Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

Which part of the Navy SEALs operations do you feel qualified to talk about?

Are you at all familiar with the First Amendment to the Constitution? It guarantees the right of free speech, and it's not a right that depends on military service.

I for one am glad we don't live in the alternative universe you imagine where speech depends on military service somehow.

I hope it's not a sore spot for you, but your service record also doesn't give you more than one vote on election days--same as the rest of us.
 
Possibly.....They are cool, very cool, they have been called the longest, darkest, and coldest ride a human can withstand.

No shooting=no interest.....just ride.

The British spent 10+ hours at a time in "chariots" (I forget what the British called them, the Italians called them chariots) in various operations, and days in arctic waters in three man submarines to take out Tirpitz, so it isn't just SEALs who deploy in tiny submersibles in the cold and dark.

I know you are the best of the best, and justifiably proud, but give some credit to other elite forces who did things possibly more difficult with technology a lot less reliable.
 
Originally Posted by Trakar
So you only talk about the things SEALs don't talk about in public, when it is something that you personally find "cool?"

Possibly.....They are cool, very cool, they have been called the longest, darkest, and coldest ride a human can withstand.

No shooting=no interest.....just ride.

IMO, a (former) soldier who displays this type of rationalization tendency generally isn't in a position to dictate to others what they can or can't talk about. Men in my former command with such tendencies did not remain in my command for long.
 
I think Obama deserves to be proud of the decision he made and the risk he took and I don't think he's overselling it, I think he has been quite humble actually. I was giddy when I heard the news last year. He also made his position unambiguous prior to the election:
If we have actionable intelligence about high-value terrorist targets and (Pakistani) President Musharraf won’t act, we will.
And he delivered. No surprises.
 
Being a navy seal does not mean elite. I've known quite a few that were lighted it of the Navy for, generally, lazy behavior.

FWIW I was a nuke in the Navy for ten years.
 
While everyone else is throwing out joints prostrating themselves to the SEAL I'd like to point out he hasn't answered some fundamental questions on why he is upset with Obama.
 
Just sing a lullaby, give it some milk, teach the baby to count sheep, set up a musical mobile. How hard can it be?
You are assuming people don't try those things. I'm not sure if you are pulling my leg but let me tell you, the desire to sleep is pretty damn powerful. People actually try everything. Buy books, talk to friends, family and pediatricians.

When my kids were young we tried different diets, different kinds of diapers, the ignore them technique, etc. Two of my kids had night terrors and I'll confess, life was a living hell. I'm not sure how I would have managed without my wife and family members who could help. I'm not exaggerating, and I'm not an idiot. It was damn hard if not always simply impossible. One of the few things that would work more often than other techniques with one of my kids was the car. In the middle of the night you could find me cruising around the block with my child in the child car seat just hoping that when I stopped my child would not wake up.
 
You are assuming people don't try those things. I'm not sure if you are pulling my leg but let me tell you, the desire to sleep is pretty damn powerful. People actually try everything. Buy books, talk to friends, family and pediatricians.

When my kids were young we tried different diets, different kinds of diapers, the ignore them technique, etc. Two of my kids had night terrors and I'll confess, life was a living hell. I'm not sure how I would have managed without my wife and family members who could help. I'm not exaggerating, and I'm not an idiot. It was damn hard if not always simply impossible. One of the few things that would work more often than other techniques with one of my kids was the car. In the middle of the night you could find me cruising around the block with my child in the child car seat just hoping that when I stopped my child would not wake up.

So would it be fair to say that I am not qualified to spout my ignorant opinions?

Sure, I may be legally qualified. I may have the right. But I may not have the background knowledge before my opinions can qualify as informed.

I'm only saying that because I found nothing particularly strange in Navy SEAL's response to Upchurch here:

"Being in the public eye after your mission is over does not hurt it, either."

By you leave sir, what qualifies you to make such a statement?

Some posters, I thought, missed the point when they said the First Amendment qualifies them. I read Navy SEAL's comment as "How do you know that being in the public eye after your mission is over does not hurt it?"
 
You are assuming people don't try those things. I'm not sure if you are pulling my leg but let me tell you, the desire to sleep is pretty damn powerful. People actually try everything. Buy books, talk to friends, family and pediatricians.

When my kids were young we tried different diets, different kinds of diapers, the ignore them technique, etc. Two of my kids had night terrors and I'll confess, life was a living hell. I'm not sure how I would have managed without my wife and family members who could help. I'm not exaggerating, and I'm not an idiot. It was damn hard if not always simply impossible. One of the few things that would work more often than other techniques with one of my kids was the car. In the middle of the night you could find me cruising around the block with my child in the child car seat just hoping that when I stopped my child would not wake up.

And people wonder why I wished laudanum were still legal...
 
So would it be fair to say that I am not qualified to spout my ignorant opinions?
I've no doubt that a few minutes with Google and you would be more than qualified and not so ignorant. Am I right?
 
Last edited:
Some posters, I thought, missed the point when they said the First Amendment qualifies them. I read Navy SEAL's comment as "How do you know that being in the public eye after your mission is over does not hurt it?"
Navy SEAL's not giving a rat's anus about the movie Act of Valor (a movie about Navy SEALs, made by Navy SEALs) indicates that he is not qualified to comment on the impact of Navy SEALs being in the public eye. It is pretty obvious that his outrage is totally based on his dislike of the president.

Daredelvis
 
That's a ridiculous comparison. It's...

*lost in thought*


...We have a saying in the Monketeyverse: fool me once, ...

Never heard that one. How's it go, again? :D

Romney's going to have to live with that particular weather vane gaff. When asked a few months ago what he meant about going about it differently, he should've commented on the uniforms or the support logistics. Instead, he hemmed and hawed and left us to dig up old reports of his '07 statements.
 
I have not seen any solid proof that real military people have a problem with Obama in re whacking ObL.

Most of the comments by real or fake SEALs and assorted other self-styled military commentators harp on what I consider to be utter crap.

Bush the Lesser screwed up the mission to whack ObL, perhaps intentionally, then screwed up the intel operations. I can only conclude that it was to have ObL to play Lex Luthor to his Superman to make it look like we had some actual use for him and the merry morons while they went about the job of reducing working people to peons.

I listened to Obama's speech live. I heard him giving full credit to the SEALs and their leadership for pulling of such a complex mission. He laid out a rather clear program for ending our part of the war in Afghanistan. I see no reason that any military man should have a problem with that.

As for what Mittens thinks of it, screw him. He has never really admitted that Bush the Lesser sucked as C-in-C. This tells me that Mittens would suck tremendously at the job.

As for putting the SEALS in the spotlight, I think it was an entirely valid thing to do. He pointed out the difference between male posturing which leads to the pointless destructikon of whole countries and well-thought-out surgical strikes to accomplish the same thing.

He also pointed out that we do not have the resources for nation-building abroad.

Mittens is probably just pissed off that he cannot show Obama to be a failure as a war leader.
 
First without checking I am declared a phony.
Then I might be real but still a coward.
Now you dont like my conduct.
OK
I am not a phony.
I am not a coward, I have done two combat tours.
My military conduct, the last time I was graded, was one notch down from 4.0.
May we please move on?

Christ man.

Sorry about all scepticism on this sceptics board.

Come on, how many fakers have you met personally?
How many on-line forums and bars and shooting ranges are filled with "special forces" fakers.
Here in the Netherlands, we have yearly recurring incidents of fake veterans showing up at parades, decorated with their medals from Ebay.
 
What Tricky said.

Also, I'll reiterate that "I'm a Navy SEAL. Don't question me or my opinions." is not a valid argument. If NavySEAL has a point to make, he should actually make it.

Or not.

But if he doesn't, there should be no surprise that his opinion is given no more weight than any other opinion on this topic.
 
The sheer hypocrisy of Republicans and Fox News whining about Obama politicizing OBL's death is hilarious. I mean, it's so obviously shameless that it's giving me the honest-to-god laugh-out-loud giggles.
 
Well let us be honest. If McCain was in office he would have made the same decision to get get him.

Perhaps. Keep in mind we are Monday morning quarterbacking here. Go back and consider that the intel was not sure Bin Laden was there. Plus we know the raid worked with no loss of US life. Easy to make the decision to go after Bin Laden when we already know the outcome.

Plus I would add that Obama took the riskier decision in sending in the Seal Team. A more risk averse President might have just bombed the compound remotely so as to not risk US life. Problem then would be in how do you determine if you got Osama?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom