Hang on. Are you saying that not even the accounts of the students are good enough for you?????
- JQ presents Brown's alleged account.
- BNRT says he doesn't know whether the events happened or not.
- I say I do, and the events, according to the video, could not have happened even remotely close to the order Brown described, he never says he personally witnessed these events, and eyewitness testimony is often unreliable.
- JQ hedges about how Brown "may" be wrong, and says it's irrelevant since BNRT doesn't know whether it's true or not.
- Several pages later, an account is presented from one of the "peaceful protestors" themselves saying they blocked the police.
- JQ declares it unreliable, like all eyewitnesses, and reiterates the claim that the video does not show the cops "encircled". S/He does not directly claim the protestors are wrong in their claims, or that the cops were not blocked.
I'm betting if we followed this road, we'd end up arguing on the head of a pin about the precise definition of "encircled", ignoring the sense it was actually used. Anything to prolong the debate and get it further away from the pertinent facts.
So because the kids let some of the cops and some of the prisoners through, that means they did not block them at any time? I mention this to you before, and you refused to respond to it.A lie. Here is a kid leaving the field under arrest before the pepper spray. http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111studentarrestedtakenoutofthebarrier.jpg
The kid with the policeman on the left is being taken away from the kids who "surrounded" the police. Arrested kids were taken away from the quad, the police were not blocked. Kids saying they were trying to block the police from removing the kids arrested, failed to block anything.
Yet the police only left with one or two prisoners. If the obstruction was symbolic, why did they not just leave? Did they wake up in the morning and go "Oh boy, I hope I get to pepper spray innocent students on false pretenses while in front of a half-dozen cameras! It's the perfect crime!"?By sitting? I believe the student believes they encircled the police, but it served as a symbolic obstruction backed with words; as effective an obstruction as Les Nessman's masking tape walls. Failed to stop the police.
Or those with hands tied behind their backs and a cop's hand(s) on their shoulder(s).What is the point?
The only people who would be obstructed by sitting students; those who can't walk, those with short legs, or those who can't think for themselves.
Non-compliant obstructors refusing to disengage on their own, who had standard police compliance measures used on them and suffered no lasting harm. and if you bring up Nathan Brown, I debunked that a few pages ago.Sitting kids armed with words. Better pepper spray them in the face.
They were blocking the police's transport of prisoners. How did you straw man what was already a straw man?http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/...manstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
(lol, there is a guy with a camera inside the sitting kids, how did he get "surrounded" since the students were "blocking"..., this is hilarious)
Which means the same as letting all of the police go, despite their stated and admitted intent to not do that and actions corresponding to same, right? A crowd threatening to use force is a riot by Cali law. "Obstructors" is being nice.The sitting students failed to obstruct the police removing arrested kids before the pepper spray punishment was dished out.
Given that you're very carefully not providing time stamps, I'm pretty sure that was after the car with backup arrived and made a hole in the outer ring. In fact, if that's Pike stepping over just before using pepper spray, I'm sure of it.Surrounded? They were on both sides of the kids, surrounded? There is a clear path off the quad in the "still".
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
Maybe the video in motion is hard to see things, which debunk surrounded.
One frame, over 6 police not surrounded, and more in the video.
And, oh look, the students in the inner ring have by this point formed a solid, unbroken line it would be difficult to walk a prisoner over safely. If you think it would be so easy, try it. Find three friends, make sure you're the prisoner (with hands cuffed), and tell the "protestors" they can reach up and grab the "cop" at any time if they feel like it, giving the prisoner a chance to escape.
Who is making this claim? Source, please.The students said? Let me look.
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111pepperspraymanstepovergiantwallofsittingstudentsohmy.jpg
Nope, the students were wrong. I see >6 police not surrounded, and one walking over the kids, so the police could surround the kids and pepper them in the face, and from behind. Surrounded students, claim they surrounded the police who shot them with pepper from both sides.
So because the police were not surrounded for the fractions of a second you took these screenshots, the students did not surround or obstruct them at any time during the 13+ minutes in the video?Oh, yes, I was fooled, I guess a frame showing police not surrounded is; fake? A visual illusion? The truth? Right.
You are still strawmanning. It would be nigh-impossible to reliably get the prisoners over the line safely, and the police are under no obligation to. Just trying to obstruct, resist, or delay the cops makes the students subject to arrest.
http://dmv.ca.gov/pubs/vctop/appndxa/penalco/penco148.htm
How? How, pray tell, would an officer remove them from the line? What feasible alternatives to pepper spray were there available to the officers? Describe them for the class.Irony, two frames debunk the surrounded lie, and no arrested students could be taken away.
In the "still", proof a rational policeman could take one student at time, arrest them, and easily move them off the quad. Is it easier to pepper spray kids, let the fire department fix them up or send them to the hospital, than arresting them?
I have directly asked you this in the past, and you avoided answering. What you've got is "appeal to magic", like a Truther. Why do you spread lies?
So if charges are dropped, that means no crime was committed? What if the charges are filed again, and the students are convicted? The school can file and drop as many times as they like as long as the statute isn't out, and Katehi only dropped them because of the political consequences.On a personal note, yes I am, Suitable for Framing, Three Dog Night, side one, track one. Thank you very much.
Arrested students, charges dropped.
Last edited: