Nibiru, Planet X and the Doomsday Magnetic Field

When the planetx nonsense first started up Nancy claimed that she was in 'telepathic' communication with the race of beings that inhabited planetx.
And planetx was a 'brown dwarf'...

For a good definition of a brown dwarf I refer you to Phil Platt :)
 
...He basically ignored everything I wrote, brought up some BS about how the law of conservation of angular momentum is falsified by Venus's clockwise axis rotation (presumably to cast doubt on the entirety of astrophysics), and then referenced the Dogon people again.

... because Leonard Nimoy narrated a TV show about that African tribe in the late 70s, he (Nimoy) is a more credible source than Sitchin and "that dog-eater" Lieder; and that the Dogons, because they supposedly have some legend about a red planet that threatens the Earth, have precedence over either fraudulent author with regard to this horse-hockey about Nibiru.

Oh well. I've learned a lot myself, and at the end of the day I think that's what matters. :cool:

Mr Nimoy celebrated his 81th birthday recently. I wonder how he feels about being associated with such a filthy scam as the Nibiru nonsense.
Interesting. here's the FB page to the TV show: https://www.facebook.com/pages/In-Search-of-with-Leonard-Nimoy/177871155590182


"I've learned a lot myself...."
So have I, as this thread was my introduction to Gorian slave girls.
 
Last edited:
I'm all over the reality of the Dogon too, Isigu tolo is a myth forged from the very best psudo history intentions. To believe that Woo he's been introduced to the works of two people, firstly Marcele Griaule, who wrote about their astronomical knowledge in "the pale fox", the first review here can put that to bed.
http://www.amazon.com/The-Pale-Fox-...=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1335101386&sr=1-1
or you could take the word of the follow up done by anthropologist Walter van Beek who concluded after his research among the Dogon that,

"Though they do speak about sigu tolo [which is what Griaule claimed the Dogon called Sirius] they disagree completely with each other as to which star is meant; for some it is an invisible star that should rise to announce the sigu [festival], for another it is Venus that, through a different position, appears as sigu tolo. All agree, however, that they learned about the star from Griaule"
wiki treats it matter of factly here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogon_people#Dogon_and_Sirius

Then Robert Temple who expanded on their knowledge in the best tradition of Woo authorship, by not bothering to ask any of them the truth,
wiki said:
His writings on the Dogon are based on an interpretation of the work of ethnographers Marcel Griaule and Germaine Dieterlen.
i.e. his interpretation
:D
the only other person silly enough to have run with that ball is a guy called Laird Scranton, who again just using Griaules book has come up with all kinds of nonsense, my favourite of which is that he published the Dogon believed in string theory, because, well can you guess where his inspiration for that came from
the Dogon actually use string

Liard is one of those dedicated researchers who gets most of the content from books he writes from pseudo history internet forums
but don't believe me, see for yourself
heres his latest book
"The Velikovsky Heresies: Worlds in Collision and Ancient Catastrophes Revisited"
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1591431395/theofficialgraha
His book discusses Velikovskys belief that Venus was ejected from Jupiter in 1500BCE

heres a thread he started in Sep-10 on a well known woo forum "Velikovsky"
http://www.grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=291377&t=291377
oh and another from Aug-09 "Velikovsky and that darned niggling evidence"
http://www.grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=270877&t=270877
and another two from Jan-09
"Velikovsky - Let's try another approach"
http://www.grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=259428&t=259428
"Velikovsky's lucky streak continues"
http://www.grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=259236&t=259236
and again here in Jun-08 "A partial list in favor of Velikovsky"
http://www.grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=244845&t=244845
and also in Jun 08 "Ice on Mars - "Good for Velikovsky"
http://www.grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=244645&t=244645
for some strange reason Liard is currently author of the month at the very same forum
http://www.grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?f=8&i=24291&t=24291
hehe
what he fails to mention on the back cover of course is that observations of Venus were made before the proposed ejection in 1500bce, during the reign of King Ammisaduqa and exist written on dateable cuneiform tablets known astoundingly as the Venus tablet of Ammisaduqa, who ruled Babylonia in the mid 17th century BCE. some two hundred years earlier
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_tablet_of_Ammisaduqa
which is odd because it was these very tablets which gave Velikovsky the idea that Venus was wobbling in the first place, however back in the fifties Velikovsky had never heard the term "scribal error" whereas thats well understood thesedays as a factor caused by copying corruptions

Its ironic that he operates mainly at the Graham Hancock forum, thats the guy who the BBC said was "an intellectual fraudster, who put forward half-baked theories and ideas in bad faith, and that he was also incompetent to defend his own arguments."
These are the type of people that your friend has been influenced by Vort, perhaps you should tell him the whole story, I mean not just the story they are permeating, but the actual truth of their character, for instance most of the best selling pseudo history authors, don't have one history based qualification between them. They do have something in common though
Sitchin - Journalist
Hatcher Childress - Journalist
Hancock - Journalist
Von Daniken - criminal fraudster
:D
if Griaule hadn't actually died more than half a century ago, I'm sure he'd have more to say about it,
probably be on his ninth book by now
;)
 
Last edited:
Hey Vortigern99, what about trying my approach?

Propose a bet. Nibiru comes and wrecks the Earth at a given date, all you base are belong to him. If not, all his base are belong to you. What he's got to loose if he actually believes in this crap?

More than once I tried to bet U$5K with believers in prophecies of impending doom. Just two accepted, utill now. One is owning me money. Given his background, I don't think I'll ever get it. The other one downgraded the bet to a (good) beer box and some major world crisis.
 
Nibiru is supposedly four times the size of the earth, right? That would make it about 32,000 miles in diameter. That's about the size of Neptune. A body that size in a polar orbit would seriously screw up the orbits of the other planets, would it not?

Not to mention that it would probably be visually detectable for decades before the "collision".
 
Hey all.

A friend of mine is into this Nibiru collision/magnetic field disruption baloney, and I'm trying to amass a whopper of a rebuttal to his uncritical delusions.

For those unfamiliar with this ridiculous claim, Nibiru (also called Planet X among other names) is a planet hiding on the far side of the sun which will collide with, or nearly collide with, the Earth -- as some believe, this year.

The Sumerians knew about it, some African tribe called the Doga know about it, and possibly the Mayans as well. :rolleyes:

Any scientific rebuttal to this preposterous claim (such as: the gravity of this unseen planet would be detectable in the orbits of the other planets of our solar system) has so far been met by my deluded friend with protestations of a NASA cover-up.

Will you help me construct an iron-clad rebuttal to this nonsense? My friend is not, I believe, a lost cause: he is an intelligent but woefully under-educated person who has uncritically accepted a bill of goods that someone (or a host of someones) has sold him. I think that if I can show him where his sources are blatantly mistaken, I can blast the cotton from his ears and bring him back to the good side of the Force.

Thanks to any and all future contributors.

how is nibiru's gravity detectable with the sun in the way?

straw man you be
godwin invoked
 
Being only 8 months away from impact, amateur astronomers the world over should have a front row view by now, like we did with Haley's Comet a year or two before perihelion.

Amateur astronomers have no agenda or vested interest to cover up an astronomical event like this. Many, like comet hunters have the tools to detect objects years away from Earth at magnitudes only visible on CCD images.

Small dark asteroids are more difficult but Nibiru being planet size would be visible to the unaided eye long before now, let alone through telescopes.

There's simply nowhere in this solar system for a planet size object to hide that has an impact or close call date of December 2012. It would be impossible to miss.

nope. I dont buy the armadillo jumping a canyon in armageddon either. Try harder hippie.
 
how is nibiru's gravity detectable with the sun in the way?

straw man you be
godwin invoked
.
There is nothing out there that is always on the "other side of the sun" from us.
If we can't see it today, wait a day or two.
That's the way orbits work.
 
Space surrounds us... there's no "sides" other than we're inside it.
Alla time.
 
Space surrounds us... there's no "sides" other than we're inside it.
Alla time.

you didn't say the object had to have sides, just that the sun does, I gotta tell you though, the sun doesn't have sides either, cos its a sphere
:D
 
A few thoughts:

This will be for him tied up with the claim that the Sumerians originated the idea
you can easily debunk that
just ask him to research the first three words here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiamat
this is as simple as I can make it
;)

Thanks for that. Yeah, "Larry", like other paranormal believers with whom I've had exchanges, appears to prefer accepting the myths and folklore of ancient cultures as factual or accurate. I suppose that means Zeus and Apollo were aliens, or some such. Ho hum. Russel's teapot, I say.

I think I've effectively defeated Sitchin's claim that the Sumerians were aware of a 12th planet they called Nibiru. As you've been cogent enough to point out, Marduk, in Mesopotamian texts the word 'neberu' was applied to any planet under observation; it is nowhere suggested that it is a name for an extrasolar planet or unknown celestial object.

Even my friend Larry is no longer contending that the Sumerians knew about Nibiru. He knows I've got him checkmated on that claim, at least.

Here's a whole forum of them.

http://www.rr-bb.com/

I shudder to clink on that link. Let's just say I'll take your word on it, okay? ;)

If Nimburu existed astronomers would be able to see it especially if we're on a collisiom course.

Precisely as I've shown in my post #32. The gist:

As of April 2012, if Nibiru were the size of the Earth, it should be at least m 2.2, as visible as Mars to the naked eye, and easily studied in a telescope. If per Lieder’s claim Nibiru were 4 times the size of the Earth, it would be m -0.8, or roughly the same magnitude as the second-brightest star in the night sky, Canopus.​

ha yes, if it were that simple, what part of "government conspiracy to hide the truth" didn't you understand
imagine you're woo and you read this
http://www.google.co.uk/#hl=en&scli....,cf.osb&fp=d45e2f6ae8b83e7a&biw=1280&bih=569
scary huh, the goverment conspiracy to hide the truth of Nibiru doesn't appear to be all that effective, that means the government is ineffectual which in turn means we're all going to die.
:D

Yeah, "Larry" made this claim last night. I countered that even if it's true that Google/the US/every government in the world is hiding/censoring so-called "Nibiru images" (whatever those may be, exactly)... what about all the other search engines that aren't hiding them, such as yahoo? What about the 10s of 1000s of amateur astronomers the world over who don't need Google to look up into the night sky, identify what they see, and report it on the Internet semi-anonymously?

Hey Vortigern99, what about trying my approach?

Propose a bet. Nibiru comes and wrecks the Earth at a given date, all you base are belong to him. If not, all his base are belong to you. What he's got to loose if he actually believes in this crap?

More than once I tried to bet U$5K with believers in prophecies of impending doom. Just two accepted, utill now. One is owning me money. Given his background, I don't think I'll ever get it. The other one downgraded the bet to a (good) beer box and some major world crisis.

Sorry, laying bets is just not my style. Come December 22, either the Earth will be incinerated/annihilated/destabilized/electromagnetically screwed, or it won't be. No money need change hands to demonstrate that the claimant has been embarrassingly, humiliatingly mistaken in his ridiculous, unsupported inventions and bare assertions.
 
Last edited:
Nibiru is supposedly four times the size of the earth, right? That would make it about 32,000 miles in diameter. That's about the size of Neptune. A body that size in a polar orbit would seriously screw up the orbits of the other planets, would it not?

Not to mention that it would probably be visually detectable for decades before the "collision".

Yes, I've covered this in detail on the first page of the thread. QV post #32, etc.

thats because for Gor being part of the BDSM subculture is a grey area.
BDSMers don't identify with Goreans and vice versa
:D

In Dallas/Ft Worth the Gorean subculture is very much tied up in/overlaps the larger BDSM community.

how is nibiru's gravity detectable with the sun in the way?

straw man you be
godwin invoked

The gravity of one celestial object affects the orbits of the other objects in the solar system. Even the Sun wobbles a bit from the gravitational pull of the planets it has captured.

Thus we do not have to see an object to detect the effect of its gravity on the other objects in our system. Theoretically, a planet could hide behind the Sun in a perpetual tandem orbit such that we from the Earth can never see it. But we can calculate the gravity that planets exert on other planets. There is no hidden planet behind the Sun.

nope. I dont buy the armadillo jumping a canyon in armageddon either. Try harder hippie.

Please be more clear about what claims you are making and/or disputing. I haven't any idea what you're saying here. Thanks in advance.
 
Part II

Nancy Lieder is a Wisconsin woman who claims that she has been contacted by gray extraterrestrials called Zetas, ....
Lieder was discredited years ago when she claimed planet X was visible at sunset. The planet was about to crash into Earth.

Of course it didn't. Then Lieder got into a fight with people in her little financial circle which controlled about $12,000 in donations.

Exit stage left for Lieder......


Wait for it, wait for it...


Surprise! Lieder is back with the same scam as soon as people forgot what she'd done the first time.



BTW, Sitchin and Lieder, which Dr Plait addressed on occasion on Coast to Coast, provided my introduction to the skeptical community.
 
Last edited:
In Dallas/Ft Worth the Gorean subculture is very much tied up in/overlaps the larger BDSM community.
the largest Texas Gorean online group has 46 members, there are probably more furries and cos players in the area.
Someone should organise a rumble, how awesome would that be ?
:D
compared to the largest BDSM Texas online group with 1,857 members (fetlife figures)
The Goreans are akin to fundamentalist Christians compared to regular BDSM liberal christianity.
;)
BTW, Sitchin and Lieder, which Dr Plait addressed on occasion on Coast to Coast, provided my introduction to the skeptical community.

Sitchin got me into Mesopotamian studies, originally terrified fact checking, then I discovered the archaeologist Sir Leonard Woolley and have been in love with his work ever since.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonard_Woolley
439px-Woolley__Lawrence_at_Carchemish.jpg


Thats Woolley on the left, the guy on the right is his assistant, a young chap called T.E. Lawrence (of Arabia)
:D
 
Last edited:
Just to give you an idea of how the international astronomy community works. 24 hours ago a star suddenly brightened in the constellation of Sagittarius.

It was discovered by a Russian team after a Chinese team confirmed earlier observations of that piece of sky showed nothing. An Italian team using a robotic telescope in Mew Mexico confirmed the observation. Then the international Astronomical Union posted an alert, in the meantime NASA swung their SWIFT space probe around and took a look.

I heard of the discovery on an astronomy forum that boasts 57,000 members world wide, and found a web link to one of the worlds largest astronomy magazines published in English.

This all occurred in a 24 hour period.

So next time someone claims something is sneaking up on us, explain to them how the real world works
 
Thanks for that, MG. I reported that almost verbatim to my friend. Not that it will do a lick of good. His ears are plugged up with brown dwarfs and ancient aliens.
 
And wasn't the claim that you would only be able to see it from Antarctica? I can see the South Celestial Pole from my house, just like northeners can see the Pole Star. There isn't any region of the sky that you can't see from some inhabited place on the planet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom