Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I DID answer the question. I stand by that answer. In fact, there are TWO answers. Either are sufficient.
Look RandFan, at this point I can only assume you didn't even read the pdf you referenced. The alternative is that you're just trolling or suffer incredibly poor reading comprehension.

Please provide the stats of death and injury of pepper spray vs. alternative uses of force. And don't bother looking in your pdf, you won't find the answers there. There is not a single statistic on it relating to injuries and deaths related to various uses of non-lethal force.

Present your evidence, or admit you have no basis for your claims.
 
EXACTLY! Thank you. Where the hell do protestors get off thinking the police are going to weigh the pros and cons of the various tools at their disposal?

[qimg]http://img100.imageshack.us/img100/5309/bhamdog1b.jpg[/qimg]

I used to say about the people who compared Bush to Hitler that they weren't intentionally minimizing Hitler's evil or overstating Bush's. They were trying to compare themselves to the poor, doomed souls who stood up to Hitler in Germany, like the White Rose Society.

That is exactly what you are doing here. You're trying to puff yourself and the OWS buffoons up as the equivalent of the freedom riders. No dice.
 
I used to say about the people who compared Bush to Hitler that they weren't intentionally minimizing Hitler's evil or overstating Bush's. They were trying to compare themselves to the poor, doomed souls who stood up to Hitler in Germany, like the White Rose Society.

That is exactly what you are doing here. You're trying to puff yourself and the OWS buffoons up as the equivalent of the freedom riders. No dice.
Rhetorical, and, well, no. You can't really play that game and do so in an intellectually honest fashion.

You will need to explain WHY they are different. Otherwise you are arguing by assertion. And THAT is, how did you put it? Oh yeah, no dice.
 
Look RandFan, at this point I can only assume you didn't even read the pdf you referenced.


  • The pdf is one part of one answer.
  • That answer consists of two propositions.
  • You haven't addressed the propositions.
  • You haven't demonstrated that the pdf file doesn't support the proposition.
  • You haven't even addressed the other answer.
You are being dishonest.
 
http://culvercitycrossroads.com/2011/12/05/dear-editor-lapd-arrests-the-truth-at-occupy-la/
My name is Patrick Meighan, and I’m a husband, a father, a writer on the Fox animated sitcom “Family Guy”, and a member of the Unitarian Universalist Community Church of Santa Monica.
...

... I unlinked my arms voluntarily and informed the LAPD officers that I would go peacefully and cooperatively. I stood as instructed, and then I had my arms wrenched behind my back, and an officer hyperextended my wrists into my inner arms. It was super violent, it hurt really really bad, and he was doing it on purpose. When I involuntarily recoiled from the pain, the LAPD officer threw me face-first to the pavement. He had my hands behind my back, so I landed right on my face. The officer dropped with his knee on my back and ground my face into the pavement. It really, really hurt and my face started bleeding and I was very scared. I begged for mercy and I promised that I was honestly not resisting and would not resist.

My hands were then zipcuffed very tightly behind my back, where they turned blue. I am now suffering nerve damage in my right thumb and palm.
 
Next Monday, they plan to shut down all West Coast ports.



My guess is they get a massive container of fail.
 
Again, wow! A lot of posters here seem to think the same way you do on this, but I am totally baffled by this attitude.

It sounds like you consider posting evidence to be a burden or a punishment being imposed on you: He didn't post his evidence, so why do I have to post mine?
I and others have posted evidence. He ignored it.

Having a place such as this forum where one has the opportunity to share evidence, and having good evidence to share, is a privilege and a pleasure. I can understand people who don't have any substantive evidence available to support their claims being frustrated at the thought of having to post evidence -- but to a skeptic, the opportunity to post evidence in support of something one believes to be true is close to heaven.
There was a thread on the 9/11 Forum where a poster named Ergo demanded a full thesis statement for a two-digit number. I and others refused, because he clearly just wanted to jerk us around, and given his usual posting habits, would rationalize it away anyway.

RandFan has ignored or rationalized away just about every bit of evidence anyone has presented indicating Pike's use of force was justified.

When you are arguing with someone, and you have competing claims, there are 4 basic possibilities:

  1. You both post good evidence to support your claims, after which the two of you and anyone else interested examine and weigh the evidence which has been posted.

  2. You post good evidence to support your claim, but the other person for whatever reason doesn't do so. In that case, only your evidence can be examined and weighed.
  1. Guess what I and others have already done? RandFan, by contrast, has shied away from NoahFence directly asking him to explain his position to him. He has shied away from providing any example of a lesser effective use of force, and I asked him if any of his experts provided such examples, and still nothing. In fact, the people on my side have had to provide alternatives and ask him if he approved. He still didn't answer.


    [*]The other person posts good evidence to support their claim, but you for whatever reason do not post evidence to support your claim.
    RandFan is providing a biased ACLU report from 1995, and "experts" who say they're "investigating".

    [*]Neither you nor the other person posts good evidence.
The first scenario, where both you and the other person provide evidence, is to my mind the most desirable. It's the one most likely to help people discern most quickly what is and isn't true in the matter being considered. The fourth scenario, in contrast, strikes me as the least desirable of the lot.

And yet your expressed preference seems to be for the 4th scenario. If someone you are arguing with doesn't provide evidence to your satisfaction, you'll respond by also not providing satisfactory evidence?
I and others have provided satisfactory evidence, and RandFan still wasn't satisfied. His evidence is shaky at best.

I don't get it. I really don't. That makes no sense at all to me.
My preference is for the first. What is actually happening, from my perspective, is the second. The reason sophists don't seek out evidence against their position is that they can easily dismiss evidence from their opponents, but it's a lot harder to explain away or ignore stuff you find. There is no point in presenting evidence to RandFan, because he'll just ignore it.
 
I used to say about the people who compared Bush to Hitler that they weren't intentionally minimizing Hitler's evil or overstating Bush's. They were trying to compare themselves to the poor, doomed souls who stood up to Hitler in Germany, like the White Rose Society.

That is exactly what you are doing here. You're trying to puff yourself and the OWS buffoons up as the equivalent of the freedom riders. No dice.
Actually, he seems to think that they should've been removed, just that the force used to do so is excessive.

However, he has steadfastly refused to endorse any alternatives, because he's "not an expert". He'll go on about how badwrong pepper spray is, and say that the law was enforced before it, but ignores any elaboration on what the riot control measures actually were; police dogs, water hoses, batons. All of which are more likely to cause damage to pepper spray. Even the ACLU PDF he keeps waving around is over a decade old, and does not compare statistics about injuries and deaths from pepper spray compared to alternative uses of force.

RandFan isn't really complaining about excessive force, he's complaining about force, period.
 
HERE IS YOUR ANSWER! Already posted.
Pepper Spray Incidents Backfire In California and Oregon; When Is Pepper Spray Excessive Force?

In a ranking of police officer use of non-lethal force in a study of 7,512 arrests (pdf), deploying pepper spray ranked 45.9 on scale of 1 (no action) to 82 (use of handgun); the average ranking was 30.0.
Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car. As you can see from the YouTube clip, the situation on campus was not one where these earlier actions in a use of force continuum had been deployed.

Actually, the ranking is from 1 to 100. 82 just happens to be the highest-scoring item in their survey. A minor point, but such carelessness is indicative of the sloppy analysis done by your Moderate Voice source. It's also a purely subjective measure (they got it by asking cops to assign a number to each item on the scale from 1 to 100), and is NOT actually a measure of harm or potential harm done to the subject. Nor is it actually any indicator of appropriateness of the response. For example, "Police Spit on Suspect" is ranked at a mere 23.2 on this scale, whereas "Police Display Baton" is ranked at 34.6. I don't know about RandFan, but I can't think of any situation (other than life-or-death hand-to-hand combat) where a police officer spitting on someone is appropriate behavior. But apparently he thinks cops spitting on protesters would be better than police grabbing protesters, since it's lower ranked.
 
Once again, the post does not really address the legality or illegality of the actions of the protestors or cops.

when 1,400 heavily-armed LAPD officers in paramilitary SWAT gear streamed in.
SWAT gear is distinctly different from "paramilitary gear". Even SWAT officers attempt to capture suspects alive. How did he count how many officers there were, and how did he distinguish SWAT from standard riot-control gear?

When the LAPD finally began arresting those of us interlocked around the symbolic tent, we were all ordered by the LAPD to unlink from each other (in order to facilitate the arrests). Each seated, nonviolent protester beside me who refused to cooperate by unlinking his arms had the following done to him: an LAPD officer would forcibly extend the protestor’s legs, grab his left foot, twist it all the way around and then stomp his boot on the insole, pinning the protestor’s left foot to the pavement, twisted backwards. Then the LAPD officer would grab the protestor’s right foot and twist it all the way the other direction until the non-violent protestor, in incredible agony, would shriek in pain and unlink from his neighbor.
And this is why John Pike used pepper spray. Because the alternative is more likely to seriously harm people.

It was horrible to watch, and apparently designed to terrorize the rest of us.
Riot cop gear is designed to intimidate rioters by presenting the appearance of a unified force.

At least I was sufficiently terrorized. I unlinked my arms voluntarily and informed the LAPD officers that I would go peacefully and cooperatively. I stood as instructed, and then I had my arms wrenched behind my back, and an officer hyperextended my wrists into my inner arms. It was super violent, it hurt really really bad, and he was doing it on purpose.
On what basis is Mr. Meighan assuming this? Harming people more than one intends is an inherent risk of physical compliance methods, which is why cops prefer things like pepper spray.

When I involuntarily recoiled from the pain, the LAPD officer threw me face-first to the pavement. He had my hands behind my back, so I landed right on my face. The officer dropped with his knee on my back and ground my face into the pavement. It really, really hurt and my face started bleeding and I was very scared. I begged for mercy and I promised that I was honestly not resisting and would not resist.

My hands were then zipcuffed very tightly behind my back, where they turned blue. I am now suffering nerve damage in my right thumb and palm.
After the woman at OccupySeattle who claimed that the police accidentally terminated her pregnancy but refused to provide medical records, I'm going to disbelieve until I see medical records. In addition, he is welcome to seek civil recompense.

I was put on a paddywagon with other nonviolent protestors and taken to a parking garage in Parker Center. They forced us to kneel on the hard pavement of that parking garage for seven straight hours with our hands still tightly zipcuffed behind our backs. Some began to pass out. One man rolled to the ground and vomited for a long, long time before falling unconscious. The LAPD officers watched and did nothing.
Here are the LAPD regulations for prisoner medical treatment.

The charge was sitting in the park after the police said not to. It’s a misdemeanor. Almost always, for a misdemeanor, the police just give you a ticket and let you go. It costs you a couple hundred dollars. Apparently, that’s what happened with most every other misdemeanor arrest in LA that day.
Unsourced claim.

With us Occupy LA protestors, however, they set bail at $5,000 and booked us into jail.
Unless that's actually illegal, I'm not sure what the complaint is.

I’m lucky and I could afford it, except the LAPD spent all day refusing to actually *accept* the bail they set. If you were an accused murderer or a rapist in LAPD custody that day, you could bail yourself right out and be back on the street, no problem. But if you were a nonviolent Occupy LA protestor with bail money in hand, you were held long into the following morning, with absolutely no access to a lawyer.
Why does he keep bleating about "nonviolent"? Who is he trying to convince? We've already established Meigahn was nonviolent, along with a few others, according to the narrative. Why does he have to keep saying it every bloody paragraph?

Finally, at 2:30 the next morning, after twenty-five hours in custody, I was released on bail. But there were at least 200 Occupy LA protestors who couldn’t afford the bail. The LAPD chose to keep those peaceful, non-violent protesters in prison for two full days… the absolute legal maximum that the LAPD is allowed to detain someone on misdemeanor charges.
In other words, he's complaining the police enforced the law to the maximum extent. The implication is that they are inherently unjustified in doing so.

In any event, believe it or not, I’m really not angry that I got arrested. I chose to get arrested. And I’m not even angry that the mayor and the LAPD decided to give non-violent protestors like me a little extra shiv in jail (although I’m not especially grateful for it either).
Pat does know that a "shiv" is an improvised prison knife, right? And how is it "extra"? On what basis of comparison? Compared to "most people"? A longer period of detention than the usual is not necessarily "extra".

Any point he is trying to make is lost under the great steaming heaps of self-martyrdom.
 
Last edited:
And this is why John Pike used pepper spray. Because the alternative is more likely to seriously harm people.
The alternative is a system of government that serves the people rather than an avaricious, criminal elite.
 
Instead of games why don't you explain how I'm wrong? Can you do what brainster can't and explain the difference?
Your claim, your burden of proof.

Present you evidence that pepper spray is more likley to cause injury or death than other forms of non-lethal force.

I won't be holding my breath.
 
  • The pdf is one part of one answer.
The pdf isn't any part of the answer. The pdf doesn't even address the question. You never even read the pdf, did you?


  • That answer consists of two propositions.
None of which supports your claim.

  • You haven't addressed the propositions.
Not my burden of proof. You made the propositions, you provide the evidence.

  • You haven't demonstrated that the pdf file doesn't support the proposition.
It's not my responsibility to prove a negative claim, it's your responsibility to prove your positive claim. If you think any part of that pdf addresses your claim that pepper spray is more likely to cause injury or death than other means of non-lethal force you need to quote it. Will you be doing so? Or will you continue your attempts to shift the burden of proof?


  • You haven't even addressed the other answer.
The "other answer" appears to be a straw man of your constructon. No one is claiming that pepper spray cannot be an excessive use of force in some circumstances. You need to show that it was an excessive use of force in this particular circumstance. You do accept that use of pepper spray is not always an excessive use of force, correct?

You are being dishonest.
:id:

Provide your evidence, or retract your claim. Stop with the truther tactic of claiming irrelevant documents prove your case, or that you already provided evidence when you clearly haven't.

Once again, provide evidence that pepper spray is more likely to cause injury or death than other non-lethal uses of force, and that this particular case was excessive use of force. If you're going to cite court cases you have to show more similarities than "it involves the use of pepper spray".

Can you support any of your claims RandFan? And please actually read the pdf and understand what it is about before you cite it yet again.
 
Last edited:
The pdf isn't any part of the answer. The pdf doesn't even address the question. You never even read the pdf, did you?
Yes it is and Yes I did. And this isn't helping anything. You are simply gainsaying.


None of which supports your claim.


Not my burden of proof. You made the propositions, you provide the evidence.
Gainsaying.

It's not my responsibility to prove a negative claim
You don't get to simply assert something. That's just gainsaying.

The "other answer" appears to be a straw man of your constructon.
Not even close.

No one is claiming that pepper spray cannot be an excessive use of force in some circumstances. You need to show that it was an excessive use of force in this particular circumstance. You do accept that use of pepper spray is not always an excessive use of force, correct?
Correct, but given the California appeals court decision then I stand by the contention. I honestly could not come to a different conclusion.

Provide your evidence, or retract your claim. Stop with the truther tactic of claiming irrelevant documents prove your case, or that you already provided evidence when you clearly haven't.
Here's a hint, saying "clearly haven't" and cutesy "truther tactic" isn't an argument.

Once again, provide evidence that pepper spray is more likely to cause injury or death than other non-lethal uses of force, and that this particular case was excessive use of force. If you're going to cite court cases you have to show more similarities than "it involves the use of pepper spray".
The PDF provides scientific proof. The police place it on a gradient as being MORE of a risk. End of story.

Can you support any of your claims RandFan? And please actually read the pdf and understand what it is about before you cite it yet again.
Sorry, this isn't going to win anything for you. I eat crow all of the time. Honestly, HONESTLY, if you had a point I would have no problem agreeing with you. You don't. I can sleep just fine tonight.

ETA: That was pathetic. I think you better. I didn't mean to point by point gainsay. If you continue in that vain then I will ignore you. I'm an honest person, I don't need someone to browbeat me. I'm not going to change a position that is unreasonable to change. Improve your game.
 
Last edited:
Not responsive. I can't make you provide evidence. If you are going to be unresponsive then our discussion is over.
And I can't make you keep up with the disucssion. If you're going to continue to troll, our discussion is indeed over.

Asked and answered in depth. I'm not going to keep repeating it. However, unlike Neally I will actually provide a link.
Imagine that! You're don't want to repeat yourself, but expect others to. Hypocrisy much? I already provided it. Do try to keep up with the discussion. Don't expect to learn much otherwise.

EXACTLY! Thank you. Where the hell do protestors get off thinking the police are going to weigh the pros and cons of the various tools at their disposal?
Police use the tools they are taught to in their training. Pepper spray in the Davis situation was the best choice and done according to established protocol. The fact that you and the other occutards don't like it doesn't matter.

Lie. Posted before. Do try to keep up.

The alternative is a system of government that serves the people rather than an avaricious, criminal elite.
Are you advocating anarchy until your revolution is completed?
 
Last edited:
Imagine that! You're don't want to repeat yourself, but expect others to. Hypocrisy much?
If you provided a link after I asked then I sincerely apologize. Could you post it again?

Police use the tools they are taught to in their training. Pepper spray in the Davis situation was the best choice and done according to established protocol.
I look forward to reading your proof on that. Thanks.

BTW: This would raise an important question. HOW DID the appeals court find that the police acted with excessive force in the appeals court decision? According to the links I provided it's up to the courts to decide "what is best", right? How was this incident different from the other one?

So we need to document what the protocols were. I will thank you in advance for that. And we need to know the likelihood of these protocols, if you are right, standing to scrutiny of the courts. Right?

And let's go back to that ACLU document, according to the ACLU many protocols are not based in science. If you can step away from your ego for one moment, I think you will admit that this is not as cut and dry as you think, right?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom