Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

And how many levels did your avatar go up for that?

Again, you just can't stand to see anyone rationally discuss the facts of an issue that you don't understand, so you pee in the pool with strawmen fallacies and whining challenges when you are called on those fallacies.
Projecting much?

I am literally asking you to openly prove me wrong, and you just keep on with the personal attacks instead of doing so. In fact, your posts in this thread have a remarkably high Ad Hominem/actual logic ratio, especially when people directly contradict you. I certainly hope that's not typical.

I think that the police should have used the best means possible to deal with an evolving situation.

So what exactly is your point in making up a load of horse manure like you just did and pretending I said that's what I believe?

The only place that drivel has currency is inside your head.
Shhhh! Someone might actually get the idea that you are trolling, and we wouldn't want that now would we?
 
I think that the police should have used the best means possible to deal with an evolving situation.

So what exactly is your point in making up a load of horse manure like you just did and pretending I said that's what I believe?

The only place that drivel has currency is inside your head.

You're right, I'm sorry, you never said that people should be lifted over the barrier. I thought you had said that or endorsed it. My apologies.

Could you explain exactly what "the best means possible" were?

My point that the following two posts are kind of hypocritical, even though I didn't explicitly make it, still stands though.

Again, you just can't stand to see anyone rationally discuss the facts of an issue that you don't understand, so you pee in the pool with strawmen fallacies and whining challenges when you are called on those fallacies.

Ahhh but cops are always supposed to know that granny isn't dangerous, or the kids are just having fun, or that white folks belong in this neighborhood, and so forth.

And besides, I'm sure one of our resident 'experts' will be happy to explain how the cops can simply shoot the knife out of the attacker's hand.

:wink:

Isn't the second post a perfect example of a strawman fallacy and a whining challenge?
 
That's exactly what happened.

So we agree!
As I've said since the onset, my point here is that cops can still be in trouble for actions that would usually be deemed appropriate, if the brass hangs them out to dry, and that this could be such a case.
 
You're right, I'm sorry, you never said that people should be lifted over the barrier. I thought you had said that or endorsed it. My apologies.

Could you explain exactly what "the best means possible" were?

My point that the following two posts are kind of hypocritical, even though I didn't explicitly make it, still stands though.

Isn't the second post a perfect example of a strawman fallacy and a whining challenge?

No, it is a perfect example of sarcasm. Note the winking smiley?

Did you just get Poeslawed?

ETA: As far as hindsight about what should have been done in that exact situation, no, thank you.
I've not said that I saw anything notably wrong with the actions of either the students or the officers.

In general, there is training for crowd control, and picking people up and carrying them is not the first thing on the list of removal options.
Should it become necessary, then the one of the OSC's responsibilities would be how to safely extract over human or envoronmental obstacles.
 
Last edited:
Projecting much?

I am literally asking you to openly prove me wrong, and you just keep on with the personal attacks instead of doing so. In fact, your posts in this thread have a remarkably high Ad Hominem/actual logic ratio, especially when people directly contradict you. I certainly hope that's not typical.


​
And again, when a skeptic points out that you are using well documented logical fallacies, instead of dealing in relevant facts and rational conclusions, it isn't a personal attack to call you on them.

That's how discourse works.

The demands to prove reality, or to prove what has already been proven on the other hand, are how *debate* works.

You seem to be here only to debate, which I find to be a boring waste of time.
 
Last edited:
And again, when a skeptic points out that you are using well documented logical fallacies, instead of dealing in relevant facts and rational conclusions, it isn't a personal attack to call you on them.
It is, however, a personal attack to repeatedly make claims about another and offer no evidence while not actually addressing the argument at hand. Discussing the alleged errors of another with evidence, however, is something the mods do not generally consider a personal attack.

I have asked you to prove me wrong, and already admitted I was wrong on a matter discussed upthread.

That's how discourse works.

The demands to prove reality, or to prove what has already been proven on the other hand, are how *debate* works.
Proven to who, pray tell? And I note that you are specifically not stating what you are referring to as "reality" or "what has already been proven". Your posts grow more and more abstract.

You seem to be here only to debate, which I find to be a boring waste of time.
I'm here to discuss things. You have made several claims which have been, I believe, proven wrong. I believe they were honest misunderstandings, but you stubbornly insist on ignoring corrections or even discussing your possible mistake, preferring instead to discuss me.

Now I have explained in detail what I believe to be your errors, and turnabout is fair play. I have handed you both my petard and the match, yet you refuse to touch light to fuse. Curious.
 
It is, however, a personal attack to repeatedly make claims about another and offer no evidence while not actually addressing the argument at hand. Discussing the alleged errors of another with evidence, however, is something the mods do not generally consider a personal attack.

I have asked you to prove me wrong, and already admitted I was wrong on a matter discussed upthread.

Proven to who, pray tell? And I note that you are specifically not stating what you are referring to as "reality" or "what has already been proven". Your posts grow more and more abstract.

I'm here to discuss things. You have made several claims which have been, I believe, proven wrong. I believe they were honest misunderstandings, but you stubbornly insist on ignoring corrections or even discussing your possible mistake, preferring instead to discuss me.

Now I have explained in detail what I believe to be your errors, and turnabout is fair play. I have handed you both my petard and the match, yet you refuse to touch light to fuse. Curious.
You've proven nothing that I said as 'wrong'. You've merely asserted it.

You have repeatedly made up positions that I never claimed and argued against *them*.

That's a textbook strawman fallacy, end of story, and yes, I've stubbornly persisted in ignoring your attempts to get me to own them. I've asked you to address what I actually posted, and you simply won't do that.

And there can be no innnocent misunderstanding on your part, when I have clarified repeatedly:
As I've said since the onset, my point here is that cops can still be in trouble for actions that would usually be deemed appropriate, if the brass hangs them out to dry, and that this could be such a case.

On the more recent issue, it is up to the person making the extreme assertions to provide extreme proof.

I've asserted that it is not automatically illegal to 'impede' anyone, as the other poster claimed. If it were, every time someone got in front of me in the Express checkout with 21 items, I could arrest them.
*Obstruction* of LEOs, is of course, a different matter. And 'serious charges' would be an inaccurate description for a misdemeanor offense.
http://www.dmv.ca.gov/pubs/vctop/appndxa/penalco/penco148.htm


I've asserted that the 'serious charge' involving hostages under state law would commonly be referred to as kidnapping, instead of going into details about the difference.
Referring to what happened in that video as either kidnapping or hostage taking is laughable. The notion that those officers were in fear, or not free to leave simply doesn't match up.
http://www.shouselaw.com/false-imprisonment-hostage.html


I'll leave it anyone who wants to, to figure out why your bringing in federal criminal code is a strawman when talking about California officers.

So, you assert that I'm wrong in the above, where's your proof?

I predict another round of spin and evasion, but hey, who knows? I could be mistaken.
 
Last edited:
So would the police be able to reliably carry handcuffed suspects safely over the line, without risking harm or impediment to anyone? Yes, no, or I don't know. If you say "yes", then it's not a very good barrier, is it?

The answer is yes, and that's my point. It's not a very good barrier.

I said "not just a weapon". It is both a weapon, and a tool to get suspects to comply with officers.

So is a baseball bat. What's your point? The use of the tool on a person is still an act of violence. Such violence must be justified.

They have tasers, dogs, cars, foot chases, and pepper spray for that. Shooting someone in the thigh may hit an artery and kill them, or severely injure them. Use of deadly force is a last resort.

Use of violence, at all, should be the second-to-last resort.

You have no idea what use of force standards are, do you?

That doesn't matter. I'm not arguing based on the "force standards."
 
The answer is yes, and that's my point. It's not a very good barrier.

Actually, the answer is "no".

It is not easy to carry someone who doesn't want to be carried over people who don't want to be stepped over.

Try it...

It is also (tactically) suicide. The person carrying is exposing their softest underparts to the crowd and have their hands occupied. It would be idiocy of the highest order to try to do that.

With a user name like yours, I am surprised this hasn't occured to you...
 
The answer is yes, and that's my point. It's not a very good barrier.
Incorrect. Find three friends and try it. Two to form the line, one to have his hands bound behind his back and act as a resisting prisoner. Or try it with four friends, and have two "cops".

Remember, by obstructing you, the people on the ground are subject to arrest, and you have no guarantee that they won't actively try to impede your progress, especially since they're part of a crowd that has issued threats to you.

So is a baseball bat. What's your point?
If people were sitting in a circle around me, I'd simply step over them, or jump. If they grab for me, then that would be violence and would justify pepper spray.
...
Pepper spray is a compliance tool, not just a weapon. It is not necessarily used by police officers in response to violence. In fact, it is usually used to prevent violence by making it easier for officers to subdue suspects.
My point is that you were wrong. Use of pepper spray does not require violence to have been committed to be justified. You were also wrong about cops shooting people in the thigh to prevent escape, which they do not and are not trained to do. You have demonstrated remarkable ignorance about the effects and standards for use of force.

The use of the tool on a person is still an act of violence. Such violence must be justified.
Disengaging suspects from each other to effect an arrest safely. I note that you do not request justification for the students' attempts to hinder and threaten officers.

Use of violence, at all, should be the second-to-last resort.
Incorrect. Pepper spray is actually around the middle. Boadly: Officer presence > verbal request > pepper spray/ taser > [other stuff] > deadly force (guns). And they tried the first two.

That doesn't matter.
So, no.

I'm not arguing based on the "force standards."
Yet you are willing to condemn the police's use of same. Said standards specifically include what harm is likely to occur based on use of said force. Those standards informed UCPD's decision, and are thus directly relevant to discussing that decision.

You are aware that college students who apparently have lungs healthy enough to yell "F* THE POLICE!" in response to Pike's attempts to communicate with them are not at any sort of significant risk for serious harm from pepper spray, I assume? And there is no evidence of Brown's allegedly "coughing blood" student. Read his account closely, and he does not actually say he witnessed the events personally. He's just repeating what people told him. Feel free to dig up the ACLU report on pepper spray; I already have my cannon run out and loaded, and can blow it out of the water.

You're not arguing based on anything other than your belief that what the cops did was wrong, as far as I can tell.
 
Last edited:
You've proven nothing that I said as 'wrong'. You've merely asserted it.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8057425#post8057425
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8066754&postcount=111

You have repeatedly made up positions that I never claimed and argued against *them*.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8057735&postcount=76
This is where I point out you "distilled" an entire post of mine down to a single line, while dismissing the entire rest of the post and attacking me. A straw man.

You still haven't proved your earlier statement about UCPD force standards.

That's a textbook strawman fallacy, end of story, and yes, I've stubbornly persisted in ignoring your attempts to get me to own them. I've asked you to address what I actually posted, and you simply won't do that.
I've asked you to prove me wrong. The simplest way to do that would be to say what you actually posted.

And there can be no innnocent misunderstanding on your part, when I have clarified repeatedly:

As I've said since the onset, my point here is that cops can still be in trouble for actions that would usually be deemed appropriate, if the brass hangs them out to dry, and that this could be such a case.
So if there's no innocent misunderstanding on my part, that means
a)I'm deliberately misinterpreting (lying)
b)You're innocently misinterpreting
c)You're deliberately misinterpreting

On the more recent issue, it is up to the person making the extreme assertions to provide extreme proof.
Such as the guy saying I make strawmen, yet providing no links to prove such?

I've asserted that it is not automatically illegal to 'impede' anyone, as the other poster claimed.
Schplurg. Their name is schplurg.

If it were, every time someone got in front of me in the Express checkout with 21 items, I could arrest them.
Arguably true, but I don't recall you making that argument earlier.

*Obstruction* of LEOs, is of course, a different matter. And 'serious charges' would be an inaccurate description for a misdemeanor offense.
I had no idea "serious" was an objective definition. I'm betting a student spending a few months in jail would likely disagree.

Well, that's weird, because schul claimed

...
The crowd was certainly threatening! Impeding the progress of a police officer - or anyone for that matter - is certainly threatening. But, more importantly, it's illegal. Shouting that they won't "Let them go" unless their friends are released is certainly illegal too. If you wanted to get technical, some serious charges could have resulted. They were, in effect, holding the police hostage...

Then you posted, in response to someone else

The 'fuss' was the claim that the other students could have been arrested on the 'serious charge' of kidnapping.

The reality is that it would have been laughed out of court, and handed someone a nice fat check for false arrest or malicious prosecution..
You were referring to Schplurg's post, yet he never accused them of kidnapping, or said that they were literally kidnapping, and I provided a link that shows hostage taking is itself a federal crime regardless of whether kidnapping occurs. Schplurg said their actions had effects comparable to kidnapping.

I've asserted that the 'serious charge' involving hostages under state law would commonly be referred to as kidnapping, instead of going into details about the difference.
You asserted that Schplurg said it was kidnapping. This is false.

Referring to what happened in that video as either kidnapping or hostage taking is laughable. The notion that those officers were in fear,
That's the same "they didn't feel threatened!" straw man people have been throwing out since the start. The claim is that the hostile crowd both issued a threat to the officers and was a credible threat to their safety, in addition to mere obstruction. Unless one ignored to "continue to protest peacefully" remark, this is true.

So the crowd of dozens of people who said they wouldn't let the police go were incorrect?

I'll leave it anyone who wants to, to figure out why your bringing in federal criminal code is a strawman when talking about California officers.
Schplurg did not say where these serious charges would be laid, or even go into much detail. Limiting it to California is your restriction, not his. My example was to show that the "serious charges" need not be kidnapping, even if Schplurg had meant that the police were literally being held hostage, which I do not believe he did.

IF
Schplurg did not mean the police were literally taken hostage
THEN
The 'serious charges' must have been something else, such as the obstruction and threats he explicitly mentioned as illegal.

IF
Schplurg did mean the police were literally taken hostage
THEN
The serious charges need not be kidnapping, which still does not rule out the obstruction and threats he explicitly mentioned as illegal.

And this is ignoring the fact that the first few sentences of that paragraph clearly state that impeding and threatening the cops are illegal. You focused mainly on the portion you interpreted as "they were literally kidnapping/holding the cops hostage".

I find it interesting that you never responded to Schplurg's post itself, but you still were willing to scoff at it.

So, you assert that I'm wrong in the above, where's your proof?
Considering that I just showed you have a fairly flexible interpretation of others' statements, no need.

I predict another round of spin and evasion, but hey, who knows? I could be mistaken.
You certainly are. On many things.
 
Last edited:
[You certainly are. On many things.
But not on this.

My links are posted, my references are cited, and my points are clear.

You've got nothing but the expected tap dance, complete with high school debate club 'cleverness', and outright lies... which are a total validation of my prediction.

Your false claim that post #104 simply doesn't exist ('you never responded to)' is typical. Just like your repeated claim that the Chancellor never made the statements I linked to. And when you later posture with 'See what an honest person I am, I admit my completely innocent mistakes', you prove me right about you refusing to engage in honest discourse.

You continue to pretend that obstruction is 'serious charges', even after the link proves it is merely a misdemeanor.

You run away from actually addressing your ludicrous insertion of federal hostage laws into a situation involving California officers.

You simply 'don't recall' things that are inconvenient to your fantasy of being an expert.

At one point you say that it is arguably true that impeding anyoneis not illegal, then you later say that the other poster was right to claim it was illegal. You can't even keep track of your game within one post.

You still haven't proven your claim that I'm totally wrong to say that the lawsuit includes issues of vicarious liability.

If you are going to keep playing the 'You can never get me to admit I'm wrong, no matter how many facts and citations you link to, or what logic you employ La-la-la-la-la, are so one too!' game, at least try to get some skills.

As I said, your bush league tactics are simply boring... maybe not to you, but definitely to me.
 
Last edited:
Keep it civil please. Ensure your posts address the argument, not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
Do moderators get to carry pepper spray?

;)
 
Last edited:
Keep it civil please. Ensure your posts address the argument, not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
Okay. I think the matter has been resolved to everyone's satisfaction anyway.

I'm still waiting for Ken to try my little experiment. I think I mentioned it in the last thread, and he never got around to it then either.
 
This certainly satisfies my interest in the matter.


28. Defendant JOHN PIKE is a Lieutenant in the University of California at Davis Police Department. As a result of the actions described in this complaint Defendant Pike was placed on leave by the University. He is sued in his individual capacity.
http://edca.typepad.com/files/baker-v.-katehi-12-cv-450-jam.pdf

Now that the filing is available and instead of arguing that the complaint against the police officer should proceed in the face of the immunity of his official capacity, it names him individually. Katehi is named in her official and individual capacity.

WHAAAT???? :eek:

Buuuhh...buuuhh...buuuh.....buuuhhtt... How could that ever possibly be???

We've been assured that there would be no way that the officer could be separated from the immunity against being sued for the performance of lawful official duties.
We were told in no uncertain terms that the notion of vicarious liability hanging him out to dry, and forcing him to defend himself personally, simply didn't exist.
In fact, we were promised that was just crazy talk.

Oh well, maybe declaring that those claims were never posted, or that this simply isn't true, or that it means the exact opposite of what it says, and then demanding proof of a negative (as was done with previous links to articles and such) will work its magic...
 
Last edited:
This certainly satisfies my interest in the matter.



http://edca.typepad.com/files/baker-v.-katehi-12-cv-450-jam.pdf

Now that the filing is available and instead of arguing that the complaint against the police officer should proceed in the face of the immunity of his official capacity, it names him individually. Katehi is named in her official and individual capacity.

WHAAAT???? :eek:

Buuuhh...buuuhh...buuuh.....buuuhhtt... How could that ever possibly be???

We've been assured that there would be no way that the officer could be separated from the immunity against being sued for the performance of lawful official duties.
We were told in no uncertain terms that the notion of vicarious liability hanging him out to dry, and forcing him to defend himself personally, simply didn't exist.
In fact, we were promised that was just crazy talk.

Oh well, maybe declaring that those claims were never posted, or that this simply isn't true, or that it means the exact opposite of what it says, and then demanding proof of a negative (as was done with previous links to articles and such) will work its magic...

Me? I never understood the side-track about whether such a suit could be brought, so I'm not concerned that all the claims that it couldn't turned out to be wrong.

To me, the interesting questions have always been: "Do I think the police acted appropriately?" and "Will the justice system reach the same conclusion I did?"

I guess if you thought the interesting question was "can a clever lawyer figure out a way to sue a cop on allegations of being mean to someone", then this thread has taken an exciting turn.
 
Me? I never understood the side-track about whether such a suit could be brought, so I'm not concerned that all the claims that it couldn't turned out to be wrong.

To me, the interesting questions have always been: "Do I think the police acted appropriately?" and "Will the justice system reach the same conclusion I did?"

I guess if you thought the interesting question was "can a clever lawyer figure out a way to sue a cop on allegations of being mean to someone", then this thread has taken an exciting turn.
I understand that.
Which is why I've pointed out more than once that my interest was in the real world legal aspects, and not in armchair quarterbacking the specific techniques used.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom