Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

But then they might've gotten bruised!

Noah, since it's obvious you're not really following the thread, I'll make something clearer for you. I have 000063 on ignore, and while I sometimes use that as a pause (since I can choose to look at individual posts), I did establish that I was no longer looking at his posts. You can call that 'blind', if you like (you could even try 'BLIND' if you think it makes an ignorant assertion more valid).
I have been able to consistently trounce you, logically. I have proven you flat wrong on several points in the debate, including the claim that you admit you are wrong (#217). No wonder you have me on ignore.

For the record, I have both you and beachnut on ignore, but I'm choosing to read your posts here. That probably won't last long...
Do that a lot, do you? Ignore people after they ask you to look at evidence? Then keep "peeking" at their posts? Because all it proves is that certain people keep saying things you don't like to hear, but you keep actively choosing to discuss them anyway.

More pertinently, I originally addressed the claim that the video showed the police surrounded. Pay attention: it does not (if it helps, 'it DOES NOT'). Later, I addressed your specific claim that a specific photo showed the police surrounded. Pay attention: it DOES NOT.
Assuming that to be true, and I do not think it is, that is not the same as saying the protestors did not obstruct the police, which even they openly admit they did. In fact, you've effectively done as much; you said they were protesting, and you said the protest "took the form" of obstructing police. Given that the students had specifically stated they were going to obstruct police unless the prisoners were released, a statement which you have directly referred to, it would be highly illogical for the cops to think the students making it harder to transport prisoners were doing so by accident.

Plus, there's the whole thing about only looking at one video. Like I said, shorter video = more bias. The What Really Happened video, as well as others--or did you not notice the half-dozen cameras in the various screenshots?--shows quite clearly that they were surrounded.

The 'bottom' of this, in case you truly are so blind you've missed my countless repetitions, is that I DON'T CARE whether the police were 'surrounded' or not. I refer you to beachnut's excellent (if idiosyncratic) post on the issue of them being 'surrounded'.
Yet you keep arguing about it.

Beachnut's posts, as I have pointed out, keep leaving out his sources. He is presenting instants in time as representative of an hour or so. (I'm not sure about the exact timeline.) He's doing the equivalent of quote-mining something which he refuses to source because he knows the context refutes him. Saying "the students were not surrounding and obstructing the cops during these few milliseconds" is rather different from "the students were not surrounding and obstructing the cops at all", yet he's explicitly trying to conflate them.

There's also the sheer illogic of saying that the students were not able to obstruct or threaten the cops, but were able to drive them out of the area. How is that possible if they represented no resistance or threat?
 
Last edited:
What were the goals. Goals are important -

Katehi:
“I explicitly directed the chief of police that violence should be avoided at all costs. It was the absolute last thing I ever wanted to happen,” she said.
Katehi said she directed police only to take down the tents. “My instructions were for no arrests and no police force.”
Police failed.
Good point. Following Katehi's instructions trumps everything else. For example if one of the students busted out a gun and started shooting people, the cops would have been failures if they used violence or made an arrest.
 
Yes, and never mind that her orders/request might not have had any significant legal weight whatsoever. Beachnut even posted an unsourced quote indicating a town's mayor can only take direct control of the police force in time of an emergency. This was off my post comparing her legal control of the police to a town mayor. Of course, if the mayor is only in direct control in emergencies, that means he or she is not in direct control the rest of the time.

I'm still waiting for him to tell me what the police's alternatives were. He has said that if they were really surrounded and threatened in a small space, they would've acted differently, but did not specify. JQ said the cops should've tried patience and communication, and did not respond to my post where I pointed out that they did and those did not work. I'm waiting for more alternatives.

Of course, Beachnut has also suggested that the police should've simply arrest all the students and marched them in to Katehi's office to speak with her, which directly contracts his assertion that they should've listened to her orders for no arrests, and would've required more force than what was used.

I am going to be very worried if the students win the suit. The police were acting well within standards, and the students have openly admitted they were breaking the law. I would be surprised if that does not come up during the suit. Of course, UCD may settle, which Occupy will see as a "win", and then we'll have even more people trying stunts like this. Sooner or later, people are going to mob a group of police and overwhelm them for no good reason, and then idiots watching doctored video on the internet will say the cops "provoked" them.

EDIT: There's also the curious fact that Bechnut keeps claiming the seated students were unable to obstruct the officers' transport of prisoners, but has neglected to provide a single screenshot or video proving this after the inner ring was formed but before Pike started to arrest them. Not to mention arguing that the inner students were not a barrier, but the cops didn't even try to walk their prisoners over it. They did, however, ask the students to leave, try to gently tug them apart, and hang around an angry crowd which had threatened them when they could've just left at any time, apparently.
 
Last edited:
I have been able to consistently trounce you, logically. I have proven you flat wrong on several points in the debate, including the claim that you admit you are wrong (#217). No wonder you have me on ignore.

Interesting claim, that depends entirely on a massively delusional view of your self and your ability to 'pwn'. I've had you on ignore for a long, long time - probably since the events you link to in #217 (a post I hadn't seen before now). You know it's considered very bad form to drag in arguments from unconnected threads to bolster what is, as is now evident, simply a personal issue for you. You don't like me. Get over it.

For the record, I am sometimes wrong and do admit it. What do you think you have achieved by saying so, except to imply that you believe you are never wrong? Trust me, nobody believes that. I'll believe you never admit when you're wrong, that's not an extraordinary claim at all...

I have you on ignore because I'm naturally courteous, and tend to make an effort to reply to anything addressed to me. Ignore allows me to keep at arms length the sort of poster who turns an intractable opposition of ideas into a trollish playground squabble, dragging a debate down into a slapfight.

Do I do that a lot, ignoring people who are engaged in a vendetta born in some other thread on some other topic? Yes, yes I do.

Do that a lot, do you? Ignore people after they ask you to look at evidence?

See above. I'm not sure (nor care terribly much) what 'evidence' you're referring to (there may be a reason why you don't mention it...) Was it the video and photos, which is the only 'evidence' I recall being raised here? I've looked at them (pay attention). They are not evidence for the claims being made about them, which you could see if you looked...

Assuming that to be true, and I do not think it is,

Well you're wrong. Demonstrably wrong. It's been demonstrated. Will you (see above) admit you're wrong? I think my decision to ignore delusional fanatics is better than a fanatically delusional decision to keep addressing someone who has you on ignore, gradually replacing what little substantive argument you have with attacks on the arguer, to the extent of dragging up a delusional account of a previous encounter in an unconnected thread. Do I do a lot of that? Ignore people who I wouldn't invite into my home, or waste time actually talking to? Yes, yes I do...

that is not the same as saying the protestors did not obstruct the police, which even they openly admit they did.

Since you're an adherent of that 'labelling' school of debate, here's another one for you: 'moving the goalposts'. Of course the protestors were 'obstructing' the police. Have I ever suggested otherwise? No. Are you hoping to suggest I did suggest otherwise? Yes. I make no judgement on that...

Well, ok, just a little one :rolleyes:

In fact, you've effectively done as much;

Guilty. See above. By the same token, you've used punctuation :eek:

you said they were protesting, and you said the protest "took the form" of obstructing police. Given that the students had specifically stated they were going to obstruct police unless the prisoners were released, a statement which you have directly referred to, it would be highly illogical for the cops to think the students making it harder to transport prisoners were doing so by accident.

None of which has been in dispute, but since you've failed to find any headway attempting to dispute the indisputable, you can pretend I've somehow disputed all this and then force me to admit. In the right light, from the right angle, that might look a bit like a win.

Plus, there's the whole thing about only looking at one video. Like I said, shorter video = more bias. The What Really Happened video shows quite clearly that they were surrounded.

A claim was made about a video. That claim was not supported by that video. The claim was erroneous. I pointed that out. Ever since, a handful of posters to whom the veracity of the claim has taken on undue significance have attempted to engage me on the matter of the veracity of the claim, as if that mattered (and despite my repeatedly pointing out that it doesn't matter).

I made no claim about the veracity of the claim regarding the crowd, only about the claim regarding what the video shows. That you cannot distinguish between the two is your problem (and currently mine, of course - I work with problematic youths, it's just in my nature to try to help people with problems, even though it's inevitably largely fruitless).

jiggeryqua said:
I DON'T CARE whether the police were 'surrounded' or not
Yet you keep arguing about it.
No, I keep responding to delusional fanatics who want a slapfight, because they can't distinguish two separate claims, one of which I made and one of which I did not (the two having no bearing on each other and only the most tenuous of connections in sharing the same subject matter).

Do I do that a lot, ignoring people who really haven't the faintest idea what's going on and yet insist on scrapping about it anyway? Yes, yes I do.


Beachnut's posts, as I have pointed out, keep leaving out his sources. He is presenting instants in time as representative of an hour or so. (I'm not sure about the exact timeline.) He's doing the equivalent of quote-mining something which he refuses to source because he knows the context refutes him. Saying "the students were not surrounding and obstructing the cops during these few milliseconds" is rather different from "the students were not surrounding and obstructing the cops at all", yet he's explicitly trying to conflate them.

Go argue with beachnut. It's ridiculous of you to expect me to defend him. I do again refer you to his excellent comments on the issue of 'surrounded' police, which do not require a 'source' to be cited, which do not depend on his view of time, contain no quote mining and conflate nothing. I don't want to be engaged in this sort of slapfight on my own account, I certainly won't be fielding for beachnut.


There's also the sheer illogical of saying that the students were not able to obstruct or threaten the students,

Well, yes, that's illogical ;)

Oh, you probably meant to type 'the police' for one of those 'students'. I'm guessing the latter, though I'll happily concede I'm wrong if you like.


but were able to drive them out of the area. How is that possible if they represented no resistance or threat?

Really? Do you honestly not see yourself? Of course the students resisted the police. No, the police were not threatened. Resistance is not the same as threat. But then you didn't actually just make that claim, you simply, suddenly added the word 'resistance' to a dispute about 'threat'. Maybe some fool reading will think you achieved something there. Resistance is only a 'threat' to those whose need for power is pathological and whose self-confidence is paranoiacally low. Resistance is a duty of the citizen of a free country. Opposition to the notion of resistance, viewing civil disobedience as a 'threat', is antithetical to the development of a free society.

You can continue talking about me or to me, if you must. Concoct more elaborate fictions in the hope of goading a response and getting someone to play slapfight with you, if you must. But we're truly done now.
 
Noah, since it's obvious you're not really following the thread, I'll make something clearer for you. I have 000063 on ignore, and while I sometimes use that as a pause (since I can choose to look at individual posts), I did establish that I was no longer looking at his posts. You can call that 'blind', if you like (you could even try 'BLIND' if you think it makes an ignorant assertion more valid).

For the record, I have both you and beachnut on ignore, but I'm choosing to read your posts here. That probably won't last long...

More pertinently, I originally addressed the claim that the video showed the police surrounded. Pay attention: it does not (if it helps, 'it DOES NOT'). Later, I addressed your specific claim that a specific photo showed the police surrounded. Pay attention: it DOES NOT.

The 'bottom' of this, in case you truly are so blind you've missed my countless repetitions, is that I DON'T CARE whether the police were 'surrounded' or not. I refer you to beachnut's excellent (if idiosyncratic) post on the issue of them being 'surrounded'.

Maybe you should take him off ignore so you can learn something.
 
Wow. If there weren't people asleep near here, I'd be laughing really loud. So you think the police should have just stepped over them? Risking people getting kicked in the head (police brutality!) or one of the people who was arrested not coming with them? Because dragging arrested people over other people would be such a good idea...

Its absurd really. those protesters were laughing about this they practically admitted that's what they wanted to happen.

That the cops should just hoist a bound suspect in the air and jump or climb over the protesters is the most laughable suggestion yet.

Do you think the protestors who were arrested would willingly jump over their fellow protestors to get to the paddywagon?

Seriously, we covered all of this pages ago.

Hold on a moment. I thought you said you weren't even interested in this aspect of the discussion, that you preferred to be talking about something else entirely?
So here you are, having succesfully made a point you weren't even interested in making, and instead of promptly dropping it faster than you picked it up, and going straight back the stuff that actually interests you, you're still arguing a point that you supposedly don't even care about? How does that work? ...
Some aspects more than others.
 
Maybe you should take him off ignore so you can learn something.
Whoa there. No need to get radical.

EDIT: I went back and looked at 552, and I was wrong about something; both Beachnut's screenshot and mine are taken from the same basic angle. Note the position of the young woman in the Raiders jacket. The only part of my argument this actually affects is the claim that the police in BN's shot are facing the direction backup will arrive.
 
Last edited:
...
Woefully disingenuous. Who has said they are claiming to be 'peaceful protestors'? They are, I trust, claiming to be non-violent direct activists. 'Peace' and 'non-violence' are not directly interchangeable. The shouting is not 'peaceful', as in 'peace and quiet' but it is non-violent in the sense of 'war and peace'....
Guys, I think I see the problem. JQ's been using a different dictionary from us since page one. Explains a lot.

Let's look at post 488, where I quote JQ, later, specifically referring to "peaceful protestors". Repeatedly. Of course, the idea that the students specifically threatening to riot and knowingly obstructing police are "peaceful" in the "war and peace" sense is ludicrously false on its face. At the very least, it's hypocritical, as ID pointed out.

They needed to be removed, in order for the police to leave.

Please, if you have a better alternative to accomplish that goal, we're all ears.

Pepper spray is uncomfortable, but it is the safest possible way to move that many people. It does so without lingering after effects or permanent damage.

It is safer than brute force, driving a truck or police car over them, tasers, guns or water cannon. It allowed the police to do their jobs and get home safely again. It even comes in large, useful containers for *exactly* this style of crowd dispersal.

Note that the police were heavily outnumbered, the crowd had acted belligerently towards them, and showed every sign of behaving like typical rent-a-crowd, they appeared to want a confrontation, that could be strip-mined for sound bytes and video.... which they eventually got, though the longer version(s) of the video shows pretty clearly who was at fault.

Hell, the kids that got sprayed with pepper sprary were *interviewed* by reporters afterwards. They weren't hurt. They weren't even arrested (and that in itself surprised me).

They just acted like typical young adults from over-privileged families, aghast that THEY might actually be called to account for their actions.
It certainly does look like they encircled the area where the police hanging out with their arrestees....
Yes, police definitely overstep their authority to harass and intimidate protestors some of the time. And I think things like "free speech zones" and some of the anti-assembly laws are BS. But OWS has repeatedly used selective video editing to demonize cops who are just doing their jobs IMO.

Even if the police make an unjustified arrest, you can't just surround them and demand that they let the people go. That's ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
Stundie worthy.

Because if you have no substantive argument, then hoping to invoke the baser emotions of the crowd will pass for oratory.

If you bother to read the whole of beachnut's thoughts on the 'surrounded' cops, you'll appreciate that if the 'surrounding' was the real threat then they wouldn't have wasted the pepper spray on seated, unarmed, non-threatening students.

They weren't interested in resolving the situation peaceably and with the least risk. They were interested in displaying their strength, and chose the easiest target.
 
If you bother to read the whole of beachnut's thoughts on the 'surrounded' cops, you'll appreciate that if the 'surrounding' was the real threat then they wouldn't have wasted the pepper spray on seated, unarmed, non-threatening students.

Why don't you mention those people wore clothes? That they sat with their backs to the police? Or that hey had eyes, ears and arms? I think they all had hair too. I mean, that they were seated, unarmed and non-threatening* were not the reasons they were pepper sprayed. They were pepper sprayed because they didn't want the police to leave with the people the police arrested.

*For the sake of my argument, I'll call them non-threatening. I don't think they were non-threatening, mainly because of the things they said.
 
Why don't you mention those people wore clothes? That they sat with their backs to the police? Or that hey had eyes, ears and arms? I think they all had hair too. I mean, that they were seated, unarmed and non-threatening* were not the reasons they were pepper sprayed. They were pepper sprayed because they didn't want the police to leave with the people the police arrested.

*For the sake of my argument, I'll call them non-threatening. I don't think they were non-threatening, mainly because of the things they said.

Because the police wore clothes, and had eyes, ears and arms. D-, must try harder. They did indeed sit with their backs towards the police. That's the best way to threaten someone, isn't it? To turn your back on them? D-, must stop shooting self in foot.

They were pepper sprayed because the police are an unfortunate by product of the best bad solution we have to living together, and for all the reasons expounded on above.

For the record, you honestly think the seated unarmed students with their backs towards the police were 'threatening' the solidly built armed and armoured officers? With their words? Please refer to my remarks above, and seek help.
 
Because the police wore clothes, and had eyes, ears and arms. D-, must try harder. They did indeed sit with their backs towards the police. That's the best way to threaten someone, isn't it? To turn your back on them? D-, must stop shooting self in foot.

They were pepper sprayed because the police are an unfortunate by product of the best bad solution we have to living together, and for all the reasons expounded on above.

For the record, you honestly think the seated unarmed students with their backs towards the police were 'threatening' the solidly built armed and armoured officers? With their words? Please refer to my remarks above, and seek help.

You think you can't threaten someone with words? So if I were to say to someone on this forum that I would go by their house with a gun, I wouldn't be banned or get a warning?

You're missing the point. Yes, the students were sitting and unarmed, but that is not why they were pepper sprayed. They were pepper sprayed because they didn't want the police to leave with their arrestees. (Is that a word in English?) I think that is illegal, because the police should be allowed to do their job. Why won't you go into that?

Also, saying "seek help" doesn't address the argument and isn't very civil or polite.
 
You think you can't threaten someone with words? So if I were to say to someone on this forum that I would go by their house with a gun, I wouldn't be banned or get a warning?

You're missing the point. Yes, the students were sitting and unarmed, but that is not why they were pepper sprayed. They were pepper sprayed because they didn't want the police to leave with their arrestees. (Is that a word in English?) I think that is illegal, because the police should be allowed to do their job. Why won't you go into that?

Also, saying "seek help" doesn't address the argument and isn't very civil or polite.

jiggeryqua said:
No, the police were not threatened.[...] Resistance is only a 'threat' to those whose need for power is pathological and whose self-confidence is paranoiacally low.

Meanwhile, link to the 'threatening words' of the protestors. Where did they say they would go by the houses of the cops with guns? Oh no, they didn't, you're just making stuff up in a frantic attempt to defend the superiority of the servants of the people over the will of the people.

I haven't missed the 'point' you attempt to make, though you've clearly missed several points as you dismiss anyone who doesn't agree with you. In a way, of course, you're 'right' - the students were not pepper sprayed 'because' they were seated and unarmed. They were pepper sprayed despite the fact that they were seated, unarmed and evidently unthreatening (unless you equate "I turn my back on you" with "I will drive past your house with a gun", in which case (you've guessed it) seek help).

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for Rule 0.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom