Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Did I mention 'belligerence' or 'warlike activity'? No, I didn't, thank you very much. I talked about not listening to the police and then facing the consequences.

Without looking back, I don't know whether you mentioned belligerence. I do know, without looking back, that I was responding to someone who had mentioned belligerence. OK?

I'd imagine not listening to the police and not complying with their orders isn't exactly legal, no. Why should it be? Remember, I'm not talking about protesting, I'm talking about not going out of the way of the police.

The protest took the form of peacefully obstructing the police. You can't talk about this protest and claim you're not talking about protest. If you're not talking about this protest, you're off topic.

Not listening to the police and not complying with their orders is not the same as 'peaceful lawful protest'.

Yes it is. Now you say 'No it isn't' and we can pretend we're having a debate.
 
They do, they have TVs, internet connections, and newspaper subscriptions just like everyone else.
That's not a reasonable opportunity. Read the article I linked to. One could protest in their front yard but that doesn't mean that they are likely to be heard by their intended audience.

What if you found out they were a block or 2 down the street? Try to leave Mr. Straw at home.
Oh stop with the BS straw man accusation. It's a reasonable example. If you have little to no chance of your intended audience to hear then you have no free speech rights.
 
The protest took the form of peacefully obstructing the police.
Which will get you arrested by the police. And they will use force if necessary.

But crying about it later just exposes the protestors as whiny brats. Protest in a legal manner if you don't want to get arrested. If you want to get arrested don't resist the arrest.

It's really pretty simple.
 
What if you found out they were a block or 2 down the street? Try to leave Mr. Straw at home.
So, this time could you bother to read what I posted?

wiki said:
The constitutionality of police-imposed 'free-speech zones'

The protesters did not have a right to a captive audience, or a right to protest anywhere they wanted to. But they did have the right to speak and protest. And that implies that they had the right to at least have a good chance to be heard by their desired audience -- the conventioneers. Yet they argued that this chance was denied them: They said that, given the combination of the penning and the placement of the protest pens, they could not easily be seen protesting by delegates and others on their way to the Convention.

If that is true, it raises a serious First Amendment problem. Certainly, if the DNC protesters had only been able to speak their piece in a submarine on the bottom of the ocean, their rights would have been violated. And the protestors have said that their Convention placement had more or less the same effect.
A policy that ensures that one cannot or will not be heard strikes me as unconstitutional.

  • You don't have a right to have a captive audience.
  • You don't have a right to protest anywhere you want to.
  • The law implies that you have a right to at least have a good chance to be heard by your desired audience
 
That's not a reasonable opportunity. Read the article I linked to. One could protest in their front yard but that doesn't mean that they are likely to be heard by their intended audience.
There is no Constitutional right for anyone to hear your protest, including the targets of your protest. Protest all you want, other people have the right to ignore you.

Oh stop with the BS straw man accusation. It's a reasonable example. If you have little to no chance of your intended audience to hear then you have no free speech rights.
Really? You think your example of confining protests to a foreign country is reasonable, or has any semblance to the subject at hand?

It's pure straw.
 
Last edited:
Which will get you arrested by the police. And they will use force if necessary.

But crying about it later just exposes the protestors as whiny brats. Protest in a legal manner if you don't want to get arrested. If you want to get arrested don't resist the arrest.

It's really pretty simple.

Tiresome. Over and over, supporters of police brutality claim that there are occasions when force is warranted and necessary. We've done that, you have no argument there. We agree.

The pepper-spraying of peaceful seated unarmed student protestors was not warranted nor was it necessary.

It wasn't necessary to describe the protestors as 'whiny brats', either. That the supporters of police brutality can't express their support without making their biases and deficiencies clear is informative.
 
Without looking back, I don't know whether you mentioned belligerence. I do know, without looking back, that I was responding to someone who had mentioned belligerence. OK?
Perhaps you should look back then.

The protest took the form of peacefully obstructing the police.
So you admit they were breaking the law, good. I maintain that the fact that the crowd actively issued threats and was hostile to the 5-0 informed their decision and actions(and that the crowd's actions were not "peaceful"), though they may have behaved in a similar or identical fashion without that Damocles sword hanging over their heads.

You can't talk about this protest and claim you're not talking about protest. If you're not talking about this protest, you're off topic.

Yes it is. Now you say 'No it isn't' and we can pretend we're having a debate.
Disobeying...the lawful orders...of the police...is breaking the law. Obstructing...the police...is breaking the law. I'm not sure why you're saying they weren't breaking the law, when you just claimed they were performing actions which broke the law.

MLK Jr. Letters from a Birmingham Jail said:
In no sense do I advocate evading or defying the law, as would the rabid segregationist. That would lead to anarchy. One who breaks an unjust law must do so openly, lovingly, and with a willingness to accept the penalty. I submit that an individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust, and who willingly accepts the penalty of imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the highest respect for law.

If this were the Conspiracy theory forum, I'd nominate you for a Stundie.

It's kind of hard to listen to an argument from someone who will abandon their own evidence once it's proved inconvenient. BTMO alleged that the kids were not hurt, you presented Brown's account as a contradiction, BTMO said he had no opinion on it's validity (after saying he thought didn't have a hope of convincing you, no matter what argument he made), and I did and pointed out where it's wrong and useless as evidence. Which means your point about the damage undergone by the students is without any support.
 
Last edited:
So, this time could you bother to read what I posted?

A policy that ensures that one cannot or will not be heard strikes me as unconstitutional.

  • You don't have a right to have a captive audience.
  • You don't have a right to protest anywhere you want to.
  • The law implies that you have a right to at least have a good chance to be heard by your desired audience
Assertions are evidence now?
 
The pepper-spraying of peaceful seated unarmed student protestors was not warranted nor was it necessary.
Name the options for the police in this situation that are acceptable to you.

But we both know you won't answer this question, don't we?
 
Assertions are evidence now?

  • Which are simply asserted?
  • Which do you disagree with?
ETA: Please to explain the difference between the following.

  • You cannot speak.
  • You can only speak where you are likely not to be heard.
 
Last edited:
Assertions are evidence now?
They were with him the last go-round. During the last debate, he was repeatedly asked to provide alternatives to pepper spray. When he finally provided a document, it was pointed out that by his interpretation of it, the cops should've spat on the students or chased them with a helicopter.

Fun times.
 
Oh, I said I wouldn't but here I am. After this, I'm popping you back on ignore, OK?

Perhaps you should look back then.

Perhaps you should engage your brain and read what you quoted.

So you admit they were breaking the law, good. I maintain that the fact that the crowd actively issued threats and was hostile to the 5-0 informed their decision and actions(and that the crowd's actions were not "peaceful"), though they may have behaved in a similar or identical fashion without that Damocles sword hanging over their heads.

Your definition of 'threat' is still idiosyncratic and does not relate to the real world at all. I did not, by the way, admit anything - that you have to claim I did shows how weak your position is.

Disobeying...the lawful orders...of the police...is breaking the law. Obstructing...the police...is breaking the law. I'm not sure why you're saying they weren't breaking the law, when you just claimed they were performing actions which broke the law.

I do not believe the orders (or actions) of the police were lawful. I'm not sure why you're still playing.

If this were the Conspiracy theory forum, I'd nominate you for a Stundie.

It's kind of hard to listen to an argument from someone who will abandon their own evidence once it's proved inconvenient. BTMO alleged that the kids were not hurt, you presented Brown's account as a contradiction, BTMO said he had no opinion on it's validity (after saying he thought didn't have a hope of convincing you, no matter what argument he made), and I did and pointed out where it's wrong and useless as evidence. Which means your point about the damage undergone by the students is without any support.

Again, since you seem to have difficulty getting this: it does not matter whether Brown is truthful or accurate. Your claim as to my purpose in presenting his account is inaccurate. Somebody (and I've lost interest as to who) claimed that 'nobody was hurt'. When presented with a claim that somebody was hurt, he then admitted he had no idea whether anyone was hurt. That was the purpose of my post. I've said repeatedly, and I say again, it does not matter whether Brown is correct. I don't care either way. I did care about an inaccurate, untruthful wild-assed guess by someone who (like you) will apparantly say anything and interpret anything in a way that will appear to shore up their support for the violent suppression of peaceful unarmed protest.
 
Name the options for the police in this situation that are acceptable to you.

But we both know you won't answer this question, don't we?

Go for the million. The question is, should they have done what they did?
 
Name the options for the police in this situation that are acceptable to you.

But we both know you won't answer this question, don't we?
Yep.

This is disingenuous. JQ thinks the police were not justified in removing the protestors, so any means used to accomplish those ends are unjustified. It doesn't matter if it was pepper spray, hands-on force, or tickle kittens.
 
  • Which are simply asserted?
  • Which do you disagree with?
The wiki you quoted was assertions. Lots of "ifs" unsupported by any evidence.

ETA: Please to explain the difference between the following.


  • You cannot speak.
  • You can only speak where you are likely not to be heard.
I thought we were talking about the "free speech zones"?

I really have no interest in your strawmen.
 
Go for the million. The question is, should they have done what they did?
We all know you think the answer is "no", and that you don't think they were justified removing the "peaceful protestors", period. Why the pretense? At the very least, you think pepper spray was wrong.

Nice dodge, by the way. WC is asking you to provide feasible alternatives. Stop trying to reverse the question.
 
Last edited:
Go for the million. The question is, should they have done what they did?
Unfortunaltely I don't get the million for the equivalent of predicting the sun to rise in the morning.

Whining is not a path forward.
 
I bulleted my points. Could you tell me which ones you disagree with?
The straw man ones and the ones unsupported by any evidence.

So what free speech zone confined protestors to Mexico?

There is no straw man. That's a dodge on your part. To answer the question would put your world view at risk. That's something you simply cannot do so call it a straw man and avoid the dissonance.
It's a straw man because that circumstance bears no resemblance to the subject at hand, you just made it up in order to burn it down.

People had the opportunity to hear/see the protests. They also have the right to ignore them if they wish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom