Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Does anyone know why students were arrested? I have googled but cannot find the reason. My bet would be failure to comply with police orders.
The ones arrested were interfering with the police taking down the tents.
 
They were not blocked! If they were blocked, they would pepper spray the kids blocking them! They picked to pepper spray the kids sitting, the deadly kids sitting.
The kids were sitting on the walkway in order to block the police from leaving with those they arrested.

Do you know anything at all about what happened? There's been lots of video posted, perhaps you should watch them.
 
So why were not all of the protestors arrested? Why did the police leave while many of the protestors were still there?
Because no one was arrested for protesting. There's nothing illegal about protesting.
 
The kids were sitting on the walkway in order to block the police from leaving with those they arrested.

Do you know anything at all about what happened? There's been lots of video posted, perhaps you should watch them.

Youtube "evidence"? don't have time for that, is there a transcript?
 
I just thought of something. JQ has said they do not believe the students were disobeying a lawful order. However, the definition of obstruction of police is not limited to disobeying lawful orders. Any willing and knowing obstruction of an officer's duties may qualify. And cops do not make arrests based on reasonable doubt, which is the standard for conviction, but probable cause. Given that the crowd had stated their intent to confine the police unless demands were met, and even JQ admits they were actively obstructing the police, they were well beyond probable cause. They were recorded on several different cameras actively obstructing the police, and no matter what anyone says, protesting does not absolve you of consequences if you commit other crimes doing it. Obstructing police in the execution of their duties is a crime, and not lawful.

Therefore, the arrests were just.

There's a reason people who think the cops weren't justified keep focusing on the "threat" part. Because they know, on some level, the crowd was knowingly obstructing the cops, and were breaking the law.
 
Last edited:
Youtube "evidence"? don't have time for that, is there a transcript?
Basically, the cops took down the tents after several days warning, left the protesters alone, tried to leave with only the people who had interfered with the tent takedown under arrest. Somewhere upwards of 100 protesters followed them, surrounded them, and threatened to hold them there and stop "protesting peacefully" unless the prisoners were turned over. (This is obstruction under California law, along with, arguably, a riot.)

Basically, either the police used force, or they just hung around and hoped the crowd didn't riot. They formed a line of several cops around their prisoners, while others walked around. At some point during this period, a cop or two managed to leave with a prisoner or two, after which some of the crowd formed a line sitting on the ground with interlinked arms around the cops, in order to prevent the police removing the prisoners without getting by them first.

Backup arrived, and cleared the outer perimeter with a car and officers, making a hole. The inner students remained seated, including between the police and their exit. After all feasible lesser uses of force were tried, including asking nicely--seriously!--Lt. John Pike pepper sprayed several of the students directly in the police's way, and both he and several other officers disengaged them from each other, which the pepper spray made easier, arrested several students, and carted them off.

Then someone took the video, edited it to just show Pike beginning to spray and nothing else, and posted it on YouTube, in a bit of underhanded editing that would make Fox News proud, to make the protesters seem like innocents and the police like the nasty aggressors needlessly pepper-spraying people who were just sitting in a path minding their own business. Ironically, the opposite was true; the police had been peacefully minding their own business when the protestors started spoiling for a fight and forced the cops into using force.

Oh, and the Chancellor rolled over like a dog with a bone in the face of the backlash, putting the police chief on leave, and swearing up and down the cops weren't acting on her orders when they did their jobs arresting people breaking the law.

Funny thing; people who think the cops were wrong are oddly unable to provide alternatives, and don't seem to ask themselves why, if the cops were wrong in any case, the most common version of the video is so heavily edited.

#000063bookmark
 
Last edited:
...
No, they removed a few kids, then the crowd sealed up and demanded the cops turn over the prisoners or they wouldn't let them go (at least), then backup arrived and made a hole in the outer protestors.

Are you having a concussion?
They removed the people who they arrested, one at a time, clearly seen on video. The students did not block the police from leaving with arrested kids. The police were never blocked, there are infinite routes out of the Quad, they were in the middle of the Quad, there were no fences, no walls, no barriers to stop egress. Did you make up the surrounded claim, or believe someone else? The video shows that claim to be false.

I think pepper spraying kids sitting is wrong, the school agrees. The police failed, there was a disconnect.

those arrested were served with an eviction notice to dismantle the camp by 3 p.m. but refused.

Why was no one arrested the day before? The day after? They arrested those who refused to remove tents.


UC Davis police chief claimed the officers were unable to leave the circle the students had formed sitting and standing. The liar said “There was no way out,”... “They were cutting the officers off from their support. It’s a very volatile situation.” Videos show that the seated students made no effort to impede the officers’ movement. Lt. Pike, who initiated the pepper spraying, was inside the circle moments earlier. To get ready to spray, he stepped over the line. Cover their what? With lies. How did any students get arrested when the police were blocked? 9 students were arrested. How did the police get out with the arrested students? They were blocked by students they stepped over to pepper spray???
Ignore the fact students were arrested and removed before the idiot started pepper spraying the kids sitting. Kids removed before the violence broke out, kids sitting violently ...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjXk9wYWIE8
"turn up your radio... " turn up your video...
you know how many videos there are? Do you remember how big the quad is?

How did they arrest 10, 9 students, and escape with their lives? Oh, yes, they pepper sprayed kids they could step over who were sitting, surrounding them! I see



While apologizing for the pepper-spraying, UC Davis Chancellor Linda Katehi said she expected student demonstrations to escalate in response to continued budget cuts. The hearing came a day after Gov. Jerry Brown announced $100 million in reductions for each of the two university systems — on top of the $650 million hit they both took in the current budget.
"We will not do justice to our university, my campus and to our state if we allow the events of November 18 to mask the reasons our students have been protesting in the first place," she told lawmakers. "While the images of pepper-spraying spark justifiable outrage … we all need to work together to make higher education more affordable and more accessible to our students or there will be continued frustration." LA Times

justifiable outrage - from the person at the top of UC Davis


The kids were sitting on the walkway in order to block the police from leaving with those they arrested.

Do you know anything at all about what happened? There's been lots of video posted, perhaps you should watch them.

The police left with students, one at a time, before the pepper spraying. This is why they had 10 people already out of the area, arrested. Have you failed to watch the many hours of video available which clearly show kids escorted away from the quad.

We can see on video students lead away. Don't be confused, the police arrested students who refused to remove tents, they were evicted and arrested when they refused. They were removed, talk by the students failed to form action to stop the police; as seen on the video.

The police stepped over the kids to pepper spray the same kids, clearly seen on video. Not sure how kids sitting block anything. Explain, how officers who step over kids to pepper spray kids are blocked by said kids. Thank you.

I cheated, I watched all the videos, and not the ones carefully selected to prove a point. If you wish, you can find proof the arrested kids passed through the crowd without incident.


"justifiable outrage" - from the person at the top of UC Davis. She knows they screwed up. She admits the error. Not sure what you are arguing about.
 
Last edited:
Was that the criteris for the zones? Or did you just make it up?
That's a great question. I made it up to make a point. What is there to keep politicians from abusing free speech zones to stop protests?

I am under no obligation to commenbt on your fallacious argument.
Oh come on. That is dishonest.

More straw, eh?
Your chosen dodge. It is dishonest WC.

Would you like to comment on the actual reasons for the zones, that of balancing the right to protest with the right of others to be secure while they conduct their business?
I accept your premise. Would you be willing to comment on the fact that the zones can be abused? Would you be willing comment on the fact that putting protestors where they are not likely to be seen is the same as prohibiting free speech.
 
Stop quote-mining, and start sourcing quotes, beachnut.
They removed the people who they arrested, one at a time, clearly seen on video.
What video? They removed some of the kids, then the crowd sealed.

The students did not block the police from leaving with arrested kids.

The police were never blocked, there are infinite routes out of the Quad, they were in the middle of the Quad, there were no fences, no walls, no barriers to stop egress.
So the crowd of people was not a barrier?

Did you make up the surrounded claim, or believe someone else? The video shows that claim to be false.
They could only leave if the crowd let them leave. The crowd stopped letting them leave, and they didn't want to make the situation worse by forcing their way out.

I think pepper spraying kids sitting is wrong, the school agrees. The police failed, there was a disconnect.
The Chancellor agrees. The school has thousands of students. The police chief disagrees. Is she not part of "the school"?

Why was no one arrested the day before? The day after? They arrested those who refused to remove tents.
No, they dismantled the tents themselves, and arrested those who interfered.

UC Davis police chief claimed the officers were unable to leave the circle the students had formed sitting and standing. The liar said “There was no way out,”... “They were cutting the officers off from their support. It’s a very volatile situation.” Videos show that the seated students made no effort to impede the officers’ movement.
She said the crowd cut them off. The students, by sitting there like that, were preventing the officers from transporting their prisoners, as you have ignored me saying again and again.

Lt. Pike, who initiated the pepper spraying, was inside the circle moments earlier. To get ready to spray, he stepped over the line. Cover their what? With lies. How did any students get arrested when the police were blocked? 9 students were arrested. How did the police get out with the arrested students? They were blocked by students they stepped over to pepper spray???
The students were blocking the transport of the prisoners, who had been arrested in a separate incident.
Ignore the fact students were arrested and removed before the idiot started pepper spraying the kids sitting. Kids removed before the violence broke out, kids sitting violently ...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjXk9wYWIE8
"turn up your radio... " turn up your video...
you know how many videos there are? Do you remember how big the quad is?
Are. You. Drunk.

How did they arrest 10, 9 students, and escape with their lives? Oh, yes, they pepper sprayed kids they could step over who were sitting, surrounding them! I see
Kids they could step over, but not safely carry prisoners over, especially since said kids might easily resort to more active obstruction.

justifiable outrage - from the person at the top of UC Davis
What if she disagreed with you? Would you still be taking her word as holy writ? Why do you ignore most of my posts? Why have you not explained why the cops were wrong to arrest the sitting students against the Chancellor's orders, yet you think they should've arrested the entire crowd and marched them into the Chancellor's office? Why do you spread lies?

And most importantly; are you drunk?
 
Last edited:
This is all established law RandFan, please cite the court case which leads you to conclude that moving protestors to Mexico is reasonable.
Moving protestors to Mexico is unreasonable. I'm trying to establish what is reasonable. You concede that there is a line that can be crossed. You are conceding my point. If Mexico is too far then how far can the protests can be moved.

BTW: If it is established law then why be so difficult? Why not just answer my questions? I don't know everything. If the courts have determined what is reasonable then just give me a source and we can move on. Why the chip on your shoulder and the refusal to follow the philosophical principle of charity? Or as Phil Plat says "don't be a dick".
 
Why were they arrested?
Those who refused to remove tents after they were evicted. http://www.news10.net/news/article/163658/2/Campus-police-move-to-break-up-Occupy-UC-Davis-camp?odyssey=tab%7Ctopnews%7Cbc%7Clarge

The police feared for their lives... stepped over the super impenetrable wall of sitting students to pepper spray the impossible to get by blockade of sitting students, which the police stepped over to spray.

There are so many sources, this is common knowledge and summarized by the president of UC Davis. She said it was a mistake to pepper spray the kids. Is she a liar? She is an expert; the buck stops with her. (no I am not drunk, I am watching lotsssssssssssss of B-ball)
 
Last edited:
irrelevant, and answered already .... ON THIS PAGE.
Excuse me for missing the post. Jesus Christ chill out. I explained why it might not be irrelevant but you missed that post. Look, you have criticized me for putting people on ignore. It is that kind of rude and obnoxious behavior that will cause me to put someone on ignore. I don't treat people that way. If you can't act with a modicum of decency I will put you on ignore also.
 
The kids were sitting on the walkway in order to block the police from leaving with those they arrested.

Do you know anything at all about what happened? There's been lots of video posted, perhaps you should watch them.

Are you talking about YouTube? Hmmm? Why is it that we need YouTube as a narrative for the Occupy Movement? Could it be because WildCat demands us to watch YouTube in order to verify such trivial information that only pertains to what HE WANTS IT TO pertain to?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom