Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Odd that you're unwilling to provide any evidence yourself, and it's you who's making the claim.
Odd that you won't address my arguments with anything substantive. Gainsaying makes for poor argument. In fact, it's not argument at all.
 
Phantom protocols?

I've read several not-so-phantom protocols in the last 2 or 3 pages. We even have a post with neat little pictures! Where do you get that you've not seen protocols?
If I missed them then I sincerely apologize. Could you post a link (links) to those? My thanks in advance.
 
You have GOT to be kidding me.

Maybe I'm a bit fuzzy due to lack of sleep caused by tinnitus....

Here's where I'm at:

RandFan thinks that Pepper Spray is far too dangerous, and other methods are less dangerous, so the police should have used those.

Among those less dangerous methods are firehoses and police dogs.(!?!)

RandFan is asking for evidence/proof/documentation from others that explain the use of pepper spray and other methods of crowd control.

Here's where I get fuzzy:

He doesn't think those have been provided?
 
Last edited:
You do realize that the protest at UC Davis was not terribly unique. Sit-ins and a demonstrations happen at the thousands of US colleges campuses with some regularity. In many cases, the demonstrators are inside a building, an area which would be much more difficult for a police force to exit if they were "surrounded" than an outdoor quad with a row of seated protestors. (That Pike nonchalantly stepped over before spraying them. Oh yeah, the man was obviously terrified, that's why he tossed in a pirouette.:rolleyes:)
I did not say the police were "terrified". I said the protestors had them outnumbered and were deliberately trying to intimidate them. In spite of this, the police reacted in a calm and professional manner, only attempting to remove those who were directly obstructing the passage of their vehicle. In addition, the students who were actively pepper sprayed were, once again, actively impeding the police in their duties, and the police tried all lesser uses of force.

I said the crowd had surrounded the cops, not just the people on the ground. They only left when backup showed up, seconds before Pike used the pepper spray.



I do not see how raising his arm to show the crowd that you are not going to "shoot" the students with a lethal weapon can be considered a "pirouette". You'd rather he applied the pepper spray behind his back? He stepped over them, he turned while holding his arm up so it was clear he was not using a gun, then he used the pepper spray. Your bias is showing.

Also, a pirouette generally requires at least a full turn, not a half, and the dancer has to go up on one leg. Likening Pike to a ballet dancer seems rather an exaggeration.

And yet, we haven't heard about any incidences of pepper-spraying or professors getting hit with clubs or dragged by their hair. Somehow, for years and years now, campus police have done just fine without resorting to weapons evolved for use against violent or mentally deranged criminals.
You're going to need to provide a source for that claim.

I'll bet, like Rand, you cannot off the top of your head even name the alternatives, or describe their pros and cons compared to pepper spray. In fact, I doubt you can explain why such a dangerous, harmful substance is street-legal for personal defense throughout most of the US.

They didn't even pepper-spray the rioters at Penn State.
yes they did.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-11-10/riot-police-use-pepper-spray-on-penn-state-students.html
http://news.yahoo.com/video/tulsakj...epper-spray-in-penn-state-riots-27217022.html
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/11/s...s-in-clashes-after-joe-paterno-is-ousted.html

Those are all the first three google results for "penn state riots pepper spray".

I can see where a street cop might defend the use of pepper spray because the same situation outside of a campus would have a different set of dangers. Americans aren't big on protesting and large gatherings of upset people have let to riots. However, within the campus environment, this sort of thing has a natural progression, the cops have dealt with it before and, aside from campus police over-reaction, have little history of turning violent.
"Except for the times they've turned violent, they don't often turn violent. And most of those were obviously the fault of campus police, so they don't count."

None of which explains why, according to you and Rand, pepper spray was excessive in this particular situation, where the students were actively obstructing police, and could not be removed with lesser force, which the police tried.

You basically addressed nothing in my post, and even made an incorrect point of your own. A man who literally wrote the book on the subject says it was justified, and not unusual procedure.
 
Last edited:
Aside from the pepper spraying incident which was promptly denouced by UC Davis and an investigation was opened is there evidence the federal government is failing to protect the rights of citizens.
My thanks to the tone of your post. And we are in agreement here.

Is breakup up demonstrations that were allowed to go on for long periods of time many times in violation of local laws considered not protecting the rights of the citizens. to me it looks as if government officials, albeit not the federal government, bent over backwards to accomodate the OWS protests.
I would agree that in many instances they did. Not every instance obviously (IMO). Given your premise I don't think it obviates the point about the federal govt given the events like the one where the cop walked up and pepper sprayed the corralled women for no apparent reason but to punish (if you need a link I will provide one).

The citizens whose rights were not protected were those non protesting citizens who were being adversely affected by the OWS demonstations.

Let me make a point for perspective, the rights of citizens during the civil rights protests were adversely affected. The sit-ins and marches were no different than they are now. IMO, the only difference to give weight to your point is to assume that the cause(s) of OWS is/are A.) unimportant or B.) ill defined.

To be perfectly clear. I disagree with both. I would find both presumptive. Arguable. Further, and more importantly, to make such a distinction would be to engage in prior restraint.
 
He doesn't think those have been provided?
Yes and I await your proving me wrong. Yes and I have said I would apologize on being proven wrong. Yes and I have thanked anyone who proves me wrong in advance.

Among those less dangerous methods are firehoses and police dogs.(!?!)
IMO, yes. Is there emperical evidence to the contrary? Or are you appealing to intuition? I provided A.) empirical evidence via the ACLU report and B.) the claims of police. (hey, ask me for a link and see what I do in that case, hint, it won't be to obfuscate and dissemble).
 
(hey, ask me for a link and see what I do in that case, hint, it won't be to obfuscate and dissemble).
Anyone see a difference here?

Look, I'm honestly not trying to be snarky. I resent being told there is evidence out there somewhere and then being refused the evidence or links to that evidence. If I tell you that I provided evidence for cold fusion in a thread last January and it is your job to find it and rebut it, wouldn't you object? Honestly now?
 
If a man has a bad ticker, and gets attacked by a police dog, he can die of cardiac arrest.

If a person is hopped up on drugs, and gets pepper sprayed, there's a possibility their airway can be constricted and he can die.

What's the difference?
Yes and I await your proving me wrong. Yes and I have said I would apologize on being proven wrong. Yes and I have thanked anyone who proves me wrong in advance.


What you're asking for has been provided so many times, it's almost funny.

Almost.
 
I did not say the police were "terrified". I said the protestors had them outnumbered and were deliberately trying to intimidate them. In addition, the students who were actively pepper sprayed were, once again, actively impeding the police in their duties, and the police tried all lesser uses of force.

I said the crowd had surrounded the cops, not just the people on the ground. They only left when backup showed up, seconds before Pike used the pepper spray.



You're going to need to provide a source for that claim.

I'll bet, like Rand, you cannot off the top of your head even name the alternatives, or describe their pros and cons compared to pepper spray. In fact, I doubt you can explain why such a dangerous, harmful substance is street-legal for personal defense throughout most of the US.

yes they did.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-11-10/riot-police-use-pepper-spray-on-penn-state-students.html
http://news.yahoo.com/video/tulsakj...epper-spray-in-penn-state-riots-27217022.html
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/11/s...s-in-clashes-after-joe-paterno-is-ousted.html

Those are all the first three google results for "penn state riots pepper spray".

"Except for the times they've turned violent, they don't often turn violent. And most of those were obviously the fault of campus police, so they don't count."

None of which explains why, according to you and Rand, pepper spray was excessive in this particular situation, where the students were actively obstructing police, and could not be removed with lesser force, which the police tried.

I think I missed the part where they tried. Was it the order to disperse memo sent (presumably) from the dean's office? Or a few half-hearted tugs on a leg or two?

Pepper spray was excessive in this instance because the UC Davis campus police guidelines restrict it's use to the violent or mentally incapacitated. This guideline seems to be universal. If you can find a single police or campus police which suggest the use of pepper-spray to remove people who are being stubborn as opposed to violent, I'd love to see it. (also, you might want to dig up some guidelines about post pepper-spray use - cops are supposed to decontaminate and monitor people they have sprayed.)

And really? Turn violent? Threatened? The UC Davis police force offers no evidence of being threatened until after the pepper-spraying incident. Before that they are relaxed, they haven't pulled together into a tight group. Pike himself is completely unconcerned. He talks with a protestor, slaps him jovially on the back, then steps over the ones seated, and turns his back on the people he sprays when he does his little spin. Trying to paint this as some sort of defense is just goofy.

It was punishment, which is the privilege of the courts, not the cops.
 
Last edited:
Let me make a point for perspective, the rights of citizens during the civil rights protests were adversely affected. The sit-ins and marches were no different than they are now. IMO, the only difference to give weight to your point is to assume that the cause(s) of OWS is/are A.) unimportant or B.) ill defined.

To be perfectly clear. I disagree with both. I would find both presumptive. Arguable. Further, and more importantly, to make such a distinction would be to engage in prior restraint.

I am going strictly upon my memory of the peace and civil rights demonstrations but,

In my recolection for the most part the rights of other citizens were only adversely affected for a short period of time. The OWS protester are expecting to be able to occupy an area for weeks or months at a times.

To me this is the difference. Why should whether or not I(or you) feel a cause is unimportant or ill defined have anything to do with if someone has a right to demonstrate.
 
If a man has a bad ticker, and gets attacked by a police dog, he can die of cardiac arrest.

If a person is hopped up on drugs, and gets pepper sprayed, there's a possibility their airway can be constricted and he can die.

What's the difference?
That's fair. Just an opinion based on intuition and what I would chose between given the option.

What you're asking for has been provided so many times, it's almost funny.
And wouldn't it be a kick in the head to show me? Wow, wouldn't that just make me look silly (even though I never claimed it didn't exist).

So, I guess that proof won't be forthcoming then? Kinda like my proof for cold fusion, it's there but it's up to others to find.
 
link

There is commentary from a police officer from Baltimore in there, an expert on these matters. His opinion should carry the weight you seek. The link was provided by 000063
 
I would take the dogs.

I take it you've never been attacked by a dog.

I was, two years ago, the thing tried to rip my left hand off and only stopped when I brained it with a beer bottle. I lost the use of my left arm for three days, had to maintain a steady diet of antibiotics and painkillers and...bonus, this was in Thailand so I had to undergo anti-rabies treatment.

A police dog is a nasty, nasty weapon.
 
In my recolection for the most part the rights of other citizens were only adversely affected for a short period of time. The OWS protester are expecting to be able to occupy an area for weeks or months at a times.

To me this is the difference.
Not my recolection. The sit-ins at campuses during the 60s and 70s were not for a short period of time at all. Perhaps shorter. But let's grant the premise to advance the discussion. Would it really matter? What good is civil disobedience if the powers that be can figure out ahead of time just how long to allow it before it's detrimental to their cause?

Look, I admit that OWS effect the rights of citizens. It's nothing compared to the trillions wiped out from the corruption of wall street. I honestly think OWS is worth the inconvenience. The bus strike hurt and/or inconvenienced people. The sanitation strike hurt and/or inconvenienced people. If you are arguing that inconvenience or infringement of other rights like visiting a park are the benchmark then I cannot agree.

Why should whether or not I(or you) feel a cause is unimportant or ill defined have anything to do with if someone has a right to demonstrate.
Isn't that the purpose of the thread (see thread title)? In any event, it does not have anything whatsoever to with anything. Thank you.
 
That's fair. Just an opinion based on intuition and what I would chose between given the option.

You would rather be attacked by police dog(s)?

:jaw-dropp

Have you ever met a police dog? I have. Yikes. Thankfully it was my friend's father's dog. I'd hate to be on the recieving end of their job description.


I understand this is a long thread, but this was posted last night.

FIVE posts later, you posted. FIVE. This is like the drivel you'd see Ergo or Miragememories do. You're better than that, aren't you?
 
Last edited:
Prove it.
Already did. Go read it.

But I am willing to keep posting the URL.
First you say you won't keep repeating yourself, then when the obvious hypocrisy is pointed out, you say you will. Funny that.

Folks, again, I'm willing to dial down the snark in order to have a rational conversation.

Oops, that didn't last long:

BTW: I posted the evidence that proves 9/11 was a conspiracy and the existence of god, leprechauns and fairies. Go read it.
--And that makes hypocrisy #2.
 
Because it was both breaking the school's rules and obstructing other students.

Their rule-breaking and obstruction was very minor. Why not just ignore them?

I'm not sure why you expect me to link you to every single person who has expressed a desire for Kelly's bodily harm.

You claimed "hundreds". Your supporting evidence was a "bunch", of which one actually supported your claim.


He put me on ignore because I kept asking him to prove his points and find evidence for himself rather than regurgitating the opinions of "experts".

No he didn't.

You may be oblivious to your intellectual dishonesty. Others aren't. It makes having an honest conversation with you impossible.

Stop it. Have an honest conversation with me or I'm putting you on ignore.



Sure is strange how many people Rand has had to threaten to break off conversation with in the last few pages, all of whom asked him to back up his claim. In my case, I got put on his Ignore List after asking him to seek evidence to support his own point about Excessive Force, instead of claiming to be just regurgitating the opinions of "experts" when I asked him to present alternatives. Currently, it's his opinion again.

Another intellectually dishonest post.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom