Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!


Measuring the Amount of Force Used By and Against the Police in Six Jurisdictions


Police Twist Suspect’s Arm 35.1
Police Kick Suspect 40.6
Police Hit Suspect 40.8
Police Use Chemical Agent 45.9
Police Wrestle With Suspect 48.2

This does not prove either proposition.

Yes, the bit you're selectively quoting does not. I mean, you had to quote-mine a sentence fragment, and you're ignoring 297, which has links to reports which explicitly say use of pepper spray reduces risk of injury to officer and suspect, especially when they're physically resisting.

Guys, let's not have the same 'enthusiastic debate' again.
 
Last edited:
You got my head spinning over here.

Are you saying that these:

Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car.

Were the options available in the UC Davis case, instead of pepper spray?
 
Noah, please quote the bits I included in my post, with the links.

I mean, how hard is it to skim a report, or a page of text? I did.
 
Last edited:
Was a big deal made of dislocating shoulders because students has their arms interlocked? I'm not assuming anything about the answer. I apologize I asked. I apologize that I don't know. Though in a skeptics forum people ought to be able to ask questions. Right?
Actually, the defenders of the students seem unable to get past the "peaceful students" claims to address the question of what force would be appropriate assuming the police were justified in removing the students. Their claims seem to really be about removing them, period, rather than any specific method used. JQ has stated, in effect, that any removal of the students was unjustified. Why they continued to ask questions pertaining specifically to pepper spray I do not know.


Originally Posted by RandFan
I honestly don't know that. I believed that proposition and I still do. I did attempt to support that proposition. That does not speak ill of me and hardly justifies your behavior toward me. And that raises two point.
What evidence is there that the physical force that would be necessary to move seated students is relatively a greater risk than pepper spray?
This.

I will concede that I don't know A.) that pepper spray is a relatively greater risk. B.) that I have any proof to demonstrate that.

I believe one of your reports said that pepper spray was likely to cause an hour or so of intense discomfort that makes it nigh-impossible to remain resolute and decreases physical resistance. Have some studies.

http://www.nij.gov/journals/267/use-of-force.htm

Quote:
Researchers coded 467 use-of-force reports from January 2005 to July 2006. The most frequent force level used by deputies (59 percent of incidents) was soft empty hand control (e.g., holding a suspect to restrain him), which increased the odds of officer injury by 160 percent.

Pepper spray decreased the odds of suspect injury by almost 70 percent,
...
Use of both soft hand tactics and hard hand tactics (e.g., using kicks or punches to restrain a suspect) by officers more than doubled the odds of officer injury. Hands-on tactics also increased the odds of injury to suspects, as did the use of canines.
...
The use of physical force by officers increased the odds of officer injury 258 percent. Not surprisingly, the odds of officer injury also increased when suspects resisted by using physical force or when suspects used or threatened to use a weapon.
http://www.nij.gov/journals/267/use-...ce-factors.htm

Quote:
Physical force and hands-on control increased the risk of injury to officers and citizens. When controlling for the use of CEDs and pepper spray in the multiagency analysis, using force increased the odds of injury to officers by more than 300 percent, and by more than 50 percent to suspects.
...
Increasing levels of suspect resistance were associated with an increased risk of injury to officers and suspects. The increased injury risk was especially acute for officers.
http://www.policechiefmagazine.org/m...ssue_id=102010

Quote:
Whereas CEDs and OC spray, which typically are deployed at a distance from resistive or combative suspects, were associated with injury reduction, the use of hands-on tactics that require officers to be in close physical proximity to suspects to effect arrests was associated with an increased risk of injury to both officers and suspects, although some variations on this finding existed among the three agencies.
...
The authors’ findings consistently show a significant reduction in the risk of injury to suspects when CEDs or OC spray is used.
...
If injury reduction is the primary goal, then agencies that authorize OC spray and/or CEDs to overcome defensive resistance are clearly at an advantage based upon the results from the current study. Both of these less-lethal weapons help prevent or minimize physical struggles that cause injury, albeit relatively minor ones, to officers and citizens.
Can someone quote this for Rand and remove my name from the quote? He has me on ignore, and asked that this be done in the last thread.


When you quote someone with url's apparently it removes the content. I hope this is tidy enough.
 
Last edited:
Were the options available in the UC Davis case, instead of pepper spray?
Please to answer my earlier question that I asked directly of you. I will answer this one but if I'm expected to answer questions then I very much expect others to do likewise. Are you saying the options were not? What about the situation obviates all options below use of pepper spray?

And please, I've conceded that I do not know. I'm not trying to convince anyone I'm right. I'm trying to have civil conversation. Could we all precede with that assumption?

ETA: I now note you addressed my earlier question. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
What about the situation obviates all options below use of pepper spray?
Officer presence; tried, ineffective.
Verbal command; tried, ineffective.
Gentle physical compulsion; tried, ineffective.
Warning suspects of use of force; tried, ineffective.

The next step after pepper spray is hard physical compulsion, which, given the position the students were in, would have had to go through heavy physical resistance. Tugging hard on someone's arm when they don't want to move and are strenuously resisting is likely to lead to, you guessed it, dislocation. The linked arms are designed to make it difficult to even get a good hold on the arm in the first place; even if the individual is not resisting, their partners may be. Without the pepper spray to soften 'em all up, they would've been hurt much worse.
 
Last edited:
Thank you very much. The links are giving me a 404 but the previous links do work. I will concede that does appear to be evidence in support of the proposition that pepper spray is a lower relative risk.

Can someone quote this for Rand and remove my name from the quote?
I don't put people on ignore lightly. If you would promise to act civil I will take you off. Putting people on ignore is a last resort.
 
No, I'm fine. I just wanted to give you the information you requested, even if indirectly.
 
I think you're under the impression that you asked me a question, when it was IDB87 you meant to ask.

Are you saying the options were not? What about the situation obviates all options below use of pepper spray?

That's mine.
The other options weren't available, or were used. Here are your options:

Techniques ranking lower (ie, should be deployed first) included use of handcuffs, threaten use of chemical agent or baton, pressure hold, twisting an arm, kick or hit suspect, or chase suspect in a car.

Handcuffs - not available. Their arms were interlocked. You can't put cuffs on them in that position.
Threaten Use of Chemical Agent or Baton - was used. This is backed up by the video and the students' accounts.
Pressure Hold/Hit/Kick/Twist Arm - unavailable. This would have caused far, far more injuries than the pepper spray and was thus deemed too extreme.

Chase by a car - I'm assuming we don't have to discuss this.
 
Pressure Hold/Hit/Kick/Twist Arm - unavailable. This would have caused far, far more injuries than the pepper spray and was thus deemed too extreme.
In the context of the PDF file, this is ranked lower, right?

Police Twist Suspect’s Arm 35.1
Police Kick Suspect 40.6
Police Hit Suspect 40.8
Police Use Chemical Agent 45.9
Police Wrestle With Suspect 48.2

Given the claims made in that PDF file they A.) were available and B.) ranked lower. Right? Moot given the other links but I was correct given the PDF file.
 

Measuring the Amount of Force Used By and Against the Police in Six Jurisdictions


Police Twist Suspect’s Arm 35.1
Police Kick Suspect 40.6
Police Hit Suspect 40.8
Police Use Chemical Agent 45.9
Police Wrestle With Suspect 48.2

This does not prove either proposition.

Police Bite Suspect 37.7
Police Spit on Suspect 23.2

So perhaps the solution would have just been to spit on the protesters a whole bunch.

Somehow, I'm not seeing this ranking as any sort of indicator of appropriateness. But maybe I just don't understand how useful biting and spitting can be as a police tactic.
 
In the context of the PDF file, this is ranked lower, right?

Police Twist Suspect’s Arm 35.1
Police Kick Suspect 40.6
Police Hit Suspect 40.8
Police Use Chemical Agent 45.9
Police Wrestle With Suspect 48.2

Given the claims made in that PDF file they A.) were available and B.) ranked lower. Right? Moot given the other links but I was correct given the PDF file.

That PDF file is irrelevant. It doesn't apply to what was going on at UC Davis.
 
That PDF file is irrelevant. It doesn't apply to what was going on at UC Davis.
Could you work with me here for a moment? I've conceded your other links but I think it fair to me to understand the context of the discussion and this question.

  • There is a sub thread of a conversation going on.
  • I asked a question.
  • Someone else posted the PDF file.
  • Someone else made claims about that PDF file.
  • So I asked questions about the PDF file.
  • That question was not addressed to you.
  • You then asked me if those options were available.
  • When I challenged you on that you said "Pressure Hold/Hit/Kick/Twist Arm - unavailable. This would have caused far, far more injuries than the pepper spray and was thus deemed too extreme."
  • I then pointed out that according to the PDF file those ranked lower so, based on the PDF file, I think you were wrong.
If you think the other links make the question moot then say that. But I specifically said in context of the PDF file, right? And BTW: I didn't introduce the PDF file in this thread, right?
 
Officer presence; tried, ineffective.
Verbal command; tried, ineffective.
Gentle physical compulsion; tried, ineffective.
Warning suspects of use of force; tried, ineffective.

The next step after pepper spray is hard physical compulsion

You forgot spitting and biting. The police should have spit on the suspects first, then tried biting them. I mean, they're lower on that list than pepper spray, right?
 

Measuring the Amount of Force Used By and Against the Police in Six Jurisdictions


Police Twist Suspect’s Arm 35.1
Police Kick Suspect 40.6
Police Hit Suspect 40.8
Police Use Chemical Agent 45.9
Police Wrestle With Suspect 48.2

This does not prove either proposition.

*sigh*

Do you believe this list in anyway represents a list of force a police officer should use in escalating order? In other words, would you have found it acceptable had pike attempted to bite apart the chain before he used pepper spray?

Please tell me the point of the list?
 
Police Bite Suspect 37.7
Police Spit on Suspect 23.2

So perhaps the solution would have just been to spit on the protesters a whole bunch.

Somehow, I'm not seeing this ranking as any sort of indicator of appropriateness. But maybe I just don't understand how useful biting and spitting can be as a police tactic.
Because it's not. This is the second thread RandFan has been using this chart show somethiong it doesn't actually show.

RandFan, this was pointed out to you in the other thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom