Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Hang on. Are you saying that not even the accounts of the students are good enough for you?????
  • JQ presents Brown's alleged account.
  • BNRT says he doesn't know whether the events happened or not.
  • I say I do, and the events, according to the video, could not have happened even remotely close to the order Brown described, he never says he personally witnessed these events, and eyewitness testimony is often unreliable.
  • JQ hedges about how Brown "may" be wrong, and says it's irrelevant since BNRT doesn't know whether it's true or not.
  • Several pages later, an account is presented from one of the "peaceful protestors" themselves saying they blocked the police.
  • JQ declares it unreliable, like all eyewitnesses, and reiterates the claim that the video does not show the cops "encircled". S/He does not directly claim the protestors are wrong in their claims, or that the cops were not blocked.

I'm betting if we followed this road, we'd end up arguing on the head of a pin about the precise definition of "encircled", ignoring the sense it was actually used. Anything to prolong the debate and get it further away from the pertinent facts.


A lie. Here is a kid leaving the field under arrest before the pepper spray. http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg

The kid with the policeman on the left is being taken away from the kids who "surrounded" the police. Arrested kids were taken away from the quad, the police were not blocked. Kids saying they were trying to block the police from removing the kids arrested, failed to block anything.
So because the kids let some of the cops and some of the prisoners through, that means they did not block them at any time? I mention this to you before, and you refused to respond to it.

By sitting? I believe the student believes they encircled the police, but it served as a symbolic obstruction backed with words; as effective an obstruction as Les Nessman's masking tape walls. Failed to stop the police.
Yet the police only left with one or two prisoners. If the obstruction was symbolic, why did they not just leave? Did they wake up in the morning and go "Oh boy, I hope I get to pepper spray innocent students on false pretenses while in front of a half-dozen cameras! It's the perfect crime!"?

What is the point?
The only people who would be obstructed by sitting students; those who can't walk, those with short legs, or those who can't think for themselves.
Or those with hands tied behind their backs and a cop's hand(s) on their shoulder(s).

Sitting kids armed with words. Better pepper spray them in the face.
Non-compliant obstructors refusing to disengage on their own, who had standard police compliance measures used on them and suffered no lasting harm. and if you bring up Nathan Brown, I debunked that a few pages ago.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/...manstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
(lol, there is a guy with a camera inside the sitting kids, how did he get "surrounded" since the students were "blocking"..., this is hilarious)
They were blocking the police's transport of prisoners. How did you straw man what was already a straw man?

The sitting students failed to obstruct the police removing arrested kids before the pepper spray punishment was dished out.
Which means the same as letting all of the police go, despite their stated and admitted intent to not do that and actions corresponding to same, right? A crowd threatening to use force is a riot by Cali law. "Obstructors" is being nice.

Surrounded? They were on both sides of the kids, surrounded? There is a clear path off the quad in the "still".
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
Maybe the video in motion is hard to see things, which debunk surrounded.
One frame, over 6 police not surrounded, and more in the video.
Given that you're very carefully not providing time stamps, I'm pretty sure that was after the car with backup arrived and made a hole in the outer ring. In fact, if that's Pike stepping over just before using pepper spray, I'm sure of it.

And, oh look, the students in the inner ring have by this point formed a solid, unbroken line it would be difficult to walk a prisoner over safely. If you think it would be so easy, try it. Find three friends, make sure you're the prisoner (with hands cuffed), and tell the "protestors" they can reach up and grab the "cop" at any time if they feel like it, giving the prisoner a chance to escape.

The students said? Let me look.
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
Nope, the students were wrong. I see >6 police not surrounded, and one walking over the kids, so the police could surround the kids and pepper them in the face, and from behind. Surrounded students, claim they surrounded the police who shot them with pepper from both sides.
Who is making this claim? Source, please.

Oh, yes, I was fooled, I guess a frame showing police not surrounded is; fake? A visual illusion? The truth? Right.
So because the police were not surrounded for the fractions of a second you took these screenshots, the students did not surround or obstruct them at any time during the 13+ minutes in the video?

You are still strawmanning. It would be nigh-impossible to reliably get the prisoners over the line safely, and the police are under no obligation to. Just trying to obstruct, resist, or delay the cops makes the students subject to arrest.

http://dmv.ca.gov/pubs/vctop/appndxa/penalco/penco148.htm

Irony, two frames debunk the surrounded lie, and no arrested students could be taken away.

In the "still", proof a rational policeman could take one student at time, arrest them, and easily move them off the quad. Is it easier to pepper spray kids, let the fire department fix them up or send them to the hospital, than arresting them?
How? How, pray tell, would an officer remove them from the line? What feasible alternatives to pepper spray were there available to the officers? Describe them for the class.
I have directly asked you this in the past, and you avoided answering. What you've got is "appeal to magic", like a Truther. Why do you spread lies?

On a personal note, yes I am, Suitable for Framing, Three Dog Night, side one, track one. Thank you very much.

Arrested students, charges dropped.
So if charges are dropped, that means no crime was committed? What if the charges are filed again, and the students are convicted? The school can file and drop as many times as they like as long as the statute isn't out, and Katehi only dropped them because of the political consequences.
 
Last edited:
It is kind of sad that the most fervent defenders of the students have now been reduced to denying accounts from the students themselves, even when they are contradictory to their earlier claims. To wit;

...The protest took the form of peacefully obstructing the police....
Interesting use of the passive voice. Amazing how the "protest" has the agency here, and the the students themselves are not mentioned. Almost as if the person making the statement is unable to acknowledge any agency or choice on the part of the students in "peacefully obstructing the police", and that they might therefore be responsible in the slightest for the ensuing events. As if the obstruction was something that just happened, like the winds and the tides and the sun's rise and set. A force of nature, an act of God.

Of course, that is ridiculous. The students went there to obstruct the po-po, by their own claims. JQ even says their "peaceful protest" was obstructing. By Cali law, that's obstruction, no matter how fast one tries to backpedal or rationalize it away.

Funny thing; JQ said the students were obstructing, and Beachnut, somewhere in his babbling brook of words, says they weren't. I predict that Beachnut will ignore the contradiction, and JQ will either backpedal while not admitting they were wrong, or ignore it and not respond to any post where it's mentioned, like with post 217.
 
Last edited:
Of course, even if one were...intellectually flexible enough to claim that the students were somehow accidentally obstructing police, and were thus not breaking the law, this runs counter to their claims and video evidence of specifically stating they were going to obstruct the police, which would give the police probably cause for an arrest if the students were doing it accidentally, even in some kind of parallel universe where the cops did not explicitly ask the students to move and they flat out refused.
 
Last edited:
If you believe that's been established, have fun with that. However, you don't have to rely on reports of what she said here, you can listen to her say it herself if you follow the link to the clip from Democracy Now!

That they were encircled is supported by the account of this woman who got pepper sprayed, the account of the police at the scene and by the implications of the protestors in the video telling the cops that they will only allow them to leave if they release their friends from arrest. Not sure why you think this woman would lie to make herself look bad.

BTW, what claim is it you think I've dismissed..?

Oh dear. I forgot to include a :cool: or somesuch and you took it all seriously. You took that first paragraph seriously? Seriously?? I concede it has not been 'established' (that was comedy) but it has been demonstrated on several occasions.

You took the second paragraph so seriously you continued to miss the point: I don't care whether they were encircled or not. I said so, right there, yet you're still trying to prove it. I only disputed the claim that the video shows them encircled, and it doesn't. That is not a claim that they weren't encircled because, you guessed it, I don't care either way.

By the by, you refer to the 'implication' of the students words and actions. Your interpretation of the 'implications' of what they said and did is of very little interest. At what point (or collected points, if it helps) do the students say that the police will not be permitted to leave unless the release those arrested? Is that the 'threat' that some people perceive? "We will block your exit"? Scary stuff. The answer to that is words, communication, probably also patience. It's not the brutal pepper spraying of seated unarmed students.

As for why people might lie in order to look 'bad', firstly, to try to hold in your mind that I'm not calling her a liar - I am uninterested in the veracity of her claim. You may recall that from earlier posts (and earlier in this post...) But what looks 'bad' to you looks 'good' to others. They are not fixed values. For that matter, people are complicated - she might easily lie to look 'bad'. Just because you wouldn't do something doesn't mean other people won't or shouldn't. Even if you're carrying pepper spray at the time.
 
You took the second paragraph so seriously you continued to miss the point: I don't care whether they were encircled or not. I said so, right there, yet you're still trying to prove it. I only disputed the claim that the video shows them encircled, and it doesn't. That is not a claim that they weren't encircled because, you guessed it, I don't care either way.

By the by, you refer to the 'implication' of the students words and actions. Your interpretation of the 'implications' of what they said and did is of very little interest. At what point (or collected points, if it helps) do the students say that the police will not be permitted to leave unless the release those arrested? Is that the 'threat' that some people perceive? "We will block your exit"? Scary stuff. The answer to that is words, communication, probably also patience. It's not the brutal pepper spraying of seated unarmed students.

As for why people might lie in order to look 'bad', firstly, to try to hold in your mind that I'm not calling her a liar - I am uninterested in the veracity of her claim. You may recall that from earlier posts (and earlier in this post...) But what looks 'bad' to you looks 'good' to others. They are not fixed values. For that matter, people are complicated - she might easily lie to look 'bad'. Just because you wouldn't do something doesn't mean other people won't or shouldn't. Even if you're carrying pepper spray at the time.
Wow, that's some world-class rationalization and backpedaling! Too bad it's not an Olympic sport.
 
Wow, that's some world-class rationalization and backpedaling! Too bad it's not an Olympic sport.

Are you even reading? Either I made an utterly fatuous claim that we'd 'established' any testimony at all could dismissed, or I was wryly commenting on the very several examples of that happening (depending on the position expressed and the position of the dismisser, as you might imagine). You can call it 'back-pedaling' if you have to have the joke explained to you, I guess.

What am I 'back-pedaling' from? I have always and often said I don't care whether the cops were encircled or not. That so many people are so rabid to present that encirclement as a threat deserving pepper spray doesn't change my position, although it does seem to blind them to it.

So, in case anyone's tempted to dismiss your testimony as untruthful and inaccurate, can you document any 'back-pedaling' or 'world-class rationalisation', other than your absence of a sense of humour?
 
There was debate earlier on whether the students acted "belligerently".
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/belligerent
1.
warlike; given to waging war.
2.
of warlike character; aggressively hostile; bellicose: a belligerent tone.
3.
waging war; engaged in war: a peace treaty between belligerent powers.
4.
pertaining to war or to those engaged in war: belligerent rights.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/belligerent
: waging war; specifically : belonging to or recognized as a state at war and protected by and subject to the laws of war
2
: inclined to or exhibiting assertiveness, hostility, or combativeness

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/belligerent
1. Inclined or eager to fight; hostile or aggressive.
2. Of, pertaining to, or engaged in warfare.

The students pursued the police who were willing to let them continue to protest, surrounded them, declared their intent to obstruct them unless their demands were met, and threatened to stop "protesting peacefully" in response to same. Later on, one of the seated students responded to Pike's attempts to peacefully talk to them by yelling "F* THE POLICE!"

They were certainly hostile to the police, and certainly aggressive in their actions. They were, in fact, belligerent by three separate definitions of the word, ones consistent with its standard use.
 
Wow, that's some world-class rationalization and backpedaling! Too bad it's not an Olympic sport.
Let's go to the commentary.

jiggeryqua said:
You took the second paragraph so seriously you continued to miss the point: I don't care whether they were encircled or not. I said so, right there, yet you're still trying to prove it. I only disputed the claim that the video shows them encircled, and it doesn't. That is not a claim that they weren't encircled because, you guessed it, I don't care either way.
So you vigorously contested an assertion you do not actually disagree with and do not care about.

You have done this throughout the discussion. Question your opponents' points, carefully avoid making assertions, and generally shucking and/or jiving. It is odd that you do not ask Beachnut when his two screenshots were taken. In fact, as someone who takes Youtube screenshots on a regular basis, he would've had to go out of his way to avoid getting the scrubber in the shot.

The police did attempt to communicate peacefully with the students, and waited defensively for backup. They tried the very things you recommend, and they didn't work. I'm not sure how much "patience" you expected them to reasonably exhibit.

By the by, you refer to the 'implication' of the students words and actions. Your interpretation of the 'implications' of what they said and did is of very little interest. At what point (or collected points, if it helps) do the students say that the police will not be permitted to leave unless the release those arrested? Is that the 'threat' that some people perceive? "We will block your exit"? Scary stuff. The answer to that is words, communication, probably also patience. It's not the brutal pepper spraying of seated unarmed students.
Straw man, but interesting weasel wording. The threat would be the part seconds later where they say if the prisoners are released, they will "continue to protest peacefully". Which carries the clear implication that if the students are not released, they will not "continue to protest peacefully", and will become violent. This is the part where you argue about all the possible meanings of the statement in order to introduce the possibility (however remote) that they totes weren't threatening to riot, while ignoring the prima facie interpretation, the one which the police, in the interests of prudence, would be working under. Much like you keep ignoring the fact that the police do not have to be under active threat to use pepper spray, or even passive threat. All they really need is for lesser options to be unfeasible. And they were; the cops tried.

Unless someone started attempting to use deadly force on the cops, they would not have used deadly force in response, so please don't introduce that straw man. I am tired of people pretending or honestly believing the only options the police had available were Do Nothing, Pepper Spray, and Hail of Bullets.

As for why people might lie in order to look 'bad', firstly, to try to hold in your mind that I'm not calling her a liar - I am uninterested in the veracity of her claim. You may recall that from earlier posts (and earlier in this post...) But what looks 'bad' to you looks 'good' to others. They are not fixed values.
That's nice. The veracity of her claims is relevant, as it directly concerns the allegations my side have been making; that the students directly acted to obstruct the duties of the police officers. The cops said it, the cameras show it, even the people in question admit it. The only people who claim that they weren't obstructing is you and the other defenders, and you do so in the face of the preponderance of evidence. When you have to effectively claim even the people you are defending do know what they are talking about, it's time to throw in the towel.

For that matter, people are complicated - she might easily lie to look 'bad'. Just because you wouldn't do something doesn't mean other people won't or shouldn't. Even if you're carrying pepper spray at the time.
Which is a bunch of mealy mouthed, obfuscating tripe intended to draw the debate farther and farther away from the objective questions, such as "did the police have reasonable cause to use pepper spray?" (Yes.) "Are protesters granted exemptions to standard and legal uses of force when they commit actions which would warrant said force, solely because they're protestors?" (No. "All equal before the law.") "Does the charges being dropped indicate their innocence, in practical terms, of the crimes they were charged with?" (No.) "What were the lesser alternatives to use of pepper spray?" (There were no lesser uses of force that were feasible, regardless of Beachnut's rather amusing suggestions.) "Were the protestors who say that they were obstructing the police lying or mistaken?" (They, the police, and the person who made the title card for the most popular version of video seem to think not. One would have to ignore the claims of three separate groups on opposing sides of the issue, which you seem eager to do.) And so on.
 
Last edited:
I'm unsure of the relevant standards of civility round here, when it comes to explaining to someone that you have them on ignore, which is why you said you were putting them on ignore and then repeating clearly that it would be futile to address you. It seems churlish (and uncivil) not to mention it again when they seem to have forgotten, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were considered uncivil (and off topic) to remind them.

Maybe it's deliberate? Some people are orating rather than debating, and the words I won't read perhaps have some influence on some putative 'audience'. Maybe those words will chime with them. A fool can always find company...

But let's cut through any...let's call it mealy mouthed obfuscating tripe, to coin a phrase, and see if we can get an answer from the pro-brutality 'side' to one simple objective question: is it acceptable to pepper spray seated unarmed protestors?

Unsurprisingly, some say yes, some say no, and ne'er the twain shall meet.

Next question: is it acceptable to pepper spray posters protesting the use of pepper spray on seated unarmed protestors?
 
In the 9/11 Conspiracies forum, 9/11 Truthers frequently claim that WTC 7 fell at freefall speed, according to a report on it's collapse by NIST, therefore it was bought down by controlled demolition. There are several different reasons this is incorrect, the most prominent being that NIST does not make such a claim. They claim that part of the building was observed descending at free-fall speed during part of its descent, in the second of two periods where it was moving at slower than freefall. The truther's version is something similar.

Both beachnut and I are regulars on that forum, yet he seems to have done something similar. He has taken two screenshots from edited videos and openly claimed that they were representative, that they "prove" police were not obstructed.

Why did he not provide links to the source videos for these screenshots? I dunno. It's not like he's been even vaguely reliable for sourcing during this debate, despite repeated entreaties to do so.

Let's start with the first shot.

111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg


Beachnut claims this shows the police freely leaving the barrier of students, and thus they were free to go, regardless of the crowd of dozens declaring that they weren't. However, this is not shown in the screenshot. What is shown, however, is a prisoner being moved by a police officer.

The funny thing is that no one disputes the police were able to move some prisoners, individually, out of the crowd. What is being disputed is the idea that all of the officers were free to leave. In fact, based on the angle and proximity of the screenshot, it was taken from near the center of the confrontation, where the police formed a defensive position around their prisoners. Dozens of students are clearly visible in the background. What is not visible is, of course, the interior line of students blocking the prisoners. So any claims regarding the seated students' inability to block police are unsupported if they are not there.

Of course, this could easily be cleared up by providing a source for the video, along with an appropriate timestamp in order to view its context. At your pleasure, Beachnut.

111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg


This video I was able to find a source for. It is the most popular version of the video, the shortest, the most heavily edited, and thus the most favorable to the protests because it omits the most information.

Just to get it out of the way, there is a cameraman visible. Beachnut alleges that his presence shows the protestors were not "blocking". Blocking what, he does not say. However, this is a straw man. The claim of my side is that the protestors were blocking the police in the execution of their duties; the transport of their prisoners. They seemed to have very little problem with anyone else.

Here's that video.



During the video, you can clearly see the squad car, as well as several officers holding the outer crowd back. This would be the officers' backup. My side has alleged that the officers were unable to safely transport all of their prisoners. When backup arrived, they made a hole in the outer crowd, which still left the inner, seated protestors.

I've asked several of you to try and simulate the situation. To take three friends, have two form a line, seated, with linked arms. Tie your arms behind your back, and have your third act as the cop attempting to guide you over the line. And tell the protestors they can randomly reach up and more actively hinder the cop at any time. Perform this a dozen times. See how easy it is to safely get prisoners across it. None of you has performed it, or at least performed it and responded. What it may be possible for one person to do becomes much harder with a mobility restricted prisoner. Remember, the students wanted the cops to leave, just not with their prisoners. They literally said as much.

It is remarkable that Beachnut presents, as evidence the cops and their prisoners were able to leave without help, a screenshot from a point when the cops had help to leave, and presumably sees no contradiction. Unreal.

Bottom line, Beachnut has failed, utterly, to show that the police officers were able to or did carry prisoners over the inner line of seated students.
 
I'm unsure of the relevant standards of civility round here, when it comes to explaining to someone that you have them on ignore, which is why you said you were putting them on ignore and then repeating clearly that it would be futile to address you.
Yet here you are, responding. I'm not responding for your benefit. I'm just showing everyone else how wrong you are. Feel free to keep ignoring me; I'm not expecting any sort of intellectually honest response anyway.

It seems churlish (and uncivil) not to mention it again when they seem to have forgotten, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were considered uncivil (and off topic) to remind them.

Maybe it's deliberate? Some people are orating rather than debating, and the words I won't read perhaps have some influence on some putative 'audience'. Maybe those words will chime with them. A fool can always find company...
The funny thing is that you think it's not obvious you're addressing me by referring to "some people", yet you accuse me of "orating".

But let's cut through any...let's call it mealy mouthed obfuscating tripe, to coin a phrase,
You mean you're dismissing every point your opponent made out of hand using vague, generalized terms that don't actually address anything? Again?

and see if we can get an answer from the pro-brutality 'side'
And now you're poisoning the well.

to one simple objective question: is it acceptable to pepper spray seated unarmed protestors?

Unsurprisingly, some say yes, some say no, and ne'er the twain shall meet.
Well, yes, because one side acknowledges that the students have some sort of responsibility, that they created the incident when police were trying to leave them alone, that they were belligerent and hostile, and other relevant facts, as opposed to the other side's abandoning even one's own evidence when it is proved wrong, gainsaying the testimony of the protestors themselves when it directly contradicts their claims, dodging questions about what the cops should've done, vigorously questioning claims one later says one does not even care about the answer to, and making claims that are inconsistent with each other, all of which you have personally done over the course of this argument. I can provide links.

We are allowed to address the alleged logical inconsistencies of people in the discussion, by the way, as long as it does not devolve into merely personal attacks.

Next question: is it acceptable to pepper spray posters protesting the use of pepper spray on seated unarmed protestors?
Is it always okay? No. Is it sometimes or ever okay? Yes, under certain circumstances. Such as when those protestors are also resisting arrest, or obstructing police, or have issued active threats to police which they outnumber by the dozens, all of which have been conveniently edited out of the videos which most people first based their opinions on. Like most folks, they will defend these inaccurate conclusions no matter how illogical it is, even when the premises on which they are based are objectively shown to be false. (c.f. "confirmation bias") A skeptic, however, looks at all the relevant evidence, as opposed to being willing to declare their own evidence irrelevant in lieu of admitting it's wrong, and questioning claims they say they do not think are relevant anyway.

Of course, these students in question were not, at the time, protesting the use of pepper spray or use of force at UC Berkley. They were actively hindering the transport of the people who had been arrested for interfering with the tent removal. You have to literally deny all the evidence to believe they were not obstructing, even from the protestors themselves. I have already pointed out the police had no problem leaving the students who did not actively obstruct them alone, and the students deliberately went out of their way to obstruct police.

So the police initially had no problem leaving the protestors alone, except for the ones that interfered with tent removal, who were arrested. Therefore, the protestors who were arrested were not peaceful, and the ones who were left alone were.

Then the students decide to obstruct the police.

The police response to them changes.

Therefore, once the students decided to obstruct the police, they were no longer merely "peaceful protestors". Either they became something in addition to that, or they became something instead of that, both of which the police felt warranted a different response than they had used minutes earlier.

Therefore, insisting that the students were still "peaceful protestors" and nothing else is incorrect. Even more so if one admits they were doing more than "peacefully protesting", but still refer to them exclusively as "peaceful protestors" or paraphrases of such.

Here's a more pertinent question; "acceptable" to who? On what standards are you basing the decision? Because you have already said that you do not think any removal was justified, so framing the question like the pepper spray is the relevant portion is intellectually dishonest.

Here's another: is it ever okay to pepper spray people deliberately obstructing police in the execution of their duties, when all lesser measures have been tried or are unfeasible? Should the police in this situation have just left their prisoners behind?

Here's another: Assuming the protestors had done something to justify attempts to remove them, what would that have been? And what use of force would have been appropriate? I am absolutely certain you will not answer these last two questions, much like you ignored post 217, if you answer any at all. And not just because you have me on ignore.
 
Last edited:
Oh dear. I forgot to include a :cool: or somesuch and you took it all seriously. You took that first paragraph seriously? Seriously?? I concede it has not been 'established' (that was comedy) but it has been demonstrated on several occasions.

I assume it was some kind of shot at an earlier post by someone, but that has nothing to do with me. I'll take it that you accept the truth of her claim that the cops were encircled, since you weren't serious.

You took the second paragraph so seriously you continued to miss the point: I don't care whether they were encircled or not. I said so, right there, yet you're still trying to prove it. I only disputed the claim that the video shows them encircled, and it doesn't. That is not a claim that they weren't encircled because, you guessed it, I don't care either way.

If you don't care then I'm not sure why you responded to my post. Forgive me for thinking you actually had something serious to say.
 
There was debate earlier on whether the students acted "belligerently".
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/belligerent
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/belligerent


http://www.thefreedictionary.com/belligerent


The students pursued the police who were willing to let them continue to protest, surrounded them, declared their intent to obstruct them unless their demands were met, and threatened to stop "protesting peacefully" in response to same. Later on, one of the seated students responded to Pike's attempts to peacefully talk to them by yelling "F* THE POLICE!"

They were certainly hostile to the police, and certainly aggressive in their actions. They were, in fact, belligerent by three separate definitions of the word, ones consistent with its standard use.

Unfortunately, no amount of rationality is going to let it sink in that it was the students who were in the wrong here.

This is backed up by the statments the students themselves have made!!!

I find it terribly dishonest to imply otherwise. They ADMITTED it.
 
I assume it was some kind of shot at an earlier post by someone, but that has nothing to do with me. I'll take it that you accept the truth of her claim that the cops were encircled, since you weren't serious.
What I like about this is that it will take a lot of effort for JQ to contradict you without discussing what their actual claim is. Money on 1. not answering, or 2. just denying that they ever said that or that they care, but not explaining why they asked in the first place. I'm not sure, at this point, even JQ knows, especially since they already asserted that the kids were a)there on purpose, and b) the protest was obstructing the police. It's just tap-dancing now.

If you don't care then I'm not sure why you responded to my post. Forgive me for thinking you actually had something serious to say.
Weird, huh? It's like how they have me on ignore, but keep looking at my posts and responding to the ones addressed to them and then passive-aggressively insinuating I should stop responding to their posts just because they don't want to see mine. At least if I look at the posts of people I have on ignore, I don't pretend it's their fault, whether I told them so or not.

Telling.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, no amount of rationality is going to let it sink in that it was the students who were in the wrong here.

This is backed up by the statments the students themselves have made!!!

I find it terribly dishonest to imply otherwise. They ADMITTED it.
I'd be surprised if they, any of them, even admit the students were the aggressors who actively and intentionally prevented the cops from leaving peacefully.
 
I assume it was some kind of shot at an earlier post by someone, but that has nothing to do with me. I'll take it that you accept the truth of her claim that the cops were encircled, since you weren't serious.

I'll assume your assumption is right, it's certainly not worth checking. But do try to read all the words - you can take it that I don't give a hoot whether they were 'encircled' or not. For the record, I have no opinion about 'beleagured' or 'surrounded' or whatever other emotive terms anyone may use. I have a distinct opinion about 'threatened', at least when applied to armed and armoured cops in the presence of seated unarmed students.

If you don't care then I'm not sure why you responded to my post. Forgive me for thinking you actually had something serious to say.

I responded to you because you addressed me. In my world, that's courteous. Seriously, the cops weren't threatened and the students were brutally pepper sprayed. It may be the only serious thing I have to say, but unless someone comes up with something more compelling than "I hate long-hair pinko subversives, I'd set dogs on them, pepper spray is too good for them", then I'll keep saying it.

The performance of authority has progressed admirably since Kent State but there's still considerable room for improvement.
 
Weird, huh? It's like how they have me on ignore, but keep looking at my posts and responding to the ones addressed to them and then passive-aggressively insinuating I should stop responding to their posts just because they don't want to see mine. At least if I look at the posts of people I have on ignore, I don't pretend it's their fault, whether I told them so or not.

Telling.

You're right, it's silly. I like having to choose to see the posts of people who've demonstrated their irrelevance, but I see the error of my ways now. I was amused by the posts where you kept talking to me after I said I had you on ignore, less so by those where you talk about me (as though this were about arguers rather than arguments...)

Bye bye now.
 
Aaand now quote-mining, and not actually addressing the actual substantive content of posts #421, 422, 423, 427, 428, 430, or 431 (on this page alone) where I present lots and lots of actual facts. And, and you are still avoiding explaining why you asked a question about his claim when you didn't care about the answer.

Obstruction is relevant, whether you care about it or not, as are Penal Codes 148, 404, 404.6, 405a, 406, and 407, and whether you admit when you're wrong. It's clear you don't. I can provide that list from 431 at any time, provided you're willing to address the rest of the post, especially the parts I have accused you of ignoring which you are currently admitting you're ignoring.

Well done! You're fooling no one but people who already agree with you, now.

"I hate long-hair pinko subversives, I'd set dogs on them, pepper spray is too good for them", then I'll keep saying it.
Literally one guy has made anything like that claim (shortly before he gave up on trying to convince you logically), and it was his personal opinion, mentioning nothing about "long-hair pinko subversives". That's your straw man. No, not a satire, a straw man, a personal attack, and it has nothing to do with whether the police were justified using pepper spray.

...And I didn't advocate the use of dogs. That would be excessive, as clearly the use of pepper spray worked.
So you have been actively contradicted, yet keep making the claim.

I do not know why you keep assigning to everyone else on his side (perhaps to avoid getting your knuckles rapped by the mods for a personal attack?), and the fact that you are confused or actively lying about an opinion expressed by one person is rather telling. I think pepper spray was exactly right, in light of lesser options not being feasible. Greater force, such as attempting to disengage the protestors without pepper spray to decrease resistance--it's physiologically impossible for your average person to stay tough with a face full of chile juice--would likely have led to things like dislocated and/or broken and/or injured limbs. I am able to say this because I chose to educate myself about the alternatives, and no, the cops had no other choice unless they actually wanted to hurt the kids more. They did not jump to pepper spray; the need for its use to disengage the kids was demonstrated repeatedly, and they were specifically warned that it would be used in order to arrest them if they did not leave voluntarily.

Oh, and the crowd was acting belligerently. I described the specific incidents. We both know they're in the video. Several videos, actually. If you want to dispute that they happened, feel free, but don't go asking me for evidence for a point you'll say you're not interested in a few posts later.

I find it interesting how you admitted the protests "took the form of peaceful obstruction", yet are unable to admit the protesters were actually obstructing, even when they say so post facto and explicitly said they would at the scene. In fact, when they say so, you claimed that you didn't care about obstruction at all, and have moved on to the "threat", which required asking us what the threat allegedly was, and ignoring when I explicitly described it in post 428, along with the fact that the cops explicitly tried the things you said they "should've tried" and they didn't work. Just like when I proved Brown's account was utter nonsense, and you said it was irrelevant. No, BTMO did not say he didn't know whether anyone got hurt, he said he did not know whether Brown's account, specifically, was accurate.

Again, just ignore me, like you claim you've been doing for a while now, but are clearly not. You are under no obligation to answer my posts, and have seen fit to ignore them in the past, such as, notably, #217, and just about any point I make you don't like.

#000063bookmark
 
Last edited:
Also odd how reluctant the side condemning the police has been to directly address the "continue to protest peacefully" declaration, and to a lesser extent the "we will let you leave" demand. JQ addressed the latter in #424, but only to scoff at the idea that it was a threat, not to actually address what it was. They then asked what remark was threatening, and it was the former, which was literally seconds later in the video. I'm not sure how one can miss two statements less than a minute apart, unless one somehow skipped over precisely that portion, or was being disingenuous, or just plain forgot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom