The Great Zaganza
Maledictorian
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2016
- Messages
- 33,280
CTs are often "yes, and" to get someone else to buy into yours by combining it with theirs.
Thanks for the synopsis, though I was hoping the OP would restate their assertion in layman's terms and with all the nonsense removed.The hypothesis is that there exists at least one highly eccentric super-comet, and that by using historical information for timing we can predict its next pass.
The problem becomes, as often the case, that the historical information is little more than wishful question begging, because such a dwarf planet existing would be evidence the history occurred rather than the other way round. Think Atlantis, biblical plagues and so on.
That was layman’s terms.I was hoping the OP would restate their assertion in layman's terms
Even completely contradictory CTs, as long as you question what "They" are saying you're OK by me!CTs are often "yes, and" to get someone else to buy into yours by combining it with theirs.
Is it that ancient sources unanimously claimed that a red comet is to blame for the events you picked, or is it that you chose only a handful of events around the time that a couple of ancient sources mentioned a red comet, then circled back to claiming that the events you filtered for happened around when the sources you chose mentioned a red comet, then that proves they were caused by that red comet?Your arguments are valid; I've thought about this too, and I can't explain how such an influence could arise at such a distance based on these patterns. Furthermore, the Roman Climatic Optimum, which I'm relying on as an anomaly indicating a cycle, lasted several hundred years, when the distance was incomparably great. However, a cycle of anomalies or events exists without explanation, and therefore some explanation for the mechanism must exist. It could, of course, be anything, but the point is that ancient sources unanimously claim that a red comet is to blame. Therefore, I'm primarily considering this possibility. Perhaps this comet isn't so small, though that makes the hypothesis more extreme. It could be a matter of the balance of the entire solar system. It could be a matter of the magnetic field or electrification.
Only the comet of 60 CE is described in connection with specific events. The other descriptions, including Marduk and Typhon, are not tied to any date. The events were selected based on geochronological data as anomalies.Is it that ancient sources unanimously claimed that a red comet is to blame for the events you picked, or is it that you chose only a handful of events around the time that a couple of ancient sources mentioned a red comet, then circled back to claiming that the events you filtered for happened around when the sources you chose mentioned a red comet, then that proves they were caused by that red comet?
And therefore..?Only the comet of 60 CE is described in connection with specific events. The other descriptions, including Marduk and Typhon, are not tied to any date. The events were selected based on geochronological data as anomalies.
When you consider what level of disturbance in a delicate balance might trigger, say, an earthquake, you have to remember the moon is right there, and that the earth, not just its oceans, distorts tidally as it turns every day. Whatever triggering effect you seek would have to be significant on that scale.
A planet several times more massive than the earth could exert a moon-like pull from much further away than the moon is, but of course it is also a lot larger than the moon. So could the ancients have seen it clearly?
Back of an envelope time - moon is, to a first approximation, 1/80 earth mass, so a planet of roughly 5 earth masses would be 400 times the lunar mass and exert the same gravitational pull as the moon does when roughly 20-ish times as far away (square root of 400). Its diameter would be roughly 7.5 lunar diameters (cube root of 400).
So the 5-earths-mass planet would exert a moon-scale pull on the earth from a distance where it appeared 7.5/20 = 0.375 times the size of the moon in the sky. I suggest no ancient astronomers would be unaware that an object more than a third the size of the full moon was a very different kind of comet than they had seen before and they would be guaranteed to take note.
Feel free to argue the planet would only have to exert some modest fraction of the moon's pull to have a notably disruptive effect but I think the ball is pretty much in your court to argue for both the disruption you wish to attribute and the fact both the Romans and Chinese seem to have thought this was a regular, if impressive, comet.
Other dates are based on geochronological data. Legends only describe the possible cause of the events.And therefore..?
As discussed earlier, given the visibility at a distance, the planet's influence should have been almost imperceptible. Perhaps a little stronger than the influence of Venus. But I assume that this weak influence could disrupt the climate balance that has been established for millennia and become a trigger for climate events. Theoretically this is acceptable, but no one can tell you exactly what the effect of this flight will actually be.Such an object, if it came anywhere near enough to us to trigger earthquakes or disasters on the massive scale claimed, would literally have flung the moon out of its orbit, and probably disturbed NEO orbits so much that it would likely have rained them them down on us in a global ◊◊◊◊-storm of epic proportions. The effects would be impossible to ignore in the historical record.
This is all junk-science along the lines of the crap that Scott Wolter and Graham Hancock promote. I dismiss it without evidence!!
And therefore..?Other dates are based on geochronological data. Legends only describe the possible cause of the events.
You want the influence to be noticeable at the same time as being almost imperceptible. Don't you see a problem here?As discussed earlier, given the visibility at a distance, the planet's influence should have been almost imperceptible. Perhaps a little stronger than the influence of Venus. But I assume that this weak influence could disrupt the climate balance that has been established for millennia and become a trigger for climate events. Theoretically this is acceptable, but no one can tell you exactly what the effect of this flight will actually be.
Two independent lines of data point to the same thing, complementing each other. Otherwise, you need to find a separate explanation for each element and acknowledge the amazing coincidence.And therefore..?
What? What is your conclusion from all of this?
No. This provides a solution. The Roman climatic optimum is almost entirely explained by known factors. However, some researchers insist on the need for external forcing, which became the triggerYou want the influence to be noticeable at the same time as being almost imperceptible. Don't you see a problem here?
As discussed earlier, given the visibility at a distance, the planet's influence should have been almost imperceptible. Perhaps a little stronger than the influence of Venus. But I assume that this weak influence could disrupt the climate ...
You want a planet with hardly any influence be a trigger, and without perturbing the entire solar system when it passes inside of the orbit of the Earth! I am anxiously awaiting your calculations of the orbit, and the gravitational effect on the solar system. If you propose a stable system, you'll have quite a task ahead of you.However, some researchers insist on the need for external forcing, which became the trigger
Such a calculation, given the complexity of the climate system, is a very difficult task even for specialists in this field. I can propose any variant of mass and orbit with any gravitational influence, but I can’t calculate the actual climatic response, I’m not sure that this is even possible. I'm not saying that this will be unnoticeable, but on the contrary, I'm saying that it contributes to climate cycles, Milankovitch, etc. The stability of the solar system is limited in my hypothesis to 1-3 million years when a change of cycles occurred for an unknown reason. This is very small compared to what is called stability in astronomy.You want a planet with hardly any influence be a trigger, and without perturbing the entire solar system when it passes inside of the orbit of the Earth! I am anxiously awaiting your calculations of the orbit, and the gravitational effect on the solar system. If you propose a stable system, you'll have quite a task ahead of you.
Actual astronomers propose orbits that never comes close to the inner planets for exactly that reason: the system would be highly unstable.
The influence of the planets of the solar system, including Venus, plays a role in climate cycles and this is taken into account in climatology.