Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

Sure they are!

Don't you know the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are all about defending internet message boards?
 
I honestly feel like the last time we fought a full-on war to literally preserve the Constitutional rights of American citizens was 70 years ago. That's not to say that there have not been smaller-scale (often covert) military actions against people who would wish to completely restructure America from the ground up, but it generally disgusts me to see people take a moral high ground based on being in the military. The idea of deferring to "military = correct," usually in the form of a response like this:

Go for it Ben!!!! Brave men and women are out there every day putting their lives on the line so you can make such a statement on a public forum.

Just reeks of wishing to not address the argument at hand and simply defer to one's occupation (honorable or risky as it may be) to get a sense of being "right."

For example, NavySEAL, I'm sure you are a good person and in no way am insinuating otherwise. On the other hand, I've personally known aspiring neonazis who joined up purely out of a stated desire to kill. Are their opinions on foreign policy more justified than my own, simply because they ostensibly fight for my right to have those opinions?

Surely you can see the moral quagmire we bog ourselves in when we resort to arguments such as these.
 
Last edited:
THIS is why we have a Constitution which renders the military subordinate to civil authority - this attitude that only the military knows its business and that civilians should shut up.


Which part of the Navy SEALs operations do you feel qualified to talk about?

Do you know what an SDV is? Why dont we talk about them?
 
THIS is why we have a Constitution which renders the military subordinate to civil authority - this attitude that only the military knows its business and that civilians should shut up.

That's why Jesse Ventura, BUD/S Class 58, was the Best State Governor Ever, and should be President some day. And why all the conspiracy theories he talked about on his TV show are the utter and complete truth, too.
 
Which part of the Navy SEALs operations do you feel qualified to talk about?

Do you know what an SDV is? Why dont we talk about them?
This is a common fallacy. Mormons tell non-Mormons they are not qualified to discuss Mormonism. Same goes for Scientologists, Homeopathic practitioners, hell Dawkins was criticized for his stance against theism as he is not a theologian.

BTW: Thank you for your service NavySEAL. In any event, I reject that skeptics must be experts in any field before they can talk about that field. By that logic James Randi's qualification is called into question.

I feel unqualified simply because I know next to nothing about special forces other than what I've seen in the media. And I'm skeptical enough to know I can't trust any of that.
 
Which part of the Navy SEALs operations do you feel qualified to talk about?

Do you know what an SDV is? Why dont we talk about them?

I feel qualified to discuss any of it.

The concept that citizens "can't handle the truth" is very much counter to the good of the military and by extension of the country.

The only parts I won't and can't talk about are the parts where your life depends on the equipment I design.

I have not designed anything for your submersibles, and so I can talk about them; I'm glad you have them, and I would approve of expenditures to keep them under active development.
 
NavySEAL said:
Which part of the Navy SEALs operations do you feel qualified to talk about?

This is a common fallacy. Mormons tell non-Mormons they are not qualified to discuss Mormonism. Same goes for Scientologists, Homeopathic practitioners, hell Dawkins was criticized for his stance against theism as he is not a theologian.

Reminds me of this joke:

Q. How many Vietnam veterans does it take to change a light bulb?







A. [with wild-eyed anger] You don't know, man, 'cause you weren't there!!!!

As I've said, I also don't know what it was like to sit on the board at Enron, but I feel entirely qualified to condemn those criminals. Or if you prefer, I have no idea what's like to be the member of a cult like the Charles Manson Family, but I'm qualified to condemn Family members for the murders they committed.
 
I get the feeling that the next 3 pages are going to be a derail about someone taking Joe's post as insinuation that all military members are murderers. I'd like to just nip that in the bud and sum up the argument here so we can all just skip it and move on to more productive things:

1) Are you trying to insinuate that all military members are murderers?
2) No, of course not. Sometimes, they are, sometimes they aren't.
3) When are they? Provide evidence!
4) *Someone drives-by the thread with a one-sentence reply about war being murder or something*
5, etc.) People bicker back and forth with relevant counter-examples and never reach an agreement
6) ALB complains that the thread isn't even close to on the original, interesting topic anymore, since he's a curmudgeon

There. Glad we got those 3 pages out of the way.
 
Anyway, to try and drag things slightly more back on topic, for me the issue is this:

As Commander-in-Chief, the President of the United States of America is qualified to comment on whatever he wants regarding the US military.

As a citizen and voter, I am qualified to comment on whatever I want regarding the President.

Simple as that.
 
Romney said this "Well, thank heavens Barack Obama was not president over the last year, because, had Barack Obama been president over the last year, Osama bin Laden would have been declaring victory in Iraq." and the Fox news faux outrage machine was silent. They (Fox and Romney) have no legs to stand on here. As they reap.

Daredelvis
 
"Being in the public eye after your mission is over does not hurt it, either."

By you leave sir, what qualifies you to make such a statement?

Thank you for your service, but on this point you must be really torqued about the clowns that were involved in this debacle. They really put the SEALs in the spotlight.

I eagerly await your condemnation of everyone involved in Act of Valor, the movie. Alternatively, I can just conclude that your outrage is totally manufactured, and is entirely based on unrelated policy decisions of the president.

You may are a Navy SEAL, but clearly you don't speak for the Navy SEALs when you say,
We dont want or need publicity. Being in the publics eye is not helping our mission at all.
.

Daredelvis
 
Romney said this "Well, thank heavens Barack Obama was not president over the last year, because, had Barack Obama been president over the last year, Osama bin Laden would have been declaring victory in Iraq." and the Fox news faux outrage machine was silent. They (Fox and Romney) have no legs to stand on here. As they reap.

Daredelvis

Source on that one, plz?
 
I kind of think the discussion is going to wither away, since it seems like NavySEAL pulled the "I'm in the military and you're not" card and left. :(
 
the actual ad

I noticed a number of us had not even seen the ad that fox news (and apparently SEALs) are so upset about.

The actual word "SEALs" is use once at the very beginning by Bill Clinton and the majority of the ad is about being able to make tough choices - not the actual raid. I am sorry but NavySEAL I don't understand the objection.

Everyone already knows the event occurred and everyone already knows the SEALs were involved. You can blame the media for that but seeing as how freedom of the press is one of those sacred rights we fight for I don't think thats a good plan of action.

This ad brings no more publicity to the SEALs than was already on them from the media circus that followed the event.

I don't watch FOX news but I can imagine their objection would be along the lines of, "He is stealing the SEALs spot light and should give them more attention!"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom