Nibiru, Planet X and the Doomsday Magnetic Field

Another exchange:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nI5iBtIJr24&feature=email

Larry said:
you have to see this is exactly what i was seeing last night only the light was orange and green

And my reply:

If the colors are different, then it wasn't "exactly" what you saw. To say "this is exactly what i was seeing last night" and then go on to explain that it was not exactly what you saw is disingenuous and confusing. Either it was exactly like what you saw, or it wasn't. Turns out it wasn't, so what's the point?

We've already established, via [our mutual friend] Jason's device which I examined last night, that the bright star in the west isn't Nibiru. It's Vindemiatrix, also called Epsilon Virginis, which is a giant star 10 times the size of our sun, and radiates about 77 times the energy as our sun.

Vindemiatrix is currently a little closer to us along its (and our) orbital path, so it looks brighter than usual.

When you zoomed in on it the other night with a digital device, the image software likely created artifacts because the device is not a telescope, and cannot accurately capture a pulsing blob of light with no discernible features. Zooming in on a digital image of a blob of light does not actually increase the level of detail that the device can record. or reveal hidden images that the eye cannot see. It shows you a larger blob of light, only with much bigger pixels because you've zoomed in to a pixellated image.

At best, the device you were using may have been capturing the pulsating energetic output of this incredibly bright, giant star, Vindemiatrix. Either way there is nothing paranormal or unusual about it. Nibiru is not coming. Don't quit your dayjob.
 
Sorry Vortigern,

You stepped their obvious trap. The believers I mean. You're not a betting man, as you have mentioned, but I would bet he is laughing behind your back with his believer friends about how he stood you up and showed you what's what...

Sad thing is, you were wrong to ever engage him in the debate to begin with. Debating a believer serves no purpose, ever. Don't do it. Resist the temptation at all costs.

You're entitled to your opinion, but I disagree wholeheartedly. If no one engaged the woos then 1) this forum would not exist, and 2) no one would ever be persuaded through evidence to abandon their irrational beliefs. Whether you are aware of it or not, it does happen. People change their minds through a preponderance of evidence and persistent argumentation.

I know this because I've seen it first-hand.

Also, see my signature, below. :cool:

ETA: The second half of your post (which I snipped prior to reading it) is quite insightful. "The only thing they ever gain from this is some distant shimmer of hope that all this suffering is about to finally end, and that they won't have to do the dirty work themselves." That describes Larry to a "T", I think.
 
Last edited:
If no one engaged the woos then 1) this forum would not exist, and 2) no one would ever be persuaded through evidence to abandon their irrational beliefs. Whether you are aware of it or not, it does happen. People change their minds through a preponderance of evidence
I would not be here telling you what I know about Mesopotamia, I was 2 once
:D
is nothing I've said tangible wheunis ?
 
And I used to believe in bigfoot, the Loch Ness monster, and other modestly, superficially biologically plausible cryptids. But a long, slow examination of the facts, and the persistent and persuasive arguments of several JREF contributors, convinced me otherwise.
 
You're entitled to your opinion, but I disagree wholeheartedly. If no one engaged the woos then 1) this forum would not exist, and 2) no one would ever be persuaded through evidence to abandon their irrational beliefs. Whether you are aware of it or not, it does happen. People change their minds through a preponderance of evidence and persistent argumentation.

I know this because I've seen it first-hand.

Also, see my signature, below. :cool:

ETA: The second half of your post (which I snipped prior to reading it) is quite insightful. "The only thing they ever gain from this is some distant shimmer of hope that all this suffering is about to finally end, and that they won't have to do the dirty work themselves." That describes Larry to a "T", I think.

I have tried on many occasions - unsuccessful myself. Opinion absolutely. Personal Experience - yeah mix that in there.
I have yet in my life to successfully swing a person one way or the other. They're just so attached to their woo that even death would only serve to prove their point...

My "enlightenment" came a decade or two ago. Same **** different era. Some thing is coming for us, and we cant see it, and omg we all gonna die. You get the idea...
An acquaintance of mine was solid in his belief in all of it. Quit his job, put down his pets, built shelter, the whole 9 man!
And even 2 years AFTER the event DID NOT take place - he just jumped the next one. Right now he is still on that same string - all these decades later - saying that "this time its for real, Niburu is the REAL DEAL! I HAVE SEEN IT!!!".

Funny part of it is that same phrase, in EVERY SINGLE occurrence, quoted. EVERY single one was just a "miscalculation", even through the claims of seeing it themselves.

The delusion has set in so deep for the believers, that nothing, not even the faker himself admitting fakery, would dissuade them.
Sociopath behavior at it's finest, really...
 
And I used to believe in bigfoot, the Loch Ness monster, and other modestly, superficially biologically plausible cryptids. But a long, slow examination of the facts, and the persistent and persuasive arguments of several JREF contributors, convinced me otherwise.

OOH! OOH! OOH!

THAT is what makes you different from Larry. You were curious enough to start the examination yourself.
You had no REASON TO CLING to the fallacies.

These believers have actual reasons (in their minds anyway) to cling to these things.

The first step to truth is to WANT IT FOR YOURSELF.
 
I hear you Wheunis. But part of my purpose here in posting this stuff publicly is so that the fence-sitters, the salvageable minds, can be persuaded back to reality. My friend Larry may be a lost cause, or he may not be, but there are definitely lurkers out there wondering which side to accept/believe, and I hope that this thread will lead them to the light of scientific methodology and critical thinking.

Now a previous exchange between Larry and me, detailing his first glimpse of the star he thought might be Nibiru:

Larry said:
hey noah saw very bright star tonight in the western sky @ about the 10 oclock position from 9pm till now never seen anything this bright before jason says he thinks it is virgo,we used a cell phone to zoom in on it you could actually see a orange plum of light extending from the top and bottom and spinng orange light around it ,thought you might shed some light on this ,was strange cause a 3yr old girl drew a picture an hr before of a space ship we askher if aliens told her to draw it she look @ us and said GOD told her to.

My response:

Yes, children have any number of irrational beliefs and say very unpredictable things. Are you submitting this as proof of a divine being? What is your point here?
 
Moving on to the next youtube video (which Larry gives me as some form of evidence of his ludicrous imaginings):

Larry said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zz2yilwoMqI&feature=email
i know things can be photo shoped but this looks real

And my predictable reply:

Pardon me, but... this is 4 and a half minutes of inscrutable imagery of the sky. We see the sun and some unidentified celestial object which we are meant to take, on the sole authority of the video's creator, as a "brown dwarf" that's headed on a collision course towards the Earth.

Not a single professional astronomer, independent researcher, nor one of the tens of thousands of amateur astronomers the world over agree with the crackpot conclusions of the creator of this video.

On what basis am I -- are we, any of us -- to accept the claims of a youtube video over the vast preponderance of evidence that points to nothing at all alarming, eventful or unusual in the night sky? Perhaps more importantly, why do /you/ believe a youtube video holds answers to the secret doom of the Earth that thousands of others -- experts and amateurs alike -- dismiss as pure invention?

I suggest acquiring some astronomical software for yourself, buying a telescope and matching up what you're seeing in the sky with the software. Just like we used last night, and in about 11 seconds proved that the mysteriously bright object in the west was, in fact, Vindemiatrix, despite your earlier assertions that [our friend] Jason's software could not locate the star in question.

You are being deluded. Someone has sold you a bill of goods -- doom! fear! the end is night! -- and you've bought it without inspecting it for lies or mistakes. To separate fantasy from reality, you have to use critical thought processes and examine claims as they arise. Research and attempt to falsify every bit of extraordinary data that comes your way. Don't just accept these outrageous claims without looking for signs of fraud, error or stupidity.

The Nibiru claim is alternately fraudulent (Sitchin and Lieder), riddled with errors or just plain stupid. There is not a shred of evidence for its existence.
 
And finally:

Larry said:
im sure your right , but there was no comment on the '2 hr lecture video did you get a chance to view it yet ?

And me:

Why? How valuable will my comments on the video be to you? You haven't addressed a single point I've made so far. I don't see why I'm being invited to spend time crafting careful rebuttals which you then proceed to ignore.

The pattern of our exchanges so far has been:

1. You come at me with a number of claims.
2. I find hard evidence to defeat the baseless speculations of your sources.
3. You move on to some new extraordinary claim without either a) offering some shred of evidence to support your source's imaginings, or b) admitting your sources were in error.

It seems fairly pointless to me now. I have little interest in investing two hours of my time in considering the possible truthfulness of evident fictions, lies, errors, delusions and fraud which I've already spent a week or more dissecting and exposing as complete and utter baloney.

Is there anything new in this 2-hour video that I haven't already heard or addressed? If so -- if it is indeed chock full of new! amazing! claims regarding this impending Doomsday Event codenamed "Nibiru"-- will you please ask yourself why no other person in the world apart from this single youtube creator is advancing these remarkable new claims?

Will you ask yourself why we should accept the fanciful assertions of a single youtube video creator over the preponderance of concrete evidence gathered from a host of scientific disciplines and independent research teams which have no affiliation with any government?

Will you please acquaint yourself with the scientific method by typing that two-word phrase -- scientific method -- into a yahoo search?

And if not -- if the 2-hour video is full of the same claims I've already addressed, please explain the point of watching it.

Nibiru is not coming. Don't quit your dayjob.
 
And I used to believe in bigfoot, the Loch Ness monster, and other modestly, superficially biologically plausible cryptids. But a long, slow examination of the facts, and the persistent and persuasive arguments of several JREF contributors, convinced me otherwise.
.
60 years ago, I'd devour the articles on crypto-everythings in "True" (just about all of which turned to be untrue) and "Argosy". Amazing stuff there. :)
Their modern counterparts don't even attract my attention.
"Weekly World News" was fun to read while it lasted.
Amazing photoshopping efforts before the days of Photoshop.
 
I have tried on many occasions - unsuccessful myself. Opinion absolutely. Personal Experience - yeah mix that in there.
I have yet in my life to successfully swing a person one way or the other. They're just so attached to their woo that even death would only serve to prove their point...
.

I have succeeded, but usually its not the facts that persuade them, its this
Sitchin said:
He gained a degree in economics from the University of London, and worked as an editor and journalist in Israel,
Woo proponents don't trust the press, they assume the press is part of the government cover up, when they find out that they've bought into something written by a journalist, its all over for that belief system because the next thing they do is check the backgrounds of the other authors on their bookshelves for other journos. That eliminates David Hatcher Childress, Graham Hancock, Giorgio A. Tsoukalos, and Robert K. G. Temple, these are the big boys of the ETH, that leaves them with David Icke,
nuff said
:D
 
Giorgio A. Tsoukalos

Threw up in my mouth a little...

I absolutely loathe that windblown little odious pest...
And his hair freaks me the F*** out! Now THAT is worthy of Alien investigation!

A good point.
But I would not do this myself as part of an argument, unless appropriate.
I would not paint Journo's as the solution just to the detriment of Journos by default.
Yes, true, a very large of the Journo population is scum; Then again, at least a same portion of atheists conduct themselves the same way.

Should we demean our arguments to such low blow tactics?
A difficult topic within that question... Should we pull lowblows and cheapshots just to sway discussions in our own favor?
 
Threw up in my mouth a little...

I absolutely loathe that windblown little odious pest...
And his hair freaks me the F*** out! Now THAT is worthy of Alien investigation!
Giorgio.jpg

hehe
I would not paint Journo's as the solution just to the detriment of Journos by default.

thats unnecessary, they already regard the press as scum. Its a (for them) natural assumption, if there really were aliens, the press should be reporting it, why aren't they.
obviously because the press is in league with the government. The only other explanation is that the press aren't reporting it because there isn't anything to report. Thats unacceptable, see your average woo can not ever accept that theyve been fooled, they believe they are far too intelligent for that, so the only remaining answer is that someone has lied to them. So they reject the liars and then try to focus on the evidence from non journos, who they now regard as full time liars, when they look for that evidence, its game over, because the only place left to research the facts is Academic publications

Academia is usually the first time they learn critical analytical skills, books written by academics are full of assumption, but its well thought out empirical evidence based assumption

I usually recommend the works of Sir Leonard Woolley as a great source material for Mesopotamian facts, from my perspective because he was an adventuring Indiana Jones type archaeologist who knew his stuff and could spin a good yarn, but primarily for the following reason

DIGGING UP THE PAST. (Paperback) by Sir Leonard. Woolley
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-li...?ie=UTF8&qid=1335300716&sr=1-3&condition=used cost £0.01

History unearthed (Paperback) by Leonard Woolley
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-li...?ie=UTF8&qid=1335300716&sr=1-5&condition=used cost £0.01

UR The First Phases [Hardcover] by Leonard Woolley
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-li...?ie=UTF8&qid=1335300716&sr=1-9&condition=used cost £0.01

A Forgotten Kingdom (Paperback) by Sir leonard Woolley
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-listing/B000N5GGQ4/ref=dp_olp_used_mbc?ie=UTF8&condition=used cost £0.01

Ur of the Chaldees : seven years of excavation (Paperback) by Sir C Leonard Woolley
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-listing/B00086JI9K/ref=dp_olp_all_mbc?ie=UTF8&condition=all cost £0.50

The young archaeologist (A Practical book) [Hardcover] by Leonard Woolley
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-listing/B0000CL7S1/ref=dp_olp_used_mbc?ie=UTF8&condition=used cost £1.00

i.e. They could buy all of them for the price of one Sitchin paperback
:D
 
Last edited:
thats unnecessary, they already regard the press as scum.

Ok, let me try bring my point across differently.
You should please excuse the following outburst as merely demonstrational.

Marduk, sir.
You are despicable. You hate how woo proponents turn people's weaknesses and fears against them in order to make their story's more believable.
And yet, here you sit in your cheeto-stained chair, claiming to have done the exact same thing! You are no skeptic, you are simply a fanatic of the other side.

/Demonstrational part ends

See there? That's what I was trying to convey.
Don't you think it is quite unethical to turn people's weaknesses and fears against them, Just so you can swing them to your side of the debate?
That's EXACTLY what woo sells...
 
Ok, let me try bring my point across differently.
You should please excuse the following outburst as merely demonstrational.

Marduk, sir.
You are despicable. You hate how woo proponents turn people's weaknesses and fears against them in order to make their story's more believable.
And yet, here you sit in your cheeto-stained chair, claiming to have done the exact same thing! You are no skeptic, you are simply a fanatic of the other side.

/Demonstrational part ends

See there? That's what I was trying to convey.
Don't you think it is quite unethical to turn people's weaknesses and fears against them, Just so you can swing them to your side of the debate?
That's EXACTLY what woo sells...

Nope, in my morale structure if you're telling the truth, then thats whats important
I'm not beyond a little psychological manipulation, I'm human

what are you saying wheunis, you don't regard journos as unethical yourself ?
didn't you say earlier ?
a very large of the Journo population is scum; Then again, at least a same portion of atheists conduct themselves the same way.
just for the record, I'm not an atheist.
:p
 
Last edited:
Another exchange:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nI5iBtIJr24&feature=email



And my reply:

If the colors are different, then it wasn't "exactly" what you saw. To say "this is exactly what i was seeing last night" and then go on to explain that it was not exactly what you saw is disingenuous and confusing. Either it was exactly like what you saw, or it wasn't. Turns out it wasn't, so what's the point?

Just to help you out - the blocked out section of sky is the Sun. The other image is the Moon. In the second image he showed I believe that should be the Moon, but possibly the Sun. The clue is Mercury
 
I hear you Wheunis. But part of my purpose here in posting this stuff publicly is so that the fence-sitters, the salvageable minds, can be persuaded back to reality. My friend Larry may be a lost cause, or he may not be, but there are definitely lurkers out there wondering which side to accept/believe, and I hope that this thread will lead them to the light of scientific methodology and critical thinking.

Now a previous exchange between Larry and me, detailing his first glimpse of the star he thought might be Nibiru:



My response:

Yes, children have any number of irrational beliefs and say very unpredictable things. Are you submitting this as proof of a divine being? What is your point here?

Is there anything this guy doesn't believe in ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom