I take it that the main evidence for your idea is that it is difficult even for specialists to disprove?Such a calculation, given the complexity of the climate system, is a very difficult task even for specialists in this field.
I take it that the main evidence for your idea is that it is difficult even for specialists to disprove?Such a calculation, given the complexity of the climate system, is a very difficult task even for specialists in this field.
What is your evidence for this?The influence of the planets of the solar system, including Venus, plays a role in climate cycles and this is taken into account in climatology.
This is how it should be.I take it that the main evidence for your idea is that it is difficult even for specialists to disprove?
No lad, unfalsifiable "evidence" rightly renders an argument null and void.This is how it should be.
I didn't say that the orbit should change more than other planets do. And besides that, I also take solar cycles into account. Many studies indicate that planets modulate solar cycles. At the same time, my article shows that the period 3600 is a fundamental mode, while others Long-period cycles arise as subharmonics. With the exception of the Heinrich cycle of 4000-3600 years which have a ratio with a period of 1/1 and do not have a comprehensive explanation. Probably also related to solar activity. The Roman climatic optimum is explained as a coincidence of several cycles at once, and this fits into the concept of resonance with a period of 3600 years as a peak of amplification. Resonance explains how a weak gravitational influence produces a multifactorial noticeable effect.Fascinating. Thanks!
Does their result, claiming to detect a stable 405,000 year orbital cycle, suggest the Earth's orbit is not very likely to be being disrupted on 3,600 year cycle?
I mean, if experts find it hard to refute, that might indicate that the evidence is valid.No lad, unfalsifiable "evidence" rightly renders an argument null and void.
What is your evidence for this?
Milankovitch cycles describe the collective effects of changes in the Earth's movements on its climate over thousands of years
The Earth's rotation around its axis, and revolution around the Sun, evolve over time due to gravitational interactions with other bodies in the Solar System. The variations are complex, but a few cycles are dominant.
But you're not bringing any evidence, just assumptions, suppositions and daydreams. The stuff you have is unfalsifiable because there is nothing there to grasp at, to test, to verify. There is no there there.I mean, if experts find it hard to refute, that might indicate that the evidence is valid.
I think this can be verified by conducting a more detailed analysis of indirect signs and using modeling. Adjust the search for Planet Nine to take these features into accountBut you're not bringing any evidence, just assumptions, suppositions and daydreams. The stuff you have is unfalsifiable because there is nothing there to grasp at, to test, to verify. There is no there there.
Get back to us when you have done this and when your speculation approaches the level of an actual evidence backed hypothesis that can be rationally critiqued.I think this can be verified by conducting a more detailed analysis of indirect signs and using modeling. Adjust the search for Planet Nine to take these features into account
...And? Go on. Keep going with this train of thought. You haven't reached any actual conclusions yet.Two independent lines of data point to the same thing, complementing each other. Otherwise, you need to find a separate explanation for each element and acknowledge the amazing coincidence.
...And? Go on. Keep going with this train of thought. You haven't reached any actual conclusions yet.
Apparently there is a faint fingerprint, and it has already been discovered.Instead of assuming, you could look to see whether the planet Venus has a detectable influence. Have you looked into that? I'm unaware of any evidence that it has, and, if there is none, it would suggest you're going to need an influence that's much stronger than Venus. Not just a little stronger.
Venus makes its closest approach to us every 584 days. If there's even a faint fingerprint on Earth's weather and climate, it ought to be discoverable even if it hasn't been searched for before. If Venus can't make its presence felt at all, then your proposed large planet is going to have to have come closer to cause notable events, and yet somehow still have been taken to be a regular comet.
Can you tell me what kind of evidence this should be? Besides direct detection with a telescope. When it comes to the main Planet Nine hypothesis, it is perceived as something serious and well-founded. Do you take into account that this alternative hypothesis of Nibiru, besides being based on the same evidence, including the results of Batygin and Brown's modeling, explains many other things as well and is supported by historical evidence?Get back to us when you have done this and when your speculation approaches the level of an actual evidence backed hypothesis that can be rationally critiqued.
Yes, as I thanked the OP for linking to a paper yesterday. It was a surprise to me that such a cycle was detectable in traces left by climate trends.Apparently there is a faint fingerprint, and it has already been discovered.
Now, let's not put words in their mouth.I believe, reading between the hints, it's "climate change is just a cycle maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan..."
Scientific Disproof: Scientists and astronomers have debunked the Nibiru cataclysm, as such a massive, nearby object would have been visible to the naked eye and gravitationally disrupted the solar system long ago.