New evidence of Nibiru / Planet 9

Your article is not peer reviewed, and in my opionion, in its current form, it (and you) would not survive viva voce before a disstertation committee.
Perhaps, if you nitpick, since I am not very educated and made a lot of mistakes there However, this doesn't change the essence of the matter. All that can be done is to consider this evidence insufficient.
 
Nibiru exists
The evidence you have provided has other, more scholarly explanations, and does not support your conclusions.

We know that while there was massive variations in the first 500 to 700 million years after the sun's formation, with the giant planets migrating inwards and outwards, once they settled into their current positions about 3.8 billion years ago, they have remained relatively stable ever since.

However, if a companion star to the sun really existed on the highly elliptical orbit you claim, it would have caused colossal disruption to planetary orbits. Massive objects like stars tend to clear their orbits very efficiently. Most planets would have been flung out of the solar system long ago.
 
The evidence you have provided has other, more scholarly explanations, and does not support your conclusions.

We know that while there was massive variations in the first 500 to 700 million years after the sun's formation, with the giant planets migrating inwards and outwards, once they settled into their current positions about 3.8 billion years ago, they have remained relatively stable ever since.

However, if a companion star to the sun really existed on the highly elliptical orbit you claim, it would have caused colossal disruption to planetary orbits. Massive objects like stars tend to clear their orbits very efficiently. Most planets would have been flung out of the solar system long ago.
The mass of a super-Earth is much less than the mass of a star. Although the theory you are talking about generally explains the evolution of the solar system, No one knows for sure what kind of fluctuations occurred before our observations. Again, how did the asteroid belt appear in the place of the planet, how did the planets acquire their tilt and eccentricity? There is no single theory that fully explains this from start to finish. Moreover, the emergence of the new planet could have occurred relatively late in cosmic terms, and we may well be witnessing only the beginning of destruction. I wrote about this
 
The mass of a super-Earth is much less than the mass of a star.
It would still be colossal in its gravitational effects. A super earth on the type of orbit you claim would massively disrupt the orbits of at least the terrestrial planets

Although the theory you are talking about generally explains the evolution of the solar system, No one knows for sure what kind of fluctuations occurred before our observations.
True, but they have a fair idea through modelling

Again, how did the asteroid belt appear in the place of the planet
There is not enough material in the main asteroid belt to make a planet. The total mass of the main asteroid belt is between 2.4x10
21 and 3x1021 kg... about 3.5% of the mass of the moon, and even then is concentrated in the four minor planets (Ceres, Vesta, Pallas, and Hygiea), which make up over 60% of the total mass

The asteroid belt formed during the first few hundred million years of the solar system from primordial solar nebula material that failed to coalesce into a planet due to Jupiter's intense gravity. It is understood from modelling that originally, there was far more material - only 0.1% of it remains.

How did the planets acquire their tilt and eccentricity?
Late stage impacts

There is no single theory that fully explains this from start to finish.
Yes there is. Its called the Nebular Hypothesis. It is the most widely accepted model because it explains why all planets orbit in the same direction and plane, and why the composition differs between inner and outer planets

Moreover, the emergence of the new planet could have occurred relatively late in cosmic terms, and we may well be witnessing only the beginning of destruction. I wrote about this
Where did it come from?
 
In this hypothesis, P9 is a captured rogue planet, which is consistent with its parabolic orbit. How long will it take for this to destroy the solar system? A lot depends on whether you count time from the beginning of the solar system or from one of the catastrophes of the past. As discussed here before, a very close approach, is required to noticeable influence . At the same time, the orbital inclination increases the distance to other planets. Therefore, in the short term, this has a barely noticeable effect.
 
Oumoamoa is an example of a "transient" object "just passing through" the solar system. In the little time we've been aware of them we've already collected a few such objects of interest. Over a few billion years they would accumulate, even the transient ones. Niven and Pournelle suggested that the Moties might drop "rocks" into a star to clear out unwanted creatures already there.
 
Oumoamoa is an example of a "transient" object "just passing through" the solar system. In the little time we've been aware of them we've already collected a few such objects of interest. Over a few billion years they would accumulate, even the transient ones. Niven and Pournelle suggested that the Moties might drop "rocks" into a star to clear out unwanted creatures already there.
To pass through in transit it must have sufficient speed. And such events are also not frequent. This doesn't make the capture scenario anything special. Space is full of rogue planets.They may not be as fast
 
Well, of course, just as homeopaths want the effects of their remedies to be self evident and simultaneously so "subtle" that they are undetectable in RCTs.
Unlike homeopaths, I try to find evidence. Irregularity of impact is not excluded here.
 
Unlike homeopaths, I try to find evidence. Irregularity of impact is not excluded here.
Where do you do that?

So far you've taken a few well known facts, including that fact that humans like to look up at the sky and draw real or imagined things about that on rock/paper/papyrus and then made the completely unproven leap that 'must be all connected trough some unseen planet'

Why not take one of the many programs that simulate the solar systems and orbits, plug in your scenario and let it run a bit. My prediction will be that any planet of your proposed size and orbit will be slingshotted out by jupiter in no time.
 
Unlike homeopaths, I try to find evidence.

Not only do homeopaths try to find evidence, they're convinced they've found plenty of it. They just don't understand what constitutes evidence, as that word is used by scientists. They think anecdotal evidence is more than adequate, and they don't realise that they need to look just as assiduously for evidence against the thing they would quite like to believe as for it.
 
Where do you do that?

So far you've taken a few well known facts, including that fact that humans like to look up at the sky and draw real or imagined things about that on rock/paper/papyrus and then made the completely unproven leap that 'must be all connected trough some unseen planet'

Why not take one of the many programs that simulate the solar systems and orbits, plug in your scenario and let it run a bit. My prediction will be that any planet of your proposed size and orbit will be slingshotted out by jupiter in no time.
Universe Sandbox would be fine for that... and yes, a super earth size planet in a close encounter with Jupiter would almost certainly eventually result in the super earth being flung out of the solar system.
 
Where do you do that?

So far you've taken a few well known facts, including that fact that humans like to look up at the sky and draw real or imagined things about that on rock/paper/papyrus and then made the completely unproven leap that 'must be all connected trough some unseen planet'

Why not take one of the many programs that simulate the solar systems and orbits, plug in your scenario and let it run a bit. My prediction will be that any planet of your proposed size and orbit will be slingshotted out by jupiter in no time.
I just did that. The article has been updated.

10 Numerical modeling of the
dynamic evolution of the Solar
System with the participation of
P9

Was employed the REBOUND N-body integrator with the adaptive IAS15 algorithm to simulate the long-term gravitational influence of a hypothetical P9(m = 5 M, a = 236 AU, e = 0.99576, q = 1.0 AU, i = 25◦) on the Solar System over 200 000 and 500 000 years. The model includes the Sun, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus,
Neptune, and Earth, with initial conditions taken from JPL DE ephemeris (via REBOUND’s built-in data) and shifted to the barycenter. The integration was performed from using 30 000 uniformly spaced output points (∆t ≈ 6.67 yr). At each timestep, was recorded Earth’s eccentricity e and the three-dimensional distance between Earth and Planet 9.

As a result of numerical modeling of the dynamic evolution
of the Solar System with the participation of a massive object
P9, data were obtained that make it possible to reconsider the mechanisms of orbital variability of the Earth. It has been established that the classical long-period oscillations of Earth’s eccentricity (periods of 100 and 400 kyr)
undergo significant high-frequency modulation as the perihelion of Planet 9 approaches the 1.1 AU limit (Fig. 7,8). The gravitational influence of the object does not destroy the structure of the Milankovitch cycles but acts as a nonlinear
amplifier, increasing the amplitude of eccentricity oscillations to critical values of e ≈ 0.05–0.06. This suggests that the severity of glacial periods observed during the Pleistocene was partiallyd etermined by external gravitational resonance.

The model demonstrates a specific ”sawtooth” profile of eccentricity changes (the ”green saw” effect). Unlike the smooth secular perturbations from the gas giants, Planet 9 induces step-
like changes in orbital parameters over timescales of 3–5 kyr. This correlates with empirical ice core data regarding ultra-
abrupt temperature oscillations (Dansgaard–Oeschger events), the nature of which was previously attributed solely to internal
terrestrial processes. A dynamic threshold has been identified at the q = 1.1 AU mark. At q > 1.5 AU, the object’s influence becomes negligible within the Pleistocene timescales.

Thus, Earth’s current climatic regime is a consequence of temporary resonance capture, occurring when the perihelion of the perturbing bodye
ntered critical proximity to Earth’s orbit.

The model indicates the metastable nature of the current configuration. A forecast for the next 500,000 years shows that Earth’s orbital evolution will be determined by a phase
in which Planet 9 migrates to more distant orbits via energy dissipation through interactions with Jupiter. This predicts a gradual decrease in the amplitude of ”shock” eccentricity changes and a potential stabilization of the climatic rhythm in the long term, barring a recurring resonance encounter. It is noteworthy that the model exhibits the greatest stability precisely with the calculated orbital characteristics, whereas significant changes in mass and inclination angle lead to a more fast destruction of the orbit.

Figure 7: Evolution of P9 orbit with q 1.1 AU Figure 8: Evolution of P9 orbit with q 1.0 AU
Another image is an overlay of the period on climatic events, showing the occurrence of the most abrupt and catastrophic of them. Although, as can be seen from the simulation, the period can vary significantly, which can result in a more accurate hit.


11 Conclusion
The model of Planet 9’s orbital impact successfully
integrates classical Milankovitch theory with anomalies found in paleoclimatic records. An object with a mass of 5M⊕ acts as a key factor of ”orbital chaos,” responsible for transforming smooth climatic cycles into a series of catastrophic events that shaped the modern biosphere. Historical evidence, such as the legends of the catastrophic Marduk and the drought-bringing Typhon/Seth, which likely originated during the Piora Oscillation period, directly support this hypothesis.
 

Attachments

  • Planet9 _q1AU_T3600.pdf
    Planet9 _q1AU_T3600.pdf
    3.4 MB · Views: 2
  • Без названия (37).png
    Без названия (37).png
    150 KB · Views: 1
  • Без названия (34).png
    Без названия (34).png
    120.7 KB · Views: 1
  • Без названия (12)-01-02.jpeg
    Без названия (12)-01-02.jpeg
    245.3 KB · Views: 1
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom