Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Are you talking about YouTube? Hmmm? Why is it that we need YouTube as a narrative for the Occupy Movement? Could it be because WildCat demands us to watch YouTube in order to verify such trivial information that only pertains to what HE WANTS IT TO pertain to?
Dude, the incident in question was filmed by multiple people from multiple angles. You want to argue about what happened but refuse to watch the video of the actual incident? :boggled:
 
Dude, the incident in question was filmed by multiple people from multiple angles. You want to argue about what happened but refuse to watch the video of the actual incident? :boggled:

So I should watch YouTube videos but then again I should not watch YouTube videos... it all depends on what WildCat agrees with and not anyone else, eh??
 
The fact is I don't think anyone has posted the official arrest record yet. A few sources say those who refuse to remove their tents, were arrested, 9 studs and 1 other.
Maybe you should post one of those sources, and quote it? Because none of the sources you cited so far say anyone was arrested for refusing to remove a tent.
 
Why should I take your opinion seriously when you can't even get the most basic facts straight? No one was arrested for refusing to remove a tent.
NPR - Prosecutors have decided not to charge any of the protesters who were arrested at the University of California, Davis the day campus police used pepper-spray on a group that had blocked a sidewalk.

Yolo County District Attorney Jeff Reisig said Friday there was insufficient information in police reports of the Nov. 18 protest to warrant charges against eight men and two women who were cited for unlawful assembly, failure to disperse or illegal camping during a campus version of the Occupy Wall Street demonstrations.

The arrests happened before and after two officers doused a line of protesters seated on a sidewalk with pepper spray, an action that was caught on video and led to widespread criticism of UC Davis' chancellor and police chief.

The district attorney's office has been investigating the spraying at the chancellor's request.
I don't know what anyone was arrested for, I was posting the news, or paraphrasing the news. I know the news is wrong many times.

Charges all dropped. The university apologized for being wrong in pepper spraying kids who you can step over to pepper spray. The big wall of people, two feet tall, with gaps, ... a barrier for cops, the very low hurdles for me. I could carry a person over them. The sidewalk is not needed to exit the quad. The police moved the arrested off by way of the grass.

How did that police person get over the barrier to spray the kids in the face? I thought the students were blocking the way. lol

Are you saying no kids who refused to remove their tents were arrested? or what?
 
Last edited:
RandFan, I'm not trying to be difficult.
See, here is the problem. I posted an article by Julie Hilden. You didn't even respond to it. You were dismissive and demonstrated an unwillingness to even consider points counter to your own. It's hard for me to imagine how you could be any more difficult. Why wouldn't you consider the argument made by Julie? Instead of responding in a substantive fashion you started accusing me of fallacy. Look, just because Julie is a gradute of Yale Law school and just because she is a writer for FindLaw doesn't mean she is right but isn't acting in bad faith to ignore her argument?

Julie Hilden said:
Julie was an associate at the law firm of Williams & Connolly in Washington, D.C., where she worked on First Amendment, criminal defense, appellate, and other issues. Her legal commentary on First Amendment and other issues may be found collected on her webpage at FindLaw.com
You don't have to agree with her. Her authority isn't proof of anything. But could you acknowledge that someone who has a degree and has worked in First Amendment issues has an opinion?

So what was unreasonable about the zones?
Let me try again.

Julie Hilden; CNN said:
The constitutionality of police-imposed 'free-speech zones'

The protesters did not have a right to a captive audience, or a right to protest anywhere they wanted to. But they did have the right to speak and protest. And that implies that they had the right to at least have a good chance to be heard by their desired audience -- the conventioneers. Yet they argued that this chance was denied them: They said that, given the combination of the penning and the placement of the protest pens, they could not easily be seen protesting by delegates and others on their way to the Convention.

If that is true, it raises a serious First Amendment problem. Certainly, if the DNC protesters had only been able to speak their piece in a submarine on the bottom of the ocean, their rights would have been violated. And the protestors have said that their Convention placement had more or less the same effect.
 
Last edited:
Could you give me some case law on free speech zones or relevant case law that would tell me what the reasonable distance would be or under what circumstances?
Why should I do your homework for you? You claim it's unconstitutional, you provide evidence for your claims.

A speech zone that has the same effect of prohibiting speech is unconstitutional.
You stopped writing before you showed how the free speech zones were unconstitutional. Will you be doing so?
 
Could you give me some case law on free speech zones or relevant case law that would tell me what the reasonable distance would be or under what circumstances?

A speech zone that has the same effect of prohibiting speech is unconstitutional.
ACORN v Secret Service. Dismissed when the government agreed that line of sight and earshot be maintained for the zones.
 
Dude, the point is... most who choose a career in law enforcement do so because they feel a badge and a gun gives them a license to be thugs! I have said this many times before, but you guys just keep laughing and having your little fraternity "hoo-ras" dismissing this **** like it's no big deal! It is a big deal!

I don't believe that for a second. Clearly you've been wronged in your mind by chops, but they're hardly thugs.
 
Maybe you should post one of those sources, and quote it? Because none of the sources you cited so far say anyone was arrested for refusing to remove a tent.

WildCat


You keep asking for sources, you keep pleading for some sort of reference. However, you don't back up your claims as to why the students were arrested... The question again -- WHY. WERE. THEY. ARRESTED?????
 
So I should watch YouTube videos but then again I should not watch YouTube videos... it all depends on what WildCat agrees with and not anyone else, eh??
It's video of the actual incident in question, not some talking head giving his opinion.

You really don't understand the difference?
 
It's video of the actual incident in question, not some talking head giving his opinion.

You really don't understand the difference?

I understand completely! I understand that you and some others here (on JREF) take this notion that you should not rely on YouTube videos unless it conveniences you!
 
I don't know what anyone was arrested for, I was posting the news, or paraphrasing the news. I know the news is wrong many times.

Charges all dropped. The university apologized for being wrong in pepper spraying kids who you can step over to pepper spray. The big wall of people, two feet tall, with gaps, ... a barrier for cops, the low hurtles for me.
Can you take a screen shot of one of the videos and circle these gaps you claim the officers could have strolled through with prisoners in tow?

How did that police person get over the barrier to spray the kids in the face? I thought the students were blocking the way. lol
What video were you watching? What time in the video does this happen? Because I saw no such thing.

Are you saying no kids who refused to remove their tents were arrested? or what?
No, I'm saying they weren't arrested for refusing to remove their tents. And in that very post you quoted the reasons for arrest, none of which were for refusing to remove a tent!
 
ACORN v Secret Service. Dismissed when the government agreed that line of sight and earshot be maintained for the zones.
Thank you. :) I don't get it, the Secret Service admits something in favor of plaintiffs and the case is dismissed? Was it dismissed because the Secret Service did something wrong and agreed not to do it anymore?
 
Last edited:
See, here is the problem. I posted an article by Julie Hilden. You didn't even respond to it. You were dismissive and demonstrated an unwillingness to even consider points counter to your own. It's hard for me to imagine how you could be any more difficult. Why wouldn't you consider the argument made by Julie? Instead of responding in a substantive fashion you started accusing me of fallacy. Look, just because Julie is a gradute of Yale Law school and just because she is a writer for FindLaw doesn't mean she is right but isn't acting in bad faith to ignore her argument?

You don't have to agree with her. Her authority isn't proof of anything. But could you acknowledge that someone who has a degree and has worked in First Amendment issues has an opinion?

Let me try again.
Feel free to show case law showing that such an argument has ever been upheld by any US court.

Your claim, you provide the evidence.

Hint: in every court case ever argued, at least one attorney makes a legal argument that doesn't hold up.
 
I understand completely! I understand that you and some others here (on JREF) take this notion that you should not rely on YouTube videos unless it conveniences you!

LOL. Do you seriously believe that all online videos are of equal validity and relevancy to all topics?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom