Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

I don't watch FOX news but I can imagine their objection would be along the lines of, "He is stealing the SEALs spot light and should give them more attention!"
I suspect it's more along the lines of "He's a Democrat and that was a good event, we need to spin this to make the President look like ****".
 
I kind of think the discussion is going to wither away, since it seems like NavySEAL pulled the "I'm in the military and you're not" card and left. :(

I will just pull the "I was a military brat" card!

My father was a Lt. Col when I was growing up and I recall he often griped about superiors taking credit for his work. Not saying thats what President Obama is doing just that complaints always go up the chain.
 
...I wouldn't be surprised if we shortly hear complaints about why hasn't the president fixed health care, or global warming?

Well, I would be a little surprised about the latter.

You shouldn't be, many have been giving the president just this sort of questioning (myself among them), but these arguments are coming from progressives, not conservatives.
 
The preemptiveness I think is the key: anything that might become an important postive point for the president in the next election, we'll see the opposing party try to get out in front of now. Nothing particularly surprising about the tactic (they are already grappling with what the economy might look like by November), and I'm sure there is more to come.

I wouldn't be surprised if we shortly hear complaints about why hasn't the president fixed health care, or global warming?

Well, I would be a little surprised about the latter.

You shouldn't be, many have been giving the president just this sort of questioning (myself among them), but these arguments are coming from progressives, not conservatives.

The context of my quote was that I would be surprised to hear it from the opposing party. I should be surprised if the opposing party starts complaining about his lack of progress on global warming?
 
Not your right to speak, your qualifications to speak about what is good or bad for the Navy SEALs?

As you are no longer with the SEALs or the military, by what accord do you assert the right to speak for all other current and former SEALs?
 
"Being in the public eye after your mission is over does not hurt it, either."

By you leave sir, what qualifies you to make such a statement?

Being a rational human being. If you have an argument to make, then make it.

I'll not be bullied by "I'm military and you're not, so shut up." Thank you very much. Either you have a valid reason that you can articulate or you don't. Argument from authority doesn't fly in a free forum.
 
The context of my quote was that I would be surprised to hear it from the opposing party. I should be surprised if the opposing party starts complaining about his lack of progress on global warming?

(psst, I'm Republican - just a somewhat rare, progressive Republican)
 
I like SDVs. Nothing secret about them, go to a SEAL demo and they will let you sit in one.

So you only talk about the things SEALs don't talk about in public, when it is something that you personally find "cool?"
 
Is making unsupported assertions and avoiding direct questions something they teach you in BUD/S, or do you have to learn that later?
 
(psst, I'm Republican - just a somewhat rare, progressive Republican)

Are you saying you think the opposing party will start complaining about why Obama hasn't fixed global warming? Because it seems to me the party's stance is that global warming either isn't happening, or isn't fixable by man.
 
Mitt has no leg to stand on here.
Then there is this. Sorry if it has already been posted.

The Hill said:
source “Look, just a few years ago. President Obama, then a candidate said in a speech that if we had actionable intelligence of a high-value target in Pakistan we’d go in and get that high value target,” said Gibbs on NBC’s "Meet the Press" on Sunday. “Mitt Romney said that was foolish, he wouldn’t do such a thing. They wouldn’t move heaven and earth to get Osama bin Laden.”
I'm a little more sympathetic to the idea that Romney wouldn't have made the same choice. To be sure I don't know but Romney himself said that it would be foolish to go into Pakistan to get Bin Laden.
 
I am a big fan of the Navy Seals. They are the elite of the elite. They have executed (no pun intended) at least two flawless missions during the Obama administration. Thank you NavySEAL for your service and whatever part you may have had in these missions.

And I don't begrudge you your right to be unhappy about Obama politicizing it. Like any other citizen, you should have the right to publically disagree with any politician.

But in spite of your great work, you are not the only organiztion that helped to make this mission and others a success. Thank the politicians who put the plan into motion, most of them starting during the Bush administration. Thank the intel guys who worked in the fields for many years to identify the opportunity. Thank the remote sensing guys who provided accurate maps and air photos without which the mission could not have been planned. And yes, thank Obama for giving you the opportunity to show your stuff. The SEALS deserve and got a lot of credit for the results, but they didn't operate in a vacuum, nor do they have total ownership over what is later said about it or who takes credit.

But let me ask you a question, NS: If the raid had occurred during the Bush (or potentially McCain) administration, do you think they would have tried to use it to make political points? Would you still have been just as annoyed? Were you annoyed when Bush made political mileage for capturing Saddam Hussein?
 
So you only talk about the things SEALs don't talk about in public, when it is something that you personally find "cool?"


Possibly.....They are cool, very cool, they have been called the longest, darkest, and coldest ride a human can withstand.

No shooting=no interest.....just ride.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom