Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

What? I'm not sure that says what you mean. I'm saying that just because no court to date has found any merit whatsoever in the argument against Roe v Wade does not mean that there is no merit to arguments against Roe (likewise with the Free Speech Zones).

BTW: Could you comment on ACORN v Secret Service?

Why did the Secret Service make that acknowledgment? Was it because they had done that very thing? Would you concede that it's possible for the Secret Service to abuse free speech zones?
It means that they can't use that as a criteria for setting up the zone, but not that they have to have line of sight or be within earshot. Because it's simply not possible in all cases, especially if you have very large numbers of protestors wanting to demonstrate in a very small space.

You can say "we're expecting 50,000 protestors so we'll keep them confined to the park a few blocks down the street", but you can't say "let's put them in the park down the street so the politicians can't see them".

How close they get is a function of the number of protestors involved, security requirements, keeping roads open for emergency vehicles, safety reasons (such as not cramming so many people in a room they can't get out in an emergency), etc etc.
 
illegal camping
The students who removed their tents were not arrested, the student who refused, were arrested. They gave the kids to 3 pm to remove the illegal camping stuff... quibble if you wish, the ones who refused remove tents, like continue illegal camping, were arrested. NPR...
Did it occur to you the "illegal camping" charge would be for those refusing to leave their tents?

Still nothing about people arrested for refusing to remove tents?

eta: no, the part you quoted does not say they were arrested for refusing to remove their tents. It says they were arrested when they refused to remove their tents. That's when the police went in (per the request of UC-Davis) to remove the tents. Those who obstructed them were arrested.
 
Last edited:
Well, you are to be congratulated... that one actually made me go find the laughing dog.

So not one single case out of all the cases ever argued, has ended in a hung jury, or a mistrial, or a withdrawn complaint...
Does this mean you're backing away from your apparent claim that if a legal argument can be made it must have merit?

You've done this in other threads too.
 
It means that they can't use that as a criteria for setting up the zone, but not that they have to have line of sight or be within earshot. Because it's simply not possible in all cases, especially if you have very large numbers of protestors wanting to demonstrate in a very small space.

You can say "we're expecting 50,000 protestors so we'll keep them confined to the park a few blocks down the street", but you can't say "let's put them in the park down the street so the politicians can't see them".

How close they get is a function of the number of protestors involved, security requirements, keeping roads open for emergency vehicles, safety reasons (such as not cramming so many people in a room they can't get out in an emergency), etc etc.
Thank you for that. So, the reasonable line that I've been searching for would be, it seems to me, as close as possible and still allow for security and safety.

So, free speech zones can be abused. It would have to be taken on a case by case basis. My reading of the Wiki article would indicate that there are a number of concerns. Unless we dismiss the UCLA in an ad hominem fashion then it is obvious that they most certainly have concerns. One case was dismissed simply because the ACLU was deemed to not have standing. The following information is particularly troubling.

As a result of ACLU subpoenas during the discovery in the Rank lawsuit, the ACLU obtained the White House's previously-classified presidential advance manual. The manual gives people organizing presidential visits specific advice for preventing or obstructing protests. "There are several ways the advance person" - the person organizing the presidential visit - "can prepare a site to minimize demonstrators. First, as always, work with the Secret Service to and have them ask the local police department to designate a protest area where demonstrators can be placed, preferably not in view of the event site or motorcade route. The formation of 'rally squads' is a common way to prepare for demonstrators... The rally squad's task is to use their signs and banners as shields between the demonstrators and the main press platform... As a last resort, security should remove the demonstrators from the event site."[36]
No court case to date but the advance manual seems rather damning and would support the claim that free speech zones are used a pretext to obstruct freedom of speech. We will see.
 
Last edited:
The quad is a field 500 x 600 feet, there are infinite ways to leave. The students seem to be in the center of the quad, see Google Earth, you can see exactly how it is set up. This is where you want your protest, away from classes.

If you want I will go down to the campus soon and take pictures for you.

Why do you keep hammering this point when no one is even arguing it? The issue being discussed in the thread is that they had encircled the cops and expressed verbal intent not to let them leave, not that their protest was obstructing people from getting around the quad.
 
Are you talking about YouTube? Hmmm? Why is it that we need YouTube as a narrative for the Occupy Movement? Could it be because WildCat demands us to watch YouTube in order to verify such trivial information that only pertains to what HE WANTS IT TO pertain to?
Ironic, considering that this whole mess was started by a video specifically edited to misrepresent the situations.

Either that, or the person who cut it honestly thought that the fact the students had surrounded and threatened the police was irrelevant.

Friday Nov. 18th at 4:54 PM

Police pepper spray students who refused to move out of the way.
Not quite the whole picture, is it?

Its also well known, practically common knowledge. I find it hard to imagine anyone talking about this subject who doesn't know.
Wait, so RandFan threatened to put you on ignore for talking about how he puts people on ignore?

What I think is hilarious is that those here on JREF who like to criticize the Occupy movement not only have a problem spelling the word - OCCUPY - they also have a problem with thinking they know every little thing as well as pretending they have some sort of law enforcement fantasy! It gives them a boner!
I love how knowing more than you is the same as thinking we're omniscient or want to be cops. This is a skeptics forum. Making an uninformed decision and ignoring evidence is worse than making a decision on no evidence at all.
 
Dude, the point is... most who choose a career in law enforcement do so because they feel a badge and a gun gives them a license to be thugs! I have said this many times before, but you guys just keep laughing and having your little fraternity "hoo-ras" dismissing this **** like it's no big deal! It is a big deal!
This is incorrect. My mom babysits a cop's kids. He's a nice guy who rides a motorbike and watches those daytime TV "judge" shows and laughs at how inaccurate he thinks Burn Notice is.

Poisoning the well. "Oh, the police officers are meanies, so what they did wasn't justified!" It's an irrelevant and spurious attack on their characters, to avoid the discussion of their actions.

You use the 9/11 forum; do you really think the hundreds of cops rushing toward the burning buildings were jackbooted thugs?
 
Last edited:
Dude, the incident in question was filmed by multiple people from multiple angles. You want to argue about what happened but refuse to watch the video of the actual incident? :boggled:
So I should watch YouTube videos but then again I should not watch YouTube videos... it all depends on what WildCat agrees with and not anyone else, eh??

Wait, so you read WC telling you to watch several Youtube videos, and you think he's telling you not to?
 
In other words, they were being thugs!
Removing tents that were there illegally (the school even had a poll, and most people who responded wanted them gone) after several days of advance warning, and a warning on the scene, and leaving the bulk of the protestors alone is "acting like thugs"?

No.

There are online videos and people here on JREF that give bias against the Occupy movement.

That's what I believe!
Which, logically, means there are videos and people here on JREF that give biases toward the Occupy movement. But you have no problem with that, right?

The original video was specifically cut to obscure most of the facts we are discussing, to make it seem like the police were responsible for the situation, when in reality it was the students.

I do think discounting a video because it might be biased in a direction you don't like is a novel technique.
 
Last edited:
Why are you listening to NPR? It's a liberal-commie news source!!! You really need to be watching Fox News, and ONLY Fox News. It's fair and balanced.....

And just because the police stepped over the kids, for the purpose of pepper-spraying them doesn't mean that stepping over the kids again wouldn't have lead to assured death!
I have pointed out several times there was no way to safely carry prisoners over the line. I have asked you, personally, to round up some friends and try to do so, keeping in mind that anyone in the line could reach up and hinder the cops at any time, and the students are breaking the law by blocking the cops way.

Stop strawmanning.

Say, would it have been better if the kids were standing with interlinked arms? What should the cops have done if they wanted to humanely pass through them then?

You mean the "what really happened" video that has biased commentating in it?
There is a version without commentary.



And here it is with.


Interesting how the original video is about a minute from events that spanned over an hour, but when longer video is presented, it's biased because of "the commentary".

Wow. I guess you simply don't understand the power of pre-framing.
Yet you have no problem with the original video omitting almost all of the context, and having a caption card in the very start that misrepresents the situation.

Hypocrite. Especially in light of your refusal to address the question of whether the prisoners could've been carried safely over the seated protestors. In fact, just about everyone on your side seems reluctant to discuss that part, or the fact that the students started the confrontation, not the cops. I wonder why?
 

Attachments

  • jref_UCD_firstframe.JPG
    jref_UCD_firstframe.JPG
    43.3 KB · Views: 4
Last edited:
Does this mean you're backing away from your apparent claim that if a legal argument can be made it must have merit?

You've done this in other threads too.
This means that once again you've made an irrational claim, and then started up with the usual tap dance of lying about what other people have posted, denying all facts that prove you wrong, and running away when you are called on it.

In this thread alone, you took my comments that I wasn't going to argue the techiques used by the police, and that I was going to focus on the legalities, and flat out lied by claiming that I said exactly the opposite.

Do you have anything to support your claim that "Hint: in every court case ever argued, at least one attorney makes a legal argument that doesn't hold up."?

Do you have anything either correct or useful on any of these topics?

Anything other than ankle biting on any topic?
 
This means that once again you've made an irrational claim, and then started up with the usual tap dance of lying about what other people have posted, denying all facts that prove you wrong, and running away when you are called on it.

In this thread alone, you took my comments that I wasn't going to argue the techiques used by the police, and that I was going to focus on the legalities, and flat out lied by claiming that I said exactly the opposite.

Do you have anything to support your claim that "Hint: in every court case ever argued, at least one attorney makes a legal argument that doesn't hold up."?

Do you have anything either correct or useful on any of these topics?

Anything other than ankle biting on any topic?
That's a lot of words to try to deflect from your claim that just because a lawyer makes an argument it must have legal merit.

Do you stand by this claim?
 
http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=pen&group=00001-01000&file=403-420.1
404. (a) Any use of force or violence, disturbing the public peace,
or any threat to use force or violence, if accompanied by immediate
power of execution, by two or more persons acting together, and
without authority of law, is a riot.

404.6. (a) Every person who with the intent to cause a riot does an
act or engages in conduct that urges a riot, or urges others to
commit acts of force or violence, or the burning or destroying of
property, and at a time and place and under circumstances that
produce a clear and present and immediate danger of acts of force or
violence or the burning or destroying of property, is guilty of
incitement to riot.

405a. The taking by means of a riot of any person from the lawful
custody of any peace officer is a lynching.

406. Whenever two or more persons, assembled and acting together,
make any attempt or advance toward the commission of an act which
would be a riot if actually committed, such assembly is a rout.

407. Whenever two or more persons assemble together to do an
unlawful act, or do a lawful act in a violent, boisterous, or
tumultuous manner, such assembly is an unlawful assembly.
If Pike warned the protestors they were merely unlawfully assembled, he was being remarkably generous, IMO.
 
Last edited:
The police there went above and beyond the call in trying to use as little force as needed. They rationally discussed with the students in question. The students knew they were breaking the law. They knew this came with consequences.


They also knew the idiocy of the country in general would allow them to look like the good guys in all this. They were right.

All that is needed in this day and age is to see what something looks like at the outset. It simply does not matter what the facts are. This is clearly demonstrated in the UC Davis incident, and countless others strewn all over every topic imaginable.
 
That's a lot of words to try to deflect from your claim that just because a lawyer makes an argument it must have legal merit.

Do you stand by this claim?
Do I stand by your claim that "just because a lawyer makes an argument it must have legal merit"?

Don't make me break out the laughing dog again. Those are *your* words and not mine. Has anyone ever fallen for your strawmen and actually joined you in pretending they said something they didn't? Because you are batting zero around here.

Do you have anything either correct or useful on what I actually said?
 
Last edited:
Do I stand by your claim that "just because a lawyer makes an argument it must have legal merit"?

Don't make me break out the laughing dog again. Those are *your* words and not mine. Has anyone ever fallen for your strawmen and actually joined you in pretending they said something they didn't? Because you are batting zero around here.

Do you have anything either correct or useful on what I actually said?

That wasn't his claim. Read again.
 
That wasn't his claim. Read again.
That was a direct quote of what Wildcat wrote, and I never posted anything even remotely resembling those words.

So yes, that claim belongs to no one but him.

And no, I'm not going to play games with someone who won't honestly address what is actually said.

If you want to fall for the strawmen and fabrications, be my guest.
 
That wasn't his claim. Read again.
Note how he carefully avoids addressing what the straw man actually is. He says those are WC's "words"--and is rather specific in referring to "words"--but that still leaves an accurate paraphrase or summary as a possibility.

Still, WC, I'd like to see where CR allegedly made this claim or equivalent.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom