Here is the first part of my rebuttal (minus a friendly intro paragraph; this is after all for a friend of mine), for your review and critique:
Let me begin by pointing out a concept called Russel’s Teapot, also called the celestial teapot or cosmic teapot, which illustrates the idea that the burden of proof lies upon a person making scientifically unfalsifiable claims, rather than shifting the burden of proof to others who hold no such ideas. The philosopher who coined the term, Bertrand Russell, wrote that if he claimed that a teapot were orbiting the Sun somewhere in space between the Earth and Mars, it would be nonsensical for him to expect others to accept his proposal on the grounds that they could not prove him wrong. Simply put, the burden of proof rests on the claimant.
That said, I’ve willingly undertaken the effort to dispute these Nibiru claims because 1) I don't think Russel's Teapot analogy is going to satisfy you, and 2) I think we can both gain something from this exercise.
The path to the current claim that the Nibiru cataclysm will occur in our lifetime, specifically in 2012, is a tangled one. Bear with me as I trace its origins.
Zecharia Sitchin, in his 1976 book The 12th Planet, was the first to propose a planet orbiting beyond Pluto called Nibiru. According to Sitchin's interpretation of Sumerian religious texts, a giant planet, called Nibiru or Marduk, passes by Earth every 3,600 years and allows its sentient inhabitants to interact with humanity. These beings, which Sitchin identified with the Annunaki of Sumerian myth, became humanity's first gods.
No other scholar or academic involved in the translation of Sumerian texts agrees with Sitchin’s claims. To take one example, in his paper “The Myth of a Sumerian 12th Planet: Nibiru According to the Sumerians” by Michael S. Heiser, Ph.D., Hebrew Bible and Ancient Semitic Languages [
http://www.michaelsheiser.com/nibiru.pdf.] corrects Sitchin’s errors in this regard:
Nibiru was regarded as a planet (specifically, Jupiter, but once as Mercury), a god (specifically, Marduk), and a star (distinguished from Jupiter). … This tri-fold (fourfold if you count Mercury) designation for Nibiru is why scholars of cuneiform astronomy have not been able to determine with certainty what exactly Nibiru is. … One thing is certain from the texts, though: Nibiru is NEVER identified as a planet beyond Pluto.
And of course, an investigation into Sitchin’s claims to be a linguist and archeologst reveals the fact that Sitchin graduated from the University of London with a degree in economic history. He worked for years as a journalist and editor in Israel before settling in New York, where he commenced to write would-be erudite works of pseudo-scholarship detailing his theories of ancient astronauts. Contrary to the scientific method, Sitchin begins with a belief about ancient visitors from other worlds and then proceeds to fit facts and fictions to his hypothesis. This is the opposite of the accepted methods of scientific inquiry, in which one first collects data, then forms a hypothesis based on observation, and tests that hypothesis in an attempt to falsify it before drawing conclusions. Error analysis and peer review by the global scientific community follow.
Sitchin promoted himself as a Biblical scholar and master of ancient languages, but he purposefully mistranslated Biblical passages to support his readings of Sumerian and Akkadian writings. Areospace engineer Rob Hafernik points this out on his website debunking Sitchin’s claims:
All three of the translations of the Bible I checked (representing the reputations of hundreds of Biblical scholars) translate [the Hebrew word] "shem" as "name". Asimov and Kramer go along with the rest. Sitchin argues that shem meant "monument", but that the monuments were copies of the rockets used by the ancient gods (space aliens). [Hafernik, Rob. 1996. Sitchin's Twelfth Planet
http://roborant.info/main.do?entry=1443 (accessed 3/22/2010)]
Perhaps most damning to the claims of an impending Nibiru-related cataclysm, Sitchin (who died in 2010) expressly denied any connection between his work and the claims by avowed extraterrestrial contactee Nancy Lieder involving an impending cataclysm brought about by “Planet X”. In 2007, partly in response to Lieder's fear-mongering assertions, Sitchin published a book, The End of Days, which set the time for the previous passing of Nibiru by Earth at 556 BC. This would mean, given the object's supposed 3,600-year orbit, that it would return sometime around AD 3044.
This is an extremely important point, so I’m going to stress it again. The man who first identified an outlying planet called Nibiru, and claimed that the ancient Sumerians were aware of its existence, expressly rejected the claim that this planet was in any way an impending threat to the Earth or humanity. Even if we accept all of his (baseless, as I think I’ve shown) claims that such a planet exists, it would in no way impact our lives according to the very man who “discovered” and wrote about it.
NEXT: Nancy Lieder's fear-mongering horror story