Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Sorry but that's not how the law works.

Dura lex sed lex? At the present time there are enough laws on the books that the odds of someone not breaking one of them are effectively zero. We survive this problem by adopting a certian atitude of pragmitism with regards to legal enforcement.

In the case of students this means putting up with however they are protesting this week. If you find this unnacceptable you are free to avoid employment at universities.

You don't get a choice in how long you plan on staying somewhere illegally once you have been asked to leave numerous times. College kids think they are entitled to something, as if they are special and the rules don't apply. Then once rules are actually enforced, they cry for abuse. Ridiculous.

No no. Someone tried to use what they thought was the law against them so you can hardly complain when they try and use the law back.
 
Dura lex sed lex?

Taking down tents which were put up illegally on campus is anything but a harsh rule/law. Knock it off.

In the case of students this means putting up with however they are protesting this week. If you find this unnacceptable you are free to avoid employment at universities.

Immature and impractical opinion noted.
 
Taking down tents which were put up illegally on campus is anything but a harsh rule/law. Knock it off.



Immature and impractical opinion noted.

Your complete and utter ignorance of the matter is also noted.

The UC Davis Chancellor is on record as saying that she specifically ordered her employees, the police not to use force to make people leave.

ETA: http://articles.latimes.com/2011/nov/21/local/la-me-1122-ucdavis-protest-20111122


The people who were sprayed were sitting on the ground, not attacking or even offering to attack the police in any manner.

Under UoF policies and case law, that's grounds to file a VL lawsuit anywhere in the country.
 
Last edited:
They weren't protesting peacefully - they were verbally threatening the officers after encircling them.

Is there video of this event that supports your interpretation?


The video does not support your interpretation, though the captions do.

"Telling police you will let them leave if they release people they have arrested is a threatening action."

A 'threatening action'? This is a non-violent direct action protest. The police know that the protestors are not likely to co-operate willingly. Are you honestly suggesting that a group of armed and armoured men, who have chosen a career in law enforcement (albeit 'campus police') feel 'threatened' by the words of a group of students in a situation they ought to be have trained for?

If those words were "we're going to attack you, with the possibility of injury or death to you", perhaps you'd be right. But the words were (approx.) "We're going to stand our ground, as part of the glorious American history of non-violent protest by the people. We object to your actions and implore you to reconsider them". Not threatening.

I'm going to take it on trust that the police were 'encircled', not least because surely they'd be bright enough to find an alternative route if one were available. Are you happy with that assumption? The video doesn't show them encircled, but it does make that claim and offers a link to an interview of someone claiming the police were encircled.

"Some protestors seem intent on antagonising the police"

That 'seem' crops up a lot. I would have preferred a video that didn't keep blocking my view with opinions of what 'seems' to be happening. "**** the police" is, in my view, misguided, but really, they are police officers. They'll be used to the idea that their work is not universally appreciated.

[chant] you use weapons, we use our voice [/chant]

Who is more threatened? The people with the voices or the people with the weapons? This is not to dispute that the police may have acted lawfully, or even optimally, but the suggestion that they were 'threatened' is facile.

"Protestors begin screaming for the police not to use pepper spray to clear the path, yet just seconds before they were telling those on the ground to get ready for it"

Who is this guy? Some protestors (he was saying 'some' earlier, and I concede that many of them chant in unison, but it's a tiresome ploy to clump your enemies together and claim they think as one). More to the point, what on earth is that 'yet' for? Where is the disconnect? The police prepare to use pepper spray, protestors are warned to prepare for the pepper spray, protestors ask ('scream', if you feel the need to use misogynistic terms to describe women's voices raised in protest) police not to use pepper spray. As in "we know you could, we know you might, and we're prepared for it. Please don't". I'm having difficulty understanding what the caption writer thought that 'yet' implied.

"Now the protestors say they are willing to give the police a moment of peace...so much for peaceful protestors"

Woefully disingenuous. Who has said they are claiming to be 'peaceful protestors'? They are, I trust, claiming to be non-violent direct activists. 'Peace' and 'non-violence' are not directly interchangeable. The shouting is not 'peaceful', as in 'peace and quiet' but it is non-violent in the sense of 'war and peace'. I've seen real concern over whether speech can be violent - as I suggested, I think "**** the police!" might be 'violent' speech, it's a tough call...unless you already made the call, then it's easy. At the Newbury road protest I heard a tree-dweller call down to a climbing bailiff "Nobody likes you very much, as I think you already know", but not everybody can be so scrupulous under pressure. Which is helpful, because you only need one example for your tar brush.
 
It is repeated, several times IIRC, that,

"If you let them go we will continue to protest peacefully."

Did you not hear this part, or just didn't bother to write about it?

"Them" were people arrested because they broke the law.

You can't stop police from lawfully arresting someone. It's against the law.
 
"Them" were people arrested because they broke the law.

You can't stop police from lawfully arresting someone. It's against the law.
'Lawful' would be the direct order not to use force to remove the protestoers.

Disobeying that direct order isn't lawful.
 
"Telling police you will let them leave if they release people they have arrested is a threatening action."
[/I]
A 'threatening action'? This is a non-violent direct action protest. The police know that the protestors are not likely to co-operate willingly. Are you honestly suggesting that a group of armed and armoured men, who have chosen a career in law enforcement (albeit 'campus police') feel 'threatened' by the words of a group of students in a situation they ought to be have trained for?

I didn't make the video, I posted it - if you wish to critique the captions the person put over the video, feel free to PM them on youtube.

Considering the circumstances, surrounded and outnumbered and being told,

"If you let them go, we will let you leave."

And

If you let them go, we will continue to protest peacefully."

That is a verbal threat, echoed by the mob.

If those words were "we're going to attack you, with the possibility of injury or death to you", perhaps you'd be right.

:rolleyes:

But the words were (approx.) "We're going to stand our ground, as part of the glorious American history of non-violent protest by the people. We object to your actions and implore you to reconsider them". Not threatening.

I'm loving the emotion you're injecting into this. However, your translation is incorrect. The proper translation is,

"We object to your actions and implore you to reconsider them or else."

The video doesn't show them encircled, but it does make that claim and offers a link to an interview of someone claiming the police were encircled.

The police removed those who were arrested to a location where they would be picked up by a cruiser and removed from campus. As well as physically blocking this cruiser, you can see the police being surrounded on all sides by the protesters. I'm not sure how you overlooked this, but I'd hate to think you did it on purpose.

[chant] you use weapons, we use our voice [/chant]
Who is more threatened? The people with the voices or the people with the weapons? This is not to dispute that the police may have acted lawfully, or even optimally, but the suggestion that they were 'threatened' is facile.

The protesters were verbally threatening the police with rioting. I'm not sure why you want to discuss whose more threatened as it is irrelevant to the legal issue.

Who has said they are claiming to be 'peaceful protestors'?

Most of their defenders, like thaiboxerken for instance.
 
Last edited:
:p

Honestly, I'm all ears to hear a new argument from a different person.
I'm not arguing. I haven't even stated my opinion as to who was 'right', or anything like that. Note my sig file.

I'm pointing out that the use of force policies and case law are a matter of factual record, as is the legal precept of vicarious liability. In the real world, the lawsuit has a factual basis. Under that reality, filing this lawsuit is an obvious step.


You on the other hand are trolling for a pointless internet argument, as proven by your demanding a 'source' after I've already given a link to the LA Times article reporting that the Chancellor said not to use force to remove the people.

Go ahead and play all the breathy and dramatic 'the police were under attack', and 'the students threatened to raise their voices' woo-woo denial that you want, at the end of the day, reality isn't going to care at all about your fantasy constructs and debate games.
 
I'm not arguing. I haven't even stated my opinion as to who was 'right', or anything like that. Note my sig file.

Fair enough.

You on the other hand are trolling for a pointless internet argument, as proven by your demanding a 'source' after I've already given a link to the LA Times article

You edited a post and put that source in, a while after the discussion moved on. Forgive me for not rechecking every single post in this thread for ETAs.

reporting that the Chancellor said not to use force to remove the people.

No where in the article you linked to did the Chancellor state she ordered the police NOT to use force.

Katehi has said that she ordered protesters' tents removed but had not authorized police to use the chemical spray in the manner shown on the videos. Campus spokesman Andy Fell on Monday declined to comment on who gave that order, saying it would be looked at by investigators.

That is, by the way, not even close to the same thing you're claiming. If the article claims it was not authorized, it very well may not have even been discussed - like I said, not the same thing as an explicit prohibition on the use of force.
 
'Lawful' would be the direct order not to use force to remove the protestoers.

Disobeying that direct order isn't lawful.

You're aware that people were arrested BEFORE this silly little sit-in of theirs?
Two seperate and distinct things happened.


1) Protesters were lawfully arrested
2) Additional protesters blocked the police from removing the lawfully arrested protesters.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom