Nibiru, Planet X and the Doomsday Magnetic Field

Vortigern99

Sorcerer Supreme
Joined
Mar 7, 2009
Messages
7,905
Location
Austin, Texas
Hey all.

A friend of mine is into this Nibiru collision/magnetic field disruption baloney, and I'm trying to amass a whopper of a rebuttal to his uncritical delusions.

For those unfamiliar with this ridiculous claim, Nibiru (also called Planet X among other names) is a planet hiding on the far side of the sun which will collide with, or nearly collide with, the Earth -- as some believe, this year.

The Sumerians knew about it, some African tribe called the Doga know about it, and possibly the Mayans as well. :rolleyes:

Any scientific rebuttal to this preposterous claim (such as: the gravity of this unseen planet would be detectable in the orbits of the other planets of our solar system) has so far been met by my deluded friend with protestations of a NASA cover-up.

Will you help me construct an iron-clad rebuttal to this nonsense? My friend is not, I believe, a lost cause: he is an intelligent but woefully under-educated person who has uncritically accepted a bill of goods that someone (or a host of someones) has sold him. I think that if I can show him where his sources are blatantly mistaken, I can blast the cotton from his ears and bring him back to the good side of the Force.

Thanks to any and all future contributors.
 
The Sumerians knew about it, some African tribe called the Doga know about it, and possibly the Mayans as well. :rolleyes:

They were Dogons and they had no legends regarding any of this rubbish. They were apparently aware of a white dwarf star around Sirius. Anthropologists have pretty much put this to bed. Fascinating story actually

NASA controls virtually none of the world's telescopes.
 
Get "The 12th Planet" by Zechariah Sitchin.
It's the source for all this Niburu nonsense.
Sitchin lists lots of qualifications as an archeologist, which are generally disparaged by his peers.
His cosmology is even worse.
The basic scenario of a monster planet whipping through the Solar System every 3000 years can't stand scrutiny at all.
That there could be genetically compatible inhabitants on the thing that flit from there to here when it passes "perigee" is totally absurd. Solar system objects orbit the Sun, and have a perihelion. And an aphelion at the other end. Sitchin has these things using the Earth as the close focus point, error one. It goes downhill from there.
His interpretations of Sumerian glyphs and images is just plain cuckoo!
The events described as occurring 3 billion years and further in the past as he says are replicated in those old artifacts can't have been observed by anyone!
There wasn't anything sentient around to observe, much less record for posterity 3 billion years later all those passes and impacts.
 
Well the most important point is that there are no planets sneaking up on us and planning to mug us. NASA had a guy check and all the planets are where they are supposed to be and being responsible citizens, obeying the Laws of Motion. If there were a planet coming for us , we'd see it by now. I've heard from these whackados that the planet can only be seen from the South Pole. That's not really possible for the same reasons the seasons change. The direction the poles point change as the Earth rotates on its axis.
 
I think Russell's Teapot shows how such an idea may be perpetuated and defended. The analogy relates to Nibiru in a literal sense.

If such a body did exist, amateur stargazers would be able to find it. If not, the Nibiru claimant would have to put another condition for why this is not the case, which might seem valid, but it just adds another unnecessary step that complicates the claim. You can use Occam's razor to suggest that the simplest explanation is most often the right one.

Hope that helps.
 
Thanks for the efforts so far. I'll post a draft of my rebuttal to the Nibiru claim as soon as I collate enough info, and open the floor for comments and criticisms.
 
Being only 8 months away from impact, amateur astronomers the world over should have a front row view by now, like we did with Haley's Comet a year or two before perihelion.

Amateur astronomers have no agenda or vested interest to cover up an astronomical event like this. Many, like comet hunters have the tools to detect objects years away from Earth at magnitudes only visible on CCD images.

Small dark asteroids are more difficult but Nibiru being planet size would be visible to the unaided eye long before now, let alone through telescopes.

There's simply nowhere in this solar system for a planet size object to hide that has an impact or close call date of December 2012. It would be impossible to miss.
 
Being only 8 months away from impact, amateur astronomers the world over should have a front row view by now, like we did with Haley's Comet a year or two before perihelion.

Amateur astronomers have no agenda or vested interest to cover up an astronomical event like this. Many, like comet hunters have the tools to detect objects years away from Earth at magnitudes only visible on CCD images.

Small dark asteroids are more difficult but Nibiru being planet size would be visible to the unaided eye long before now, let alone through telescopes.

There's simply nowhere in this solar system for a planet size object to hide that has an impact or close call date of December 2012. It would be impossible to miss.

This well demonstrated by Comet C/2011 L4 ( PanSTARRS ) It was discovered in June 2011 - However will not become a naked eye object till April 2013. Something the size of a planet would have a multiple year lead time
 
Well the most important point is that there are no planets sneaking up on us and planning to mug us. NASA had a guy check and all the planets are where they are supposed to be and being responsible citizens, obeying the Laws of Motion. If there were a planet coming for us , we'd see it by now. I've heard from these whackados that the planet can only be seen from the South Pole. That's not really possible for the same reasons the seasons change. The direction the poles point change as the Earth rotates on its axis.
If there were an object coming towards us that could only be seen from the south pole, then it would either be in a highly eccentric orbit and we'd have seen it long before now, or it would be entering our solar system from interstellar space and we'd have seen it long before now.
 
If there were an object coming towards us that could only be seen from the south pole, then it would either be in a highly eccentric orbit and we'd have seen it long before now, or it would be entering our solar system from interstellar space and we'd have seen it long before now.

One of the reasons we have permanent telescopes covering that blind spot
 
Well the most important point is that there are no planets sneaking up on us and planning to mug us. NASA had a guy check and all the planets are where they are supposed to be and being responsible citizens, obeying the Laws of Motion. If there were a planet coming for us , we'd see it by now. I've heard from these whackados that the planet can only be seen from the South Pole. That's not really possible for the same reasons the seasons change. The direction the poles point change as the Earth rotates on its axis.

It's not a mugging, it's a surprise party! It's why you can't find anything out there, it's hiding behind the sofa. It doesn't know someone let the cat out of the bag down here so things are still going ahead from that sneaky Planet X's point of view. Too bad we found out, it would have been a great surprise party. Don't spoil it, okay? Just try to look surprised. :covereyes
 
Here is the first part of my rebuttal (minus a friendly intro paragraph; this is after all for a friend of mine), for your review and critique:

Let me begin by pointing out a concept called Russel’s Teapot, also called the celestial teapot or cosmic teapot, which illustrates the idea that the burden of proof lies upon a person making scientifically unfalsifiable claims, rather than shifting the burden of proof to others who hold no such ideas. The philosopher who coined the term, Bertrand Russell, wrote that if he claimed that a teapot were orbiting the Sun somewhere in space between the Earth and Mars, it would be nonsensical for him to expect others to accept his proposal on the grounds that they could not prove him wrong. Simply put, the burden of proof rests on the claimant.

That said, I’ve willingly undertaken the effort to dispute these Nibiru claims because 1) I don't think Russel's Teapot analogy is going to satisfy you, and 2) I think we can both gain something from this exercise.

The path to the current claim that the Nibiru cataclysm will occur in our lifetime, specifically in 2012, is a tangled one. Bear with me as I trace its origins.

Zecharia Sitchin, in his 1976 book The 12th Planet, was the first to propose a planet orbiting beyond Pluto called Nibiru. According to Sitchin's interpretation of Sumerian religious texts, a giant planet, called Nibiru or Marduk, passes by Earth every 3,600 years and allows its sentient inhabitants to interact with humanity. These beings, which Sitchin identified with the Annunaki of Sumerian myth, became humanity's first gods.

No other scholar or academic involved in the translation of Sumerian texts agrees with Sitchin’s claims. To take one example, in his paper “The Myth of a Sumerian 12th Planet: Nibiru According to the Sumerians” by Michael S. Heiser, Ph.D., Hebrew Bible and Ancient Semitic Languages [ http://www.michaelsheiser.com/nibiru.pdf.] corrects Sitchin’s errors in this regard:

Nibiru was regarded as a planet (specifically, Jupiter, but once as Mercury), a god (specifically, Marduk), and a star (distinguished from Jupiter). … This tri-fold (fourfold if you count Mercury) designation for Nibiru is why scholars of cuneiform astronomy have not been able to determine with certainty what exactly Nibiru is. … One thing is certain from the texts, though: Nibiru is NEVER identified as a planet beyond Pluto.​

And of course, an investigation into Sitchin’s claims to be a linguist and archeologst reveals the fact that Sitchin graduated from the University of London with a degree in economic history. He worked for years as a journalist and editor in Israel before settling in New York, where he commenced to write would-be erudite works of pseudo-scholarship detailing his theories of ancient astronauts. Contrary to the scientific method, Sitchin begins with a belief about ancient visitors from other worlds and then proceeds to fit facts and fictions to his hypothesis. This is the opposite of the accepted methods of scientific inquiry, in which one first collects data, then forms a hypothesis based on observation, and tests that hypothesis in an attempt to falsify it before drawing conclusions. Error analysis and peer review by the global scientific community follow.

Sitchin promoted himself as a Biblical scholar and master of ancient languages, but he purposefully mistranslated Biblical passages to support his readings of Sumerian and Akkadian writings. Areospace engineer Rob Hafernik points this out on his website debunking Sitchin’s claims:

All three of the translations of the Bible I checked (representing the reputations of hundreds of Biblical scholars) translate [the Hebrew word] "shem" as "name". Asimov and Kramer go along with the rest. Sitchin argues that shem meant "monument", but that the monuments were copies of the rockets used by the ancient gods (space aliens). [Hafernik, Rob. 1996. Sitchin's Twelfth Planet http://roborant.info/main.do?entry=1443 (accessed 3/22/2010)]
​
Perhaps most damning to the claims of an impending Nibiru-related cataclysm, Sitchin (who died in 2010) expressly denied any connection between his work and the claims by avowed extraterrestrial contactee Nancy Lieder involving an impending cataclysm brought about by “Planet X”. In 2007, partly in response to Lieder's fear-mongering assertions, Sitchin published a book, The End of Days, which set the time for the previous passing of Nibiru by Earth at 556 BC. This would mean, given the object's supposed 3,600-year orbit, that it would return sometime around AD 3044.

This is an extremely important point, so I’m going to stress it again. The man who first identified an outlying planet called Nibiru, and claimed that the ancient Sumerians were aware of its existence, expressly rejected the claim that this planet was in any way an impending threat to the Earth or humanity. Even if we accept all of his (baseless, as I think I’ve shown) claims that such a planet exists, it would in no way impact our lives according to the very man who “discovered” and wrote about it.

NEXT: Nancy Lieder's fear-mongering horror story
 
Last edited:
Part II

Nancy Lieder is a Wisconsin woman who claims that she has been contacted by gray extraterrestrials called Zetas, who implanted a communication device in her brain. In 1995 Lieder claimed to speak on behalf of these Zetas, asserting that “the Hale-Bopp comet does not exist.” The comet was a fraud, she said, manufactured to distract people from the imminent arrival of a large planetary object, "Planet X", which would soon pass by Earth and destroy civilization.

After Hale-Bopp's perihelion revealed it as one of the brightest and longest-observed comets of the last century, Lieder removed the first two sentences of her initial statement from her site, though they can still be found in Google's archives.

Lieder’s assertions were very specific. She claimed (presumably on the authority of the Zetas) that the orbit of “Planet X”, an object four times the size of the Earth, would take it near to the Earth on May 27, 2003, resulting in a cessation of the Earth's rotation for 5.9 days. Shared magnetic forces would then cause the Earth's poles to destabilize. This in turn would supposedly disrupt the Earth's core and lead to a displacement of the Earth's crust.

In 1996 Lieder expressly connected her Planet X to Sitchin’s Nibiru on her website: "Planet X does exist, and it is the 12th Planet, one and the same."

In May 2003, roughly a week before the supposed arrival of Nibiru/Planet X, Lieder appeared on KROQ-FM radio in Los Angeles, and advised listeners to put their pets down in anticipation of the cataclysmic event. When asked if she had put her own animals down, she replied that she had, and that "The puppies are in a happy place." She also advised that "A dog makes a good meal" [Mark Pilkington (2003). "Planet Waves". Fortean Times]. After the prophesied date passed without incident, Lieder said that her claim had merely been a “white Lie ... to fool the establishment" ["Pole Shift in 2003 Date". zetatalk.com. 2003]. She also said that to disclose the true date would have given those in power time to declare martial law and trap people in cities during the shift, leading to their deaths ["ZetaTalk: White Lie". zetatalk.com. 2003].

Nearly nine years have passed since the date Lieder initially prognosticated as the Earth’s Day of Doom. Given that she claims to be in contact with alien beings who speak through her, without offering a shred of evidence of this extraordinary pronouncement, is it reasonable to accept her at her word? Lieder stated that she killed her own dogs (or had them killed) in anticipation of the prophesied event, and on broadcast radio counseled the public to do the same. Yet nine years later the cataclysm has yet to occur – nine years in which those animals might have lived fully and happily. If Lieder (or her alien contacts) knew the “real” date of Planet X’s approach, why would she have her own dogs destroyed a decade before the actual event? To support the “white lie”? Is this a woman whose claims should be taken seriously?

Others have since taken up the claim of Planet X and the impending terrestrial upheaval and the doom of civilization. Websites abound espousing this belief. But Lieder is the source of the claim. The Sumerians did not believe in an impending cataclysm, even according to Zacharia Sitchin who “discovered” Nibiru in their ancient religious tablets. The Planet X Cataclysm is the sole invention of Nancy Lieder, the dog-murdering alien contactee from Wisconsin who has an alien chip in her head that allows her to speak with gray extraterrestrials who tell her lies about a supposedly fraudulent comet that indisputably exists.
 

The Earth tilts on its axis as it moves around the sun. At the moment the Northern hemisphere is leaning closer to the sun. So, an object only visible at a pole in one season would be visible from a land mass in during another season.
 
A friend of mine used to believe in Planet X but he ended up visiting his uncle who works as an astronomer. His uncle told him that there were telescopes all around the world pointed at most quadrants trying to find new discoveries in this universe and others. He dropped the subject like a rock.

Perhaps your friend could visit a working astronomer and get first hand information about the viewing coverage that humankind has on the cosmos. Believing that a planet can sneak up on us could quickly be debunked. Perhaps seeing may be more helpful in believing rather than what you can try and explain?


Hubble Deep Field 3D video on Vimeo if he hasn't seen it. Looking back 13 billion years rather than at a planet that is supposed to be less than a year of travel away.

http://vimeo.com/7742288
 
Last edited:
hello
Nibiru was regarded as a planet (specifically, Jupiter, but once as Mercury), a god (specifically, Marduk), and a star (distinguished from Jupiter). … This tri-fold (fourfold if you count Mercury) designation for Nibiru is why scholars of cuneiform astronomy have not been able to determine with certainty what exactly Nibiru is. … One thing is certain from the texts, though: Nibiru is NEVER identified as a planet beyond Pluto.​

just a quick one, as its been some time since Michael Heiser wrote that one, the understanding of Mesopotamian linguistics has gotten better. As it turns out Neberu isn't a noun, where it used to be perceived as one, it is the Akkadian (didn't exist in Sumer) word for "quay/port/ford/crossing" a more modern usage would be "traversing". So whenever the Mesopotamians used the word, they were referring to a planet which was being observed. So it can be applied to any planet and as such there is no seperate planet called "crossing", its a generalism, the reason it was most often applied to Jupiter, is that Jupiter is the planet of Bel Marduk and as the planet of the King of the Gods it was observed a lot more (so appears connected to more often) for the purpose of omen reading.
http://psd.museum.upenn.edu/epsd/epsd/e148.html
There was also a shrine called Nibru in Nippur dedicated to Enki, a religious centre concerned with crossing something to reach the Gods in the next world, what could it be
:D


but even if you suspend your disbelief of linguistic science and start with the default position, of it being a real planet on a highly eccentric 3600 year orbit, then do the math

2500bce is the earliest mention, so it would have been back in 1100CE in time for the Medieval period (it was a no show) and won't be back again until 4700CE, so nothing to worry about for 2688 years.

I posted my article on the truth about Nibiru over two years ago at this forum,
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=141366&highlight=scorpion+planet
I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it,
:D
 
Last edited:
Part II

Nancy Lieder is a Wisconsin woman who claims that she has been contacted by gray extraterrestrials called Zetas, who implanted a communication device in her brain. In 1995 Lieder claimed to speak on behalf of these Zetas, asserting that “the Hale-Bopp comet does not exist.” The comet was a fraud, she said, manufactured to distract people from the imminent arrival of a large planetary object, "Planet X", which would soon pass by Earth and destroy civilization.

After Hale-Bopp's perihelion revealed it as one of the brightest and longest-observed comets of the last century, Lieder removed the first two sentences of her initial statement from her site, though they can still be found in Google's archives.

Lieder’s assertions were very specific. She claimed (presumably on the authority of the Zetas) that the orbit of “Planet X”, an object four times the size of the Earth, would take it near to the Earth on May 27, 2003, resulting in a cessation of the Earth's rotation for 5.9 days. Shared magnetic forces would then cause the Earth's poles to destabilize. This in turn would supposedly disrupt the Earth's core and lead to a displacement of the Earth's crust.

In 1996 Lieder expressly connected her Planet X to Sitchin’s Nibiru on her website: "Planet X does exist, and it is the 12th Planet, one and the same."

In May 2003, roughly a week before the supposed arrival of Nibiru/Planet X, Lieder appeared on KROQ-FM radio in Los Angeles, and advised listeners to put their pets down in anticipation of the cataclysmic event. When asked if she had put her own animals down, she replied that she had, and that "The puppies are in a happy place." She also advised that "A dog makes a good meal" [Mark Pilkington (2003). "Planet Waves". Fortean Times]. After the prophesied date passed without incident, Lieder said that her claim had merely been a “white Lie ... to fool the establishment" ["Pole Shift in 2003 Date". zetatalk.com. 2003]. She also said that to disclose the true date would have given those in power time to declare martial law and trap people in cities during the shift, leading to their deaths ["ZetaTalk: White Lie". zetatalk.com. 2003].

Nearly nine years have passed since the date Lieder initially prognosticated as the Earth’s Day of Doom. Given that she claims to be in contact with alien beings who speak through her, without offering a shred of evidence of this extraordinary pronouncement, is it reasonable to accept her at her word? Lieder stated that she killed her own dogs (or had them killed) in anticipation of the prophesied event, and on broadcast radio counseled the public to do the same. Yet nine years later the cataclysm has yet to occur – nine years in which those animals might have lived fully and happily. If Lieder (or her alien contacts) knew the “real” date of Planet X’s approach, why would she have her own dogs destroyed a decade before the actual event? To support the “white lie”? Is this a woman whose claims should be taken seriously?

Others have since taken up the claim of Planet X and the impending terrestrial upheaval and the doom of civilization. Websites abound espousing this belief. But Lieder is the source of the claim. The Sumerians did not believe in an impending cataclysm, even according to Zacharia Sitchin who “discovered” Nibiru in their ancient religious tablets. The Planet X Cataclysm is the sole invention of Nancy Lieder, the dog-murdering alien contactee from Wisconsin who has an alien chip in her head that allows her to speak with gray extraterrestrials who tell her lies about a supposedly fraudulent comet that indisputably exists.

Well written, well done!

I came looking this morning for skeptical-anything on Nancy L., her web site zetatalk, or zetas in general, and this is better than I would have hoped to find.

I agree showing where the sources have been grossly mistaken is a great idea. I hope it works for your friend.

These people build careers out of weaseling out of past predictions or trying to sweep them into oblivion. You gotta love the internet archives.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom