Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sure is strange how many people Rand has had to threaten to break off conversation with in the last few pages, all of whom asked him to back up his claim. In my case, I got put on his Ignore List after asking him to seek evidence to support his own point about Excessive Force, instead of claiming to be just regurgitating the opinions of "experts" when I asked him to present alternatives. Currently, it's his opinion again.

The funny thing is, I'm pretty sure I and others know more about his position than he does. I am very familiar with the Humboldt case (having boned up thanks to info available on NoPepperSpray.org) and it's frequent misrepresentation in the Occupy rhetoric, and had already read and noted the deficiencies of the ACLU PDF Andrew Ryan here is waving about. Apparently, I'm not the only one.
 
Police use the tools they are taught to in their training. Pepper spray in the Davis situation was the best choice and done according to established protocol. The fact that you and the other occutards don't like it doesn't matter.
As far as I can tell, he thinks the police were justified in removing the obstructing protestors, but considers pepper spray excessive force. Except he refuses to say what reasonable force is, and admits he has no real idea what the alternatives are.

He's trying to say X>Y without knowing what Y is.
 
Folks, again, I'm willing to dial down the snark in order to have a rational conversation. I'm willing to sincerely consider arguments and evidence. But we need more than gainsaying and assertion. Please to address the arguments I make and not simply, and automatically say "no". I will do that if you will. I cannot formulate a decision on your opinion alone. I cannot form an opinion on phantom protocols and expert opinion. You need to provide that.

Can we do this without brow beating and recriminations?
 
Last edited:
BTW: This would raise an important question. HOW DID the appeals court find that the police acted with excessive force in the appeals court decision?

Read the details of the court's decision. They explain why.

How was this incident different from the other one?

It is up to you to show how they are similar.

So we need to document what the protocols were.

Your PDF does just that.

I will thank you in advance for that.

Read your own sources.

laughingdogs.jpeg
 
How was this incident different from the other one?
We told you. The Humbolt protestors were locked to various things while tresspassing, the police had a way to remove them without the pepper spray, and the pepper spray was put on Q-Tip and applied into their eyes after it was forced open. In the UC Davis incident, the individuals were actively interfering with the police by blocking their way, and all standard lesser uses of force had been systematically tried. Not some. All.

See, Nova? This is what I mean. We present information to him, it's like water off a duck's back. He admits he doesn't know much, but keeps acting like his opinion is more valid than that of people who are clearly better informed. When people ask him to backup his claims, he can't, and tries to shift the burden of proof. In fact, he is unwilling to explain evidence he presents himself, and ignores all criticism of such.
 
Last edited:
Pepper spray has been linked to deaths. How many protestors died from the dogs. I would take the dogs.
Really, you can't say anything to that. Randfan would rather be bitten by a dog or several dogs than endure an hour or so of discomfort. I'm sure the Protestors would be glad to know he feels that way. Has anyone asked them their preference?
 
If you provided a link after I asked then I sincerely apologize. Could you post it again?
No, I provided it earlier in this thread. Like you, I'm not going to keep repeating it. Keep up with the thread if you want a rational discussion.

I look forward to reading your proof on that. Thanks.
Then go read it.


So we need to document what the protocols were. I will thank you in advance for that. And we need to know the likelihood of these protocols, if you are right, standing to scrutiny of the courts. Right?
Every jurisdiction may have their own procedures and guidelines. The investigation will tell us if the Davis incident followed their own specific protocols. I suspect it will. We do know that the Davis incident was in line with other widely accepted protocols as based on statements by experts that I have previously cited.


Folks, again, I'm willing to dial down the snark in order to have a rational conversation. I'm willing to sincerely consider arguments and evidence.
Then go back and read them.
 
Can we do this without brow beating and recriminations?
Said the guy who puts people on his ignore list for asking him to back up his claims and think critically.

Asked and answered in depth. I'm not going to keep repeating it. However, unlike Neally I will actually provide a link.
If you keep demanding that I didn't answer the question then you are lying. And unlike Neally, I don't claim to answer a question and the refuse to prove it.
Rhetorical, and, well, no. You can't really play that game and do so in an intellectually honest fashion.

You will need to explain WHY they are different. Otherwise you are arguing by assertion. And THAT is, how did you put it? Oh yeah, no dice.
You are being dishonest.
Instead of games why don't you explain how I'm wrong? Can you do what brainster can't and explain the difference?
Sorry, this isn't going to win anything for you. I eat crow all of the time. Honestly, HONESTLY, if you had a point I would have no problem agreeing with you. You don't. I can sleep just fine tonight.

ETA: That was pathetic. I think you better. I didn't mean to point by point gainsay. If you continue in that vain then I will ignore you. I'm an honest person, I don't need someone to browbeat me. I'm not going to change a position that is unreasonable to change. Improve your game.
If you can step away from your ego for one moment, I think you will admit that this is not as cut and dry as you think, right?

I love that you want others to stop "bowbeating", when you did all of those over the course of the previous single page. Your ratio of posts without a passive-aggressive snipe at someone continues to drop steadily.
 
No, I provided it earlier in this thread.
Prove it.

Like you, I'm not going to keep repeating it.
But I am willing to keep posting the link, over and over and over and over and over and over and over. Are you beginning to see the difference between you and I? Are you beginning to see how your claim of hypocricy is wrong? The difference is I will prove I posted the data with a link. You won't.

We do know that the Davis incident was in line with other widely accepted protocols as based on statements by experts that I have previously cited.
(emphasis mine) Oh, you bet, sure.
 
No, it doesn't matter. You've had the differences explained to you, very clearly. You have ignored them. You have had information presented. You ignored it. You have been asked to support your opinion. You claimed it was the opinion of experts, and now its your opinion again. You have Ignored or threatened to Ignore people who ask you to be intellectually honest, and demanded standards of them you do not enforce on yourself. You have admitted your lack of knowledge, but refuse to educate yourself, or spend five minutes going back, like I did.
Charles J. Kelly, a former Baltimore Police Department lieutenant who wrote the department's use of force guidelines, said pepper spray is a "compliance tool" that can be used on subjects who do not resist, and is preferable to simply lifting protesters.
"When you start picking up human bodies, you risk hurting them," Kelly said. "Bodies don't have handles on them."
After reviewing the video, Kelly said he observed at least two cases of "active resistance" from protesters. In one instance, a woman pulls her arm back from an officer. In the second instance, a protester curls into a ball. Each of those actions could have warranted more force, including baton strikes and pressure-point techniques.

"What I'm looking at is fairly standard police procedure," Kelly said.
...
UC Davis Police Chief Annette Spicuzza said the decision to use pepper spray was made at the scene.

"The students had encircled the officers," she said Saturday. "They needed to exit. They were looking to leave but were unable to get out."
The Ex-Lt. who wrote the Use of Force guidelines for Baltimore says you're wrong. In fact, he says they could've been justified in using even more force. What you call "excessive force" is the cops holding back.

You said you're not an expert. An expert says you're wrong. Will you accept that?
 
Last edited:
No, it doesn't matter. You've had the differences explained to you, very clearly. You have ignored them. You have had information presented. You ignored it. You have been asked to support your opinion. You claimed it was the opinion of experts, and now its your opinion again. You have Ignored or threatened to Ignore people who ask you to be intellectually honest, and demanded standards of them you do not enforce on yourself. You have admitted your lack of knowledge, but refuse to educate yourself, or spend five minutes going back, like I did.
The Ex-Lt. who wrote the Use of Force guidelines for Baltimore says you're wrong. In fact, he says they could've been justified in using even more force. What you call "excessive force" is the cops holding back.
You said you're not an expert. An expert says you're wrong. Will you accept that?

You do realize that the protest at UC Davis was not terribly unique. Sit-ins and a demonstrations happen at the thousands of US colleges campuses with some regularity. In many cases, the demonstrators are inside a building, an area which would be much more difficult for a police force to exit if they were "surrounded" than an outdoor quad with a row of seated protestors. (That Pike nonchalantly stepped over before spraying them. Oh yeah, the man was obviously terrified, that's why he tossed in a pirouette.:rolleyes:)

And yet, we haven't heard about any incidences of pepper-spraying or professors getting hit with clubs or dragged by their hair. Somehow, for years and years now, campus police have done just fine without resorting to weapons evolved for use against violent or mentally deranged criminals. They didn't even pepper-spray the rioters at Penn State.

I can see where a street cop might defend the use of pepper spray because the same situation outside of a campus would have a different set of dangers. Americans aren't big on protesting and large gatherings of upset people have let to riots. However, within the campus environment, this sort of thing has a natural progression, the cops have dealt with it before and, aside from campus police over-reaction, have little history of turning violent.
 
Last edited:
Once again, the post does not really address the legality or illegality of the actions of the protestors or cops.

SWAT gear is distinctly different from "paramilitary gear". Even SWAT officers attempt to capture suspects alive. How did he count how many officers there were, and how did he distinguish SWAT from standard riot-control gear?

And this is why John Pike used pepper spray. Because the alternative is more likely to seriously harm people.

Riot cop gear is designed to intimidate rioters by presenting the appearance of a unified force.

On what basis is Mr. Meighan assuming this? Harming people more than one intends is an inherent risk of physical compliance methods, which is why cops prefer things like pepper spray.

After the woman at OccupySeattle who claimed that the police accidentally terminated her pregnancy but refused to provide medical records, I'm going to disbelieve until I see medical records. In addition, he is welcome to seek civil recompense.

Here are the LAPD regulations for prisoner medical treatment.

Unsourced claim.

Unless that's actually illegal, I'm not sure what the complaint is.

Why does he keep bleating about "nonviolent"? Who is he trying to convince? We've already established Meigahn was nonviolent, along with a few others, according to the narrative. Why does he have to keep saying it every bloody paragraph?

In other words, he's complaining the police enforced the law to the maximum extent. The implication is that they are inherently unjustified in doing so.

Pat does know that a "shiv" is an improvised prison knife, right? And how is it "extra"? On what basis of comparison? Compared to "most people"? A longer period of detention than the usual is not necessarily "extra".

Any point he is trying to make is lost under the great steaming heaps of self-martyrdom.


I wasn't looking for an argument, just figured you guys might need some new fapping material.
 
Folks, again, I'm willing to dial down the snark in order to have a rational conversation. I'm willing to sincerely consider arguments and evidence.
Odd that you're unwilling to provide any evidence yourself, and it's you who's making the claim.

Please present your evidence that pepper spray is more likely to result in injury or death than other non-lethal force available to the police.
 
I cannot form an opinion on phantom protocols and expert opinion. You need to provide that.


Phantom protocols?

I've read several not-so-phantom protocols in the last 2 or 3 pages. We even have a post with neat little pictures! Where do you get that you've not seen protocols?
 
:D

OMG I can't begin to thank you enough. A great big hug and smooch from me to you...

If we could only get those who repeatedly use anecdotes to smear the protestors.

That said, no, there is no single incident and there is evidence that the federal govt is failing to protect the rights of citizens.

Aside from the pepper spraying incident which was promptly denouced by UC Davis and an investigation was opened is there evidence the federal government is failing to protect the rights of citizens.

Is breakup up demonstrations that were allowed to go on for long periods of time many times in violation of local laws considered not protecting the rights of the citizens. to me it looks as if government officials, albeit not the federal government, bent over backwards to accomodate the OWS protests.

The citizens whose rights were not protected were those non protesting citizens who were being adversely affected by the OWS demonstations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom