Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

*sigh*

Do you believe this list in anyway represents a list of force a police officer should use in escalating order? In other words, would you have found it acceptable had pike attempted to bite apart the chain before he used pepper spray?

Please tell me the point of the list?

That's where I get confused, too.

It's a list of what officers did elsewhere. You can't use that list to determine what the appropriate response would have been at UC Davis.


RandFan:

You then asked me if those options were available.

When I challenged you on that you said "Pressure Hold/Hit/Kick/Twist Arm - unavailable. This would have caused far, far more injuries than the pepper spray and was thus deemed too extreme."

I then pointed out that according to the PDF file those ranked lower so, based on the PDF file, I think you were wrong.

The PDF file was discussing what other officers did elsewhere over a certain period of time.

It isn't relevant to what the officers at UC Davis experienced, or determined what their course of events should have been.

You're misinterpreting what the PDF file means.
 
Please tell me the point of the list?

  • I asked if there was evidence for the proposition that pepper spray was relatively less risky.
  • You introduced the PDF file accusing me of not reading the study.
  • If you don't think the list is credible then please to tell me the point of you introducing the list?
 
I asked if there was evidence for the proposition that pepper spray was relatively less risky.

Yes, there is evidence it may cause less injury to both officer and offender. Why you're hung up on the word 'may' I'll never guess.

If you don't think the list is credible then please to tell me the point of you introducing the list?

I don't know how you're trying to use the list so I cannot figure out if it's relevant to whatever point you're trying to make.

The list is credible in the context of the study, which is categorizing types of force used by certain urban precincts making arrests.
 
Last edited:
It's a list of what officers did elsewhere. You can't use that list to determine what the appropriate response would have been at UC Davis.
Then why introduce it as if it were relevant?

It isn't relevant to what the officers at UC Davis experienced, or determined what their course of events should have been.
I didn't introduce the list in this thread. You could have said that IDB87 was wrong to introduce the report in this thread. IDB87 could have said he was wrong to introduce the report in this thread.

You're misinterpreting what the PDF file means.
How? What does it mean?

This is where I really get frustrated. I have been more than willing to consider evidence and concede that I was wrong. I have been patient and respectful. But when I ask questions I get a lot of hand waving. It's a simple and straight forward point. Very easy to deal with. All anyone need do is say the study is not statistically significant and there are other studies to support the proposition. Attacking me for questioning evidence that I did not introduce is bad form.
 
I don't know how you're trying to use the list so I cannot figure out if it's relevant to whatever point you're trying to make.
You introduced the study as if it had relevance as to my question regarding the relative risk. Do you stand by that? If so what is the relevance?
 
Then why introduce it as if it were relevant?

I didn't. I'm going to go ahead and assume that at some point in time, there was a question posed, or a discussion point that needed reinforcing using that PDF.
 
I didn't. I'm going to go ahead and assume that at some point in time, there was a question posed, or a discussion point that needed reinforcing using that PDF.

But you did challenge me regarding something I said about evidence I didn't introduce (in this thread). If you are going to challenge me on something I said regarding the PDF then you ought to understand the context of the discussion, or, if I balk at your challenge then I think that decorum would dictate that you at least, at that point, find out the context of the discussion.

Look, I'm not perfect. I live in a glass house. But I am honestly trying to be more respectful and to extend the philosophical principle of charity. I'd ask others to do likewise.
 
Last edited:
The first time that PDF was referred to in this thread was BY YOU, RandFan, in post 501.

I just went through the entire thread.

I don't know why it was originally introduced, but as of now - I and I alone are stating that it has nothing to do with the UC Davis incident.

Nothing whatsoever.

eta - I don't care why it was introduced, so lets not harp on it.
 
Last edited:
I believe the report was introduced because of this quote: "Research by Kaminski and colleagues suggests that pepperspray is effective in controlling disorderly suspects and may reduce injuries to both officers and suspects." (p. 71) In other words: to present evidence that the use of pepper spray may be safer for both officers and suspects than other forms of coersion.
 
How? What does it mean?

Nothing.

In the context of determining the propriety of police action at Davis, it means absolutely nothing at all. It is not a ranking of appropriateness or suitability. It is not a ranking of safety. It is not a ranking of effectiveness. It is not a ranking of the order in which to try techniques. It is none of these things, and does not claim to be.
 
I believe the report was introduced because of this quote: "Research by Kaminski and colleagues suggests that pepperspray is effective in controlling disorderly suspects and may reduce injuries to both officers and suspects." (p. 71) In other words: to present evidence that the use of pepper spray may be safer for both officers and suspects than other forms of coersion.

Wasn't so hard eh?

:)

Also, RandFan, I was reminding you of the techniques you preferred over pepper spray, which, according to the list you provided via that source, includes biting and spitting - if I'm to understand how you're trying to use that list, at any rate.
 
...that pepperspray ... may reduce injuries to both officers and suspects.
"may". Yes. But that is based on the data which is now being called into question. You don't get to have it both ways. Either the data and conclusions are meaningful or they are not.
 
Also, RandFan, I was reminding you of the techniques you preferred over pepper spray, which, according to the list you provided via that source, includes biting and spitting - if I'm to understand how you're trying to use that list, at any rate.

  • I asked for evidence.
  • You provided a link to the PDF file.
  • The study lists biting below that of using chemical agent.
  • Either the data and conclusions of the study are meaningful or they are not.
Which is it?
 
"may". Yes. But that is based on the data which is now being called into question. You don't get to have it both ways. Either the data and conclusions are meaningful or they are not.

On what data do you think that quote is based, then?
 
The study lists biting below that of using chemical agent.

What is the value of the list? This is a question you have not, and most likely will not, answer.

Quoting for posterity:

Ziggurat said:
In the context of determining the propriety of police action at Davis, it means absolutely nothing at all. It is not a ranking of appropriateness or suitability. It is not a ranking of safety. It is not a ranking of effectiveness. It is not a ranking of the order in which to try techniques. It is none of these things, and does not claim to be.
 
Last edited:
On what data do you think that quote is based, then?
? Sorry? What is the point of the question. I believe the quote is based on the data contained in the report.

Note the word "may". Now, note that physical force brackets the use of chemical agent. It's a hedge. It's not conclusive. The inference is that it also "may" be less and that is supported by the data, right?
 
You didn't go through it very well (please see post 495).

I strongly disagree and find the assertion bizarre. However, I've conceded the other links so my question regarding evidence for the relative risk of pepper spray has been answered and for that I'm appreciative.

I apologize, I searched for the wrong wording apparently.

The point remains however. That the list of items were either not available to the the UC Davis Police, or that they were in fact used.

After all this confusion, Pepper Spray remains the best, most injury-free option.
 
? Sorry? What is the point of the question. I believe the quote is based on the data contained in the report.

That is the point of the question. It isn't based on the data contained in the report. If you had bothered to look at the quote, you would have immediately seen that it was based on:

Kaminski, Robert J., Steven M. Edwards, and James W. Johnson, “Assessing the Incapacitative Effects of Pepper Spray During Resistive Encounters With Police,” Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management, 22(1)(1999): 7–29; and Kaminski, Robert J., Steven M. Edwards, and James W. Johnson, “The Deterrent Effects of Oleoresin Capsicum on Assaults Against Police: Testing the Velcro-Effect Hypothesis,” Police Quarterly, 1(2)(1998): 1–20.

ETA: I tried accessing these journals, but I can't. So I can't assess the data (even if I would have had the expertise to do that).
 
Last edited:
What is the value of the list? This is a question you have not, and most likely will not, answer.
You are doing it again. I've honestly tried to answer every question posed to me. I can't say the same about my opponents. In any event, the list is the basis for the conclusions.

  • Look, it's your evidence.
  • Don't you know?
  • Why did you post it if you don't know the value of the list?
  • I don't get that at all.
Look, when I saw the evidence re-posted by Noahfence I did not balk. I did not start deconstructing and obfuscating. I stepped up to the plate and admitted the evidence existed.

  • I have conceded that the evidence makes the PDF file moot.
  • I have NO reason to be obtuse or obfuscate on this issue.
  • I don't enjoy this. I'm simply seeking some degree of intellectual honesty and fairness.
Could you folks be kind enough to extend a bit of charity?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom