Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

000063 said:
And not a single counter to an actual point I've made, just a blanket dismissal of it as "sophistry".

I already told you that I'm not interested in playing online RPGs with anyone.
And I'm not in the least bit persuaded to abandon reality by your choice to use cliched denier/woo-woo tactics like whining about identifying fallacies as 'personal' and calling the obvious 'hypocrisy'.

You simply can't handle the idea that someone might actually comment on this without declaring a side, so you are going to go with the knee jerk of fraudulently assigning one to me, in order to give yourself a straw opponent for a pointless game.

000063 said:
You also made a comparison to the Humboldt case, and the differences have been specifically pointed out to you. So most of your premises on which you claim the liability suit would be based are incorrect. A house on a sandy foundation.

And here is where you get caught using lies.
I'm the one who said that Humboldt didn't necessarily match everything in the UC Davis case.

crimresearch said:
Whether the court wiil accept that or not, is unknowable at this point. The Humboldt case cited above has some different factors from these circumstances.

And none of that has anything to do with my claim that the lawsuit will include issues of vicarious liability, or your pretense that I'm wrong about that.

I wouldn't sit down to play cards with someone who was just caught cheating, and there is no good reason for me to play debate games with someone who was just proven to use fabrications.
 
Well, I was wrong. I was only looking at the LA times article, not the Davis Enterprise.

http://www.davisenterprise.com/loca...f-huddled-with-13-on-decision-to-remove-camp/

In an interview with The Enterprise on Nov. 22, Katehi said recent police actions at UC Berkeley, including a video of police on that campus jabbing student and faculty protesters with batons, did come up during the teleconferences.
“We were very specific that it has to be peaceful and not like Berkeley,” Katehi said. “In a peaceful way, (Spicuzza) was only supposed to take the equipment down, not disperse the crowd, not remove the students.

“We also told her specifically she should not do anything if there were too many students or they were too upset or whatever the environment was that would not allow them to (remove the tents). That’s what she got from me.”
And they did. They left the bulk of the protestors and only arrested people who deliberately interfered. Then as they attempted to leave, the students confronted them.

The "lawful" orders--note the "we"--were to not provoke the crowd or stop the protestors, just to remove the tents, and even then only if they could do so without starting a confrontation. In short, to be peaceful while taking the tents down. UCPD obeyed those orders. However, the students confronted them, choosing to both actively obstruct them and to issue threats. They did not initiate the confrontation, the students did, and thus the officers were outside the scope of their orders, acting on their own discretion.

The statement is ambiguous (such as whether the Chancellor issued the orders or just relayed them), and there is the legal question of how much discretion cops and these cops in particular have when they are put in a situation that threatens both themselves and their prisoners, through no fault of their own, which their orders do not cover. I'm not sure the Chancellor has direct operational control over the police any more than a mayor does over his city's police force.
 
Last edited:
Then you should have no trouble providing proof that I'm wrong about vicarious liabilty being an issue in this lawsuit.

Got any?

At the time they were pepper sprayed, they were no longer protesters. They were law breakers. This IS NOT up for discussion. It is a rock-solid fact.
 
Then there's the fact that the police were responding to the students threatening and obstructing them, and had been actively attempting to avoid confrontation up until that point. Their options were basically a)wait and hope it gets better and the crowd doesn't attack, or b)remove the obstructors and get out as soon as possible.
 
The police seemed to act with commendable restraint. No one appears to be hurt (apart from their wounded pride)... what's the big issue??
 
It's obvious that the protesters were attempting to provoke a confrontation in order to gain Protester Cred™ (and possibly get on the news). And as BTMO said, the cops used admirable restraint. They used the absolute minimum force needed to take control of the situation; no one got shot, Tased, whacked with a baton, or had their shoulders dislocated.
 
And as BTMO said, the cops used admirable restraint. They used the absolute minimum force needed to take control of the situation; no one got shot, Tased, whacked with a baton, or had their shoulders dislocated.

But they did get pepper sprayed. I don't find that admirable, but I guess you're starting from a different standard.
 
But they did get pepper sprayed. I don't find that admirable, but I guess you're starting from a different standard.

Pepper spray is uncomfortable, but it is the safest possible way to move that many people. It does so without lingering after effects or permanent damage.

It is safer than brute force, driving a truck or police car over them, tasers, guns or water cannon. It allowed the police to do their jobs and get home safely again. It even comes in large, useful containers for *exactly* this style of crowd dispersal.

Note that the police were heavily outnumbered, the crowd had acted belligerently towards them, and showed every sign of behaving like typical rent-a-crowd, they appeared to want a confrontation, that could be strip-mined for sound bytes and video.... which they eventually got, though the longer version(s) of the video shows pretty clearly who was at fault.

Hell, the kids that got sprayed with pepper sprary were *interviewed* by reporters afterwards. They weren't hurt. They weren't even arrested (and that in itself surprised me).

They just acted like typical young adults from over-privileged families, aghast that THEY might actually be called to account for their actions.
 
Your asking me if the court case you claimed as legal precedent actually is comparable to the UC-Davis case matters?

:boggled:

Whatever answer I give you will only give you reason to argue nonsensically anyway!
 
Can I just mention here how completely idiotic it was for the Occupy movement to choose a form of protest they had to put all their energy and resources into defending? All they've really done is defended their right to have their protests (badly). They'd have been better off getting rid of the camps and spending all that time and energy advocating for what they wanted (which was never communicated very well anyway).

Protests are never about actually accomplishing anything. That's why they are almost always useless.

Revolutionaries, while breaking laws with their assassinations and car bombings, are nonetheless actually doing something which I can respect on a certain level.

They needed to be removed, in order for the police to leave.

Please, if you have a better alternative to accomplish that goal, we're all ears.

I think one thing they could have done that would have been hilarious would have been to simply use zipties to bind them all to each other. Then wait for them to cry uncle when hunger and thirst set in. Then you simply unbind them one by one and arrest them.
 
Whatever answer I give you will only give you reason to argue nonsensically anyway!
But you're effectively doing that now. You're presenting what you claim is evidence and refusing to explain it's relevance. In fact, you're questioning it's relevance.

...
I think one thing they could have done that would have been hilarious would have been to simply use zipties to bind them all to each other. Then wait for them to cry uncle when hunger and thirst set in. Then you simply unbind them one by one and arrest them.
I mentioned in the main Occupy thread a protest at a Citibank. The Occupiers were somehow under the impression that as customers they did not have to leave unless the bank threatened to call the police, and refused to leave when asked. Then the police show up and hold them in the bank for arrest, even retrieving protestors that had managed to get outside, and the protestors are actually surprised that the police don't just let them run off.
 
I suppose there were other options the cops could have gone for:


  • Breaking the arms of those blocking them in
  • Tossing those they arrested over those blocking them in
  • Fire hose those blocking them in
  • Sit the people they had arrested down and see if they can wait for an attack of the munchies to break the will of those blocking them in
  • Dogs......just lots of dogs
  • Throw away the rule of law and just release those they had arrested because a large crowd wants them to

Or.. walk those arrested around the sitting protestors...
 
It certainly does look like they encircled the area where the police hanging out with their arrestees. The police did not appear to actually be moving the suspects towards any location.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom