like the military. Which also applies to motocross racers, Nascar drivers, and Boy Scouts playing paintball.
 
What's your job again?

Which is what happened, at which point they were surrounded.

This was done, unless a cruiser is not up to your "wagon" standards.

I'm not sure how you think a crowd can be dispersed without a "weapon". Perhaps you could explain what you mean?

Also, please define 'weapon'.
Well, that saved me a post.

I like how Ben apparently only read the first paragraph of my response to him.
 
Cite? I see video of people making no attempt at defensive coverage spraying sitting persons. Not video of a platoon covering fore and aft and trying to make way.
Fore and Aft are parts of a ship. Making way is something a ship does. A platoon is a group of human troops.

Once again, Ben, thou hast strived to appear witty, and succeeded not, only revealing thy ignorance to any and all with any more knowledge of the matter than a novice in a nunnery.
 
No, wait, I have to post after all. Just a minor point.

...felt threatened?...
No. I didn't say they didn't feel threatened, though it would be entirely reasonable to do so, what with the angry mob surrounding them. They were threatened. They had been threatened. The crowd had issued a clear threat to them.

Incidentally, you join Jiggeryqua (IIRC) and BooKitty in the ranks of those who have tried that straw man. It's getting quite tiresome. I don't know if you three are deliberately misreading, or if you are biased, or what, but the constant dancing around this point really gets on my nerves. They threatened police. They committed a crime. In fact, as soon as they did, they legally became a riot. If you want to go with what the police "felt like", they also "felt like" they needed to pepper spray several people.
 
More fail today in the Occupy movement:
The International Longshore and Warehouse Union, which represents many thousands of longshoremen up and down the West Coast, has distanced itself from the shutdown effort. The union's president suggested in a letter to members that protesters were attempting to co-opt the union's cause to advance their own agenda.
They are very presumptuous to say this is in "solidarity" with the longshoremen and the "99%".
Also, a protester was arrested with a loaded handgun and another with a sword. Another group crashed a stolen truck on their way to the protest. This is not a peaceful protest and these folks have no understanding of civil disobedience. Their temper tantrums, delusions of persecution and total disregard for the larger community is growing tiresome.
 
More fail today in the Occupy movement:

They are very presumptuous to say this is in "solidarity" with the longshoremen and the "99%".Also, a protester was arrested with a loaded handgun and another with a sword. Another group crashed a stolen truck on their way to the protest. This is not a peaceful protest and these folks have no understanding of civil disobedience. Their temper tantrums, delusions of persecution and total disregard for the larger community is growing tiresome.
Indeed.

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/12/13/us/occupy-ports/?hpt=us_c1

"What has this accomplished?" [port spokesman Issac Kos-Read] asked. "This is disrupting the 99%"
+
"They are saying ... they have to get the attention of the ruling class. I think the ruling class is probably laughing and people in this city will be crying this Christmas," Quan said. "It's really got to stop."
+
Monday's demonstrations also took place in Los Angeles, Seattle, Houston and Portland, Oregon. Organizers said the goal was to shut down ports in an effort to "disrupt the economic machine that benefits the wealthiest individuals and corporations."
And screw anyone else who's harmed in the process.

Funny thing; the trailer and concept video for the new Rainbow Six game show villains loosely based on Occupy. If you look at the comments, there a lot of people saying they're actually on the villains side. Keep in mind that the "True Patriots" are willing to harm dozens of people along with the bankers they see as the bad guys, just to make a point.

Of course, that sort of thing don't seem to bother Occupy much.

Survey: 3 in 10 Americans identify with Occupy, Tea Party movements

That's each, mind you.
 
Last edited:
No. I didn't say they didn't feel threatened, though it would be entirely reasonable to do so, what with the angry mob surrounding them. They were threatened. They had been threatened. The crowd had issued a clear threat to them.

I've watched the videos. Where's the "mob"?

Incidentally, you join Jiggeryqua (IIRC) and BooKitty in the ranks of those who have tried that straw man. It's getting quite tiresome. I don't know if you three are deliberately misreading, or if you are biased, or what, but the constant dancing around this point really gets on my nerves. They threatened police.

:v:

They committed a crime. In fact, as soon as they did, they legally became a riot. If you want to go with what the police "felt like", they also "felt like" they needed to pepper spray several people.

If police actions are dictated by their feelings the police should be disbanded.



Indeed.

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/12/13/us/occupy-ports/?hpt=us_c1

And screw anyone else who's harmed in the process.

Funny thing; the trailer and concept video for the new Rainbow Six game show villains loosely based on Occupy. If you look at the comments, there a lot of people saying they're actually on the villains side. Keep in mind that the "True Patriots" are willing to harm dozens of people along with the bankers they see as the bad guys, just to make a point.

Of course, that sort of thing don't seem to bother Occupy much.

Survey: 3 in 10 Americans identify with Occupy, Tea Party movements

That's each, mind you.

Blah blah blah.

BenBurch, the only way they could have left without using force is if they had left the people they had arrested behind. In what sane, law-abiding world would that be an acceptable outcome.

Planet Earth, e.g.:

"We are opposed to political policing":



Football fans intervene to stop security guard brutality





Indeed, I would say that any time a police officer is confronted by a crowd of people who won't let him leave unless he releases his prisoner, that's automatically and necessarily a call to use any and all disabling force necessary to complete the arrest.

That's because authoritarianism discourages imagination and creativity.
 
Last edited:
I've watched the videos. Where's the "mob"?
That would be the large group of upset people trying to threaten the police.

:v:

If police actions are dictated by their feelings the police should be disbanded.
Not my argument. I was pointing out that trying to extrapolate what the police were "feeling" is a straw man, and logically inconsistent. One cannot argue that the police did not act threatened, therefore they weren't threatened, while ignoring that they felt they needed to use pepper spray, as indicated by their use of pepper spray.

Blah blah blah.
If you have nothing to say, say nothing.

...
That's because authoritarianism discourages imagination and creativity.
Such as, say, a crowd demanding police release prisoners. In that situation, they are the "authoritarians", only their tenuous authority derives from threat of force, not rule of law.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom