What was that you were saying a few pages back about the "police brutality" on the "seated, unarmed peaceful protestors" or suchlike?Because if you have no substantive argument, then hoping to invoke the baser emotions of the crowd will pass for oratory.
Yes, he asserted that the cops would've done something differently if they were surrounded. However, he has neglected to say what that would be, like most people who condemn the cops ' actions.If you bother to read the whole of beachnut's thoughts on the 'surrounded' cops, you'll appreciate that if the 'surrounding' was the real threat then they wouldn't have wasted the pepper spray on seated, unarmed, non-threatening students.
Again, police do not require suspects to be actively or even passively posing a threat to use pepper spray. Physical resistance is usually enough.
Weird how you were suggesting the cops try "patience and communication" in that situation earlier, and now you're suggesting it would've been a good idea to use more force if they "really" were threatened. They waited in defensive positions around the prisoners, and when backup arrived and cleared a hole in the outer protestors, they disengaged the inner students after several warnings using pepper spray.
They waited in defensive positions around the prisoners. They tried to take the prisoners out individually, in response to which the students formed the inner ring to hinder that, in addition to tightening up the outer ring. Before Pike used pepper spray, the police attempted to convince the students to leave on their own. They tried pulling them apart the easy way. After the outer ring was cleared by backup, Pike, again, warned the students he was going to use pepper spray if they didn't move. The students were given every chance to just get up and leave without being arrested.They weren't interested in resolving the situation peaceably and with the least risk. They were interested in displaying their strength, and chose the easiest target.
Those aren't the actions of police putting on a "show of force". Those are the textbook actions of police to reduce risk and injury to themselves and suspects. They could've pulled the students apart without pepper spray, but as studies linked in this thread have shown, the use of pepper spray decreases risk of injury to both officer and suspect, especially in cases where suspects may physically resist, as the students were already doing when the cops tried lesser force.
You are wrong. Again.
Basically, you can't actually prove the cops were in the wrong or acting with unnecessary or atypical force, and now all you can do is make snide insinuations about their "motivations", claims not borne out by evidence.
Weird how you condemn the cops for their "show of force", but it's perfectly fine for an angry mob to try and force the cops to give up their prisoners. Weird how you insist this was not the least-risk course of action, and/or the cops were interested in such a course, yet you have point-blank refused to provide alternatives to what they actually did other than "not what they did". It's a non-falsifiable position. You literally cannot think of what it would take to prove you wrong. You have already made it clear you think the cops should not have tried to remove them, period, so any use of force would be unjustifiable in your eyes.
Of course, the second-least risk would've been for the cops to just abandon their prisoners at the request of an angry mob. The least would've been for the students to let the cops leave with their prisoners.
Last edited: