Rosencrantz
Is Dead
- Joined
- Apr 3, 2002
- Messages
- 363
Having visited the place where the altercation occurred many times, I feel I must point out that it is not a public sidewalk. This is the quad, a big grassy square at the center of campus, with a paved walk down the center. While there are a few trees there aren't many very close to where the incident occurred. The tents were set up in the middle of the quad, and the campus police had walked down from the street to get them and arrest the people who refused to yield.
I got the impression that what the demonstrators were attempting to do was prevent the officers from driving a car up the walk to take away the people who had been arrested, not preventing them from leaving or threatening them in any way. I don't see why the officers had to do anything but walk away at that point, since the tents had been taken down. But if they wanted to get the car up the walk, they needed to disperse the crowd, and I believe that's when the pepper spray came out.
Remember that just two days before this there had been a similar incident at UC Berkeley, which Davis has lots of ties to, where several people (including faculty members and a Poet Laureate) were beaten with clubs for locking their arms around the tents. In light of that, I think it very likely that Chancellor Katehi would have instructed the campus police chief as she says she did, for there to be no violence or physical confrontation of any kind.
I got the impression that what the demonstrators were attempting to do was prevent the officers from driving a car up the walk to take away the people who had been arrested, not preventing them from leaving or threatening them in any way. I don't see why the officers had to do anything but walk away at that point, since the tents had been taken down. But if they wanted to get the car up the walk, they needed to disperse the crowd, and I believe that's when the pepper spray came out.
Remember that just two days before this there had been a similar incident at UC Berkeley, which Davis has lots of ties to, where several people (including faculty members and a Poet Laureate) were beaten with clubs for locking their arms around the tents. In light of that, I think it very likely that Chancellor Katehi would have instructed the campus police chief as she says she did, for there to be no violence or physical confrontation of any kind.
