Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wait, hold on. Just a moment. You ARE NOT LISTENTING.

Please for the love of god would you stop, take a deep breath and follow the logic? Please?

  • Okay, prior to pepper spray the police arrested people. Right?
  • Then ____insert stat here____ people die
  • People were injured. Right?
  • Then the police started using pepper spray. Right?
  • Then ____insert stat here____ people died. Right?
  • People were injured. Right?
I filled in the parts you forgot. And they are quite necessary.

Your claim, you provide the evidence.
 
Do they find jobs utilizing that type of coursework
Hell no. Business majors will take this course to fulfill curriculum requirements because it's an easy A. Just parrot back what the teacher wants to hear.
 
But some of those were not available to the cops.
Actually they had already been used. It's an escalation of force issue, you rise up the levels of force until you get to the one that works.

RandFan doesn't even consider this possibility, even though they're well-documented on the video. He just assumes they just walked up and pepper-sprayed them without even so much as ordering them to disperse first. And what's up with those rankings on the pdf RandFan posted? They list choke holds, holding a shotgun, kicking, hitting, severe restraints (meaning it pins the suspect in a very uncomfortable position), arm twisting, and threatening with a baton lower than pepper spray... actually they just list "chemical agent", so I suppose that could be tear gas also.

Imagine if they took RandFan's advice, and walked up to them brandishing shotguns and batons, and began hitting, kicking, biting and putting choke holds on the demonstrators. Would everyone be happy then? :D
 
See, here's the thing; we've asked Rand to provide evidence to support his position. All he had is some experts saying they're concerned and/or investigating. Far from conclusive. So he won't provide substantiative evidence even after over a half-dozen requests from various people, even putting two of them on ignore, then demands evidence from others. That's just hypocrisy.


Again, wow! A lot of posters here seem to think the same way you do on this, but I am totally baffled by this attitude.

It sounds like you consider posting evidence to be a burden or a punishment being imposed on you: He didn't post his evidence, so why do I have to post mine?

Having a place such as this forum where one has the opportunity to share evidence, and having good evidence to share, is a privilege and a pleasure. I can understand people who don't have any substantive evidence available to support their claims being frustrated at the thought of having to post evidence -- but to a skeptic, the opportunity to post evidence in support of something one believes to be true is close to heaven.

When you are arguing with someone, and you have competing claims, there are 4 basic possibilities:

  1. You both post good evidence to support your claims, after which the two of you and anyone else interested examine and weigh the evidence which has been posted.

  2. You post good evidence to support your claim, but the other person for whatever reason doesn't do so. In that case, only your evidence can be examined and weighed.

  3. The other person posts good evidence to support their claim, but you for whatever reason do not post evidence to support your claim.

  4. Neither you nor the other person posts good evidence.

The first scenario, where both you and the other person provide evidence, is to my mind the most desirable. It's the one most likely to help people discern most quickly what is and isn't true in the matter being considered. The fourth scenario, in contrast, strikes me as the least desirable of the lot.

And yet your expressed preference seems to be for the 4th scenario. If someone you are arguing with doesn't provide evidence to your satisfaction, you'll respond by also not providing satisfactory evidence?

I don't get it. I really don't. That makes no sense at all to me.
 
To uphold the democratic will of the people. Here in Portland, there was substantial political pressure on Mayor Sam Adams to remove the camp because the vast majority of the people wanted them removed and the city ordinance of no overnight camping in the park to be enforced. The campers were removed. This is what democracy looks like.
Indeed. OWS thinks democracy is what they decide, and the rest of society should have no say, and no rights, at all.
 
Just to inject some reality into this conversation:

Police officers use a force continuum, ranging from less than lethal to lethal force. Some departments use the intermediate term "less lethal."

A general continuum would be:

force.gif


A more exact description of the vagaries involved would be:

image005.jpg


Yes, people can (and do) die from the application of OC, etc... Of course, there are far fewer of them than would have died previously from the application of a wooden baton to the head. Complaining that a violent physical interaction is not 100% safe for all parties involved is well, silly.
 
Indeed. OWS thinks democracy is what they decide, and the rest of society should have no say, and no rights, at all.

Well, yea, but to be fair, they were "rebuilding society from the ground up"

Our locals managed to off themselves nicely, right after piss throwing guy, the occupiers announced to the media that they were inviting themselves to march in the annual Santa Claus parade.

The comments section lit up like a Christmas tree with condemnations and occupy managed a whooping six marchers followed by a two person counter protest and 15 police. Occupy is billing this as a success and, curiously, they haven't been heard from, or seen since.

Except on facebook, they're flipping videos back and forth to occupy their time.
 
Video's of police action edited to show only the response, and not the provocation no doubt.

That, and all sorts of other crap, things I can't be bothered to watch. I don't know how they find this stuff, and find the time to watch them all, but I'm happy that they're content to occupy their own little corner of the internet.
 
Remember Nathan Brown, the assistant professor of English, who organized the protest at UC-Davis and described himself in a poorly-written letter as an asset to the college community (while insisting the chancellor wasn't)?

Here's his webpage, where he describes his specialty as:



An upcoming course (Winter 2012) sounds interesting:




:rolleyes:

It also sounds like a course that should be taught either by a political science or history professor. Not that either of those would be likely to endorse the idea of communism being the movement of history.

You could probably make a case that it's a bowel movement of history.
 
Yeah, you've missed a lot of things. That happens when you come in at the end of a thread and demand everyone repeat stuff that has already been discussed.
Not responsive. I can't make you provide evidence. If you are going to be unresponsive then our discussion is over.
 
Police do not use pepper spray, or any other non-lethal method, as a substitute for lethal force. Police don't use pepper spray when someone pulls a gun on them, or a knife, or other lethal object. Lethal force is met with lethal force.

Pepper spray is used instead of the baton, as a less injurous use of force.
Source? Anyway I've dealth with this. See my link. It explains that it's not a black and white issue.
 
Well sorry, the police don't have the time and money to just wait to see if people will cease breaking the law and play a game of wait and see if they will quit resisting arrest.
You are absolutely right. Too damn busy to give a damn about the safety of malcontents.

firehose.jpg
 
Asked and answered in depth. I'm not going to keep repeating it. However, unlike Neally I will actually provide a link.
You can't repeat what you never provided in the first place.

That pdf is completely irrelevant to the question asked of you. Will you be providing the stats to support your claim, or will you be retracting your claim?
 
Last edited:
Um, the police aren't about to weigh the pros and cons of people breaking the law to decide if they actually should enforce the laws that they are paid to do.
EXACTLY! Thank you. Where the hell do protestors get off thinking the police are going to weigh the pros and cons of the various tools at their disposal?

bhamdog1b.jpg
 
You can't repeat what you never provided in the first place.

That pdf is completely irrelevant to the question asked of you. Will you be providing the stats to support your claim, or will you be retracting your claim?
I DID answer the question. I stand by that answer. In fact, there are TWO answers. Either are sufficient.
 
EXACTLY! Thank you. Where the hell do protestors get off thinking the police are going to weigh the pros and cons of the various tools at their disposal?

bhamdog1b.jpg
Nice example of that time before pepper spray you wax poetically about.

I patiently await the stats to support your claims.
 
Nice example of that time before pepper spray you wax poetically about.
Pepper spray has been linked to deaths. How many protestors died from the dogs. I would take the dogs.

I patiently await the stats to support your claims.
I patiently await for you to read my link. The PDF file is one part of one answer. If you keep demanding that I didn't answer the question then you are lying. And unlike Neally, I don't claim to answer a question and the refuse to prove it.

If you want to quote my ARGUMENT and tell me why that fails then I will happily respond.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom