Nibiru, Planet X and the Doomsday Magnetic Field

The claims seem to change daily. First Nibiru was merely the 12th planet (Sitchin), then it was the 12th planet headed for a collision with the Earth (Lieder), then it was a brown dwarf star replete with planets, then it was a comet, then it was an asteroid.

It's the all-purpose doomsday object. Whatever anomalous celestial object the believer spots that day -- real or imagined -- is labeled "Nibiru" and submitted as proof of our imminent destruction.
 
The claims seem to change daily. First Nibiru was merely the 12th planet (Sitchin), then it was the 12th planet headed for a collision with the Earth (Lieder), then it was a brown dwarf star replete with planets, then it was a comet, then it was an asteroid.

It's the all-purpose doomsday object. Whatever anomalous celestial object the believer spots that day -- real or imagined -- is labeled "Nibiru" and submitted as proof of our imminent destruction.


So then the name has reverted to its original usage and once again refers to whichever planet is under observation? ;)
 
Thanks for that, MG. I reported that almost verbatim to my friend. Not that it will do a lick of good. His ears are plugged up with brown dwarfs and ancient aliens.

My pleasure - it highlights the difficulty any government would have in trying to control the information. Similar to events in Contact. Anything unusual is found the first thing people do is reach out to other groups for verification.

Astronomy is a science that has benefited enormously from the internet
 
First Nibiru was merely the 12th planet (Sitchin).

if you like I could post some more details of exactly why cylinder seal VA 243 does not show 12 planets, or I could post some definitive proof of Sitchin fabricating evidence of "astronauts" for his books, or both
;)
 
if you like I could post some more details of exactly why cylinder seal VA 243 does not show 12 planets, or I could post some definitive proof of Sitchin fabricating evidence of "astronauts" for his books, or both
;)

Sure, why not? Let this thread be a repository for such junk science, followed by our thorough debunking of such nonsense.

MG1962: Keep those observations and communiques with your astronomer friends coming.
 
For those unfamiliar with this ridiculous claim, Nibiru (also called Planet X among other names) is a planet hiding on the far side of the sun which will collide with, or nearly collide with, the Earth -- as some believe, this year.

Point out that we should see it by now, if this were true. I mean, SEE IT. With our eyes.
 
... which is the real danger of this kind of pernicious nonsense.

My friend (mentioned in the OP) is in his 40s and buys into this fear-mongering Nibiru crud.

What emotional or psychological need is being fed or satiated by the prospect of imminent planetary doom? To the point that any and all solid evidence to the contrary is ignored or rejected in favor of a system of belief that centers on the annihilation of humanity?

I just don't see the attraction.

Make a huge bet with him. ;)
 
The claims seem to change daily. First Nibiru was merely the 12th planet (Sitchin), then it was the 12th planet headed for a collision with the Earth (Lieder), then it was a brown dwarf star replete with planets, then it was a comet, then it was an asteroid.

It's the all-purpose doomsday object. Whatever anomalous celestial object the believer spots that day -- real or imagined -- is labeled "Nibiru" and submitted as proof of our imminent destruction.

It's a doom-of-the-gaps !
 
Point out that we should see it by now, if this were true. I mean, SEE IT. With our eyes.

I have (see post #32). He responds by pointing at anything in the sky he doesn't understand or know about, and claims (for the moment) that that's Nibiru. When I debunk that claim, he moves on to another one.

It's pointless, and I'm pretty much done with him.
 
okies, here is one of many cylinder seals which Sitchin used to support his Alien Hypothesis,
Hermitage.jpg

he never states where the original is held and you never see a photo of it, its just a line drawing done by Sitchin himself, thats a little odd to start with, if he's seen the seal with his own eyes surely it would be easier and more logical to just post a photo.

this I copied from www.sitchin.com where Sitchin states it shows
an astronaut (“Fishman”, equipped for splashdowns) on Mars
The astronaut is supposedly the character on the far right

which is odd, here is a photo of a real cylinder seal from about 1700BCE,
tiamat.gif

you'll notice there is a familiar figure on the far right
womanyc2.jpg

even the star indicating that the figure is a deity has been copied

make no mistake about this, the artists that carved cylinder seals did not have any way of mass producing them, they were created on individual commission, so you never find identical images on two seals as each was carved by hand and one of a kind

as you can see Sitchin has reproduced the original with a few small changes
the clothing has become more cyber and the headdress is now a helmet.
the character which appears on a babylonian cylinder seal is described by Sitchin as Sumerian, which if you were paying attention earlier and recognise this as the fight between Bel Marduk and Tiamat you will already know is actually Babylonian. Again cylinder seals were not massed produced in the same culture, so you're even more unlikely to see exactly the same figure on a Sumerian seal circa 3000BCE and again 1200 years later on a Babylonian one,

The funniest thing about this is that the figure on the original seal is actually a woman believed to be Inanna which can be seen by the fact that shes actually wearing a dress.

the symbol in the middle is known as the winged disc, its a symbol associated with dragon killing cultures and specifically the dragon killing god, its design has changed from ancient times until some of the last appeared in symbolising Ahura Mazda, the dragon killing god of Zoroaster where it was called the "Faravahar"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faravahar
here's one of those circa 800BCE
Faravahar6.jpg

Again the similarities are overwhelming. the Iranian version is the only one which has those blocky shaped wings, all the others are represented with birds wings like this example from Susa in Mesopotamia
winged-disk20Susa.jpg

then take a look at the sword on the far left of Sitchins picture. it is shown as a typical lovely straight edged medieval shaped sword which is very strange, because straight swords weren't used until the Roman period, even then in the Mesopotamian region they were using a sword called "sappara", which is for want of a better description what most people call a "scimitar"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sickle-sword
finally we come to the smallest detail, the fish
you'll see it here in its original form on a seal from 2400BCE
boat2200.jpg

and if you look to the far left of this seal you will see another female figure which again is Inanna except this being a seal from Akkadian culture she is represented in a different style.

so Sitchins seal contains elements from:-
a cylinder seal circa 1700BCE
a symbol from 800BCE
a sword that didn't exist then
a cylinder seal circa 2400BCE

Are you starting to see why Sitchin never produces the original artifact that his line drawing supposedly represents.
It is imo, evidence like this that show that Sitchin is not just offering his interpretation, but actually manufacturing evidence to support it, this changes him from "misguided" to "fraudulent", Sitchin came up with the twelth planet concept in the same way, by interpreting a cylinder seal and lieing about what it depicts. I think my earlier article on the "scorpion planet" illustrates that quite well already
:D
 
Last edited:
Excellent work, your Mardukliness. Sitchin = officially exposed as a liar and a fraud.

My friend doesn't even bring up Sumeria anymore WRT Nibiru, so resounding has our annihilation been of the Russian-born economics historian's claims.

Evidently, however, to "Larry" it does not matter who originated the claim or how fraudulent the work of that originator has been shown to be. So many huxsters have picked up the sigil of Nibiru since the advent of the Intertoobz that what (for him) has to be addressed now are the many lengthy youtube videos purportedly depicting photography of a brown dwarf/infrared star/imaginary celestial object.

And I don't have the time to watch that crap, much less deliver a thorough debunking of the various absurdist claims being made -- especially when "Larry" never addresses my arguments, just ignores them and moves on to some new, entirely different claim.

It never ends. :rolleyes:
 
It never ends. :rolleyes:

in about 8 months it'll end in one way or another, what you should do is up the stakes, bet your friend $100 that nothing will happen on dec 21 this year, hes thinking we're all going to die, so he'll have nothing to lose by accepting.
Then bet him another $100 that after dec 22 the fringers will be recalculating a new date and pretending that their first error didn't happen. You'll be seeing a lot of pages taken down on December 22nd

Then bet him another $100 that the fringe authorities will announce the next end time prediction for 2029 or 2036
but don't tell him about this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/99942_Apophis
just tell him its a date out of thin air

you'll win $300 and Larry will stfu because people get very serious when theyre losing money on something theyve been humiliated into realising is fraudulent.

:D
 
1. Gambling is not my style. I'm just not interested in it, and it doesn't prove anything. Facts and evidence are my tools, not monetary risk or enrichment.

2. "Larry" is dirt-poor, lives with his ex-girlfriend and has no job. Even if I was interested in making bets with him, he would have no means of meeting my ante.

3. "Larry" already knows about Apophis. I had to debunk that one for him, too. The chances of it hitting us are infinitesimally small.
 
Sorry, laying bets is just not my style. Come December 22, either the Earth will be incinerated/annihilated/destabilized/electromagnetically screwed, or it won't be. No money need change hands to demonstrate that the claimant has been embarrassingly, humiliatingly mistaken in his ridiculous, unsupported inventions and bare assertions.

I think you may be missing a point (OK, its not that clear, I admit).

These guys, IMHO, don't actually believe in this doomsday crap. So, they say they believe and/or know a major catastrophe is on its way and keep living their lives, its business as usual for them during the countdown? Are they building bunkers and stocking food, fuel, batteries weapons and ammo? Have they moved to higher ground? An analogy: you're at the beach and the tsunami alert sounds. What will you do? Stay as you were, drinking beer or eating an icecream or "run to the hills, run for your liiiiife"?

The bet idea is "put up or shut up", the way I see it. If I believed an impending doomsday were knocking at my door, I would have already moved to somewhere else, far from cities and shorelines, a nice solid cave or abandomned mine with a hidden entrance, loaded with provisions.
 
okies, here is one of many cylinder seals which Sitchin used to support his Alien Hypothesis,
[qimg]http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/nn118/hazzakan/Hermitage.jpg[/qimg]
he never states where the original is held and you never see a photo of it, its just a line drawing done by Sitchin himself, thats a little odd to start with, if he's seen the seal with his own eyes surely it would be easier and more logical to just post a photo.

this I copied from www.sitchin.com where Sitchin states it shows

Marduk - you clearly have no idea how to interpret faked drawings. It is clear first that this image is both real and accurate. Clearly we see a fine domestic scene - the figure on the left is in charge of operating the solar fired BBQ - character on the right - commonly referred to as "The wife" is clearly concerned that the figure on the left - sometimes identified as "The husband" has neglected his food preparation duties in deference to practicing his juggling skill - and the evening meal of fried dolphin remains incomplete
 
My theory is that "Larry" gloms on to this stuff because believing it -- or pretending to believe it -- gives him an excuse not to 1) get a job, 2) get a life, 2) pull his head out of the sand/his proverbial ass.

For the sake of reader interest, I submit now the first of a series of e-mail exchanges between Larry and me. This one is from last Friday:

Larry said:
nibiru is that it is a star / sun itself with possibly 5 to 6 moons and maybe even a small planet in orbit around it therefore it would be more like two solar systems coming into the orbital paths of one another rather than a single planet crossing through our solar system.not sure how that would affect all that new math you were throwing at me but im sure it would have to change it in some way with those differant variables involved.also the most intriguing thing about the whole subject is the ancient cultures which seem to posses knowledge of our solar system that could not be gained by staring at the night sky with the naked eye and they all have similar stories of a planet / or star appearing and causing problems on earth.anyway gonna go read your 3rd installment and i will get back to ya.

My response:

So now Nibiru is a star? After Sitchin and Lieder, who "discovered"/proposed/invented Planet X/Nibiru have stated that it is the supposed 12th planet of ours solar system? Pardon me, but the ******** is thickening.

Okay, let's take your non-expert, non-scientist, fear-mongering, paranormal-believing sources at their word, and allow that Nibiru is indeed a solar system. The good news is WE'D BE ABLE TO SEE IT... BUT WE CAN'T!

If Nibiru were only a planet and it was on a trajectory to collide with the Earth some time this year, it would be as visible as Mars to the naked eye (see the table on Magnitude I gave you in a previous message). If it were a star, [Larry], it would be AS VISIBLE AS THE SUN.

Of course, there is indeed a star headed straight toward us... but it isn't Nibiru (unless you want to name it that for sheer entertainment purposes) and it won't be hitting us for about a million years. From a 2010 article in Scientific American at http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=star-set-to-collide-with-solar-syst-2010-03:

"New calculations show that the orange dwarf, called Gliese 710, will crash through the Oort Cloud that surrounds the Sun. The disruption to this shell of many billions of icy fragments would launch a shower of comets into the inner solar system, threatening the planets with devastating impacts.

Some believe it could lead to a repeat of the Late Heavy Bombardment that left the Moon covered with craters around 4 billion years ago. The good news is that the star is not expected to arrive for a million or more years.

The threat from Gliese 710, a star with about half the mass of the sun 63 light-years away in the constellation of the Serpent, is rated as 86 per cent likely. That is nearly as good as a certainty.

It comes after a European space telescope called Hipparcos measured precise positions and motions for 1000,000 stars in our cosmic neighbourhood. This allowed astronomers to work out accurately which might come close to the sun as they travel around the galaxy.

Russian astronomer Dr Vadim Bobylev, of the Pulkovo Astronomical Observatory in St Petersburg examined new data from 2007. He identified nine stars that have had or will have particularly close encounters by coming within 3 light-years of us."​

[Larry]! Why is this super-powered telescope observing Gliese 710 but is somehow missing a star with an expected arrival date of December 2012? Why can't see this huge ball of luminous gases with the naked eye? Why are the tens of thousands of amateur astronomers all over the world somehow blind to an entire solar system approaching us at millions of miles per hour?

Here's why: It's horse****. And I'm done with it. Believe what you like.
 
Last edited:
Marduk - you clearly have no idea how to interpret faked drawings. It is clear first that this image is both real and accurate. Clearly we see a fine domestic scene - the figure on the left is in charge of operating the solar fired BBQ - character on the right - commonly referred to as "The wife" is clearly concerned that the figure on the left - sometimes identified as "The husband" has neglected his food preparation duties in deference to practicing his juggling skill - and the evening meal of fried dolphin remains incomplete

don't be silly, they didn't have solar fired BBQ's. All their food was created in an electric processor, seen here on the left of the picture
adam1.jpg

:D

Scott, it would be AS VISIBLE AS THE SUN.

Scott! Why is this super-powered telescope observing .

hey no fair, I thought he was "Larry"
:D
but its kinda obvious where he got the idea that Nibiru is a star surrounded by planets from

cylinder_seal_va243.jpg

;)
Sitchin claimed the central object was the sun, not Nibiru, Michael Heiser then showed the Sitchenites that it was the usual depiction of "Star" depicted which is quite different from the usual depiction of "Sun"
now Larry Scott is calling it a star surrounded by planets
thats third generation woo right there
;)
its actually the Pleiades, called MUL.MUL in Mesopotamia, a word that translates as "Star. Stars"
 
Last edited:
It never ends. :rolleyes:

Sorry Vortigern,

You stepped their obvious trap. The believers I mean. You're not a betting man, as you have mentioned, but I would bet he is laughing behind your back with his believer friends about how he stood you up and showed you what's what...

Sad thing is, you were wrong to ever engage him in the debate to begin with. Debating a believer serves no purpose, ever. Don't do it. Resist the temptation at all costs.
It is the prophets and priests that need to be drawn into debate. Sadly, because they know that they are only spewing chudbabies, they will never be acquiescent to such a debate. EVER.

Lucky thing is, you hit the nail and found truth in your endeavor. "It never ends".
Damn right it doesn't.
Doomsday hype is nothing more at it's toplevel than scaring people. The only purpose is for them to spend their money on your book or video on how to survive.
Your one question struck me as offside and quite something to ponder.

Paraphrased: "What is to be gained from their Doomsday fears etc?"
Well truth is, the large scope is money at the top level.
The mid level believers all participate in forwarding it, for their own gains, usually attention.
The low-level believers are the one's who lose. This is the category I suspect your friend belongs to. They gain nothing. At least not tangibly. These lowlevel followers are usually also society's outcasts. They feel the weight of the world is too much for them, and most likely stage 2 or 3 of suicide.
The only thing they ever gain from this is some distant shimmer of hope that all this suffering is about to finally end, and that they won't have to do the dirty work themselves.
In the non-suicidal cases, it is often also motivated by other social aspects. Racists would view it as "finally being rid of all those snow mexicans (eskimos)", even if it means they go as well. "At least it's all over now".

Erase the debt records they have been unable to cope with.
Stop the constant need to look for work that I cannot get.
An end to this nagging whore in my ear that dunked 3 kids all over my dreams.

There are things to be gained by these people. Trying to tell them that their "saviour" is not coming, is too much for their senses to bare. The better way of addressing lowlevel believers is to show them that the world is not as bad as they think - which could be even harder than the actual debate you were having to begin with - but at least that path has producible/predictable/valuable results.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom