Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Here's the thing; Brown never actually says he witnessed the attack, and there is no evidence other than his claim that students were coughing blood. Not a photo, not a video, I've not even seen any other "witness" claim it, yet they were supposedly there for the better part of an hour (because the jackbooted thugs with liability want people who are seriously and visibly injured to just sit around in public for extended periods), and we know for a fact there were several cameras rolling. Moreover, coughing blood is not one of the standard effects of pepper spray, and there is, again, no evidence of students' mouths being forced open other than his claim.

The videos, you will recall, were supposedly recording this happening, so your excuse that it happened offscreen doesn't wash. In fact, the most common version of the video, which starts with Pike stepping over the line, directly contradicts Brown's timeline.

Nor do I find any evidence of police using batons to push the students apart before deploying pepper spray. The letter reads exactly like an eyewitness in a confused and chaotic situation recounting the story to someone later as best as they can remember, but still incorrectly. Anybody with legal or police experience will tell you that witnesses often get things wrong; you can take ten witnesses who saw the exact same thing, and they will give different testimonies, several of which will actively contradict more objective evidence like a security camera video.

Brown is wrong. Not even a little wrong. Absolutely wrong.

He heard the story, put it in his open letter, and everyone assumed a)he was right, and b)he was there.

I wonder why your link did not include the primary source.

I wonder why you think the primary source has any bearing? The story remains the same. Of course he may be lieing, or mistaken. That's a given, though if it's all you've got then why comment? Because it would suit you to dismiss it.

It served its purpose. We established that the claim that nobody was injured came from someone who now admits he has no freaking idea whether anybody was injured or not. Whether Brown is truthful or accurate is beside the point.
 
Let's try a different tack.

JQ, Ken, imagine the situation was the same in every way, except for the parts where it becomes justifiable in your eyes for the police to have pepper sprayed the seated protestors.

What would have to be different?

Would the crowd have to be actively assaulting the officers? Would an explicit and unequivocal threat of violence have to be made? What if the prisoners being transported, for whatever reason, were convicted felons instead of alleged suspects? What if they and the crowd were, IDK, white supremacists, members of Westboro Baptist, or Republicans? Can you imagine the situation and describe it, please?

Do your own homework. I'm busy trying to discuss the OP, which you seem now reluctant to do.
 
Do try to keep up. I'm repeating what I said from the off: the video does not show the cops encircled. Nobody has been able to show where the video shows that, because it doesn't? Are you disagreeing? Are you sure?
No. Yes. Yes.


Oh, look, they're completely encircled except for where backup has just arrived in a squad car and is keeping the way clear.

It is 'baseless speculation' that the officer commanding thought a show of force was necessary just before a show of force was deployed? I'd call it an 'educated guess', myself, if not a 'foregone conclusion'.
...If I wanted out of a circle, I'd head for the weakest link, not the strong point, but perhaps the commanding officer reasoned that a show of force was required. We all know who liked a show of force, don't we ;)...
So you went from a statement about what you'd do and a "perhaps" (that is, speculation) about what the CO would do to an "educated guess" or "foregone conclusion".


You appear to be saying, by the way, that the outer perimeter was dispersed and then the only point of blockage was pepper sprayed, rather than circumvented. Are you sure that's what you meant?
No, I'm saying at that point, the most direct path--the "weakest link", to use your term--out of the situation with the prisoners was to remove the seated and interlinked protestors. They were still blocked in every other direction.


No one has to defend 'no threat' being met with violence? Because it's a straw man?? We see it happening. If you're going to keep insisting there was threat, although the perimeter had been dispersed and the students were seated and peaceful, you'll have to be much more explicit about the nature of the threat you perceive.
Pepper spray does not need an active threat for its use to be justified. If a woman turns around and finds a large, hooded man running up behind him and pepper sprays him, that's justifed based on the information she had available, even if he turns out to be returning her dropped keys.


Oh, you are claiming the officers are threatened. You're just not explicit. Your second sentence here could use some work, I think I might see what you're trying to convince yourself of but I can't be sure. I see no violence on the part of the protestors - can you reference it in the video?
No. Straw man. Again. Violence does not need to have been commited for a threat to be issued or present.

I understand the purpose of the spraying, we're questioning the wisdom and validity of the action, not its purpose.
Then please, provide an alternative measure by which the police could've disengaged the obstructors with less harm.

My fanciful analogy involving domestic appliances is not what you're being asked to defend, and it's disingenuous to pretend otherwise. 'No threat' was met with violence. That's not a strawman. Defend that.
Done.

That paragraph has no relationship to the points it appeared to be addressing. It comes as no shock to me, by the way.
Yes it did. You mentioned the safety of the protestors. A dropped fridge would be rather unlikely to apprehend suspects alive, and cops like to do as little harm to the suspect as possible, in order to bring them in alive. In fact, it would likely be classified as "deadly force", the same as a firearm. Just bigger and messier.

Probably so. Defend the use of violence against seated unarmed peaceful protestors.
Done.

That's possibly because, as with most polarised arguments, it's easier for you to lump together everyone who disagrees with you and suppose they all share common arguments that you have imagined for them and which you can cleverly refute. What do they call that? Oh yes, a straw man. You misused the term twice earlier.
No, that would be stating that you have some sort of bias that affects your objectivity.

In fact, I work hand in hand with the police, have considerable contact with a great many officers through the course of my work and have seen on several occasions exemplary behaviour which has only increased my respect for them. But these cops, in this incident, pepper sprayed seated unarmed protestors who were offering no threat. I'm beginning to suspect you have some sort of bias against imaginary long-haired pinko intellectuals.
No, only the short-haired ones.

Ah, of course. Attack is the best form of defence, and surprise is the best form of attack, so attack the rioters before they start rioting. Hell, why stop there, we should beat students up on a random basis, that'll put a stop to all this talk of rights and democracy and a just society for all.
Straw man. You're complaining about a martial term being used, and when I point out that they were a hostile crowd threatening to riot, you do not contest the assertion, only the measures used in response to it.

My request for a reference to the point in the video where we see the crowd acting 'belligerently' was the disputation. I note you don't actually provide any evidence, just an attempt to make a putative audience believe that I might have seen some belligerence. So once again, I dispute your claim and suggest you present some evidence.
That doesn't actually tend to get anyone very far with you. And again, you do not claim that the crowd was not acting belligerently. I did mention the little "protesting peacefully" remark, which you seem to have accepted, so a specific timestamp is unnecessary.

A personal attack? To ask if you're a politician? I guess that depends how you feel about politicians. Hypocrisy is a prime requisite, I think, so you could run if you don't already.
...So when the citizenry express their common opinion, it's the job of the police to supress that? Is that because the voters can't be trusted to run their own affairs? Do you have a dog in this race? Are you a politician?...
Oh, look, you're ignoring the part about it being a straw man. What's it called when you quote-mine and/or misrepresent the positions and claims of others? Tip of my tongue...

At any time. They have the right to accept the consequences too.
These were the consequences. Standard compliance measures used on people resisting arrest for just about every cop in America, including suspects that are not an active threat.

And then a wider society has the right to decide (by court of law, not by sophomoric debate on the intertubes)
One which you're participating in.

whether they were criminal scum who deserve dogs set on them, or brave members of the continuing brother(and sister!)hood of protesting citizens who bring about laudable changes in society.
Laudable changes such as being able to demand cops let go of prisoners under threat of obstruction and violence.

UCPD was only concerned with the tents. They were letting the protests continue, except for the people who actively obstructed them. This situation was the result of the students confronting the police, not the other way around.

In what situations do you believe it is acceptable for citizens to protest peacefully? Were the Egyptians right to defy and obstruct authority? The Syrians etc?
IDK.

I said his position was entrenched. It is. The 'denial' (you say like it's a dirty word...) was indeed denial. I deny that the video shows several things that have been claimed for it here and are claimed for it in the captions. You can dismiss that with "denial" if you like, but the smart kids use actual evidence.
Well, that's ironic.


That's irrelevant. The question was, and remains, whether it was acceptable to pepper spray them as we saw happening. I love how you use the 'personal attacks' you deride in others to wriggle round addressing the actual point.
The pepper spray was a response to the obstruction I currently allege, so it's plenty relevant. It's like arguing that someone being in a pool is irrelevant to the question of whether they drowned in that pool.



Easy. They were non-violent. You can easily refute that by pointing to their violence in the video, but you don't.
I don't have to. You don't need to be actively violent to represent a threat, to issue a threat, or for police to reasonably interpret you as a threat. If a guy is running toward a cop with a knife raised, does he need to wait until the guy's in knife range before going "well, he's a threat, guess I'd better defend myself".

You keep claiming it's there, that seated unarmed protestors are a 'threat',
No, I do not. I have claimed, several times, that a)the crowd was issuing threats and behaving in a threatening manner to the officers, both of which can be construed as "violent" even if they hadn't committed active violence, and b)one does not need to be actively violent for police use of pepper spray on one to be justified.

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/kill?ref=dictionary&word=violent#
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/violent
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/violence

but you have no evidence because there isn't any. It's a post hoc rationalisation for your inate support for the pepper spraying of uppitty book-loving punk kids.
No, it's not. I started looking for evidence as soon as I saw the video, before I made a decision.
 
Last edited:
Do your own homework. I'm busy trying to discuss the OP, which you seem now reluctant to do.
So you can't even imagine a version of situation where the police were justified.

Turnabout is fair play: I think the cops were justified. They would not have been justified if the seated protestors had been, say, little old people with lung problems, or if lesser measures had proven successful when they were tried earlier.

EDIT: There are others, of course, I'm just too tired to think of 'em.
 
Last edited:
I wonder why you think the primary source has any bearing? The story remains the same.
Because it supports my claim that Brown never claimed he personally witnessed the events.

Of course he may be lieing, or mistaken. That's a given, though if it's all you've got then why comment? Because it would suit you to dismiss it.
Yes, it would suit me to show that your source is invalid. And I have.

It served its purpose. We established that the claim that nobody was injured came from someone who now admits he has no freaking idea whether anybody was injured or not. Whether Brown is truthful or accurate is beside the point.
SO your evidence gets shot down, and then you suddenly say it's irrelevant.

BTMO challenged you to find corroboration of Brown's claims in the video. You admitted parts of the account would've happened offscreen, in the middle of rhetorical chaff. BTMO then said he had no idea whether it was accurate, after asking you to provide evidence that corroborates Brown's account.

The fact that "the bits that happened after the video ended" can't be shown means there must be some bits that would've happened during the video. You have not provided evidence of such, which is ironic for someone who keeps asking for specific timestamps before admitting the students were acting belligerently or in a threatening manner or were even hostile or obstructing the police.
 
Last edited:
You highlighted 'aggressively hostile' in the dictionary definition you linked to. Now highlight 'aggressive hostility' in the video of peaceful seated unarmed students being pepper sprayed.
I can't, it was edited out of that version. You'll have to check the longer version, which shows the students actively obstructing the police and demanding the release of the prisoners or they would not let the police go or "continue to protest peacefully". If someone actively gets in one's path and says "do X and I'll continue to Y peacefully", what does that imply if one does not do X?

Telling the police to release prisoners is not an offence. Were they lawful prisoners? One minute 'lawful' must wait for a court, when it suits you, the next it is decided by the police, when it suits you.
I believe they were lawful prisoners. People have charges dropped all the time, but that does not make the actions themselves legal. When I say "lawful", I am speaking in terms of my personal opinion on the matter, not what is legally recognized in court.

Obstruction of the police can be an offence. It is in the nature of lawful protest to obstruct the police. Was their obstruction lawful? Let's see, what would suit you?
Would you care to answer your own rhetorical question? Because if actions taken by the protest break the law, then that protest becomes unlawful by definition. You have carefully avoided addressing whether they were obstructing at all, and now only bring it up in a manner that avoids a firm stand, and in an attempt at an ad hom.

I am referring to obstruction in the legal sense of wilfully and knowingly obstructing, delaying, and/or hindering the police, by California law. Under that definition, the seated students were Obstructing, and were subject to the same measures anyone is who is charged with obstructing. Whether they were protesting or not is irrelevant to the discharge of the officers' duty.
 
Last edited:
They were on the Quad, 600x500 feet of grass and trees. The students sitting were not stopping anyone from access to anything but the center of the Quad, 500x600 feet of grass, trees, and sidewalks; between the student union and library.

There was no reason to pepper spray the kids in the face from 2 feet, they were sitting. Lucky they did not have guns, then we would have a second Kent State.

The campus is over 5,000 acres, and the students were sitting on a less than 50 feet.

So you don't have to comply with the police if you're in the middle of a field? How does it matter where they were? The police said 'move or get pepper sprayed' because they had to transport the people they had arrested. It was fairly easy for the students to avoid being pepper sprayed.

Wow, lets practice pepper spraying students sitting down, not moving, it is too hard to pepper spray the students chanting let them go... Real heroes, UC Davis Police, helping students stay safe. Good job.

The Quad is there for the students - not a practice range for police pepper spray. What a bunch of cowards, unable to lead, they have to assault people.

The police should be cowards, in a sense. They should not take unnecessary risks like stepping over a line of sitting students, while transporting people who are arrested.

Our founding fathers would be peppered sprayed. (they were shot at)

You know, such an appeal to emotion doesn't work on someone who doesn't have some weird cult like respect for some 'founding fathers'.
 
And oh look, JQ, you didn't respond to post 217, the one that has the link which shows you not admitting you were wrong and strawmanning my position frantically. When someone says "I don't think X is correct in any sense whatsoever", don't respond to him like he's saying "I don't think X is literally true". I've also caught you directly straw-manning, ironically when you tried to ignore the fact that I was accusing you of using straw men.

I, by contrast, already admitted I was wrong in this very thread.

Well, I was wrong...

Brown's story, even it is his, is uncorroborated, actively contradicted by multiple videos, and illogical. The fact that you would abandon it is telling.

Speaking of earlier posts...

At the time they were pepper sprayed, they were no longer protesters. They were law breakers. This IS NOT up for discussion. It is a rock-solid fact.
Do you dispute the fact that they were breaking the law?
 
Last edited:
That's 'belligerence'? Warlike activity? No. It's protest, peaceful, non-violent protest.

Did I mention 'belligerence' or 'warlike activity'? No, I didn't, thank you very much. I talked about not listening to the police and then facing the consequences.

Oh, was what they did illegal? Or did you accidentally use the word 'legal' about some other imaginary actions you haven't specified, without meaning to imply that their untried action was illegal.

I'd imagine not listening to the police and not complying with their orders isn't exactly legal, no. Why should it be? Remember, I'm not talking about protesting, I'm talking about not going out of the way of the police.

Oh we're all for the rule of law round here. The thread is about the students using the law to seek redress for the violent (and probably illegal) response of the police to the student's peaceful lawful protest.

Not listening to the police and not complying with their orders is not the same as 'peaceful lawful protest'.
 
It relates to the question "do police ever overstep their bounds?"
Not sure how it relates. Strikes me as ad hominem. It doesn't advance the discussion or address the issue in any substantive manner.

That said I thank you for answering what you could.
 
Yes, police definitely overstep their authority to harass and intimidate protestors some of the time. And I think things like "free speech zones" and some of the anti-assembly laws are BS.
What's BS about the "free speech zones", aside from semantics?

Do you know what they even are?
 
What's BS about the "free speech zones", aside from semantics?

Do you know what they even are?
Something that easily can be abused.

wiki said:
The constitutionality of police-imposed 'free-speech zones'

The protesters did not have a right to a captive audience, or a right to protest anywhere they wanted to. But they did have the right to speak and protest. And that implies that they had the right to at least have a good chance to be heard by their desired audience -- the conventioneers. Yet they argued that this chance was denied them: They said that, given the combination of the penning and the placement of the protest pens, they could not easily be seen protesting by delegates and others on their way to the Convention.

If that is true, it raises a serious First Amendment problem. Certainly, if the DNC protesters had only been able to speak their piece in a submarine on the bottom of the ocean, their rights would have been violated. And the protestors have said that their Convention placement had more or less the same effect.
A policy that ensures that one cannot or will not be heard strikes me as unconstitutional.
 
...
Yes, it would suit me to show that your source is invalid. And I have....
Let me clarify: I noticed the holes in Brown's story since last year. They're quite evident once compared with the longer video.

I love that someone, bikerdruid, IIRC, claimed he was an impartial observer, despite the fact that his claims students had their mouths forced open has not been corroborated, and is actually contradicted by the videos of Occupy itself.

I'm not sure if Communism counts as conservative or liberal, but he's not unbiased.

I'm also suspicious that students who were coughing blood would be allowed to stick around for 45 minutes instead of being bundled off to a hospital or clinic and out of public view as soon as possible. Very incompetent, these merciless jackbooted thugs. Odd that no one got a picture or video of the blood-coughing individual.
 
Maybe everyone filming just decided to not film that part.
JQ said s/he can't show the parts that were not filmed. Which means that they can show the parts that were filmed. When I pointed out Brown's account is full of holes, JQ suddenly declared the evidence they presented irrelevant.

Hmm.
 
Something that easily can be abused.

A policy that ensures that one cannot or will not be heard strikes me as unconstitutional.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cox_v._New_Hampshire
Cox v. New Hampshire, 312 U.S. 569 (1941),[1] was a case in which the Supreme Court of the United States held that, although the government cannot regulate the contents of speech, it can place reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions on speech for the public safety.

No one has a right to be listened to.
 
How do you know about it if no one heard it?
How do you know that their intended audience had a reasonable opportunity to hear the message?

If I found out that free speech zones were in Guadalajara Mexico and that 100 protests were carried out there would that mean that I had heard any of those protests?
 
So you can't even imagine a version of situation where the police were justified.

You've turned 'no, I have no interest in engaging in speculative fiction with you, I prefer to address the facts at hand' into "you can't...blah blah blah".

That, and your inability to see that it is irrelevant whether Brown is truthful or accurate (even though I've repeatedly pointed out why) and your insistence on arguing several points that I have not presented and do not necessarily support, leads me to conclude that I have better things to do today (and in all likelihood tomorrow etc) than to engage with you.

I don't think it's acceptable to use violence on seated unarmed protestors offering no threat. We'll just have to agree to differ...
 
How do you know that their intended audience had a reasonable opportunity to hear the message?
They do, they have TVs, internet connections, and newspaper subscriptions just like everyone else.

If I found out that free speech zones were in Guadalajara Mexico and that 100 protests were carried out there would that mean that I had heard any of those protests?
What if you found out they were a block or 2 down the street? Try to leave Mr. Straw at home.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom