Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Feel free to show case law showing that such an argument has ever been upheld by any US court.

Your claim, you provide the evidence.

Hint: in every court case ever argued, at least one attorney makes a legal argument that doesn't hold up.
Yeah, this isn't good faith. I'm not asking you to prove something. I'm asking you to be a decent human being and engage in a conversation. A.) If you know something could you provide it? B.) I'm not claiming that there is case law showing that such an argument has been upheld.

And that is really weak sauce (and it is being difficult). Roe V Wade could very well be overturned. That there is no case law showing that an argument against Roe v. Wade has been upheld does NOT invalidate the opinions of legal experts who are fighting Roe. It's really a fatuous rhetorical device. If you don't want to be difficult then engage me, make an argument.
 
Last edited:
LOL. Do you seriously believe that all online videos are of equal validity and relevancy to all topics?

No.

There are online videos and people here on JREF that give bias against the Occupy movement.

That's what I believe!
 
Yeah, this isn't good faith. I'm not asking you to prove something. I'm asking you to be a decent human being and engage in a conversation. A.) If you know something could you provide it? B.) I'm not claiming that there is case law showing that such an argument has been upheld.

And that is really weak sauce (and it is being difficult). Roe V Wade could very well be overturned. That there is no case law showing that an argument against Roe v. Wade has been upheld. That does NOT invalidate the opinions of legal experts who are fighting Roe. It's really a fatuous rhetorical device.
So now your saying that just because no court to date has found any merit whatsoever in the argument that protestors have the right to be heard by those they protest it doesn't mean some court in the future might?
 
So now your saying that just because no court to date has found any merit whatsoever in the argument that protestors have the right to be heard by those they protest it doesn't mean some court in the future might?
What? I'm not sure that says what you mean. I'm saying that just because no court to date has found any merit whatsoever in the argument against Roe v Wade does not mean that there is no merit to arguments against Roe (likewise with the Free Speech Zones).

BTW: Could you comment on ACORN v Secret Service?

wiki said:
...after the Secret Service acknowledged that it could not discriminate against protesters through the use of out-of-sight, out-of-earshot protest zones."
Why did the Secret Service make that acknowledgment? Was it because they had done that very thing? Would you concede that it's possible for the Secret Service to abuse free speech zones?
 
Last edited:
Can you take a screen shot of one of the videos and circle these gaps you claim the officers could have strolled through with prisoners in tow?


What video were you watching? What time in the video does this happen? Because I saw no such thing.


No, I'm saying they weren't arrested for refusing to remove their tents. And in that very post you quoted the reasons for arrest, none of which were for refusing to remove a tent!
illegal camping
The students who removed their tents were not arrested, the student who refused, were arrested. They gave the kids to 3 pm to remove the illegal camping stuff... quibble if you wish, the ones who refused remove tents, like continue illegal camping, were arrested. NPR...

I have not seen the official arrest report, but the police reports were found to be insufficient to charge the students, plus one. I could be wrong, this is based on news reports.

My only point, you don't pepper spray kids sitting, big mistake. UC Davis agrees with me, or I agree with UC Davis on this point, please make it sound the way you want, but don't pepper spray me, I am trying to watch all the games I recorded today...

illegal camping - you left off the NPR version of arrested for failure to remove their tents as directed, illegal camping

(ref video, what video) - too busy watching B-ball, I already posted proof, and it is all over the web. You say they were surround, I say walk through them. Some people have to lie to support their actions. You can find a video to make it look like they are surrounded. Not sure how they arrested anyone if they were blocked. I watched the videos you posted, you can't watch the one I posted. I took time and watched B-ball, can you?

I bet you can find it, students taken out of the area before the police stepped over the super barrier of kids, to spray them in the face. How did he step over the barrier? Oh noes, I am surrounded by sitting people... help

Lucky this is not Syria


Not me...
http://www.news10.net/news/article/...py-UC-Davis-camp?odyssey=tab|topnews|bc|large
Campus police said they arrested 10 demonstrators at the Occupy UC Davis encampment when campers refused to remove their tents Friday afternoon.
 
Last edited:
Why are you listening to NPR? It's a liberal-commie news source!!! You really need to be watching Fox News, and ONLY Fox News. It's fair and balanced.....

And just because the police stepped over the kids, for the purpose of pepper-spraying them doesn't mean that stepping over the kids again wouldn't have lead to assured death!
 
Last edited:
Feel free to show case law showing that such an argument has ever been upheld by any US court.

Your claim, you provide the evidence.

Hint: in every court case ever argued, at least one attorney makes a legal argument that doesn't hold up.
Well, you are to be congratulated... that one actually made me go find the laughing dog.

So not one single case out of all the cases ever argued, has ended in a hung jury, or a mistrial, or a withdrawn complaint...
 

Attachments

  • laughing_dog.jpg
    laughing_dog.jpg
    29.7 KB · Views: 2
Unless it is dishonestly edited, how biased can video of the event be?
Perspective, and point of view.

The student are on a quad, it is over 500 x 600 feet of grass and trees, you can enter from infinite points, and exit the same. The students are not blocking access to anything, you can walk around them.
 
Last edited:
Can you take a screen shot of one of the videos and circle these gaps you claim the officers could have strolled through with prisoners in tow?


What video were you watching? What time in the video does this happen? Because I saw no such thing.


No, I'm saying they weren't arrested for refusing to remove their tents. And in that very post you quoted the reasons for arrest, none of which were for refusing to remove a tent!

Okay, you are more important than B-ball!

111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg

See the kid and the police officer on the left! He was arrested (for not taking down his tent... or what) and was taken away before pepper spray police person went to work. The people to be pepper sprayed are on the right, this video shows the area tangential to many of the other videos.

Note, you don't need the sidewalk to leave the quad. This why so many students arrived to see what was going on. They can arrive from all points.

The quad is a field 500 x 600 feet, there are infinite ways to leave. The students seem to be in the center of the quad, see Google Earth, you can see exactly how it is set up. This is where you want your protest, away from classes.

If you want I will go down to the campus soon and take pictures for you.
 
Last edited:
Still waiting.
Well, while you are waiting, here's a refreshing personal anecdote.

A while back some students at a certain well known US school, let's call it Football State University, started raising a stink about the food service monopoly which was cracking down on any food on campus not sold through them.
In the course of this, it was alleged that SheraMark may have been exploiting some of their workers in ways that should have been investigated.

When a rally/protest was called in the school's common area, the President had the campus police chief bullhorn everyone that they could only protest if they moved to one of the authorized 'free speech zones' on campus, so as not to obstruct other people.

When asked where these free speech zones were, the president replied 'It's a secret, but if you protest anywhere outside of them, you'll be arrested'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom