Nibiru, Planet X and the Doomsday Magnetic Field

In 1996 Lieder expressly connected her Planet X to Sitchin’s Nibiru on her website: "Planet X does exist, and it is the 12th Planet, one and the same."
.

odd timing, 96 is when Gods of the New Millennium came out,
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Gods-New-Millennium-Alan-Alford/dp/0340696125
it was written by Alan Alford (who has since dispossessed it) and the main subject is Nibiru, it was all over the best sellers list at the time of Lieder's acknowledgement. Sitchin is notoriously difficult to read, Alford writes in an easy to read popular style.
;)
 
Thanks for all the comments and contributions! The next section of my rebuttal will discuss the impossible astrophysics, the supposed 1983 report-and-retraction of Nibiru by NASA, and the importance of amateur astronomers in certifying the non-existence of said object.

All your links and suggestions have been invaluable. I must also give a shout-out to wikipedia, whose entry on the Nibiru Cataclysm (linked in the OP) forms a good 35% of my paper.
 
The Earth tilts on its axis as it moves around the sun. At the moment the Northern hemisphere is leaning closer to the sun. So, an object only visible at a pole in one season would be visible from a land mass in during another season.

The direction of the earth's axis doesn't change much over small time scales. The angle that the tilt makes with the direction of the sun varies greatly over the course of a year.

And if the Earth moved appreciably with respect to a star other than the sun, you would see the same effect with that star. But it doesn't, and the stars remain pretty much in the same direction relative to the earth's axis throughout the year.
 
The Earth tilts on its axis as it moves around the sun. At the moment the Northern hemisphere is leaning closer to the sun. So, an object only visible at a pole in one season would be visible from a land mass in during another season.
More precisely, the earth's axis is tilted at a very nearly constant angle to the plane in which it revolves around the sun.

To a very good approximation the orientation of that axis is constant. The northern hemisphere is leaning toward the sun at the moment because the earth is on that side of the sun at the moment, not because the axis direction has changed. Six months from now the axis will be (very very nearly) the same direction, but the northern hemisphere will tilt away because earth will have moved to the other side of the sun.

The effect of the slight "Chandler wobble" MG1962 noted below (thanks, I'd never heard of that before) on the objects visible from a pole is negligible for the purpose in question; 9m pole motion amounts less than a second of arc. The larger precession he mentions is a much bigger change in the axis direction, but its slow 26,000 year period is negligible over centuries for this purpose. For that matter, the precession is only a couple dozen degrees, so even that won't hide much of the sky from the poles.

Pretty much the same chunk of sky visible from a pole in one season remains visible at any season, most of it across many centuries. Polaris is as handy today for the north star as it was when I was a Cub Scout because it's "always" directly overhead at the north pole.

It's *far* from the poles that the season changes what part of the sky is visible above the horizon at a given time of day, and what times of day that sky will be obscured by sunlight.
 
Dr. E.C. Krupp, Director of the Griffith Observatory in Los Angeles published a book on the old timey sky-lookers.. "Echoes of the Ancient Skies".
He details the actual Babylonian stories of Marduk (not the one here :) ) and Tiamat, which is interesting to read alongside Sitchin's fantasies of the same. :)
 
Dr. E.C. Krupp, Director of the Griffith Observatory in Los Angeles published a book on the old timey sky-lookers.. "Echoes of the Ancient Skies".
He details the actual Babylonian stories of Marduk (not the one here :) ) and Tiamat, which is interesting to read alongside Sitchin's fantasies of the same. :)

so does wiki, note though that there is only one original story from which Sitchin along with cylinder seal VA243 fabricated the whole thing, the Enuma Elish, Tiamat doesn't appear in any earlier mesopotamian culture than Babylonian, so claiming it as a Sumerian concept is a lie.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enûma_Eliš
alternatively, it helps to actually read the original
http://www.ancient.eu.com/article/225/
http://www.sacred-texts.com/ane/enuma.htm
;)
 
Last edited:
Nancy Lieder is still pushing these claims based (seemingly) on lots of bad photographers around the world who send her photos of the Sun (with associated lens flare)...
She and her acolytes had a room over in Fire Talk from where they attempted to spread the word...
 
Next section. Several of you here will notice your own (copy edited) comments and links have made their way into the body of my essay. For that I thank you immensely! Your efforts in assisting me have been invaluable.

NASA and Astrophysics

In this section I will show you how the existence of an additional planetary object in our solar system, lying either beyond Pluto or “behind the Sun” as has been postulated by adherents of Lieder’s cataclysmic claims, is geometrically and astrophysically impossible. For this demonstration we do not need to depend on the assertions of NASA, an organization which has been accused of conspiratorial silence on the subject; we can depend on the conclusions of mathematicians who are entirely independent of NASA, and on the observations of the tens of thousands of amateur astronomers worldwide, who are unaffiliated with NASA and who watch the night skies on a daily basis using telescopes, and have done so for several decades.

The most basic rebuttal that can be made against the claim of an approaching planetary object (of any size) is that we would see it by now.

The following table has been calculated using the astronomy software StarryNight. The results assume an orbital period of 3,600 years (supplied by Sitchin). The table’s author, bikenbeer2000, has “tweaked the perihelion distance to 0.984 AU* (the same as the Earth's distance from the Sun on 12/21/2012) to ensure that it comes pretty close to us.” The magnitude assumes an Earth-sized object (a generous downsizing from Lieder’s “4 times the Earth’s size” claim). For an object 4 times the diameter of the Earth subtract 3.0 from the magnitudes.

*AU = astronomical unit, equal to 92,955,807.3 mi or approximately the mean Earth-to-Sun distance.
*Magnitude = The apparent magnitude (m) of a celestial body is a measure of its brightness as seen by an observer on Earth. The brighter the object appears, the lower the value of its magnitude.

Date Distance from Sun (AU) Magnitude (m) Comparable to
2010 Jul 01 9.36 5.5 Mercury (m 5.73)
2010 Oct 01 8.66 5.3 Uranus (m 5.32)
2011 Jan 01 7.94 5.2 Vesta asteroid (m 5.14)
2011 Apr 01 7.20 4.8 M41 cluster (m 4.5)
2011 Jul 01 6.43 3.8 Faintest stars visible in an urban neighborhood with naked eye
2011 Oct 01 5.60 3.2 Same as above
2012 Jan 01 4.72 3.1 Same as above
2012 Apr 01 3.78 2.2 Mars (m 1.84)
2012 Jul 01 2.76 0.2 no known correlation
2012 Oct 01 1.65 -3.8 Venus (m -3.82) at minimum brightness
2012 Dec 21 0.98 -17.9 The Sun as seen from Pluto at aphelion

Summary of this Table: As of April 2012, if Nibiru were the size of the Earth, it should be at least m 2.2, as visible as Mars to the naked eye, and easily studied in a telescope. If per Lieder’s claim Nibiru were 4 times the size of the Earth, it would be m -0.8, or roughly the same magnitude as the second-brightest star in the night sky, Canopus.

With a proposed impact being a mere 8 months away, amateur astronomers the world over should by April 17, 2012 have Nibiru well in their sights. Amateur astronomers have no agenda or vested interest to cover up an astronomical event like this. Many, such as comet hunters, have the tools to detect objects years away from Earth at magnitudes only visible on CCD images. Small, dark asteroids are more difficult to see; but Nibiru, being planet-sized and by now about the same magnitude as Mars, would be highly visible to the unaided eye, never mind through telescopes.

This is well demonstrated by Comet C/2011 L4 ( PanSTARRS ). This outlying object was discovered via telescopes in June 2011, but will not become visible to the naked eye till April 2013.

There's simply nowhere in this solar system for a planet size object to hide that has an impact or close call date of December 2012. It would be impossible to miss.

One of my Internet acquaintances suggested:

Perhaps your friend could visit a working astronomer and get first hand information about the viewing coverage that humankind has on the cosmos. Believing that a planet can sneak up on us could quickly be debunked. Perhaps seeing may be more helpful in believing rather than what you can try and explain?

Hubble Deep Field 3D video on Vimeo if he hasn't seen it. Looking back 13 billion years rather than at a planet that is supposed to be less than a year of travel away.

http://vimeo.com/7742288​

Moreover, not only do we know Nibiru is not approaching us because we cannot see it, its very existence is manthematically impossible.
Nibiru's orbit, as proposed by Sithcin, would be highly elliptical. So highly elliptical that it is for all intents and purposes a straight line, out and back. We know this because a simple mathematical relationship exists between the period and the length of the semi-major axis* of the ellipse.

*The major axis of an ellipse is its longest diameter, a line that runs through the center and both foci, its ends being at the widest points of the shape. The semi-major axis is one half of the major axis, and thus runs from the centre, through a focus, and to the edge of the ellipse; essentially, it is the measure of the radius of an orbit taken at the orbit's two most distant points.

Kepler's Laws

German mathematician and astronomer Johannes Kepler (1571–1630) discovered three laws of planetary motion. They are:
1. "The orbit of every planet is an ellipse with the sun at a focus."
2. "A line joining a planet and the sun sweeps out equal areas during equal intervals of time."
3. "The square of the orbital period of a planet is directly proportional to the cube of the semi-major axis of its orbit."

Kepler's Laws applied to Nibiru

1. Since all planets orbit in ellipses with the Sun at one focus, Nibiru must go around the Sun, not just through the orbital paths of the planets.
2. All planets sweep out equal areas in equal time intervals, so Nibiru must move very slowly at it's aphelion, or furthest point from the Sun, and very fast at it's perihelion, or closest point.
3. The square of the orbital period of a planet is directly proportional to the cube of the semi-major axis of its orbit. Since Nibiru's period is specified as 3,600 years, we can use Kepler's third law to determine something about its orbit.

Given a 3,600 year orbit that brings it to within 1 AU of the sun (the area of Earth's orbit) the far end of the orbit must be 469 AU out from the sun.
Just as a comparison point, Pluto is on average about 39.5 AU away from the Sun. It's year is about 248 earth years long. If we plug 248 into a certain equation, we get 39.47 AU. [You can see that the formula works at http://www.2012hoax.org/nibiru#toc10.]

Pluto's orbit is considered "highly elliptical". But it's not nearly as elliptical as the orbit proposed for Nibiru. Dr. Douglas Hamilton's 2D Orbital Elements calculator (after some trial and error) produces an orbit with an eccentricity of 0.995744. This produces an orbit with an approximate Perihelion distance of 1 AU, and a semi-major axis of 235. This is extremely eccentric.

The orbit described above would be highly unstable. A highly elliptical orbit is unstable because it will suffer drastically from the slightest perturbation - Jupiter's gravity would probably be enough to send Nibiru spiraling off to who knows where. Pluto's orbit is stabilized by Neptune, as Pluto is locked into a 2:3 orbital resonance with Neptune. The maths behind multiple body problems are nightmarish to sort out because they have no closed solutions (the objects all affect each other to such a degree that the orbits gradually precess), so professional astronomers use computers to perform these calculations. But you should understand this: As much as the fictional Nibiru would pull on other planets, those planets would also pull on Nibiru. With a long, thin ellipse as described, even the slightest nudge from the gravity of another object, even if that object is considerably smaller than Nibiru, would have a dramatic effect on Nibiru's orbit.

Let’s discuss gravity and escape velocity. At 469 AU (see above for how we calculated this number), the gravity of the Sun is negligible, almost non-existent. So as a result, Nibiru must be traveling close to the Sun's escape velocity when it comes within 1 AU of it. At a distance of 1 AU, the Sun's escape velocity is about 42km/s, so this is the speed at which Nibiru should be traveling (or a hair under it) in 2012. In comparison, the Earth's orbital velocity is a bit under 30km/s, Venus' is about 35km/s and Mercury's is 47.8. Nibiru would be whipping around the Sun nearly as quickly as Mercury.

Astronomer Michael E. Brown, professor of planetary astronomy at the California Institute of Technology (wholly independent from NASA or government oversight of any kind), notes that if this object's orbit were as described, it would only have lasted in the Solar System for a million years or so before Jupiter expelled it, and that there is no way another object's magnetic field could have such an effect on Earth. Lieder's assertions that the approach of Nibiru would cause the Earth's rotation to stop or its axis to shift violate the laws of physics. In his rebuttal of Immanuel Velikovsky's Worlds in Collision, which made the same claim that the Earth's rotation could be stopped and then restarted, Carl Sagan noted that, "the energy required to brake the Earth is not enough to melt it, although it would result in a noticeable increase in temperature: The oceans would [be] raised to the boiling point of water ... [Also,] how does the Earth get started up again, rotating at approximately the same rate of spin? The Earth cannot do it by itself, because of the law of the conservation of angular momentum."

In a 2009 interview with the Discovery Channel, Mike Brown noted that, while it is not impossible that the Sun has a distant planetary companion, such an object would have to be lying very far from the observed regions of the Solar System to have no gravitational effect on the other planets. A Mars-sized object could lie undetected at 300 AU (10 times the distance of Neptune); a Jupiter-sized object at 30,000 AU. To travel 1000 AU in two years, an object would need to be moving at 2400 km/s – faster than the galactic escape velocity. At that speed, any object would be shot out of the Solar System, and then out of the Milky Way galaxy into intergalactic space.

So that’s the math and science of the subject. I don’t pretend to understand all of it; I’ve copied and pasted much of it from http://www.2012hoax.org/nibiru#toc10 and the wikipedia entry on the Nibiru Cataclysm. But I have made every effort to check my sources, and read everything I’ve copied until I had at least a layman’s understanding of it.

NASA, Nibiru and Conspiracy Theories

Many believers in the imminent approach of Planet X/Nibiru accuse NASA of deliberately covering up visual evidence of its existence. One such accusation involves the IRAS infrared space observatory, launched in 1983. The satellite briefly made headlines due to an "unknown object" that was at first described as "possibly as large as the giant planet Jupiter and possibly so close to Earth that it would be part of this Solar System". This newspaper article has been cited by proponents of the collision idea, beginning with Nancy Lieder herself, as evidence for the existence of Nibiru. However, further analysis revealed that of several unidentified objects, nine were distant galaxies and the tenth was "intergalactic cirrus"; none were found to be Solar System bodies [J. R. Houck, D. P. Schneider, D. E. Danielson, et al. (1985). "Unidentified IRAS sources: Ultra-High Luminosity Galaxies". The Astrophysical Journal 290: 5–8.*]

Another accusation frequently made by websites predicting the collision is that the U.S. government built the South Pole Telescope (SPT) to track Nibiru's trajectory, and that the object has been imaged optically. However, the SPT (which is not funded by NASA) is a radio telescope, and cannot take optical images. Its South Pole location was chosen due to the low-humidity environment, and there is no way an approaching object could be seen only from the South Pole. The "picture" of Nibiru posted on YouTube has been revealed, in fact, to be a Hubble image of the expanding light echo around the star V838 Mon.

Another conspiracy claim regards a patch of missing data in Google Sky near the constellation of Orion, which has often been cited as evidence that Nibiru has been redacted. However, the same region of sky can still be viewed by thousands of amateur astronomers. A scientist at Google said that the missing data is due to a glitch in the stitching software used to piece the images together. Another piece of claimed evidence drawn from Google Sky is the carbon star CW Leonis, which is the brightest object in the 10 μm infrared sky and is frequently claimed to be Nibiru. [See http://astroblogger.blogspot.com/2009/08/nibiru-it-is-not.html for a thorough debunking of the claim.]

*Abstract: Optical imaging and spectroscopy measurements were obtained for six of the high galactic latitude infrared sources reported by Houck, et al. (1984) from the IRAS survey to have no obvious optical counterparts on the POSS prints. All are identified with visually faint galaxies that have total luminosities in the range 5 x 10 to the 11th power stellar luminosity to 5 x 10 to the 12th power stellar luminosity. This luminosity emerges virtually entirely in the infrared. The origin of the luminosity, which is one to two orders of magnitude greater than that of normal galaxies, is not known at this time.
 
Last edited:
And finally:

Conclusions

Zacharia Sitchin invented the planet Nibiru out of whole cloth and via gross (and likely intentional) mistranslation of ancient Sumerian texts – errors with which no other Mesopotamian academic agrees. In the years since Michael Heiser wrote “The Myth of a Sumerian 12th Planet: Nibiru According to the Sumerians”, a link to the PDF of which I’ve supplied in section II, above, the understanding of Mesopotamian linguistics has improved. Scholars of the period now understand that neberu is the Akkadian word for "quay/port/ford/crossing". A more modern usage perhaps would be "traversing". Thus, whenever the Mesopotamians used the word, they were referring to a planet which was being observed. Neberu can thus be applied to any planet; there is no distinct celestial object called "crossing”; it is a generalism. The reason it was most often applied to Jupiter is that, to the Sumerians, Jupiter was the planet of Bel Marduk; as the planet of the King of the Gods it was observed more frequently for the purpose of omen reading. [See http://psd.museum.upenn.edu/epsd/epsd/e148.html for further reading on this fascinating sidebar. Also see the opening post of this thread: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=141366&highlight=scorpion+planet for more insight from a Mesopotamian expert who calls himself “Marduk”.]

Yet even if we were to accept, against all evidence to the contrary, that Sitchin was correct and that Nibiru is an actual planetary object, the fact remains that neither he nor the Sumerians prognosticated an imminent near collision between that object and the Earth. For that claim we must look to the work of Nancy Lieder.

Nancy Lieder is a known liar, a delusional perpetrator of demonstrable fraud, and a self-professed killer and eater of pet dogs. She is the original source of the claim that “Planet X” would cause a terrestrial catastrophe; almost nine years have transpired since her originally prophesied date of doom. After her May 2003 date passed without incident, Lieder said that it was merely a "white lie ... to fool the establishment," and said that to disclose the true date would give those in power enough time to declare martial law and trap people in cities during the shift, leading to their deaths.

Yet despite these assertions, a new “true date” of December 21, 2012 has been postulated as the day of the Nibiru cataclysm. With 8 months to go to this supposed horrific event, why are our leaders not declaring martial law or “trapping people in cities” as Lieder said they would do if they knew the “true date”? How can we reconcile her reasons for delivering a “white lie” and publicly calling for the deaths of pet animals against the current certainty of the “true date”? Is the “establishment” being fooled again, and the “true date” is still farther off? Perhaps 3044 AD per Sitchin’s calculations? If the latter, what cause do we have to worry over an event that is more than 1000 years in the future?

Unfalsifiable claims aside, against all mathemathical and astrophysical calculations that such an object should by now be visible, no such object can be seen approaching the Earth. Astronomers working independently of NASA have shown that such an object, as described by Sitchin and Lieder, would have been ejected from our solar system long ago.

Claims of conspiracy and cover-up do not hold up to scrutiny. What reason would NASA have to keep secret such a literally earth-shattering event? If the answer is “to avoid panic” as it is so often in these kinds of claims, one may well ask: “What about the panic that will ensue once Nibiru approaches, and the cataclysmic events Lieder has described begin to occur?” Panic and mayhem cannot be avoided in any permutation of a cataclysmic scenario of this scope. Any response that may be imagined still does not address the fact of tens of thousands amateur astronomers the world over who can peer into the night skies, using powerful telescopes, who have seen nothing remotely similar to the object Lieder and others describe.

The claim is utter baloney. I rest my case.
 
When we were discussing this on Compuserve's Conspiracy forum 20 years or so back, I drew up the orbit... a long skinny one it would. And it would not have a "perigee" nor an "apogee", as mentioned.
And as it passed through the asteroid belt as claimed, in the million passes it has made, it would have swept up all the junk that really is there now.
The "hothouse" atmosphere... Sitch was misunderstanding "greenhouse", and the thickness of it would have prevented the inhabitants from seeing any of the details in the inner solar system as it whizzed on through. There'd not be any time to do any interplanetary travel, presuming they could have ships that do that in the first place.
In the absence of sunlight for most of the years of the orbit, something would have to heat the planet. Radioactivity, no doubt. I kinda suspect a few billion years of intense radioactive heat would do something to any alive.
And, for those inhabitants to be genetically compatible with Earthlings, their history would have had to been exactly the same as ours, with all the hits and misses that the environment has used to get to homo sap.
The massive extinctions would have had to zap only those beasties that were zapped here.
The whole idea is fun fiction, but can't begin to be supported by reality.
Oh, one of the reasons there's no hard evidence of the space ships and bases the Nefilim used, was the construction of these items out of water soluble materials... :)
 
When we were discussing this on Compuserve's Conspiracy forum 20 years or so back,

Sitchin boughtout a few more books in the last twenty years, they cover all of your points

In the absence of sunlight for most of the years of the orbit, something would have to heat the planet. Radioactivity, no doubt. I kinda suspect a few billion years of intense radioactive heat would do something to any alive.

They mined gold from earth, seeded the atmosphere of Nibiru with it creating a greenhouse effect. Of course there is no evidence of the mining.

And, for those inhabitants to be genetically compatible with Earthlings, their history would have had to been exactly the same as ours, with all the hits and misses that the environment has used to get to homo sap.
They were actually the Gods, who came down first time around and genetically engineered homo sapiens from homo erectus, this is the basis for the claim of compatibility, but even then Sitchin claims they used lab equipment to make the egg viable, this runs against the genuine texts which state that to impregnate a human woman a God need only screw her

Oh, one of the reasons there's no hard evidence of the space ships and bases the Nefilim used, was the construction of these items out of water soluble materials... :)
no, again theres no evidence because an opposing faction nuked all the bases from orbit. The evidence, is there apparently for all to see, a product misidentified as Volcanic glass. Which lies coincedentally near an active volcano.

It helps to remember that Sitchin didn't set out to overturn science and religion, he set out to seperate fools from their money, hence his degree in economics, at that he was very successful
;)
 
It was interesting reading Zech's follow-on novels. Each one would reveal more facets of the solar system he found in the old records...... After NASA's space probes discovered them. :)
Scientifically he is just good for laugh or two, or three.... :)
He did discover an exploitable niche in the masses of humanity, and did well at it.
 
Don't forget Hancock, with his series on, as I see it, "Fingerpaints of the gods"...:)
 
Don't forget Hancock, with his series on, as I see it, "Fingerpaints of the gods"...:)

now he did rip off previous woo authors, no argument there and previously was a gutter press journo. But he's small fry compared to some others, ever heard of "The Ancient American" magazine, which promotes the theory of diffusion of peoples in and out of the Americas in prehistoric times.
check out the despicable editor
Collin's downfall began with the revelation that his father, Max Simon Collin, was a Jew whose original surname had been "Cohen". Max Cohen/Collin claimed to have been a prisoner at Dachau concentration camp, where Frank Collin was said to have been conceived. While president of the NSPA, Collin was arrested by Michigan police while having sex with a pair of 10-year-old boys. These revelations led to his dismissal from the neo-Nazi movement. A psychiatrist who interviewed Collin declared that he was "consumed by hatred for his father"; it was argued that Collin rejected his father by becoming a neo-Nazi and adopting and publicly espousing antisemitic beliefs. Collin was convicted of child molestation and sent to Pontiac prison in 1979. He served three years of a seven-year sentence.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Collin
After being released, Collin re-emerged into the spotlight as the author, "Frank Joseph". In 1987 he had a book published, The Destruction of Atlantis: Compelling Evidence of the Sudden Fall of the Legendary Civilization. Collin/Joseph is now a self-described neo-pagan

like a Neo Pagan, thats just awful
:D
 
If Stichin had tried to sell his garbage as straight Science Fiction, it would have been rejected by most Sci Fi editors as being grade B cliched garbage.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom