Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Children... time to come in to dinner now. You can play with your little friends again later.
 
How did my claiming I was interested in the legal aspects throughout this whole thread lead you to the conclusion that I claimed I was not interested in the legal aspects?

What something else entirely did I say I was interested in talking about instead of the legalities?


My apologies. When you said...

Which is why I've pointed out more than once that my interest was in the real world legal aspects, and not in armchair quarterbacking the specific techniques used.


... I thought that by "real world legal aspects" you meant something similar to my own "interesting questions":

To me, the interesting questions have always been: "Do I think the police acted appropriately?" and "Will the justice system reach the same conclusion I did?"


I hope you will forgive me if my assumption is incorrect. I hope you will also understand how, having made this assumption, I would be surprised to see you involved in an argument about specific techniques used, let alone so excited about winning it.

Also, looking back over the thread, I think you are confusing the claim that a particular suit doesn't have merit, with the claim that a particular suit can't be brought. So you may actually be using evidence that the suit can be brought to try refute claims that the suit doesn't have merit. But I'm not sure about this. When you said...

We've been assured that there would be no way that the officer could be separated from the immunity against being sued for the performance of lawful official duties


... Was there a specific post or list of posts you had in mind, in which these assurances were given? The only person who mentions "immunity" up to that point in the thread is you. Interestingly enough, you seem to use in a context that I would characterize as "armchair quarterbacking the specific techniques used".
 
Last edited:
So... you haven't watched the 16 minute video on page one of this thread? Try looking at about the 6 minute mark....

I had asked earlier, so thanks...though 'about the 6 minute mark' is a curiously unspecific reference to an image of the cops encircled. Aha, I see. 'About the 6 minute mark' is where we see the caption saying the police were encircled, and then a claim that someone claimed they were claiming the claim that police were encircled. Maybe they were encircled. Who knows? Maybe they were. If I wanted out of a circle, I'd head for the weakest link, not the strong point, but perhaps the commanding officer reasoned that a show of force was required. We all know who liked a show of force, don't we ;)


Pepper spray is uncomfortable, but it is the safest possible way to move that many people. It does so without lingering after effects or permanent damage.

Pepper spray is a violent action. It is, you're right, less violent than shooting. I appreciate that the US has developed admirably since Kent State. In this instance, however, the police chose to pepper spray seated protestors presenting no threat. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.

It is safer than brute force, driving a truck or police car over them, tasers, guns or water cannon.

It is safer, too, than dropping a refridgerator on them from a crane. 'No threat' was met with 'violence'. Defend that.

It allowed the police to do their jobs and get home safely again. It even comes in large, useful containers for *exactly* this style of crowd dispersal.

Seriously? 'Safely'? 'No threat' . Seated protestors presenting no threat to armed & armoured officers and you're concerned for their safety? Their safety had no bearing on this one. Nor does the packaging of the spray - guns are perfectly designed for shooting people, they'd work for shooting unarmed seated protestors protesting no threat. Fridges aren't principally designed for crowd control, but dropping a **** off big chest freezer on the unarmed, seated protestors would have allowed the police to do their jobs and get home safely too.

Note that the police were heavily outnumbered

Yes, there were more unarmed, peaceful protestors citizens than there were public servants. 'Outnumbered' is an unnecessarily martial term, don't you think?

the crowd had acted belligerently towards them

Can you reference the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently'? Failing that, the time at which the caption saying they did appears?

and showed every sign of behaving like typical rent-a-crowd,

So when the citizenry express their common opinion, it's the job of the police to supress that? Is that because the voters can't be trusted to run their own affairs? Do you have a dog in this race? Are you a politician?

they appeared to want a confrontation, that could be strip-mined for sound bytes and video....

They wanted not to be swayed from their goal. Your language is that of the oppressor - they 'deserved what they got', they were 'asking for it'. Fancy, the audacity of the common populace to say 'no!' to the agents of power!

which they eventually got, though the longer version(s) of the video shows pretty clearly who was at fault.

The video that has been linked to only 'clearly' shows the flag flying over the trench you and the caption writer share.

Hell, the kids that got sprayed with pepper sprary were *interviewed* by reporters afterwards. They weren't hurt. They weren't even arrested (and that in itself surprised me).

A chinese burn (noogie? fill in whatever the bullies in your school did) doesn't kill anyone. Some people are bullies, some people support bullies so they don't get bullied. Some people get pepper sprayed while sitting down and presenting no threat.

They just acted like typical young adults from over-privileged families, aghast that THEY might actually be called to account for their actions.

Is this in the video? To be fair, in my experience young adults from under-privileged families are too busy trying to survive, leaving little time for protest, but perhaps you could list your fanciful ideas of what activities are permissible to one depending on family income or social status. People got pepper-sprayed (that's violence, remember) for sitting down and presenting no threat. Defend that.
 
The students were in the Campus Quad. They were not blocking access to anything, protesting, sitting. The Campus Police might qualifiy as idiots.

"Shame on you". Amazing they did not attack those yelling Shame on you. The Campus Quad is over 500 feet wide in all directions. Police must of needed to use up expiring pepper spray. Lucky they did not have shotguns.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JIewW8WNN5c&feature=related

Why can't the police give the students a permit to protest. Here sign this... and leave them alone? The quad is for students, not pepper spray practice of people sitting.

It is funny the protest is for fees...

If you feel threated by a crowd, you leave and get the real police. You don't waste your pepper spray on the students sitting, you keep it as back up to leave in-case you get attacked by students who scare you by talking mean to you.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qrx6DDgTH_w&feature=endscreen&NR=1
The students were sitting in the Quad, not blocking FOX news. How can you block access to anything from sitting in the Quad at UC Davis?
 
Can you reference the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently'?

Right at the moment the police say "move or get pepper sprayed." If they didn't want to get pepper sprayed, the protesters should have moved. If they didn't move and get pepper sprayed, I don't think they have the right to complain about being pepper sprayed.

They can complain that the police was out of line when they tried to remove the protesters, or that the protest should have been allowed to last longer. I imagine there are ways to do that in the US, legal ways that don't involve being pepper sprayed.

Yes, you can disagree with the 'agents of power', but in a democracy governed by rule of law, you can't make up your own rules while doing it.
 
Right at the moment the police say "move or get pepper sprayed." If they didn't want to get pepper sprayed, the protesters should have moved. If they didn't move and get pepper sprayed, I don't think they have the right to complain about being pepper sprayed.

They can complain that the police was out of line when they tried to remove the protesters, or that the protest should have been allowed to last longer. I imagine there are ways to do that in the US, legal ways that don't involve being pepper sprayed.

Yes, you can disagree with the 'agents of power', but in a democracy governed by rule of law, you can't make up your own rules while doing it.


They were on the Quad, 600x500 feet of grass and trees. The students sitting were not stopping anyone from access to anything but the center of the Quad, 500x600 feet of grass, trees, and sidewalks; between the student union and library.

There was no reason to pepper spray the kids in the face from 2 feet, they were sitting. Lucky they did not have guns, then we would have a second Kent State.

The campus is over 5,000 acres, and the students were sitting on a less than 50 feet. Wow, lets practice pepper spraying students sitting down, not moving, it is too hard to pepper spray the students chanting let them go... Real heroes, UC Davis Police, helping students stay safe. Good job.

The Quad is there for the students - not a practice range for police pepper spray. What a bunch of cowards, unable to lead, they have to assault people.


http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111ucdavispeppersprayrange.jpg

Do police study the big failures? Burning up David Koresh, when they could have used fire trucks and water to blast their way in and save kids.
What would Gandhi do?

The police picked on the kids sitting, because they were afraid of the kids talking? The day before the police would have been beaten up by the hundreds protesting; cowards.

Peaceful protest, which should be protected by police, rewarded with pepper spray. Lucky your grandparents did not protest Nazi occupation, you would not be here to protest students getting what you think they deserve. Our country is born on protest.

http://www.christianpost.com/news/c...y-incident-goes-viral-overnight-photos-62728/

Our founding fathers would be peppered sprayed. (they were shot at)
 
Last edited:
They were on the Quad, 600x500 feet of grass and trees. The students sitting were not stopping anyone from access to anything but the center of the Quad, 500x600 feet of grass, trees, and sidewalks; between the student union and library.

There was no reason to pepper spray the kids in the face from 2 feet, they were sitting. Lucky they did not have guns, then we would have a second Kent State.

The video suggests the police were surrounded and the protestors expressed the intention to not let them leave unless their friends were released from arrest. The initial arrests may have been unjustified (I have no idea), but at the point that they used pepper spray, they didn't have much choice and were actually exercising a lot of restraint.
 
I don't agree. Maybe if they weren't so liberal with the trigger, I'd be more understanding.
 
They were on the Quad, 600x500 feet of grass and trees. The students sitting were not stopping anyone from access to anything but the center of the Quad, 500x600 feet of grass, trees, and sidewalks; between the student union and library.

There was no reason to pepper spray the kids in the face from 2 feet, they were sitting. Lucky they did not have guns, then we would have a second Kent State.

The campus is over 5,000 acres, and the students were sitting on a less than 50 feet. Wow, lets practice pepper spraying students sitting down, not moving, it is too hard to pepper spray the students chanting let them go... Real heroes, UC Davis Police, helping students stay safe. Good job.

The Quad is there for the students - not a practice range for police pepper spray. What a bunch of cowards, unable to lead, they have to assault people.


http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111ucdavispeppersprayrange.jpg

Do police study the big failures? Burning up David Koresh, when they could have used fire trucks and water to blast their way in and save kids.
What would Gandhi do?

The police picked on the kids sitting, because they were afraid of the kids talking? The day before the police would have been beaten up by the hundreds protesting; cowards.

Peaceful protest, which should be protected by police, rewarded with pepper spray. Lucky your grandparents did not protest Nazi occupation, you would not be here to protest students getting what you think they deserve. Our country is born on protest.

http://www.christianpost.com/news/c...y-incident-goes-viral-overnight-photos-62728/

Our founding fathers would be peppered sprayed. (they were shot at)

Gandhi to the left of me, Founding Fathers to the right. Here I am, stuck in the middle with Occupiers.

I protest this lawsuit!
 
I don't agree. Maybe if they weren't so liberal with the trigger, I'd be more understanding.

So what would you have done if you were the cops? You've arrested a few people and a bunch of other people have surrounded you and said they'll let you leave if you release the arrested parties. What's your play?
 
The video suggests the police were surrounded and the protesters expressed the intention to not let them leave unless their friends were released from arrest. The initial arrests may have been unjustified (I have no idea), but at the point that they used pepper spray, they didn't have much choice and were actually exercising a lot of restraint.

They pepper sprayed kids sitting in the middle of the quad, who were not in the way of anything! They could have surrounded the kids and held them under arrest right there, sitting. A bunch of cowards.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111ucdavispeppersprayrange.jpg

The kids shouting shame on you? lol, scary stuff. No wonder they sprayed the kids sitting, the kids standing might of punched the cowards out. You don't want to pick on the students not acting like MLK or Gandhi. If don't want people to attack you, pick the students acting non-violent.

If they were surrounded by kids why did they pepper spray the kids sitting down? Why not pepper spray the kids who surrounded them, and escape? I drive past UC Davis all the time, this is very small town, out in the country. The protesters were harmless kids, on campus.

Why was the news right there with a video camera? Danger? lol

The school has already said it was a mistake. I agree, they should not pepper spray kids sitting, peaceful.

The crowd grew because the police pepper sprayed the kids sitting!

Don't worry, FOX news agrees with you, the evil students sitting deserve to be sent to the hospital, evil students.

They even lied.
"The students had encircled the officers," she said. "They needed to exit. They were looking to leave but were unable to get out."
Oh, so they pepper spray the kids sitting! Once again, Naturally, Three Dog Night, Side 2, Track 3.


http://www.christianpost.com/news/c...y-incident-goes-viral-overnight-photos-62728/
surrounded by people taking photos. scary stuff

If the police were surrounded they would need all the pepper spray to escape; They were not in danger, they are idiots. The UC Davis staff should have helped the students. Fox News agrees with you, and they spent zero time researching UC Davis, the area, or what happened.

Who got pepper sprayed? The students sitting. The police are idiots, if they were in trouble they used up pepper spray on kids that were not a threat; what would they do if they really needed to escape. Master intellectual giants of tactics; Bullies.

Anyone wishing to avoid the "violent" protest (kids sitting in the quad) could do so with 200 to 300 foot buffer of safety, in-case the sitting kids... had gas... What? Danger, in the quad, kids are sitting. Danger, Will Robinson... don't forget your pepper spray



So what would you have done if you were the cops? You've arrested a few people and a bunch of other people have surrounded you and said they'll let you leave if you release the arrested parties. What's your play?

Oh, now that you put it that way. Pepper spray the peaceful kids sitting, they are not threat, the kids you think are a threat might beat the living daylights out of you. So! Be sure to pepper spray the peaceful ones, the kids sitting in the center of the Quad, Blocking access to the center of the Quad, a strategic point in the middle of grass, and trees...

If I thought I was in danger, I would retreat and save my ammo. Pepper spraying kids in peaceful protest might make the crowd attack. But the crowd was using the most powerful weapon, TALK, WORDS; and now we know the pen is mightier than the sword.

The police are cowards, they pepper sprayed the kids sitting, not the kids who "surrounded them", which were students who came to see what was going on.

http://sfist.com/2011/11/19/uc_davis_police_brutally_pepper_spray_student_protesters_video.php

The next day.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...y_UC_Davis_from_helium_balloon_2011-11-21.jpg
They will need more pepper spray. Notice no one is sitting in the center this time.

The students were not blocking access to anything. The quad is 500x600 feet.
 
Last edited:
So what would you have done if you were the cops? You've arrested a few people and a bunch of other people have surrounded you and said they'll let you leave if you release the arrested parties. What's your play?

I wouldn't have arrested the few kids in the first place. Somehow, I don't think peaceful protest merits jail time.
 
I wouldn't have arrested the few kids in the first place. Somehow, I don't think peaceful protest merits jail time.

That wasn't the question.

Or are you saying you have no gripe with how they reacted at that point, but you have a gripe with their initial arrests?
 
If the police were surrounded they would need all the pepper spray to escape; They were not in danger, they are idiots. The UC Davis staff should have helped the students.

They weren't in danger, but they were surrounded and had to leave somehow. It was either physically force the students out of the way or use pepper spray.

Fox News agrees with you.

Good argument. :rolleyes:

The police are cowards, they pepper sprayed the kids sitting, not the kids who "surrounded them", which were students who came to see what was going on.

The kids sitting were one side of the kids surrounding them if I remember correctly.

The students were not blocking access to anything. The quad is 500x600 feet.

I'm not even arguing that they shouldn't have been allowed to protest...
 
Out of curiosity, what was the reason for the initial arrest?

I don't know, but I doubt they were simply arrested for protesting if they were the only ones arrested.
Seems intuitive. If I had to wager a bet I'd bet that it wasn't just for protesting. I think the question significant though. I doubt that the justification that the police use in court will be "duh judge, we wouldn't arrest them for protesting" (assuming the case ever makes it to court). Do police ever overstep their authority to harass or intimidate protestors? Does ego and "contempt of cop" ever come into play in such situations?
 
Last edited:
Seems intuitive. If I had to wager a bet I'd bet that it wasn't just for protesting. I think the question significant though. I doubt that will be the justification that the police use in court (assuming the case ever makes it to court). Do police ever overstep their authority to harass or intimidate protestors? Does ego and "contempt of cop" ever come into play in such situations?

Yes, police definitely overstep their authority to harass and intimidate protestors some of the time. And I think things like "free speech zones" and some of the anti-assembly laws are BS. But OWS has repeatedly used selective video editing to demonize cops who are just doing their jobs IMO.

Even if the police make an unjustified arrest, you can't just surround them and demand that they let the people go. That's ridiculous.
 
Yes, police definitely overstep their authority to harass and intimidate protestors some of the time. And I think things like "free speech zones" and some of the anti-assembly laws are BS
Thanks. It might be pro-forma but I'm dying to know. I've been googling but having found it.

But OWS has repeatedly used selective video editing to demonize cops who are just doing their jobs IMO.
Not sure what this has to do with my question.

Even if the police make an unjustified arrest, you can't just surround them and demand that they let the people go. That's ridiculous.
The Police would have a difficult time doing their job if there were not laws for obstruction of justice. Even if a police officer flagrantly breaks the law you must follow his or her instructions so long as those instructions are lawful. However, it could very well have implications for a civil suit (see comparative liability). Obstruction of justice laws do not excuse improper behavior.
 
Right at the moment the police say "move or get pepper sprayed." If they didn't want to get pepper sprayed, the protesters should have moved. If they didn't move and get pepper sprayed, I don't think they have the right to complain about being pepper sprayed.

That's 'belligerence'? Warlike activity? No. It's protest, peaceful, non-violent protest.

They can complain that the police was out of line when they tried to remove the protesters, or that the protest should have been allowed to last longer. I imagine there are ways to do that in the US, legal ways that don't involve being pepper sprayed.

Oh, was what they did illegal? Or did you accidentally use the word 'legal' about some other imaginary actions you haven't specified, without meaning to imply that their untried action was illegal.

Yes, you can disagree with the 'agents of power', but in a democracy governed by rule of law, you can't make up your own rules while doing it.

Oh we're all for the rule of law round here. The thread is about the students using the law to seek redress for the violent (and probably illegal) response of the police to the student's peaceful lawful protest.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom