Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

On November 21, Katehi attended a large student protest attended by an estimated 5,000 people.[47] After listening to their statements, Katehi said she was there to apologize.[48] On the following day, she stated that the police had gone against her specific orders to act peacefully when removing tents or equipment, and not to proceed if there were too many students, and she had not approved the police use of riot gear.[48][49] At a town hall meeting, she told around 1,000 students, "I want to unequivocally apologize to the entire community for the appalling use of pepper spray. I will do everything in my power to make sure nothing like that ever happens again." She said, "My instructions were for no arrests and no police force. I explicitly directed the chief of police that violence should be avoided at all costs."[50]

No arrests! oops, it was a big mistake. Has anyone been to the Quad? You could walk around the kids sitting with 200 to 300 feet buffer and go anywhere on campus.

I suggest if you are dispersing anything, to include Bucks in your back yard; if you have a weapon like a few large rocks, and you throw one at the BIG Buck, and he advances, you should retreat using the remaining rocks to cover your retreat... Why would you pepper spray the sitting kids when you claim the kids surrounded you? ???

Looks like people who like to pepper spray kids sitting peacefully, there are openings at UC Davis for a few good goons who can't think for themselves, or remember the directions they were given.

No arrests, means pepper spray the kids who are not a threat.
 
The straw man ones and the ones unsupported by any evidence.

So what free speech zone confined protestors to Mexico?

It's a straw man because that circumstance bears no resemblance to the subject at hand, you just made it up in order to burn it down.

It does bear resemblance. There is no difference between "you cannot speak" and "you can only speak where you are likely not to be heard".

Please to explain the difference between the following.

  • You cannot speak.
  • You can only speak where you are likely not to be heard.
Can you answer the question? What is the difference?

People had the opportunity to hear/see the protests. They also have the right to ignore them if they wish.
So a law that says I can only speak in my front yard is constitutional because people would have the opportunity to hear and see me? Really?
 
The straw man ones...
BTW: This is particularly dishonest. The point of the Mexico example is to demonstrate by extreme that there is a limit that any reasonable person would agree to.

  • A free speech zone in Mexico would be beyond the pale, right?
  • So, what is the limit?
  • How far away can officials move protestors from their intended audience?
 
Without looking back, I don't know whether you mentioned belligerence. I do know, without looking back, that I was responding to someone who had mentioned belligerence. OK?

Actually, no, it's not OK. People can make mistakes about what other people said, it happened to me too. The decent thing to do is to apologize. It isn't somehow magically OK.

The protest took the form of peacefully obstructing the police. You can't talk about this protest and claim you're not talking about protest. If you're not talking about this protest, you're off topic.

[...]

Yes it is. Now you say 'No it isn't' and we can pretend we're having a debate.

We're talking about the the students being pepper sprayed. Nobody here is saying that the students didn't have a right to protest. People are saying that the students didn't have a right to prevent the police from leaving with the people they arrested. I can have a peaceful lawful protest without not listening to the police and not complying with their orders. Moreover, I think a peaceful, lawful protest basically is exactly the same as listening to the police, as they are better qualified and authorized to determine what is safe.

It wasn't necessary to describe the protestors as 'whiny brats', either.

Yet apparently, it is perfectly acceptable to describe your opponents as "supporters of police brutality":

Tiresome. Over and over, supporters of police brutality claim that there are occasions when force is warranted and necessary. We've done that, you have no argument there. We agree.

The pepper-spraying of peaceful seated unarmed student protestors was not warranted nor was it necessary.

It wasn't necessary to describe the protestors as 'whiny brats', either. That the supporters of police brutality can't express their support without making their biases and deficiencies clear is informative.

That looks a little hypocritical to me.
 
We're talking about the the students being pepper sprayed. Nobody here is saying that the students didn't have a right to protest. People are saying that the students didn't have a right to prevent the police from leaving with the people they arrested. I can have a peaceful lawful protest without not listening to the police and not complying with their orders.
I think this a very appropriate place to point out the history of civil disobedience in America. There are times that civil disobedience might be an appropriate response. However, those who break the law must accept the consequences of their actions so long as police act lawfully.

Kayla Starr said:
The Role of Civil Disobedience in Democracy

[FONT=verdana,helvetica,arial]Civil Disobedience is the act of disobeying a law on grounds of moral or political principle. It is an attempt to influence society to accept a dissenting point of view. Although it usually uses tactics of nonviolence, it is more than mere passive resistance since it often takes active forms such as illegal street demonstrations or peaceful occupations of premises. The classic treatise on this topic is Henry David Thoreau's "On the Duty of Civil Disobedience," which states that when a person's conscience and the laws clash, that person must follow his or her conscience. The stress on personal conscience and on the need to act now rather than to wait for legal change are recurring elements in civil disobedience movements. The U.S. Bill of Rights asserts that the authority of a government is derived from the consent of the governed, and whenever any form of government becomes destructive, it is the right and duty of the people to alter or abolish it. [/FONT]
 
I think this a very appropriate place to point out the history of civil disobedience in America. There are times that civil disobedience might be an appropriate response. However, those who break the law must accept the consequences of their actions so long as police act lawfully.

Which is what I've been saying. I don't think the occupiers were protesting the right of the police to arrest people, or for the police to do their work.
 
Which is what I've been saying. I don't think the occupiers were protesting the right of the police to arrest people, or for the police to do their work.
Understood, however, it could be argued that the protestors had a moral responsibility to prevent the police from performing their responsibilities in order to "influence society to accept a dissenting point of view."
 
So the police initially had no problem leaving the protestors alone, except for the ones that interfered with tent removal, who were arrested. Therefore, the protestors who were arrested were not peaceful, and the ones who were left alone were.

Then the students decide to obstruct the police.

The police response to them changes.

Therefore, once the students decided to obstruct the police, they were no longer merely "peaceful protestors". Either they became something in addition to that, or they became something instead of that, both of which the police felt warranted a different response than they had used minutes earlier.

Therefore, insisting that the students were still "peaceful protestors" and nothing else is incorrect. Even more so if one admits they were doing more than "peacefully protesting", but still refer to them exclusively as "peaceful protestors" or paraphrases of such.
 
No arrests! oops, it was a big mistake. Has anyone been to the Quad? You could walk around the kids sitting with 200 to 300 feet buffer and go anywhere on campus.

I suggest if you are dispersing anything, to include Bucks in your back yard; if you have a weapon like a few large rocks, and you throw one at the BIG Buck, and he advances, you should retreat using the remaining rocks to cover your retreat... Why would you pepper spray the sitting kids when you claim the kids surrounded you? ???
To arrest them.

Looks like people who like to pepper spray kids sitting peacefully, there are openings at UC Davis for a few good goons who can't think for themselves, or remember the directions they were given.

No arrests, means pepper spray the kids who are not a threat.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8080292#post8080292

Jeez, man, you're reaching Ergo levels of soapboxing-without-reading-contrary-points.

The only reason the charges were dropped were political fallout because of the video specifically cut to misrepresent the situation. This does not preclude refiling charges (as long as the statute is still in effect), or necessarily provide support for a civil suit. Why does it start with Pike stepping over the line, and not show the students surrounding them, obstructing them, threatening them? Why does it not show the cops warning the seated protesters and attempting to use lesser force? These are all rhetorical; because these facts make the protestors look much, much worse, clearly showing they were not "peaceful", and were not merely protesting.


Video with no commentary, if you don't want to be biased.


Video with commentary.

It's worth noting that certain people can only kvetch about the commentary and ask others to prove things by reference to the video, instead of actively disagreeing with it's overall conclusions.
 
Last edited:
Actually, no, it's not OK. People can make mistakes about what other people said, it happened to me too. The decent thing to do is to apologize. It isn't somehow magically OK.

Well, let's see what was actually said:

the crowd had acted belligerently towards them

Can you reference the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently'? Failing that, the time at which the caption saying they did appears?

[quoting the above question] Right at the moment the police say "move or get pepper sprayed."

That's 'belligerence'? Warlike activity? No. It's protest, peaceful, non-violent protest.

Did I mention 'belligerence' or 'warlike activity'? No, I didn't, thank you very much.

Without looking back, I don't know whether you mentioned belligerence. I do know, without looking back, that I was responding to someone who had mentioned belligerence. OK?

So, I responded to someone who had mentioned 'beliigerence', you claimed belligerence was evident at a certain point. But to be fair, you just quoted me using 'belligerence' and never actually typed it yourself. Do you want now to pretend you meant something else entirely? No magic is necessary, and the only person who ought to be apologising is you.

We're talking about the the students being pepper sprayed. Nobody here is saying that the students didn't have a right to protest. People are saying that the students didn't have a right to prevent the police from leaving with the people they arrested. I can have a peaceful lawful protest without not listening to the police and not complying with their orders. Moreover, I think a peaceful, lawful protest basically is exactly the same as listening to the police, as they are better qualified and authorized to determine what is safe.

It helps, doesn't it, to rehash things nobody is arguing about, then slipping in the contentious stuff and hoping people are gulled into accepting it?

Yet apparently, it is perfectly acceptable to describe your opponents as "supporters of police brutality"

I describe the supporters of police brutality as supporters of police brutality. Who are my 'opponents'?? Is this a 'match', a 'bout'? Are you trying to find the right answer or merely trying to make your wrong answer the 'winner'? By the by, there is no comparison between describing the protestors as 'whiny brats' and describing those here who support the brutal use of pepper spray on seated, peaceful, unarmed students as 'supporters of police brutality'. One of them (might be you, might not, I've done enough scrolling back to prove you wrong for now) advocates the use of dogs. That's brutal, unless you want to introduce an idiosyncratic use of the word to go with the redefinition of 'threat'.

That looks a little hypocritical to me.

Erm...the idea is that you present compelling arguments. Calling your 'opponent' a hypocrite isn't that compelling...
 
To arrest them.



http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8080292#post8080292

Jeez, man, you're reaching Ergo levels of soapboxing-without-reading-contrary-points.

The only reason the charges were dropped were political fallout because of the video specifically cut to misrepresent the situation. This does not preclude refiling charges (as long as the statute is still in effect), or necessarily provide support for a civil suit. Why does it start with Pike stepping over the line, and not show the students surrounding them, obstructing them, threatening them? Why does it not show the cops warning the seated protesters and attempting to use lesser force? These are all rhetorical; because these facts make the protestors look much, much worse, clearly showing they were not "peaceful", and were not merely protesting.


Video with no commentary, if you don't want to be biased.


Video with commentary.

It's worth noting that certain people can only kvetch about the commentary and ask others to prove things by reference to the video, instead of actively disagreeing with it's overall conclusions.
The video you post make the police look bad. Words made them do it. Words, made the police mess up. Weak cowards, in riot gear, afraid of words. The police were not to use force, and if there were too many students they were to leave! End of story.
The UC Davis Chancellor Linda P.B. Katehi confirms I am right, it was a mistake. No big deal, but UC Davis Chancellor Linda P.B. Katehi is the person in charge. She said it was a mistake.

"My instructions were for no arrests and no police force."


Cowards pepper spray kids sitting. Cowards in riot gear, riot gear not authorized. Stupid cowards who can't get instructions correct.

The campus police are to protect students. They lied about a threat and pepper spray the kids sitting. I get it, it makes sense to me. Yes, the threat is all around you, so you pepper spray the kids you were told not to arrest. Good job.


On November 21, Katehi attended a large student protest attended by an estimated 5,000 people.[47] After listening to their statements, Katehi said she was there to apologize.[48] On the following day, she stated that the police had gone against her specific orders to act peacefully when removing tents or equipment, and not to proceed if there were too many students, and she had not approved the police use of riot gear.[48][49] At a town hall meeting, she told around 1,000 students, "I want to unequivocally apologize to the entire community for the appalling use of pepper spray. I will do everything in my power to make sure nothing like that ever happens again." She said, "My instructions were for no arrests and no police force. I explicitly directed the chief of police that violence should be avoided at all costs."[50]


111ucdavispeppersprayrange.jpg

The kids were sitting in the middle of the Quad, a place where students can gather. The police were told not to proceed if too many students. If you think too many students were yelling at the cowards who pepper sprayed the kids sitting, then the cowards were not suppose to be there in the first place.

The UD Davis event was a mistake - will they win a lawsuit? I don't know, but I don't want to pay for it either way. They should not pepper spray the kids sitting. The police lied about the event; becaue if they thougtht there was a threat, they were suppose to go away, not cause violence.

The campus police are to protect the students sitting. But these police picked the kids sitting to pepper spray, when they were instucted not to arrest anyone. Good job.

"set them free" - so you pepper spray those sitting. Good job
"My instructions were for no arrests and no police force."
UC Davis Chancellor Linda P.B. Katehi
 
Well, let's see what was actually said:

So, I responded to someone who had mentioned 'beliigerence', you claimed belligerence was evident at a certain point. But to be fair, you just quoted me using 'belligerence' and never actually typed it yourself. Do you want now to pretend you meant something else entirely? No magic is necessary, and the only person who ought to be apologising is you.
Congratulations! You proved someone forgot what he said somewhere in several pages of text! Nice to see you took my advice to look back.

It helps, doesn't it, to rehash things nobody is arguing about, then slipping in the contentious stuff and hoping people are gulled into accepting it?
Boy, that's vague. Almost as if you're making a generalized statement to avoid having to address specific points.

I describe the supporters of police brutality as supporters of police brutality.
Oh, so you think the pepper spray was wrong. Thanks for getting that out in the open. Will you stop with your rhetorical questions about whether it was right or not?

Who are my 'opponents'?? Is this a 'match', a 'bout'? Are you trying to find the right answer or merely trying to make your wrong answer the 'winner'?
Your opponents in a debate or discussion are people who support an opposing position. You and some think it was wrong, others don't, a few more are neutral.

By the by, there is no comparison between describing the protestors as 'whiny brats' and describing those here who support the brutal use of pepper spray on seated, peaceful, unarmed students as 'supporters of police brutality'.
Hang on;

...
Therefore, insisting that the students were still "peaceful protestors" and nothing else is incorrect. Even more so if one admits they were doing more than "peacefully protesting", but still refer to them exclusively as "peaceful protestors" or paraphrases of such.

One of them (might be you, might not, I've done enough scrolling back to prove you wrong for now) advocates the use of dogs.
There was precisely one guy.

That's brutal, unless you want to introduce an idiosyncratic use of the word to go with the redefinition of 'threat'.
Considering that your definition seems to be limited to "active violence", I'd say such a definition has already been provided.

Erm...the idea is that you present compelling arguments. Calling your 'opponent' a hypocrite isn't that compelling...
It's already been established that you often don't admit when you are wrong.
 
The protest took the form of peacefully obstructing the police.

HA HA HA!!!

I love this one. Peacefully breaking the law is still breaking the law.

Suppose you robbed a bank, but were very polite about it. Should you get away with it?
 
The video you post make the police look bad. Words made them do it. Words, made the police mess up. Weak cowards, in riot gear, afraid of words. The police were not to use force, and if there were too many students they were to leave! End of story.

The UC Davis Chancellor Linda P.B. Katehi confirms I am right, it was a mistake. No big deal, but UC Davis Chancellor Linda P.B. Katehi is the person in charge. She said it was a mistake.

"My instructions were for no arrests and no police force."
And they didn't use force, and they carried out their duties and tried to leave. Then the students initiated the conflict by obstructing the police officers.

"My instructions were for no arrests and no police force," she said. "I explicitly directed the chief of police that violence should be avoided at all costs."

http://www.seattlepi.com/news/artic...pper-spray-incident-2284639.php#ixzz1oBJjUJXt

There was effectively no chance the police were going to get out of that quad without someone using force, due to the actions of the students.
  1. Stand there and hope the angry crowd that threatened them disperses.
    1a: The crowd disperses. (least likely)
    1b: The crowd riots.
  2. Hand over the prisoners which the crowd has illegally demanded. (Not happening.)
  3. Use minimum force to effect an exit at the earliest possible oppourtunity.

Cowards pepper spray kids sitting. Cowards in riot gear, riot gear not authorized. Stupid cowards who can't get instructions correct.
I really shouldn't be laughing, but I am amused by the fact that you are so angry you are typing in caveman.

So! If not pepper spray, then what? You can't answer, of course, since your real objection is to the students being removed at all.

I assure you, cops, even with lethal weaponry, outnumbered by dozens of unarmed hostile people who have issued a threat to them are under threat by any reasonable definition of the word.

The campus police are to protect students. They lied about a threat and pepper spray the kids sitting. I get it, it makes sense to me. Yes, the threat is all around you, so you pepper spray the kids you were told not to arrest. Good job.
You think they should've used more force than they did? They sprayed the people who were directly obstructing them and placed them under arrest.


On November 21, Katehi attended a large student protest attended by an estimated 5,000 people.[47] After listening to their statements, Katehi said she was there to apologize.[48] On the following day, she stated that the police had gone against her specific orders to act peacefully when removing tents or equipment, and not to proceed if there were too many students, and she had not approved the police use of riot gear.[48][49] At a town hall meeting, she told around 1,000 students, "I want to unequivocally apologize to the entire community for the appalling use of pepper spray. I will do everything in my power to make sure nothing like that ever happens again." She said, "My instructions were for no arrests and no police force. I explicitly directed the chief of police that violence should be avoided at all costs."[50]
That's nice. An administrator covering her rear because of an editied video deliberately presenting a biased view of the situation does not mean the police's actions were not justified.

[qimg]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111ucdavispeppersprayrange.jpg[/qimg]
The kids were sitting in the middle of the Quad, a place where students can gather. The police were told not to proceed if too many students. If you think too many students were yelling at the cowards who pepper sprayed the kids sitting, then the cowards were not suppose to be there in the first place.
The cops were trying to leave peacefully. The protestors surrounded them in order to intimidate them and to prevent them from leaving without using force.

Police do not need to be under active threat to justifiably use pepper spray.

The UD Davis event was a mistake - will they win a lawsuit? I don't know, but I don't want to pay for it either way. They should not pepper spray the kids sitting. The police lied about the event; becaue if they thougtht there was a threat, they were suppose to go away, not cause violence.
How could they leave if they were surrounded on all sides by a hostile crowd? The only reason they left when they did is because backup arrived and made a hole in the outer ring, but not the inner ring of seated protestors, who had already been warned. All lesser methods were unfeasable, and there was literally nothing stopping the students from getting up and walking away. They were not trapped, they chose to put themselves there so the police could not carry their prisoners out.

The campus police are to protect the students sitting. But these police picked the kids sitting to pepper spray, when they were instucted not to arrest anyone. Good job.
The protestors actively and deliberately created the situation, not the police. It is intellectually dishonest to lay all the responsibility at the feet of the cops.

"set them free" - so you pepper spray those sitting. Good job
Set them free or we will not 'protest peacefully', they said. Clear threat of violence.

"My instructions were for no arrests and no police force."
UC Davis Chancellor Linda P.B. Katehi
I don't think Katehi legally had command over the police, any more than a town mayor does. The actual UCPD chief supported the officers' actions. Katehi's orders referred only to taking the tents down, not to anything happening afterward.

If someone had opened fire upon the cops with an automatic weapon, should they still had remained "peaceful"? Should they have obeyed the orders, even at the risk of their safety?

It's been said repeatedly the students were the aggressors and obstructors, not the cops.

Dude, you sound like Clayton Moore. Is that who you want as a role model?

Why do you spread lies?
 
Last edited:
http://glocktalk.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1175254
I think that the 7 yard rule comes from the Tueller principle. 25 years ago Dennis Tueller discovered that the great majority of reasonably fit people could make an attack with a knife or club from 7 yards and strike about half the time before an officer with an open carry holster could draw and shoot. That is, the attacker decided when to initiate the attack and the defender could not draw until the charge commenced.

More recent work shows that someone who is good at getting off the X can avoid the attack about half the time from 11 to 12 feet but 25 years ago it was all about draw and shoot from a fixed position.

As Tueller points out, that is not the end of the matter because even if you manage to make a hit your attacker can continue a lethal attack for some time. Since, at the time, there were cases of people absorbing 12 hits of .38Sp, blugeoning a LEO to death and running 200 yards before expiring, it was clear that 7 yards was not actually a safe distance but the converse became generally recognized. That is, shooting someone with a knife or club who was within 7 yards was justified.

English
So, if the crowd had rioted, and the cops used lethal force, there is no chance they would be able to down enough people to save themselves. The crowd had threatened to riot, and outnumbered the cops by dozens, and thus were a threat.

Frankly, I'm not sure why people are complaining about this being stopped when it was. Or would you have several officers injured or killed in a riot and the National Guard called in? If you want to say it was excessive, provide alternatives.
 
Last edited:
Well, let's see what was actually said:

So, I responded to someone who had mentioned 'beliigerence', you claimed belligerence was evident at a certain point. But to be fair, you just quoted me using 'belligerence' and never actually typed it yourself. Do you want now to pretend you meant something else entirely? No magic is necessary, and the only person who ought to be apologising is you.

Help, you're right. It seems I not only have egg on my face, but a couple of omelettes. I think I forgot because I didn't type it myself. Please accept my humble apologies, I'll be sure to double-check things now.
 
Last edited:
So you're a reasonable human being able to admit to your mistakes. Almost as if one minor mistake of memory didn't matter in the long run or to the greater argument.
 
Last edited:
Whelp, you're right. It seems I not only have egg on my face, but a couple of omelettes. I think I forgot because I didn't type it myself. Please accept my humble apologies, I'll be sure to double-check things now.

Ouch. I just lost a bet with myself. I humbly accept your humble apologies and have graciously torn up the invoice I prepared for my time spent fetching all those quotes.

But I'm an inveterate internet gambler, so let's have another wager. I bet that someone who has been told I'm ignoring them is still trying to talk to me. Double or nothing: he's making out this unfortunate little incident has some bearing on the matter at hand...

Yeah, OK, I peeked. All bets are off.
 
In case anyone missed it.

Does anyone know why students were arrested? I have googled but cannot find the reason. My bet would be failure to comply with police orders.
 
...
I don't think Katehi legally had command over the police, any more than a town mayor does. The actual UCPD chief supported the officers' actions. Katehi's orders referred only to taking the tents down, not to anything happening afterward.
...
Why do you spread lies?
oh?
The chain of command in the police department, for all intents and purposes, leads directly to the mayor,
oh?

Police out of control. A police state on campus. It is looking worse than I thought. Imagine the President, not in-charge of the military. The mayor not in-charge of the police! A police state, a police city. 1984!

ergo and clayton got something right? This is politics, is there a right side? The police are under control of the people at the top! If not there is a big problem, because we set the rules and how we enforce them, not the police.

You are saying the person in charge of the whole school is not in charge of their police. Wow, the police are in-charge?

Katehi declined to discuss the incident in detail or to say whether Vice Chancellor John Meyer, who has authority over campus police, authorized force.
oops

Police are not in-charge, we are. The whole US system is based on the fact civilians control, not the police, not the military, civilians; us.

The mayor shall be the judge in any emergency, and may assume command of all or any part of the police force of the City

Civilians are in-charge, we are the ones who decide. You will love China, they use tanks to stop protesters, in the USA we should defend the protesters who are sitting. The police messed up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom