Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

I think that Obama has a enough sense to do the exact opposite of what Fox News concern-trolls for him to do. He'll ride bin Laden's corpse to his reelection like Slim Pickens riding on a nuclear bomb, if that's what it takes.
 
Without knowledge of Obama's actual choices, it's impossible for me to say. If this is simply a case of a tip off that Obama acted upon, I can't think of any reason why any other President would not have done the same thing. If it just comes down to a tip, I think it's silly to claim credit. But if choices he made in an investigation led to the outcome, that's worth taking credit for.

But when it comes down to "Bush did not get Osama but Obama did", it would depend on if Bush got the same information and if he would have surely acted on the same information in the same way.
 
Plus I would add that Obama took the riskier decision in sending in the Seal Team. A more risk averse President might have just bombed the compound remotely so as to not risk US life. Problem then would be in how do you determine if you got Osama?

That is an interesting point and makes me question whether the operation was actually a complete success. One of the reasons for a tactical assault over a bombing would be to capture Bin-Laden alive. I am not saying that killing him makes the mission a failure, but just not as full of a success as it could have been if that was a goal of the mission.
 
But when it comes down to "Bush did not get Osama but Obama did", it would depend on if Bush got the same information and if he would have surely acted on the same information in the same way.
You should also consider, under Bush, if and how such information was pursued. Remember Bush at one point (like Romney) said getting OBL wasn't a top priority.
 
That is an interesting point and makes me question whether the operation was actually a complete success. One of the reasons for a tactical assault over a bombing would be to capture Bin-Laden alive. I am not saying that killing him makes the mission a failure, but just not as full of a success as it could have been if that was a goal of the mission.

Well, I would also add that a reason to choose a tactical assault over a bombing would be the possibility fo verification. With a bombing, there is no chance to verify that you got Osama.

Frankly, if I had been in charge of the tactical assault I would have told the team that our objective was Osama - dead. I would not have announced this publickly though. Taking him captive would have been a huge headache for us and the potential upside of a captive Osama seems rather limited to me.
 
Well, that was a totally unsurprising derail.

NavySEAL, thanks for the service, etc., but I look at your chosen username, and your presumption to speak for everyone who does what you did (in haughty tones, I might add,) and find myself not shocked in the least. And that's kind of sad. Self-caricature coming from people who take themselves very seriously never looks good.
 
Well, back to the original topic, the gripe I heard this morning on the radio was Romney complaining that Obama was politicizing bin Laden's death. I honestly don't know how to respond to that.

Was bin Laden's death too solemn to use as a campaign issues? Is Obama not supposed to mention the good things he has accomplished when campaigning?
 
Well, back to the original topic, the gripe I heard this morning on the radio was Romney complaining that Obama was politicizing bin Laden's death. I honestly don't know how to respond to that.

Was bin Laden's death too solemn to use as a campaign issues? Is Obama not supposed to mention the good things he has accomplished when campaigning?


Ding ding ding ding!

If it's a military success during a Republican administration, it can be hyped loudly, far and wide, parades and flag waving and cross your heart for the Anthem.

If it's a Democratic administration, he'll get criticized for preparing to mention it.

The double standard is insane.
 
Frankly, if I had been in charge of the tactical assault I would have told the team that our objective was Osama - dead. I would not have announced this publickly though. Taking him captive would have been a huge headache for us and the potential upside of a captive Osama seems rather limited to me.
Absolutely agree. On top of that, think of the expense. I do not really see an upside to capturing him vs. killing him. Unless I look at it from OBL's point of view.

Daredelvis
 
If it's a military success during a Republican administration, it can be hyped loudly, far and wide, parades and flag waving and cross your heart for the Anthem.

.

Even if it is a military/intelligence failure during a Republican administration it is also hyped loudly, far and wide.

Daredelvis
 
Well let's not delude ourselves, Fox News' issue with this is only that it was Obama that got the great PR victory out of it. They've made it their mission to get him out of the White House since before it was even certain he'd won the election.
 
If you go back and watch the actual ad that has the right wing panties in a bunch President Obama isn't even speaking, the subject is not the SEALs or Osama, and the theme isn't even military strength.

You have former CIC Clinton talking over mostly still iconic images of presidential/CIC duty and responsibility. Clinton remarks that the President doesn't get do overs when it comes to military decisions. The ad is about President Obama's courage even when risking everything to do what was right and necessary.

I feel it goes to highlight the campaigns (both Romney's and Obama's) comments about flip flopping and etch-a-sketch. I mean Mitt has now even flip flopped on this issue! He said it wasn't worth it but now says, "Of course I would have."
 
There are reports that Sec'y of State Gates advised against the raid. So to say that it was a no-brainer is wonderfully accurate hindsight.

I'm still waiting for our Navy SEAL to explain exactly what his issue is with this whole thing.
 
There are reports that Sec'y of State Gates advised against the raid. So to say that it was a no-brainer is wonderfully accurate hindsight.

I'm still waiting for our Navy SEAL to explain exactly what his issue is with this whole thing.

Since we've already derailed once, what is it about Republican administrations the military at large seems to love so much? Is it the $ that gets apportioned to the forces, or the likelihood to be sent into battle?
 
Monketey Ghost
A democrat formed the Navy SEALs. JFK
Doesnt matter who is POTUS, SEAL $$$$ stays the same.
Yet to meet the SEAL who wanted to get into a gun fight.
 
Monketey Ghost
A democrat formed the Navy SEALs. JFK
Doesnt matter who is POTUS, SEAL $$$$ stays the same.
Yet to meet the SEAL who wanted to get into a gun fight.

And we've yet to get one here to explain what his issue is with respect to the OP.
 
There are reports that Sec'y of State Defense Gates advised against the raid. So to say that it was a no-brainer is wonderfully accurate hindsight.

I'm still waiting for our Navy SEAL to explain exactly what his issue is with this whole thing.
ftfy
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom