Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

That is the point of the question. It isn't based on the data contained in the report. If you had bothered to look at the quote, you would have immediately seen that it was based on:

Kaminski, Robert J., Steven M. Edwards, and James W. Johnson, “Assessing the Incapacitative Effects of Pepper Spray During Resistive Encounters With Police,” Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management, 22(1)(1999): 7–29; and Kaminski, Robert J., Steven M. Edwards, and James W. Johnson, “The Deterrent Effects of Oleoresin Capsicum on Assaults Against Police: Testing the Velcro-Effect Hypothesis,” Police Quarterly, 1(2)(1998): 1–20.
I'm sorry, you are saying that the "list" and the supporting data have nothing whatsoever to do with the conclusions of the report? Really?

ETA: I tried accessing these journals, but I can't. So I can't assess the data (even if I would have had the expertise to do that).
Thank you for your honesty about that. Could you possible concede that the "list" is somehow relevant to the conclusions of the report? Even just a little bit? Or do you think the report intentionally provides conflicting information?
 
I'm sorry, you are saying that the "list" and the supporting data have nothing whatsoever to do with the conclusions of the report? Really?

Thank you for your honesty about that. Could you possible concede that the "list" is somehow relevant to the conclusions of the report? Even just a little bit? Or do you think the report intentionally provides conflicting information?

Yes, I'm saying that the quote "Research by Kaminski and colleagues suggests that pepperspray is effective in controlling disorderly suspects and may reduce injuries to both officers and suspects." (p. 71) is not supported by the list, but by the two research papers that are cited in a footnote immediately following that quote.

Another ETA: That quote is taken from a chapter that is about further research agendas. In other words: stuff that needs to be researched more, like if Kaminski et al were right in saying that pepperspray is effective.
 
Last edited:
I will not be responding to issues concerning the PDF fiel

I apologize, I searched for the wrong wording apparently.
Thank you for that.

The point remains however. That the list of items were either not available to the the UC Davis Police, or that they were in fact used.
I've not heard that but okay, at least it directly addresses my question and for that I thank you.

After all this confusion, Pepper Spray remains the best, most injury-free option.
I'm willing to concede the point. Not that I'll get one ounce of credit for it.

I suspect that this is about as much concession as I'm going to get. I'm not here to bicker over moot points. I'm not going to be involved in a one way conversation. It's disappointing that I couldn't get a concession regarding the PDF file but that's life. You take what you can get.
 
I'm willing to concede the point. Not that I'll get one ounce of credit for it.

Credit where credit is due. A lot of the frustration here comes from how the other thread ended in fireworks. If we can avoid that, the better, and thank you for conceding the point.
 
Credit where credit is due. A lot of the frustration here comes from how the other thread ended in fireworks. If we can avoid that, the better, and thank you for conceding the point.
Thank you. :) I appreciate that. I know it's been a long frustrating discussion spanning two threads and I acknowledge that I contributed to that. So I am trying to take that into account.
 
I'm willing to concede the point. Not that I'll get one ounce of credit for it.

I suspect that this is about as much concession as I'm going to get. I'm not here to bicker over moot points. I'm not going to be involved in a one way conversation. It's disappointing that I couldn't get a concession regarding the PDF file but that's life. You take what you can get.

Well, if we agree on that, I don't see the point either in discussing that pdf. It wasn't exactly a critical point.
 
There was a photo about 3 posts above this that PROVED they were surrounded. OPEN YOUR EYES

At some point you people are going to move from willful ignorance to blatant dishonesty. It's not too far off.

Do you mean beachnut's post? With the photo that in no way proves (let alone PROVES) that they were surrounded? It certainly supports that view, but you can't see all around the officers, so, no proof.

Not that that matters to me because, in case you missed me repeating it over and over again, I don't care whether they were surrounded or not.

Oh, and for the record there's only one of me. Who are these "you people" of which you speak?
 
Do you mean beachnut's post? With the photo that in no way proves (let alone PROVES) that they were surrounded? It certainly supports that view, but you can't see all around the officers, so, no proof.
But his video in the same post does. The one where the camera looks in both directions, and you can plainly see the students are all around. Except for the ones being kept back by the cops' backup, exactly as my side has been alleging for the duration of the argument.

Not that that matters to me because, in case you missed me repeating it over and over again, I don't care whether they were surrounded or not.
Well, that's strange, because it's relevant to whether they were being obstructed. Oh, wait, you don't want to talk about whether they were obstructed, after it was pointed out you would have to ignore evidence from everyone involved, including the protestors themselves, in order to keep claiming they weren't obstructing the police. I personally pointed out that you yourself said they were there to protest, and the protest "took the form" of obstructing the police. Curious. I think I can tell why you don't want to talk about it.

However, your claim of not wanting to talk about it belies your responding to a post talking about it to dispute the claim that they were obstructed. It's a curious sort of intellectual flexibility, to actively say something is false while saying one doesn't care about it. Much like how you questioned the veracity of the students' accounts then said you didn't care about them. Or presented Brown's account as factual, then said it was irrelevant (and that it said something it did not) when it was proven wrong.

I also don't recall you responding to any posts when anyone pointed out police do not need to be actively threatened to use pepper spray, which makes your whole "threat" focus largely unecessary. It informed the situation, sure, but the cops had enough to spray even if the students hadn't explicitly threatened them.

Oh, and for the record there's only one of me. Who are these "you people" of which you speak?
There was only one person who said he'd use dogs, and you had no problem saying all of the people who think the cops were justified wanted to use dogs. You said it several times. I also cannot find anyone who said the "long-haired pinko liberals" or suchlike deserved to be sprayed simply for being "long-haired pinko liberals" (even allowing for a generous amount of exaggeration) as you have repeatedly claimed your opposition does.

You're fooling no one here. But please, keep telling everyone you're arguing about things you don't actually care about. Both I and theprestige are both convinced the dishonesty point is long past.
 
Last edited:
Do you mean beachnut's post? With the photo that in no way proves (let alone PROVES) that they were surrounded? It certainly supports that view, but you can't see all around the officers, so, no proof.

Not that that matters to me because, in case you missed me repeating it over and over again, I don't care whether they were surrounded or not.

Oh, and for the record there's only one of me. Who are these "you people" of which you speak?

The photo in Post #465

Now if you're actually telling me that doesn't show the cops surrounded, then you're really in denial.

"You people" are the ones who are ignoring even the student's accounts that go against what you're saying. Why you're doing that I'll never know.
 
The most unbiased set of evidence is the largest set. Beachnut took one screenshot from a video, then linked to this video, and claimed it showed the cops weren't surrounded. What he neglected to mention is that the video is taken after backup arrives, or where the first screenshot came from. I do not know whether he is deliberately or accidentally preventing others from viewing his sources, but is likely the latter.

My side has repeatedly claimed that the police were unable to reliably transport prisoners out of the area, on account of being surrounded by the protestors. When backup arrived, they were able to make a hole in the outer ring, but not the inner one, which hindered prisoner transport. After all lesser measures were attempted, the police used pepper spray to decrease physical resistance and help get the students apart. Studies recently linked show that use of pepper spray decreases risk of injury to suspect and officer, meaning that had they not deployed pepper spray, the students would've been hurt worse and suffered more serious damage than an hour or so of tears.

Attached to this post are several screenshots to Beachnut's one. Note that these show, clearly, the cops were surrounded on all sides except the path cleared by their backup, which is to the left of the camera's field of view. unless one is willing to allege that the students suddenly came out of nowhere and surrounded the police only after backup arrived.

Bottom line; Beachnut's video, rather than proving his point, actually refutes it and strengthens ours.

EDIT: Added, for comparison, is Beachnut's unsourced screenshot, which was taken from the reverse angle from the "Owned Video", which means that the direction the police with pepperball guns is facing is to the left in the previous screenshots, and is the direction backup will arrive. Since the seated protestors are not evident, this is clearly before they set themselves up, as the police form a defensive line, while the students appear to be testing the extent of that line in an attempt to provoke a forceful response. It is rather odd that the mass of students were apparently not obstructing or threatening police in any fashion, yet when backup arrived, the same crowd was able to "drive off" even more police then those which had been present up to that point, as Beachnut alleges. Of course, the police had resolved to retreat already, so how much "driving" was necessary is questionable.
 

Attachments

  • jref_UCPDOwned-0312.JPG
    jref_UCPDOwned-0312.JPG
    91.9 KB · Views: 12
  • jref_UCPDOwned-0319.JPG
    jref_UCPDOwned-0319.JPG
    97.4 KB · Views: 9
  • jref_UCPDOwned-0331.JPG
    jref_UCPDOwned-0331.JPG
    99 KB · Views: 10
  • jref_UCPDOwned-0332.JPG
    jref_UCPDOwned-0332.JPG
    104.3 KB · Views: 11
  • 111RaidersLeadPoliceRetreat3.jpg
    111RaidersLeadPoliceRetreat3.jpg
    82.6 KB · Views: 9
Last edited:
The photo in Post #465

Now if you're actually telling me that doesn't show the cops surrounded, then you're really in denial.

Well one of us certainly has a problem. As noted in my previous post, that photo does not prove the police were surrounded, since it does not show the police surrounded. As noted in my previous post, it does tend to support the idea, since it shows the police largely surrounded and one might make the assumption that the bit you can't see looks like the bits you can see, but it does not prove anything, much less PROVE it.

It does not show the cops surrounded. It just doesn't, you don't get to see all round the cops. Tough luck.

"You people" are the ones who are ignoring even the student's accounts that go against what you're saying. Why you're doing that I'll never know.

Well in that case 'you people' are the ones who see what you want to see. 'You people' are the ones who dismiss statements that don't suit you and embrace any statement that does. 'You people' are the ones who lump anyone who thinks the pepper spraying was (or may have been) wrong into one group, to save on strawmen. 'You people' are the ones who keep insisting I care whether the cops were surrounded or not, despite my repeating ad nauseum that it does not matter. See where I argue that the video, and then the photo, do not show the police surrounded (as if they needed any more than an impartial viewing)? You mistake my interest in facts for a devotion to a particular fact. It is irrelevant (imho) whether the police were surrounded. But as it happens, neither the video nor the photo cited prove they were.
 
It does not show the cops surrounded. It just doesn't, you don't get to see all round the cops. Tough luck.

So you're assuming that outside the field of view of the camera is a totally different story than what is in the field of view?

I wonder if there are any other angles.
Hint - there are. On this very page.


But as it happens, neither the video nor the photo cited prove they were.

With all due respect, that comment is INSANE.
 
Last edited:
Surrounded, sounds like the crazy rant of faster than free-fall by 911 truthers.

Surrounded means nothing. A silly canard for lack of evidence. The police have to say they felt threatened, surrounded, so they had to casually pepper spray students. Better justify sending some students to the hospital and cover up the failed cop. The surrounded claims by police, an excuse for being stupid, spraying kids. The surrounded claims by students are egotistical bragging, an illusion. Surrounded, I was surrounded by people on the busy NYC sidewalks, as we made our way to Times Square; surrounded, OH MY. I had to pepper spray the people sitting, to make my way to Times Square, to see a movie. Surrounded! Blücher!

Confused, are thoughts reality? We were surrounded!? How did they escape? Custer was surrounded, UC Davis Police left. Custer did not leave, US Davis Police left, they moved arrested students through the vast surrounded canard.

There were onlookers "surrounding" the police on one side, or two; Not a threat! Onlookers are not protesters, the police were not surrounded by protesters.

Words vs pepper spray. Will it be guns next?

It is self-critiquing, the students are in school not jail, the police are not at work. The leader of the school, apologized for the mistake, she wants to add procedures to ensure no future failure.


The students were not a threat, they were sitting. Students were not stopping normal operations at the campus. A non-event turned into something by a moron cop who was upset and broke down. He calmly tells the student he will pepper him, the students say go ahead, make my day. A stupid cop, a smart student. I love it, the cop becomes a bully due to words. Weak cop, peppered students.


I know who the protesters are, and who the onlookers are in the photos/video. The photo I showed has onlookers, who move and let the police through with arrested kids earlier. The police retreated on the sidewalk, they could have headed through the student onlookers. The photo shows the police not surround by protesters.

I don't want the students to get money, I am paying taxes in CA. The police made an error. They can apologize, and find another job that does not include working around people.

My brother was surprised when I said, the police were morons and wrong, he agrees; surprised because he thought I was right of Attila the Hun.

How did the surrounded police make it out alive? Easy one - Spoken Words are not lethal. Too bad Custer was surrounded by people with more than words. That policeman was so brave stepping over the students who surrounded him so he could pepper them in the face. I see medals, awards, a peace prize!

Just one more thing;
Reason 1,000,451 the pepper spraying of sitting students was dirt dumb -If the frighten policeman story is true, they were surrounded, why was the pepper spray delivered so casually and not under duress as the police tried to escape their life threating surrounding event by evil sitting students. The smart thing to do, SAVE the pepper spray to break though the dangerous surrounding (onlooking students) students who refused to let you get off the dangerous quad where dangerous words were flying.

Anyone see the girl push the police back? An Obi Wan moment. That was great. BTW, there were some kids present, real live kids, like not students, but younger than students, like kids. Make me wonder why police failed to ensure people were not removed for their safety since the students were so scary.


Another note pertaining to what People Say. A full colonel was giving Me the what for, I got up and started to leave (I was a LtCol, he is a full Col), he said I can't leave. Guess what, my feet were still moving, and the door was opening, I was leaving. I don't care what is said, it is what is done that matters. Talk is cheap, and means nothing. The Col told me, a LtCol I could not leave, I left. Some said the police were unable to move arrested students out of the quad, it was a lie. Some said the police were surrounded, they use video as proof, and in the video, a majority of onlookers who are not blocking access. If the police were surrounded, why are students sitting pepper sprayed? Why did they fail to pepper spray their way out? Every-time I try to understand the surrounded canard, I think of that Full Bird Col, telling me what I can't do. Thanks for reminding me how stupid that Col was. "you can't leave"... "you are surrounded"...

Do onlookers count as being surrounded? When I am walking on a busy sidewalk, surrounded by people, do I need to pepper spray students sitting? What does surrounded mean in defense of a single coward policeman who can't think in or out of the box? One dolt out of 30 police; bet he is a biased bigot, very rare, 1 out of 1000 that lets his biases show, and someone who lost his temper. It is rare to find a policeman like pepper-cop. I am trying to see it different, but watching the policeman step over the students, with police all over, to pepper students, to make it easier to push them off the sidewalk, which you can walk around anyway, is ... No words for how much he failed.

I look at this like Vietnam, and Lt Calley. An out of control person who thinks they are in-charge, and what they do is right.

If anyone knows the UC Davis quad, normally at times like the "protest", late Friday, there is nothing to interrupt, the protesters would not inconvienience anyone. The pepper spray cop proves this, easily stepping over and dishing out the punishment. Student can gather in the quad without anyone saying anything.

What were the goals. Goals are important -
Katehi:
“I explicitly directed the chief of police that violence should be avoided at all costs. It was the absolute last thing I ever wanted to happen,” she said.
Katehi said she directed police only to take down the tents. “My instructions were for no arrests and no police force.”
Police failed.
 
Last edited:
It does not show the cops surrounded. It just doesn't, you don't get to see all round the cops. Tough luck.

So you're assuming that outside the field of view of the camera is a totally different story than what is in the field of view?

And you're assuming it isn't? What makes your assumption 'proof' and my lack of assumption about the unknown 'INSANE'?

I wonder if there are any other angles.
Hint - there are. On this very page.

You mean there is actual proof? That you've neglected to link to? And which doesn't change the fact that the video and picture cited as proof are not, in fact, proof?

With all due respect, that comment is INSANE.

I suppose that's all the respect you feel is due, fair enough. But get real. The video doesn't prove it, the picture doesn't prove it. With all due respect, your insistence that assumption is proof is insane (which is just as insane as 'INSANE', lower case notwithstanding).
 
And you're assuming it isn't? What makes your assumption 'proof' and my lack of assumption about the unknown 'INSANE'?

The rest of the images, some of which are on this page.
I'm not assuming, any more than I assume that the JR in JREF stands for James Randi.
It's a fact. LOOK AT THE DAMN PICTURES.

Oh my GOD man. You CAN'T be that blind.

Lets just try to get to the bottom of this -
Using 000063's images from this very page,

Do you see that the police were surrounded? Yes or No?
 
The rest of the images, some of which are on this page.
I'm not assuming, any more than I assume that the JR in JREF stands for James Randi.
It's a fact. LOOK AT THE DAMN PICTURES.

Oh my GOD man. You CAN'T be that blind.

Lets just try to get to the bottom of this -
Using 000063's images from this very page,

Do you see that the police were surrounded? Yes or No?

Define surrounded.:boxedin:
 
Noah, since it's obvious you're not really following the thread, I'll make something clearer for you. I have 000063 on ignore, and while I sometimes use that as a pause (since I can choose to look at individual posts), I did establish that I was no longer looking at his posts. You can call that 'blind', if you like (you could even try 'BLIND' if you think it makes an ignorant assertion more valid).

For the record, I have both you and beachnut on ignore, but I'm choosing to read your posts here. That probably won't last long...

More pertinently, I originally addressed the claim that the video showed the police surrounded. Pay attention: it does not (if it helps, 'it DOES NOT'). Later, I addressed your specific claim that a specific photo showed the police surrounded. Pay attention: it DOES NOT.

The 'bottom' of this, in case you truly are so blind you've missed my countless repetitions, is that I DON'T CARE whether the police were 'surrounded' or not. I refer you to beachnut's excellent (if idiosyncratic) post on the issue of them being 'surrounded'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom