Neanderthals & humans interbred

I've been wondering why so many are assuming that the interbreeding means cooperation between Hss and Hsn. Maybe it's similar to why we assume that extraterrestrials will be friendly and benevolent. Just as likely is that there was a little angry love making between the tribes.

Another possibility--and it's my understanding that the archaelogical record doesn't necessarily support this--is that a lot more matings took place, but due to genetic incompatibility, fertile offspring were limited, so this is all the genetic mix we got.

Is there a way to estimate how likely fertile offspring would be?
 
I think youre falling into the trap there of judging a different culture by your own cultural standards. If you take a look at some of the earliest female figurines produced by Homo Sapiens the first thing you'll notice is that they aren't catwalk models


I am not falling into the trap you describe. Who said anything about catwalk models?

Is there anything brutish about those early female figurines? No there is not.

When it comes down to it, imagining that our distant ancestors would be attracted to the gracile female form is to forget that about 90% of our own ancestors were by our own standards pretty awful looking women. Black teeth, body odour, skin disease, high infant mortality, venerial diseases, poor education. Would you date someone like that ?

Most of your ancestors did
:D

This is all is irrelevant to the point I was making. If an early man had a choice between a woman with skin disease and one with a clear complexion which do you think he chose?
 
I asked:
What would a dictionary have told him?
Marduk replied:
That being extinct means you don't live on.

I still don't see what your problem is, Marduk. The sentence you're criticizing is "Neanderthals are not totally extinct, in some of us they live on - a little bit." I see no fault whatsoever in the way Professor Svante Paabo chose to express that view. Your dictionary definition of extinct fits perfectly and shows that his understanding of the word is the same as yours, and that he used the word properly.
 
"totally extinct" is like being "a little bit pregnant". Or "One of the only". Grammatically incorrect, since it doesn't quite add up.
In the sentence in question the "totally" is the problem, not the definition of 'extinct'.

"Neanderthals are not extinct, in some of us they live on - a little bit." says it more distinctly. Totally, Dude!
 
No, this isn't a percentage of DNA. This is the percentage of the population that has (some amount? of) the neandertal genes.
Ah! That's a shame - I was hoping to spread the news that we're all a bit neanderthal!
There was an item about it on BBC Radio FiveLive during the night.

ETA I see from subsequent posts that there are many possibilities.
 
Last edited:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_figurines
A more primitve society is more likely to think wide hips and large pendulous breasts are beautiful than an attractive face, the former will propogate the species by assisting childbirth, the latter gives no such evolutionary advantage.

Wide hips may indicate fertility and an ability to survive childbirth, but a beautiful face indicates a lack of parasites, early childhood disease, and the type of genetic abnormalities that lead to asymmetry.

There's also runaway sexual selection in which a thing doesn't need to have any specific advantage, or signal any specific advantage, so long as, for instance, the males of the species happen to like that characteristic more than it's lack, the characteristic itself will be selected for in the females, and the "liking of" the characteristic will be selected for in the males.

As for "propagating the species", natural selection cares very little for it.
 
Last edited:
"totally extinct" is like being "a little bit pregnant". Or "One of the only". Grammatically incorrect, since it doesn't quite add up.
In the sentence in question the "totally" is the problem, not the definition of 'extinct'.

"Neanderthals are not extinct, in some of us they live on - a little bit." says it more distinctly. Totally, Dude!

It's possible for a species to almost go extinct (for instance if there is only one small breeding population).

If there is such a thing as almost extinct, then there is such a thing as totally extinct.

And considering that the professor was contrasting totally exitinct with "not-quite extinct because some of their genes were passed on to us" I think it's a pretty good use of the word.

Certainly the sentence conveys its meaning much better than if he had left out the word "totally" entirely*.

*ha ha
 
Ah! That's a shame - I was hoping to spread the news that we're all a bit neanderthal!
There was an item about it on BBC Radio FiveLive during the night.

ETA I see from subsequent posts that there are many possibilities.

Umm, I was wrong. Apparently form 1 to 4% of the genes of those who are of non-African extraction are derived from Neadertal genes rather than the equivalent sapiens genes - I think it was sphensic who pointed that out above. Of course, since we are rather more mixed in lineage than most admit (or even suspect), what this means for an individual is difficult to know. Very likely most of those changed genes build proteins which are identical in function, if not form, to the replaced genes, and so the difference is negligible for them. But some noticeable, perhaps significant changes, are present.
 
I've never seen these definitions before. According wiki and other sources I've used (tolweb.org for one) the binomial nomenclatureWP defines a species, while the trinomenWP defines a subspecies. Neadertal manWP was long thought to have been a subspecies of sapiens, but has more lately been recognized as a separate species, Homo neandertalensis.

Note that such a designation does not rule out interbreeding between sapiens and neadertalensis. It simply says that they did not interbreed for an interval. When a later removal of a geographic barrier (or perhaps social/behavioral barrier) between them, they could, to at least a small extent, interbreed then. Such a thing could happen if, for example, camels and llamas, obviously now separate species, for some reason began occupying a common geographical area. The camaWP has proven that there is not (yet) a biological barrier.


I would not be suprized that i got it all wrong.
 
Very likely most of those changed genes build proteins which are identical in function, if not form, to the replaced genes, and so the difference is negligible for them.
Why?

What pressure existed "discouraging"* those changed genes from manifesting themselves in significant functional variations?

*I know, "discouraging" is a stupid way of terming it.
 
I asked:Marduk replied:

I still don't see what your problem is, Marduk. The sentence you're criticizing is "Neanderthals are not totally extinct, in some of us they live on - a little bit." I see no fault whatsoever in the way Professor Svante Paabo chose to express that view. Your dictionary definition of extinct fits perfectly and shows that his understanding of the word is the same as yours, and that he used the word properly.

My problem is that you don't have a sense of humour

btw youre a towel
:D
 
Apparently the news media left out the conclusions from the studies which suggested there were alternative explanations for the findings. Interbreeding was one of several possible explanations.

Ancient Sex Scandals: Did We Get It On With Neandertals?
That's not to say that the hybridization hypothesis is without merit. Indeed, the authors did a damned good job presenting their case, and their reasoning is sound. The point I'm making is that sex isn't the only option. And if hybridization did occur to the extent they predict, we're likely to find more hints at its existence. Analyzing the DNA of some of the suspected hybrid fossils, for example, might settle it once and for all. Or we may never know if the gene variants that are similar between Eurasians and Neandertals are due to sex, selection, or substructure. Time may have simply destroyed too much of the evidence for us to be sure.

What is certain is that sex sells, which is why the only thing the media is talking about when it comes to this paper is that ancient people may have shagged their evolutionary siblings. It's just so damned frustrating because the sexual exploits of early humans is only the tiniest piece of this huge discovery. Oh, the things we may learn from this genome about our own evolution, and our closest relatives! Whether we had sex with Neandertals or not, the work this team has done will change forever our understanding of hominid evolutionary history. The impact this genome will have on the science of human evolution is huge. The breakthrough science, the future implications of this work - that's what the media should be talking about - not ancient sex scandals.

Science Blogs are your friends. :D
 
Yeah, but what if the Neanderthal males were the ones getting it on with the Sapiens females? Didn't all the posters assume the sex was between Sapiens males rutting with anything they could find? Or did I miss some subtle nuance in this thread? Is there a fossil record of " Oh you big APE! DON'T STOP!" and 'Thanks for the side of Mammoth"...
 
Why?

What pressure existed "discouraging"* those changed genes from manifesting themselves in significant functional variations?

*I know, "discouraging" is a stupid way of terming it.

The pressure that if you actually changed the function of a critical protein, you just lost the evolution game. Cash in your chips and leave, do not pass Propagation.
 
I wonder how they can tell the difference between identical genes because we share a common ancestor and genes because of interbreeding.

By the way, prehistoric humans tried to interbreed with gorillas too. Here is proof. The hair lice that human beings have mostly in their scalp is different from the lice human beings sometimes have in their personal regions. Yet this is the same lice that gorillas have all over their bodies. We have to have gotten it from trying to mate with gorillas eons ago.

If I was to bet, I would say that mixing with the neanderthals was not their idea.
 
By the way, prehistoric humans tried to interbreed with gorillas too. Here is proof. The hair lice that human beings have mostly in their scalp is different from the lice human beings sometimes have in their personal regions. Yet this is the same lice that gorillas have all over their bodies. We have to have gotten it from trying to mate with gorillas eons ago.

How does that constitute proof?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom