Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Occupy SF comes up with a great idea; they are going to start their own credit union.

The goal of this project is to encourage San Francisco residents, businesses, as well as nonprofit and city agencies to keep their money out of the big banks and to redistribute that money locally. Initial services will include micro-loans for the working poor and homeless, and subsidized student loans at low interest rates.

They will undoubtedly pay their employees a living wage, and if you default on your loan, don't worry; they would never foreclose on your home!

I don't see how this could possibly fail.
:rolleyes:
 
Occupy SF comes up with a great idea; they are going to start their own credit union.



They will undoubtedly pay their employees a living wage, and if you default on your loan, don't worry; they would never foreclose on your home!

I don't see how this could possibly fail.
:rolleyes:

LaughingDog.gif
 
Not my recolection. The sit-ins at campuses during the 60s and 70s were not for a short period of time at all. Perhaps shorter. But let's grant the premise to advance the discussion. Would it really matter? What good is civil disobedience if the powers that be can figure out ahead of time just how long to allow it before it's detrimental to their cause?

Look, I admit that OWS effect the rights of citizens. It's nothing compared to the trillions wiped out from the corruption of wall street. I honestly think OWS is worth the inconvenience.

Isn't that the purpose of the thread (see thread title)? In any event, it does not have anything whatsoever to with anything. Thank you.

Do you have any examples of long term sitins.
You honestly think OWS is worth the inconvenience but what about all those like the residents near Zuccotti park who did not think it was worth all of the "inconveniences they had to put up with.
There appeared to be a lack of concern for their rights exhibited by many of the protesters. That bothered me not that it matters.
 
link

There is commentary from a police officer from Baltimore in there, an expert on these matters. His opinion should carry the weight you seek. The link was provided by 000063
Thank you. Was that so hard? I did not see this link and 000063 is on ignore. So, I'm not going to apologize for that but I am greatful.

Charles J. Kelly, a former Baltimore Police Department lieutenant who wrote the department's use of force guidelines, said pepper spray is a "compliance tool" that can be used on subjects who do not resist, and is preferable to simply lifting protesters.

"What I'm looking at is fairly standard police procedure," Kelly said.
I accept that this is a single experts opinion. One who works for a police department. It's important to note that this does not tell us what the protocols were for the Davis police officers. However, for the moment, let's accept that you have met that burden of proof so that we might advance the argument. Given the ACLU report, isn't it a bit self serving? How do you reconcile the opinion with the report? Or do you dismiss the report out of hand? Is there a reason to conclude that the Appeals court decision was the result of an anomaly or could it be that the protocols are a problem as the ACLU asserts?
 
Or a few half-hearted tugs on a leg or two?

Yes. When they met resistance, would you advise them to pull harder next time?

Pepper spray was excessive in this instance because the UC Davis campus police guidelines restrict it's use to the violent or mentally incapacitated.

Usually when you make posts like this, you should support them with evidence. I believe you read it, so why don't you post a link?

Why don't we read U.C. Davis' actual policy?

PROCEDURE:
I.
Factors Used to Determine the Reasonableness of Force
A.
When determining whether or not to apply any level of force and evaluating whether an officer has used reasonable force, a number of factors should be taken into consideration. These factors include, but are not limited to:

1)The conduct of the individual being confronted (as reasonably perceived by the officer at the time).
2)Officer/subject factors (age, size, relative strength, skill level, injury/exhaustion and number of officers vs. subjects).
5)Availability of other options (What resources are reasonably available to the officer under the circumstances).
6)Seriousness of the suspected offense or reason for contact with the individual.
8)Potential for injury to citizens, officers and suspects.
10)Other exigent circumstance.

1 - Protesters surround the cops and verbally, and repeatedly, threaten them.
2 - Officers are extremely outnumbered.
5 - RandFan couldn't do it, but maybe you could list other alternatives that could be used instead of pepper spray (supported with facts is good too)
6 - 1/2 make this a serious issue
8 - manually pulling apart a chain that refuses to come apart puts protester and cop at risk for injury


And really? Turn violent? Threatened?

Crowds have a way of turning violent, and yes, one can be threatened when greatly out numbered.

The UC Davis police force offers no evidence of being threatened until after the pepper-spraying incident

Do you have any sort of expertise that led you to believe this?

Before that they are relaxed, they haven't pulled together into a tight group.

What do you mean 'relaxed'? How tight of a group needs to be formed? Skirmish lines aren't typically formed when going to a picnic.

Pike himself is completely unconcerned. He talks with a protestor, slaps him jovially on the back

Stop using words like "jovial" and "relaxed". I would ask how you are able to observe a "jovial" back-slap, and perhaps you can expand on your knowledge on human posturing that could lead me to believe the police were "relaxed".

And he isn't "talking" to him - he's informing him what will not happen if the protesters do not move, also known as proper police escalation.

then steps over the ones seated, and turns his back on the people he sprays when he does his little spin.

He also grouped up with other officers that were coming in with the car.

Trying to paint this as some sort of defense is just goofy.

That's because you see it as an attack and won't be swayed by anything.
 
Last edited:
Thank you. Was that so hard? I did not see this link and 000063 is on ignore. So, I'm not going to apologize for that but I am greatful.

I accept that this is a single experts opinion. One who works for a police department. It's important to note that this does not tell us what the protocols were for the Davis police officers. However, for the moment, let's accept that you have met that burden of proof so that we might advance the argument. Given the ACLU report, isn't it a bit self serving? How do you reconcile the opinion with the report? Or do you dismiss the report out of hand? Is there a reason to conclude that the Appeals court decision was the result of an anomaly or could it be that the protocols are a problem as the ACLU asserts?

The ACLU report contains several instances of mitigating circumstances. Drugs for one. You could replace the words "pepper spray" with any one of a number of things.

At UC Davis, the less dangerous methods were deployed to no avail, or could not be deployed due to the perps forming their human chain. You know this.

Listen - pepper spray sucks. The easiest way to prevent its use is to not break the law.
 
Do you have any examples of long term sitins.
I will honestly look into it.

You honestly think OWS is worth the inconvenience but what about all those like the residents near Zuccotti park who did not think it was worth all of the "inconveniences they had to put up with.
I honestly do. Given that experts think we are no better off than we were before the housing and bank fiasco I think it is a tiny price to pay. That inconvenience pales to the loss of jobs, pensions and homes. The corruption is prevalent and persistent. Something must be done to change things. I think complaining about OWS is akin to complaining about the tides. Bolshevik revolution, French revolution, Tienanmen square, Arab spring, these are not anomalies that spring up on a whim or because lazy people feel entitled to something. They are the result of a failure of govt to act the interest of the people. The people that deserve blame are not OWS but the

There appeared to be a lack of concern for their rights exhibited by many of the protesters. That bothered me not that it matters.
I understand, those who advocated for the American revolution showed a lack of concern for the rights of the loyalists and those not interested in a new nation. It's impossible to find 100% consensus. But again, I would no more blame the inconvenience of those who struggled because of the bus strike and the sanitation strike on the protestors as I would current problems arising from OWS.
 
I think I missed the part where they tried. Was it the order to disperse memo sent (presumably) from the dean's office? Or a few half-hearted tugs on a leg or two?
No. They asked the protestors to move. They tried gentle physical compulsion. Any stronger compulsion would be more likely to seriously harm the students than pepper spray.

Pepper spray was excessive in this instance because the UC Davis campus police guidelines restrict it's use to the violent or mentally incapacitated. This guideline seems to be universal.
Source.

If you can find a single police or campus police which suggest the use of pepper-spray to remove people who are being stubborn as opposed to violent, I'd love to see it.

Okay, just let me look up nearly every police manual in the English World. And while I'm at it, where's the source for your claim that Pepper Spray was evolved for use against "violent or mentally deranged criminals"?

http://www.denvergov.org/Portals/326/documents/105.pdf
Denver Police Manual said:
Chemical Agent
1. Chemical agents provide an excellent force option in certain situations.
2. Chemical agents may be used when reasonable and justified in the following
situations:
a. To prevent an injury to an officer or a third person.
d. Against subjects resisting arrest.
e. To quell rioting.
f. Against subjects interfering with an arrest.
http://www.cityofseattle.net/Police/publications/Policy/SPD_Manual.pdf
Seattle Police Manual said:
C An officer is justified in using less lethal force in circumstances where an officer reasonable believes that
other force options would be ineffective or impractical
http://www.cityofmadison.com/police/documents/PolicyandProcedureManual.pdf
Madison Wisconsin Police Manual said:
Non-deadly force is only authorized when an officer reasonably believes it is
necessary to control a person under any of the following circumstances:
1. Detaining a person reasonably suspected of unlawful behavior.
http://www.police.tas.gov.au/upload...osures/TPM_RTI_Version_-_11_November_2010.pdf
Tasmania Police Department said:
Police officers are justified in using equipment and Departmentally approved non lethal force techniques for
resolution of incidents as follows:
(a) to protect themselves or another person from physical harm;
(b) to restrain or subdue a resisting individual; or
(c) to bring an unlawful situation safely and effectively under control.
This is the part where you move the goalposts say none of those apply, because UC Davis isn't in those cities, despite the fact that you asked for this information. Of course, all you need to do is provide the UC Davis campus security manual, which I can't seem to find.


And really? Turn violent? Threatened? The UC Davis police force offers no evidence of being threatened until after the pepper-spraying incident. Before that they are relaxed, they haven't pulled together into a tight group. Pike himself is completely unconcerned. He talks with a protestor, slaps him jovially on the back, then steps over the ones seated, and turns his back on the people he sprays when he does his little spin. Trying to paint this as some sort of defense is just goofy.
Yes, because the people surrounding the cops in this video and saying they will not be released until they let the people they have arrested go is not a threat. Here's the exact timestamp, 7:00. I notice how you carefully don't say that the police were not threatened. Almost as if you didn't actually look at extended videos, like the one in my previous post, and are trying to use only the evidence you've already been presented with.

Turning around is not a spin. It's a half-spin at best.

It was punishment, which is the privilege of the courts, not the cops.
It was removal of people actively and illegally obstructing the execution of the duty of officers of the law, which is the job of the police.

http://law.onecle.com/california/penal/148.html
California Penal Code Section 148 said:
(a) (1) Every person who willfully resists, delays, or
obstructs any public officer, peace officer, or an emergency medical
technician, as defined in Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 1797)
of the Health and Safety Code, in the discharge or attempt to
discharge any duty of his or her office or employment, when no other
punishment is prescribed, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding
one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by imprisonment in a county jail
not to exceed one year, or by both that fine and imprisonment.

Watch the video. An expert in police force says the use of force was appropriate. Now you're trying to claim that they were being "punished". They were being taken into custody for obstructing the cops, using standard and appropriate force, according to the expert. Also, you have not admitted to being wrong about the Penn State riots.

EDIT: Oh, look, the manual has been provided. Won't open in Chrome, for some reason. Anyway, it's almost exactly in line with the other police departments I posted. What a shock. THat is the second time in two pages you have been flat out wrong about a claim easily verifiable by Googling. I'm starting to think you're intellectually dishonest. Where's your source on the history of pepper spray development? I doubt you have one. I think you're just repeating what someone else told you that sounded good. Parroting, just like Rand.
 
Last edited:
The ACLU report contains several instances of mitigating circumstances. Drugs for one. You could replace the words "pepper spray" with any one of a number of things.

At UC Davis, the less dangerous methods were deployed to no avail, or could not be deployed due to the perps forming their human chain. You know this.

Listen - pepper spray sucks. The easiest way to prevent its use is to not break the law.
Don't bother. A single expert is Holy Writ when he uses it (even when they aren't really supporting his position, just "investigating"), but not when they have the countervailing opinion.
 
I think complaining about OWS is akin to complaining about the tides. Bolshevik revolution, French revolution, Tienanmen square, Arab spring, these are not anomalies that spring up on a whim or because lazy people feel entitled to something.

Who are the leaders?

Who is the occupy movement leaning toward to get the change they claim they want? You folks need a candidate or candidates that are ready to go to bat for you, don't you? Or do you just point at a bank and say "your fault"?
 
At UC Davis, the less dangerous methods were deployed to no avail, or could not be deployed due to the perps forming their human chain. You know this.
No, I don't know that and I resent the brow beating.

Listen - pepper spray sucks. The easiest way to prevent its use is to not break the law.
Tell that to the protestors of the Arab spring, Soviet dissidents, Chinese dissidents.

I would have been a bit more impressed with the statement had you not said "The easiest way to prevent its use is to not break the law." One could as easily have said, "look, dogs and hoses suck...."

If the investigation rules that there was no excessive force I will accept that. If any lawsuit that might arise from this incident fails I will accept that. I'm not dogmatic. Reason and evidence can change my mind. As it stands I think it is excessive force for the reasons I've stated.
 
Why should they do that? The students, as far as I can tell, were violating the Uni's rules on protests.

Pepper spraying them violated the Uni's rules on policing the student community.

They didn't have a choice. The protestors put themselves in the cops' way. If they prevent the cops from breaking down the camps, they win. If the police use force, they win.

The "cops" could simply have stepped over the protestors.

Patience which would cost UC Davis money. The students were asked to move, and given plenty of time to do so.

So they were violently assaulted to save money? No wonder US dissidents carry signs asking for people to be put before money!
 
Last edited:
No. They asked the protestors to move. They tried gentle physical compulsion. Any stronger compulsion would be more likely to seriously harm the students than pepper spray.

Source.



Okay, just let me look up nearly every police manual in the English World. And while I'm at it, where's the source for your claim that Pepper Spray was evolved for use against "violent or mentally deranged criminals"?

http://www.denvergov.org/Portals/326/documents/105.pdf

http://www.cityofseattle.net/Police/publications/Policy/SPD_Manual.pdf

http://www.cityofmadison.com/police/documents/PolicyandProcedureManual.pdf

http://www.police.tas.gov.au/upload...osures/TPM_RTI_Version_-_11_November_2010.pdf

This is the part where you move the goalposts say none of those apply, because UC Davis isn't in those cities, despite the fact that you asked for this information. Of course, all you need to do is provide the UC Davis campus security manual, which I can't seem to find.


Yes, because the people surrounding the cops in this video and saying they will not be released until they let the people they have arrested go is not a threat. Here's the exact timestamp, 7:00. I notice how you carefully don't say that the police were not threatened. Almost as if you didn't actually look at extended videos, like the one in my previous post, and are trying to use only the evidence you've already been presented with.

Turning around is not a spin. It's a half-spin at best.

It was removal of people actively and illegally obstructing the execution of the duty of officers of the law, which is the job of the police.

http://law.onecle.com/california/penal/148.html


Watch the video. An expert in police force says the use of force was appropriate. Now you're trying to claim that they were being "punished". They were being taken into custody for obstructing the cops, using standard and appropriate force, according to the expert. Also, you have not admitted to being wrong about the Penn State riots.

EDIT: Oh, look, the manual has been provided. Won't open in Chrome, for some reason. Anyway, it's almost exactly in line with the other police departments I posted. What a shock. THat is the second time in two pages you have been flat out wrong about a claim easily verifiable by Googling. I'm starting to think you're intellectually dishonest. Where's your source on the history of pepper spray development? I doubt you have one. I think you're just repeating what someone else told you that sounded good. Parroting, just like Rand.

I know this is probably shunned in these circles, but I'm posting this in the hopes that RandFan will read it. Seems pretty silly to me to ignore someone who provides this much useful information.
 
Occupy SF comes up with a great idea; they are going to start their own credit union.

They will undoubtedly pay their employees a living wage, and if you default on your loan, don't worry; they would never foreclose on your home!

I don't see how this could possibly fail.
:rolleyes:

Are they suggesting that existing credit unions are not serving the needs of neighbourhoods?
 
Who are the leaders?

Who is the occupy movement leaning toward to get the change they claim they want? You folks need a candidate or candidates that are ready to go to bat for you, don't you? Or do you just point at a bank and say "your fault"?
I honestly don't think there is any confusion here whatsoever. The element of the alleged crime is obscure on purpose. The fault lies with the incestuous relationship between govt, banks and wall street.

It needs to stop and I don't think there exists a single politicians who doesn't get it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom