Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

[...] Again, you just can't stand to see anyone rationally discuss the facts of an issue that you don't understand, so you pee in the pool with strawmen fallacies and whining challenges when you are called on those fallacies.

Ahhh but cops are always supposed to know that granny isn't dangerous, or the kids are just having fun, or that white folks belong in this neighborhood, and so forth.

And besides, I'm sure one of our resident 'experts' will be happy to explain how the cops can simply shoot the knife out of the attacker's hand.

:wink:

Wow. If there weren't people asleep near here, I'd be laughing really loud. So you think the police should have just stepped over them? Risking people getting kicked in the head (police brutality!) or one of the people who was arrested not coming with them? Because dragging arrested people over other people would be such a good idea...
 
Wow. If there weren't people asleep near here, I'd be laughing really loud. So you think the police should have just stepped over them? Risking people getting kicked in the head (police brutality!) or one of the people who was arrested not coming with them? Because dragging arrested people over other people would be such a good idea...

It's mind boggling in its naivety isn't it?
 
That the cops should just hoist a bound suspect in the air and jump or climb over the protesters is the most laughable suggestion yet.
 
Wow. If there weren't people asleep near here, I'd be laughing really loud. So you think the police should have just stepped over them? Risking people getting kicked in the head (police brutality!) or one of the people who was arrested not coming with them? Because dragging arrested people over other people would be such a good idea...

I think that the police should have used the best means possible to deal with an evolving situation.

So what exactly is your point in making up a load of horse manure like you just did and pretending I said that's what I believe?

The only place that drivel has currency is inside your head.
 
Last edited:
Until one of them punches a cop in the nuts, thinking it is a good idea at the time.

Stepping over protesters is NEVER a good idea. You never know how they are going to react, and which one is the crazy with the knife who just came along because he likes crowds and noise...
Except the police had in fact stepped over the protesters prior to spraying them with zero problem.
 
Of course not. Was there a need to carry protesters for some reason?

I didn't see any bound ankles in the videos I saw.
Do you think the protestors who were arrested would willingly jump over their fellow protestors to get to the paddywagon?
 
Do you think the protestors who were arrested would willingly jump over their fellow protestors to get to the paddywagon?
They didn't need to jump. Just walk the arrested people over to the line and have them step over. There was plenty of police on both sides of the line to do it easily. Has anyone seen evidence or commentary that suggests this was even considered as an option at the time?

The police should have told the crowd that if they give them any trouble while exiting then they will use the pepper spray and arrest more people, but also explain that while the crowd is breaking the law they appreciate that everything so far has remained nonviolent and say they want to keep it that way. Put the responsibility for the escalation of force on the crowds actions. It's seems to me it's a better choice of action for the police no matter what happens next. If the crowd let's the police exit peacefully incident avoided, and if the crowd doesn't the use of pepper spray looks considerably more justified.
 
Last edited:
Why not? Sitting down, the protestors are not much of a barrier. They can be angry as they want, as long as they don't actually, physically attack.
So would the police be able to reliably carry handcuffed suspects safely over the line, without risking harm or impediment to anyone? Yes, no, or I don't know. If you say "yes", then it's not a very good barrier, is it?

It is a weapon. The only time it's not a weapon is when it's used to spice up a sauce. Using pepper spray on people IS VIOLENCE.
I said "not just a weapon". It is both a weapon, and a tool to get suspects to comply with officers.

Your defense would justify police shooting suspects in the thigh with a gun, just to prevent suspects trying to run away.
They have tasers, dogs, cars, foot chases, and pepper spray for that. Shooting someone in the thigh may hit an artery and kill them, or severely injure them. Use of deadly force is a last resort.

You have no idea what use of force standards are, do you?
 
They didn't need to jump. Just walk the arrested people over to the line and have them step over. There was plenty of police on both sides of the line to do it easily.
How would the cops reliably compel the suspects to step over, or ensure the hostile crowd would not become, y'know, physically violent instead of merely issuing threats to them?

Has anyone seen evidence or commentary that suggests this was even considered as an option at the time?
Has anyone seen evidence that it was not? Remember, by obstructing the police, the people sitting down were breaking the law and themselves subject to arrest. Not to mention the fact that hanging around a hostile crowd which is already angry about some of their people being arrested is a bad idea.

The police should have told the crowd that if they give them any trouble while exiting then they will use the pepper spray and arrest more people, but also explain that while the crowd is breaking the law they appreciate that everything so far has remained nonviolent and say they want to keep it that way.
It remained "non-violent" because no one had actively committed violence. The crowd was threatening it, and they were breaking the law to do so.

Put the responsibility for the escalation of force on the crowds actions. It's seems to me it's a better choice of action for the police no matter what happens next. If the crowd let's the police exit peacefully incident avoided, and if the crowd doesn't the use of pepper spray looks considerably more justified.
The crowd specifically said they were going to continue to obstruct the police unless the prisoners were released. The crowd was not listening to the cops when they tried to talk to them.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom