Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

Obama should keep this out in the public as long as possible. Republicans dropped the ball on bin Laden and got distracted in Iraq. McCain and Romney both said they would not have gone into Pakistan without the Pakistani's permission. Obama did what they said they wouldn't do. Republicans would not have hesitated to criticize Obama had the mission failed. Obama made a big gamble and he won. The victory is his.

The more this is said, the better. The myth that republicans are strong on national defense needs to die.
 
The Navy SEALs are not pleased at all by Mr. Obama's statements.
Our concerns have nothing to do with politics.

The NavyTimes article seems much more balanced than your presentation.

http://www.navytimes.com/news/2012/...ama-bin-ladens-death-isnt-celebration-043012/

While I personally disagree with Obama on many points, as I did with president Bush, I wouldn't presume to speak for all Rangers regarding either Commander in Chief, nor would I expect the general public to have any regard whatsoever for my opinions of either man's politics. This sounds too much like the disreputable Swft-boat distortions that occurred a few years back and were more harmful to general military image and reputation than to the political candidate at whom that slander was directed.
 
First without checking I am declared a phony.
Then I might be real but still a coward.
Now you dont like my conduct.
OK
I am not a phony.
I am not a coward, I have done two combat tours.
My military conduct, the last time I was graded, was one notch down from 4.0.
May we please move on?
 
Just like Carter and the failed rescue mission.

Yep. I was thinking also of JFK and the Bay of Pigs failure. In the press conference, he said, "There's an old saying that victory has a hundred fathers and defeat is an orphan... What matters is only one fact, I am the responsible officer of the government."

This operation to get OBL was very risky, and President Obama decided to go through with it. He should get credit for making that decision.
 
I've now heard complaints about Obama hyping twice and still haven't heard Obama hype it.

This has the feel of a preemptive political attack rather than a legitimate criticism.

The preemptiveness I think is the key: anything that might become an important postive point for the president in the next election, we'll see the opposing party try to get out in front of now. Nothing particularly surprising about the tactic (they are already grappling with what the economy might look like by November), and I'm sure there is more to come.

I wouldn't be surprised if we shortly hear complaints about why hasn't the president fixed health care, or global warming?

Well, I would be a little surprised about the latter.
 
...
My military conduct
...

Which I wasn't discussing.

I simply know that had I been in the military during Bush, I would have said nothing whatsoever about him in public because I don't think that it is ethical for a soldier to do so. Likewise, praise should be kept to yourself as well. It cuts both ways. - You can say whatever you like about the Congress, however, as that is not chain of command.

Now, I do need to apologize for doubting you; You have no idea how many fake special-ops soldiers I have encountered both online and off. I think you'd be the very first in many dozens who is what he says he is.
 
First without checking I am declared a phony.
Then I might be real but still a coward.
Now you dont like my conduct.
OK
I am not a phony.
I am not a coward, I have done two combat tours.
My military conduct, the last time I was graded, was one notch down from 4.0.
May we please move on?

You're attempting to use your credentials as a (former, since you graduated UDT almost fifty years ago) SEAL to speak for the members of the current SEAL teams as a whole vis-a-vis Obama's comments about the Bin Laden raid.

As a result, it's your responsibility to establish not just your own credentials here, but your authority as a reliable spokesman for the SEALs. If you don't, well, you've been through two combat tours and are a Vietnam SEAL vet. Surely you can live with the doubts of anonymous members of a skeptics' message board.
 
Upchurch
We dont want or need publicity. Being in the publics eye is not helping our mission at all. Plenty of guys were applying for training prior to all the hoopla.
 
What do they have to do with?

If you eliminate the politics then it has to be the policies and decisions.

So the Seals were unhappy with the choice to go in and take out Bin Laden while gaining huge amounts of actionable intel? That seems to be the implication according to NavySEAL.

What statement is problematic outside politics?

EDIT: Oh, so creating publicity is the criticism? Why?
 
Last edited:
Upchurch
We dont want or need publicity. Being in the publics eye is not helping our mission at all. Plenty of guys were applying for training prior to all the hoopla.
Being in the public eye after your mission is over does not hurt it, either. Unless, of course, there are still ongoing operations in Pakistan to kill Osama bin Laden.

I don't understand the complaint. Publicity after the fact should be immaterial to military operations, so long as there is limited details given for the specifics of the operating procedure. Having more applicants to choose from hardly seems like a legitimate problem.
 
"Being in the public eye after your mission is over does not hurt it, either."

By you leave sir, what qualifies you to make such a statement?
 
Not your right to speak, your qualifications to speak about what is good or bad for the Navy SEALs?
 
If you are a SEAL, you know that criticism of the CiC (no matter who he is) is grounds for a Court Martial to be convened.

Which means; I don't think you are a SEAL.

Even though he seems real if I only had a nickel for everyone on the internet that claims to be a Navy SEAL. :rolleyes:

The Navy SEALs are not pleased at all by Mr. Obama's statements.
Our concerns have nothing to do with politics.

First off you only speak for yourself.
Secondly what are your specific issues with anything Obama said because...
Upchurch
We dont want or need publicity. Being in the publics eye is not helping our mission at all. Plenty of guys were applying for training prior to all the hoopla.
...this makes no sense. Obama only announced the raid had happened and what the result was. He didn't even specifically mention it was conducted by SEALs. That was all the media afterword.

And, as was pointed out in this very thread, Obama is still not talking about it.
 
Not your right to speak, your qualifications to speak about what is good or bad for the Navy SEALs?

What reasoning are you using for dismissing it? The argument 'I'm a SEAL and you're not, so I'm right' is fallacious. If you can't explain what you mean, and why you're right, then we're not obliged to believe that you are right.

So again, why is this a bad thing? Why would this be the fault of the president, beside him having given the order that would put them in the spotlight regardless?

I still don't understand what your specific objection is.
 
Probably the same thing that qualifies people to speak as to what is good or bad for the POTUS to do, without being President themselves!
 
NavySEAL - First, like all veterans, I thank you and appreciate your service. I'll defer to ANTPogo's recent post and add this. While the SEALs may not "want or need publicity", considering the high profile nature of the event and result, you shouldn't be surprised that America wants and needs to know and recognize it. Yes, even this President, who made the decision, gets to be proud of their accomplishments. As pointed out earlier, at least he wasn't looking for a photo op standing next to the SEALs under a giant banner. I'm sure that drove you nuts.
 
Go for it Ben!!!! Brave men and women are out there every day putting their lives on the line so you can make such a statement on a public forum.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom