New evidence of Nibiru / Planet 9

MasterOgon

Scholar
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
86
I am working on a speculative interdisciplinary hypothesis exploring connections between astrophysics, geochronology and history/culture in which Planet Nine has an extremely eccentric orbit and causes periodic catastrophes, which ancient people tried to warn about. And I would like to know if there are any arguments against this?

Some hypotheses suggest that Planet Nine is a rogue planet, captured by the solar system from outer space. These theories also explain the anomalies well by phase protection, in which the most distant orbits of perturbed trans-Neptunian objects avoid dispersal, thereby forming clusters. but the problem with them, and reason they're not generally accepted, is that such captures lead to very elongated, unstable orbits, and in simulations, such planets are quickly ejected back into outer space.

But there's one caveat: our entire civilization, compared to this "quickly," is a very brief moment in the simulation, and our solar system could very well have such an unstable planet right now. It's just a matter of evidence.

Edited by zooterkin: 
<Snip> for rule 4. The text is available here - https://www.reddit.com/r/AncientAliens/s/Wt7hJadktK


The main article is attached
 

Attachments

Last edited by a moderator:
I am working on a speculative interdisciplinary hypothesis exploring connections between astrophysics, geochronology and history/culture in which Planet Nine has an extremely eccentric orbit and causes periodic catastrophes, which ancient people tried to warn about. And I would like to know if there are any arguments against this?

Some hypotheses suggest that Planet Nine is a rogue planet, captured by the solar system from outer space. These theories also explain the anomalies well by phase protection, in which the most distant orbits of perturbed trans-Neptunian objects avoid dispersal, thereby forming clusters. but the problem with them, and reason they're not generally accepted, is that such captures lead to very elongated, unstable orbits, and in simulations, such planets are quickly ejected back into outer space.

But there's one caveat: our entire civilization, compared to this "quickly," is a very brief moment in the simulation, and our solar system could very well have such an unstable planet right now. It's just a matter of evidence.

At a large distance of about 500 astronomical units, where astronomers are searching for Planet Nine by observing stellar background overlaps, detecting it is very difficult. With a very elongated orbit, it's even more difficult at its farthest point, as it appears motionless and slows there.

But if this planet approached Earth in the past, there must be evidence. There must be traces of periodic disturbances in the geochronological record—that is, catastrophes, abrupt climate changes—and there must be evidence of human observations. These traces, in turn, must fit into a cycle equal to the period of a planet that can reach the Kuiper Belt and create disturbances there.

This provides significant constraints on the period, the minimum of which under these conditions is 3,000-4,000 years, which can already be traced historically. However, the problem is that dangerous approaches may not occur every time, and it is impossible to detect a full cycle of catastrophes, and legends are not a reliable source of information.

Trying to be unbiased, I studied the history of Earth's climate, identifying abrupt climate shifts that lack a comprehensive explanation within known cycles and stand out against them. I also separately studied references to catastrophic events and celestial bodies in myths and ancient astronomical records. Then I superimposed these two separate chronologies to determine the cycle, the period of the planet's revolution.

First, the alternation of ice ages and warm periods depends on periodic fluctuations in the eccentricity of Earth's orbit and the tilt of its axis. But 1-3 million years ago, the Middle Pleistocene transition from the 41,000-year to the 100,000-year cycle occurred, and this "transition problem" requires an explanation. This provides a lower bound for the duration of solar system stability. In cosmic terms, this is a short transition period and argues against Nibiru disrupting the solar system's stability.

Tracking events in such a distant past is very difficult, so I focus on a period of 15,000 years, during which the dating of events is consistent within one or two centuries. Over this entire period, there are only three clearly defined anomalies.

One of the most discussed events is the Younger Dryas—a sharp cooling event beginning around 10,800 BCE that abruptly interrupted the warming that followed the last ice age.

The causes are not fully understood. Magnetic microspherules and nanodiamonds, characteristic only of meteorites, were found in sedimentary rocks from that period. Elevated concentrations of iridium and platinum, rare in the Earth's crust, were also discovered. Large-scale soot deposits indicate global forest fires that could have engulfed up to 10% of the earth's land area.

However, no trace of a major impact was detected. The leading hypothesis is that the breakup of Comet Encke caused a chain reaction in the climate, but this is not a definitive explanation.

Such an event is exactly what would be expected from a superearth flyby – a climate shift from the pulsed gravitational influence and a trail of meteoroids and small bodies captured from the Kuiper Belt.

Interestingly, according to astronomical interpretations, one of the most famous studies, Gölbeke Tepe, as a calendar, points to the date of this event, 10,950 BCE, although the temple is believed to have been built much later. It is believed that the monument symbolically depicts falling meteorites and is a kind of memorial to the disaster.

Going further, in 3800-3600 BC, the Pior Oscillation began abruptly, a cooling period peaking around 3250-3150 BC. The Sahara began to turn into a desert, and in the Middle East, the surface of the Dead Sea level rose by 30 meters and then dropped back down. Increased methane and sulfate levels were detected in Greenland glaciers around 3250 BCE, indicating a catastrophe—either a volcano or a meteorite. The causes of this anomaly are again unclear.

During this same period, the Sumerian civilization emerged, the so-called urban revolution took place, writing emerged, and a highly developed astronomy emerged. The Sumerians themselves were an anomaly. Their mythology, in fact, literally recounts the catastrophe in the famous cosmogonic poem Enuma Elish, in which the god Marduk, associated with Nibiru, defeats the Earth prototype Tiamat and creates a new world from it:

Nibiru is actually a Sumerian astronomical term applicable to any planet, denoting a crossing or passage across the celestial equator. Historians generally believe that Marduk is Jupiter, based on ancient astronomical texts:

The star of Marduk, Nēbiru, Jupiter.

But here's how Marduk is described in the Enuma Elish:

He flashed lightning before him,
He filled his body with blazing flame.

and

He released before him the Evil Wind, which was behind him.

He fashioned the Evil Wind, the Dust Storm, the Tempest,
The Four-fold Wind, the Seven-fold Wind, the Whirlwind,
And the wind which had no equal.

The Enuma Elish also hints at cyclicity:

He returned to Tiamat, whom he had vanquished.

And this has no obvious connection with Jupiter. Thousands of years later, Babylonian copyists of Sumerian texts also placed a strange emphasis on the color of celestial bodies:

"In the month of Duuzu [June-July], when the Arrow Star [Sirius] shines, ... a great star, whose color is red like copper, divides the sky in two. This is Nibiru."

and

"A brown-red star... divides the heavens and stands there, this star is Nebiru-Marduk."

In Greek mythology, Typhon, a monster who rebelled against the gods, was described, like Marduk, as a celestial body moving unnaturally and causing storms. Here's how he was described by the Roman philosopher Pliny the Elder:

"The ancients mention a comet called Typhon... it was blood-colored and had the appearance of a circle swirling like a whirlwind, and its appearance was terrifying; "It wasn't a star, but rather some kind of fiery knot."

"There are comets... like a kind of terror. Such was Typhon, seen by the peoples of Ethiopia and Egypt, and to whom the king of that era gave a name befitting its appearance. It was fiery, twisted into a spiral, and its appearance was more like a knot than a star."

"When such bodies appear, they foretell great droughts, followed by enormous floods."

The reference to the red color in Babylonian texts is likely related to atmospheric conditions, but could this not be an attempt to interpret visible objects, Sirius or Jupiter, as the legendary Marduk or Typhon, who caused the inexplicable catastrophes described above?

Moving on, our next stop is the Roman Climatic Optimum, a period of warm, stable climate at the junction of eras. This isn't a catastrophe, but it is still an anomaly that doesn't align with known solar cycles or other dominant influences such as volcanic, orbital, or greenhouse effects. Against this backdrop, an event that occurred approximately midway through this period in the Dead Sea region stands out. This event, referred to as a seismic storm, stands in stark contrast to the usual activity in the region. Therefore, some scientists quite seriously suggest that some external forcing must have triggered the Roman Climatic Optimum as a whole, and this forcing is still unclear.

This period also saw significant cultural events that reflect these events and echo older legends. The most famous astronomical event is, of course, the Star of Bethlehem.

It is noteworthy that in religious tradition, this event was predicted by the prophet Balaam:

"I see Him, but not yet; I behold Him, but not near." "A star shall come out of Jacob, and a scepter shall arise out of Israel..."

It is quite possible that the prophet could have been speaking of an event whose periodicity was known and which was intended to stand out from others.

It is also interesting that the New Testament, especially the apocrypha, prophecies strongly echo the legends of Marduk and Typhon, which people of that time might have known about.


1 “… fiery waterfalls will flow, darkness and gloom will come and clothe and envelop the whole world, and the waters will turn into burning coals, and everything on the earth will burn, and the sea will become a fire, and under the sky there will be a fierce flame that will not be quenched, but will rush to the judgment of wrath.

2 And the stars will be scattered by the flame of fire, as if they had not been created, and the firmaments of the heavens will pass away for lack of water and become as if they had not been created.

3 And there will be lightning in the sky, and their sorcery will frighten the world."

This indicates that people were definitely expecting some important celestial event, although its meaning was likely lost over the millennia.

Astronomers find simple explanations for the Star of Bethlehem, claiming it is a comet or a planetary conjunction. But what's interesting is that from the beginning of the era until around 70 CE, chronicles of that time recorded not just one comet, but a whole stream of comets and other objects, most of which are unknown to astronomers, as confirmed by independent sources of the time.

To summarize, a coincidence is again observed during this period. Two unexplained factors—an unusually abrupt climate change over a period of several hundred years and a whole stream of comets.

Here's what you get if you add up all the dates.
Climate:

Younger Dryas Impact 10,900–10,800 BCE

Beginning of the Pior Oscillation 3800–3600 BCE

Mid-Roman Optimum and the seismic storm of 31 CE.

Taking into account that one cycle could have been skipped because Planet Nine could have passed at a safe distance or even behind the Sun, these dates
give the number 3631–3644 years.

That is, if you divide the period from the Young Dryas Impact to the Cometary Peak of the Roman Optimum by three, you get this number, and one such period falls exactly at the beginning of the Pior Oscillation, while the other is missing.

Now the historical dates:

Göbekli Tepe (date) (which it points to) 10,950 BC

The emergence of Sumerian mythology 3100-2900 BC (considering what may have happened after the event and possible shifts)

Peak of the comet shower ~60 CE

The result is obvious:

10,950 (GT) + 60 (CP) = 11010 : 3 = 3670

Which is approximately equal to 3600, the legendary Sumerian mythological cycle of Shar, used in the king list, and approaches a multiple of 365-366 days per year. This "magic of numbers" is astonishing because each number is associated with an exceptional historical period.

Thus, two completely independent chronologies, geological and cultural, yield the same cycle of 3670 and 3631-3644 years.

To rule out coincidences, I compare this with known climate cycles.
If ±3600 years is the period of Nibiru, which influences Earth, then it should have a clear imprint over hundreds of thousands of years. And this figure indeed correlates well with known cycles. Although they have rather fluctuating values due to the complexity of the climate system, the key result is the near-commensurability between the dominant millennial solar cycle (Solar activity depends on the influence of planets, as their gravity causes tidal waves on the Sun) and the dominant millennial climate cycle.

Comparing the 3600-year period with the Hallstatt (Breuil) solar cycle of ~2300 years yields a ratio of ≈3/2, which is a parametric resonance, when the maxima of the external forcing do not coincide with the maxima of the system's response, leading to alternating phases of amplification and suppression.

The same resonance exists with other climate fluctuations, but the most important thing is the almost one-to-one coincidence. With the 3600-4000-year Heinrich Event cycle, a sharp ejection of icebergs from glaciers in the past.

In short, the 3600-year period fits perfectly into the climate and solar cycles as a factor, albeit with gaps, but consistent with the chronology of the supposed periodicity of approaches.

One simple conclusion follows from all this: if Nibiru is indeed the cause of this periodicity, people at the beginning of the new era, at the peak of the Roman Optimum and comets, were simply bound to have seen it, and for anywhere from several months to a year, while it passed close to the sun.

During this period, as I have already mentioned, a large number of celestial objects are recorded in Roman and especially Chinese astronomical chronicles. But one unknown comet from the year 60 (C/60 D1 in the catalogs) stands out in particular.

Chinese astronomers at the imperial court in Luoyang first saw this "broom star" in June-July. 60 AD and observed it for 135 days through December, until it disappeared below the horizon or due to bad weather. Their records were laconic but informative: It appeared north of Cassiopeia/Andromeda and moved south toward Virgo, with a short tail. This was later recorded as a strong astrological sign of a great flood.

It's a coincidence, because that same year a devastating flood of the Yi and Luo rivers actually occurred, inundating 32 counties in 7 prefectures.

The Romans observed this same comet for six months, and it certainly left an impression. Seneca, the Roman philosopher, described it as menacing:

"In the time of Nero Caesar, a comet appeared which, rising in the north, shone almost continuously for six months, with a very threatening appearance."

"Why is it visible for so long and does not quickly fade? For this one, which we saw during Nero's most successful principate, offered itself for observation for six months, moving in the opposite direction to the one in Claudius's time: that one, rising from the north to the zenith, always headed east and steadily grew dimmer; This one, however, began its movement from the same direction, but, heading west, turned south and disappeared from view there."

Seneca wrote extensively about comets, reflecting on their nature:

"Classes: flame hanging down like a beard; hair on all sides; diffused fire to the top. General: 'a star of strange, unusual appearance, which carries diffused fire with it' (comets = long-haired)."

“Comets are as varied as they are numerous. They are uneven in size, but not in color. Some of them…” Some are ruddy, without light; others are bright, with a pure, clear light; others are the color of flame, but the flame is not thin and weightless, but shrouded in smoke. Some are bloody and threatening, foreshadowing bloodshed. They wax and wane, like other planets. They are brighter when approaching us and appear larger at close range, smaller when receding, and dimmer when they reach a greater distance.

Seneca speaks of violent, prolonged storms throughout the region and devastating earthquakes that destroyed cities in Achaea and Macedonia shortly after the comet's appearance in 60 BC:

“Aristotle says that comets foretell a storm with unseasonable storms and rains. To prove the truth to you…” "A comet does not threaten with wind and rain immediately after its appearance, as Aristotle says, but it makes the whole year suspicious. It radiates such a force as to cause damage on land or sea, not from the place whence it first appeared, nor from the place whence it disappeared. The comet which appeared during the consulate of Paterculus and Vopiscus did what Aristotle and Theophrastus had predicted; for violent, incessant storms raged everywhere, and in Achaea and Macedonia cities were destroyed by earthquakes. The comet which appeared during the consulate of Paterculus and Vopiscus served as a terrible example of this truth. It began in the north, but..." "It did not remain there; its path lay from north to west, and it died out towards the south, gradually losing its brightness. The flame which existed during the reign of the late Emperor Claudius began in the north, but then moved east, constantly "becoming ever dimmer."

He also reports other celestial phenomena:

"In our time, we have often seen a huge spherical flame that dissipated in the very center of its path. We saw a similar omen around the time of the death of the late Emperor Augustus. We saw it again when Sejanus was executed."

Tacitus, the Roman historian, linked this event to political paranoia:

"At this time, a comet with a tail appeared, which, according to popular belief, always foretells the death of high authorities."

Many saw comets as a sign of the end of an era or the wrath of the gods. For the comet-phobic Emperor Nero, this threatening comet, looming over Rome for six months, was probably the most terrifying of them all.

Thanks to such extensive information about a single astronomical object, compared to ancient times, many modern astronomers have attempted to reconstruct the orbit of this comet. Due to the incompleteness of historical data, such a task is practically impossible, but the described path The sky and visibility still provide some limitations. At a minimum, opinions agree that the comet did not approach close to the sun, perhaps even as far away as Earth, and its period is several thousand years.

The region of the sky where the comet was observed, moving from Cassiopeia to Virgo, allows us to assume, taking into account the possible projection, that the outermost point of the orbit could be directed toward the region around Taurus and Orion, as suggested by the Planet Nine hypothesis. This is an important condition of this hypothesis, regardless of how elongated the orbit is.

Thus, from legends and historical chronicles, it follows that a menacingly red comet appears at different times with a period of approximately 3,600 years, causing impacts, storms, floods, and earthquakes. This is confirmed by geochronological data and is consistent with the Planet Nine hypothesis as a captured outcast. Provided that the comet has the mass of a planet.


Here are some considerations regarding the appearance of this comet-planet.

A red or brown color indicates tholins, organic substances that are often found on distant icy objects in the solar system, including Pluto.

But the formation of a comet-like tail by ice sublimation formation in an ice giant is impossible due to gravity. However, it is possible with a large amount of volatiles and volcanic activity, which leads to a higher initial ejecta velocity.

Short-term heating near the sun is insufficient for active volcanism, so the planet must support it itself. This is possible with a mass of 3 to 6 Earth masses, or about twice its diameter, which is comparable to Planet Nine's mass of 4.4 Earth masses.

In short, if the hypothesis is correct, the likely apocalypse will occur around the year 3700. There is time to test and prepare.

The main article is attached
Can you tl;dr this down and remove all the CT stuff, please?
 
The Chinese and the Romans both recorded seeing a really impressive comet in AD 60.

You appear to be conjecturing it was not a ~1km diameter comet but rather a ~50,000km diameter planet. How close to the earth do you propose the object passed? Close enough to trigger earthquakes, I gather.

Would it still have looked like a comet if it came close, or like something they would have described as being different? Would it have caused perturbations in the earth and moon's orbits we might still be able to detect?
 
Can you tl;dr this down and remove all the CT stuff, please?
The hypothesis is that there exists at least one highly eccentric super-comet, and that by using historical information for timing we can predict its next pass.

The problem becomes, as often the case, that the historical information is little more than wishful question begging, because such a dwarf planet existing would be evidence the history occurred rather than the other way round. Think Atlantis, biblical plagues and so on.
 
The Chinese and the Romans both recorded seeing a really impressive comet in AD 60.

You appear to be conjecturing it was not a ~1km diameter comet but rather a ~50,000km diameter planet. How close to the earth do you propose the object passed? Close enough to trigger earthquakes, I gather.

Would it still have looked like a comet if it came close, or like something they would have described as being different? Would it have caused perturbations in the earth and moon's orbits we might still be able to detect?
I can't say for sure, I'm no expert, but judging by the description, it didn't evoke an association with a planet, so it could be a distance like the orbit of Venus, closer or further away. The effect in this case would be weak and even almost imperceptible, but it could upset the delicate balance that held the accumulated seismic stress.

It would also have affected the orbit, changing the climate by pulling the planet toward the sun and then pulling it back after passing. Similarly, the planets of the solar system have a weak influence on each other during their closest approaches, which modulates the climate but doesn't change the length of the year.
 
Who did these "ancient people" try to warn? What, exactly, was the warning? How was this warning communicated? How did "ancient people" recognize this hypothetical object as a planet as opposed to some other object? How far apart were these "periodic catastrophes"? How did these "ancient people" determine the period of this objects return?
 
Who did these "ancient people" try to warn? What, exactly, was the warning? How was this warning communicated? How did "ancient people" recognize this hypothetical object as a planet as opposed to some other object? How far apart were these "periodic catastrophes"? How did these "ancient people" determine the period of this objects return?
In the astronomical interpretation, Holbeke Tepe depicts falling fireballs as snakes and fixes the date relative to the equinox points. Then it came back again, and the next time during the Sumerians they could guess that it was cyclical. They might not know what exactly it was. This does not play a major role since the period is determined independently by the geological record and human testimony, and not by their knowledge or ignorance of the period.
 
In the astronomical interpretation, Holbeke Tepe depicts falling fireballs as snakes and fixes the date relative to the equinox points. Then it came back again, and the next time during the Sumerians they could guess that it was cyclical. They might not know what exactly it was. This does not play a major role since the period is determined independently by the geological record and human testimony, and not by their knowledge or ignorance of the period.
So no actual warnings then. Merely several independent events that you are trying to connect in some way.
 
I can't say for sure, I'm no expert, but judging by the description, it didn't evoke an association with a planet, so it could be a distance like the orbit of Venus, closer or further away. The effect in this case would be weak and even almost imperceptible, but it could upset the delicate balance that held the accumulated seismic stress.

It would also have affected the orbit, changing the climate by pulling the planet toward the sun and then pulling it back after passing. Similarly, the planets of the solar system have a weak influence on each other during their closest approaches, which modulates the climate but doesn't change the length of the year.

When you consider what level of disturbance in a delicate balance might trigger, say, an earthquake, you have to remember the moon is right there, and that the earth, not just its oceans, distorts tidally as it turns every day. Whatever triggering effect you seek would have to be significant on that scale.


A planet several times more massive than the earth could exert a moon-like pull from much further away than the moon is, but of course it is also a lot larger than the moon. So could the ancients have seen it clearly?

Back of an envelope time - moon is, to a first approximation, 1/80 earth mass, so a planet of roughly 5 earth masses would be 400 times the lunar mass and exert the same gravitational pull as the moon does when roughly 20-ish times as far away (square root of 400). Its diameter would be roughly 7.5 lunar diameters (cube root of 400).

So the 5-earths-mass planet would exert a moon-scale pull on the earth from a distance where it appeared 7.5/20 = 0.375 times the size of the moon in the sky. I suggest no ancient astronomers would be unaware that an object more than a third the size of the full moon was a very different kind of comet than they had seen before and they would be guaranteed to take note.

Feel free to argue the planet would only have to exert some modest fraction of the moon's pull to have a notably disruptive effect but I think the ball is pretty much in your court to argue for both the disruption you wish to attribute and the fact both the Romans and Chinese seem to have thought this was a regular, if impressive, comet.
 
MasterOgon, based on your postings above your "speculative interdisciplinary hypothesis" appears to be devoid of any actual facts or indeed, knowledge, on your part. It is nothing but wild speculation that does not rise to the level of hypothesis. What is your purpose in posting here? You have provided nothing to indicate that this is worthy of serious discussion.
 
When you consider what level of disturbance in a delicate balance might trigger, say, an earthquake, you have to remember the moon is right there, and that the earth, not just its oceans, distorts tidally as it turns every day. Whatever triggering effect you seek would have to be significant on that scale.


A planet several times more massive than the earth could exert a moon-like pull from much further away than the moon is, but of course it is also a lot larger than the moon. So could the ancients have seen it clearly?

Back of an envelope time - moon is, to a first approximation, 1/80 earth mass, so a planet of roughly 5 earth masses would be 400 times the lunar mass and exert the same gravitational pull as the moon does when roughly 20-ish times as far away (square root of 400). Its diameter would be roughly 7.5 lunar diameters (cube root of 400).

So the 5-earths-mass planet would exert a moon-scale pull on the earth from a distance where it appeared 7.5/20 = 0.375 times the size of the moon in the sky. I suggest no ancient astronomers would be unaware that an object more than a third the size of the full moon was a very different kind of comet than they had seen before and they would be guaranteed to take note.

Feel free to argue the planet would only have to exert some modest fraction of the moon's pull to have a notably disruptive effect but I think the ball is pretty much in your court to argue for both the disruption you wish to attribute and the fact both the Romans and Chinese seem to have thought this was a regular, if impressive, comet.
Your arguments are valid; I've thought about this too, and I can't explain how such an influence could arise at such a distance based on these patterns. Furthermore, the Roman Climatic Optimum, which I'm relying on as an anomaly indicating a cycle, lasted several hundred years, when the distance was incomparably great. However, a cycle of anomalies or events exists without explanation, and therefore some explanation for the mechanism must exist. It could, of course, be anything, but the point is that ancient sources unanimously claim that a red comet is to blame. Therefore, I'm primarily considering this possibility. Perhaps this comet isn't so small, though that makes the hypothesis more extreme. It could be a matter of the balance of the entire solar system. It could be a matter of the magnetic field or electrification.
 
In the astronomical interpretation, Holbeke Tepe depicts falling fireballs as snakes and fixes the date relative to the equinox points. Then it came back again, and the next time during the Sumerians they could guess that it was cyclical. They might not know what exactly it was. This does not play a major role since the period is determined independently by the geological record and human testimony, and not by their knowledge or ignorance of the period.
Why not depict it as they saw it rather thsn as snakes?

Why be cryptic?
 
Почему бы не изобразить это так, как это видели они, а не в виде змей?

Зачем быть загадочным?
The fact is that the ancients constantly depicted everything symbolically and zoomorphically. There is nothing unusual about this.
 
Last edited:
What happened to the quote?

If you are trying to warn future generations of impending doom, wouldn't you want them to easily understand the message?
 
I am working on a speculative interdisciplinary hypothesis exploring connections between astrophysics, geochronology and history/culture in which Planet Nine has an extremely eccentric orbit and causes periodic catastrophes, which ancient people tried to warn about. And I would like to know if there are any arguments against this?

Some hypotheses suggest that Planet Nine is a rogue planet, captured by the solar system from outer space. These theories also explain the anomalies well by phase protection, in which the most distant orbits of perturbed trans-Neptunian objects avoid dispersal, thereby forming clusters. but the problem with them, and reason they're not generally accepted, is that such captures lead to very elongated, unstable orbits, and in simulations, such planets are quickly ejected back into outer space.

But there's one caveat: our entire civilization, compared to this "quickly," is a very brief moment in the simulation, and our solar system could very well have such an unstable planet right now. It's just a matter of evidence.
And therefore...?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom