Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Because if you have no substantive argument, then hoping to invoke the baser emotions of the crowd will pass for oratory.
What was that you were saying a few pages back about the "police brutality" on the "seated, unarmed peaceful protestors" or suchlike?

If you bother to read the whole of beachnut's thoughts on the 'surrounded' cops, you'll appreciate that if the 'surrounding' was the real threat then they wouldn't have wasted the pepper spray on seated, unarmed, non-threatening students.
Yes, he asserted that the cops would've done something differently if they were surrounded. However, he has neglected to say what that would be, like most people who condemn the cops ' actions.

Again, police do not require suspects to be actively or even passively posing a threat to use pepper spray. Physical resistance is usually enough.

Weird how you were suggesting the cops try "patience and communication" in that situation earlier, and now you're suggesting it would've been a good idea to use more force if they "really" were threatened. They waited in defensive positions around the prisoners, and when backup arrived and cleared a hole in the outer protestors, they disengaged the inner students after several warnings using pepper spray.

They weren't interested in resolving the situation peaceably and with the least risk. They were interested in displaying their strength, and chose the easiest target.
They waited in defensive positions around the prisoners. They tried to take the prisoners out individually, in response to which the students formed the inner ring to hinder that, in addition to tightening up the outer ring. Before Pike used pepper spray, the police attempted to convince the students to leave on their own. They tried pulling them apart the easy way. After the outer ring was cleared by backup, Pike, again, warned the students he was going to use pepper spray if they didn't move. The students were given every chance to just get up and leave without being arrested.

Those aren't the actions of police putting on a "show of force". Those are the textbook actions of police to reduce risk and injury to themselves and suspects. They could've pulled the students apart without pepper spray, but as studies linked in this thread have shown, the use of pepper spray decreases risk of injury to both officer and suspect, especially in cases where suspects may physically resist, as the students were already doing when the cops tried lesser force.

You are wrong. Again.

Basically, you can't actually prove the cops were in the wrong or acting with unnecessary or atypical force, and now all you can do is make snide insinuations about their "motivations", claims not borne out by evidence.

Weird how you condemn the cops for their "show of force", but it's perfectly fine for an angry mob to try and force the cops to give up their prisoners. Weird how you insist this was not the least-risk course of action, and/or the cops were interested in such a course, yet you have point-blank refused to provide alternatives to what they actually did other than "not what they did". It's a non-falsifiable position. You literally cannot think of what it would take to prove you wrong. You have already made it clear you think the cops should not have tried to remove them, period, so any use of force would be unjustifiable in your eyes.

Of course, the second-least risk would've been for the cops to just abandon their prisoners at the request of an angry mob. The least would've been for the students to let the cops leave with their prisoners.
 
Last edited:
You think you can't threaten someone with words? So if I were to say to someone on this forum that I would go by their house with a gun, I wouldn't be banned or get a warning?

You're missing the point. Yes, the students were sitting and unarmed, but that is not why they were pepper sprayed. They were pepper sprayed because they didn't want the police to leave with their arrestees. (Is that a word in English?) I think that is illegal, because the police should be allowed to do their job. Why won't you go into that?

Also, saying "seek help" doesn't address the argument and isn't very civil or polite.
JQ doesn't want to discuss the obstruction aspect. This might have something to do with the fact that literally everyone involved in the incident says the students were obstructing police. Even JQ's own arguments, if you read between the lines, say the students were obstructing police.

So they've retreated to their fallback position, that the seated students--and specifically those students, not the greater crowd--were not actively threatening or assaulting police, and were thus "peaceful". They have ignored, repeatedly, that cops don't need to be under active or passive threat to use pepper spray on suspects. In fact, just about any discussion of the actual standards and effects of use of force has been studiously ignored, unless you count Beachnut suggesting all the cops should've arrested all the students and marched them into the Chancellor's office, though I suspect he may have been a little drunk at the time.
 
Last edited:
Ouch

THE REYNOSO TASK FORCE REPORT said:
page 24 Lt. Pike Bears Primary Responsibility for the Objectively Unreasonable Decision to Use Pepper Spray on the Students Sitting in a Line and for the Manner in Which the Pepper Spray Was Used

...

In fact, it was during one of the “If you let them go, we will let you leave” chants that [Officer F] was able to leave, escorting an arrestee to an awaiting police car by simply walking him straight through the crowd, without incident or force escalation. then [Officer F] returned and escorted another arrestee out through the crowd, again without incident.
Again, Wow.
 
That must be a liberal Task Force Report!
Hi Ken. Did you ever get around to trying that experiment? Letting your friends try and manhandle you over a line of people with arms linked like the students were?

Let the backpedalling begin.
Why? I've asserted several times that a)the crowd closed ranks after a few cops got out, and b)the ring of seated students was attempting to hinder the police's attempts to remove their prisoners safely. No one has been able to find a single piece of audio or video between the students forming their seated ring and Pike deploying pepper spray where the police transported prisoners out through the crowd. They didn't even try, because they knew they couldn't do it safely.

How could anybody think that a Task Force headed by Cruz Reynoso would be liberal?
Time for something from "Yes, Prime Minister".

 

When I saw the coward spray the kids I knew it was a mistake. I know the school layout, the quad at UC Davis. Knowing.

Truthiness!

haUOv.jpg


It could've been prevented by the students letting the cops walk off, or not sea-lawyering about "overnight" encampments. Once the students were asked to move the tents, it became effectively trespassing. The report's implication that the cops had some sort of moral or legal responsibility to ask the organizers to remove the tents is also ludicrous.

You still haven't been able to find any evidence the cops were able to transport prisoners after the seated students formed their little barrier to keep them from transporting prisoners.
 
Last edited:
WThey were pepper sprayed because they didn't want the police to leave with the people the police arrested.

But the police were able to leave with the people the police arrested. Even if the seated protestors intended to prevent the police from doing their job, it didn't work.

THE REYNOSO TASK FORCE REPORT said:
page 24 In fact, it was during one of the “If you let them go, we will let you leave” chants that [Officer F] was able to leave, escorting an arrestee to an awaiting police car by simply walking him straight through the crowd, without incident or force escalation. then [Officer F] returned and escorted another arrestee out through the crowd, again without incident.
 
And as I just pointed out for the nth time, they were not able to safely do so after the protestors formed the inner line. The report even says that one of the prisoners refused to walk, meaning the police would have to lift and carry him over that line. Keep in mind that just forming the line makes the protestors obstructors, and subject to arrest. Even the students in question say they were trying to obstruct the cops.
 
Why? I've asserted several times that a)the crowd closed ranks after a few cops got out, and b)the ring of seated students was attempting to hinder the police's attempts to remove their prisoners safely. No one has been able to find a single piece of audio or video between the students forming their seated ring and Pike deploying pepper spray where the police transported prisoners out through the crowd. They didn't even try, because they knew they couldn't do it safely.
No one except of course, the 2 reports. They were easily able to find *other* police walking back and forth, including with arrestees, with no problem. And they show Pike as breaking vicarious liability on mutiple points, as explained to you over and over.

No one forced you to pontificate on a subject of which you had no knowledge, and no amount of your strawmen, cherry picking, fake quotes, or denier tricks is going to change the fact that these reports contradict your homemade 'facts' at every turn.
 
Last edited:
One of the things the reports debunk is the whole notion of having to remove anyone from anywhere... the UC police had made no arrangements for transport.
No bus, no wagon, not even a van.

What were they going to do with all these arrestees that they were supposedly unable to 'get out'? Ask them to hitchhike down to lockup in cuffs?

The OSC had completely abdicated any command role and was just grabbing people by the arm while the Davis PD stared at him. You can't command crowd control operations from the middle of the crowd, there has to be someone at an OP/CP of some kind.

So the whole 'preventing them from removing prisoners' and 'obstructing justice' memes are simply red herrings, there was no legitimate operation being obstructed, because there was no anti-personnel operation underway... because crowd control was never planned or authorized.

The other vicarious liability aspect the reports describe was the use of the MK-9 canisters.

While it might not seem like such a big deal that Pike was not trained or authorized to have that instead of the MK-4, there is more to it than just a difference in size... because the MK-9 is high volume, it uses a different propellant charge, which leads to a minimum safe distance for deployment of six feet....
Because the training was never held, even the University's instructor on chemical agents did not know that.
Which means that when Pike took it upon himself to open up at short range, he was operating outside of manufacture'rs specs, and outside of policy.

And that is classic vicarious liability, which gives the university immunity if they hang him out to dry... as the lawsuit indicates they already have.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom